Mass shooting in small town Texas

You don't until you do.

For the vast majority of people that is never. Let’s be real about this.

Facts not in evidence.

:con2: My testimony on my opinion is evidence, and given that I’m the world’s leading authority on what my opinion is, if you choose to disbelieve it, then I can’t help you with your paranoia.

A Domestic Violence conviction already is suppose to put the individual on the prohibited list. See the catch phrase "gun show loophole" addressed below.

Well that’s great to hear, except this guy managed to get around it because the system has huge gaps in it which we can’t address because our lawmakers are just too damned busy having moments of silence and respectfully waiting for enough time to have passed.

The numbers are not as small as you seem to think they are. Everything proposed is mostly oriented toward the responsible gun owner law abiding citizen because they are by definition the ONLY ones who obey laws. Criminals don't, no matter how many laws are on the books.

The numbers of what?

I’ve heard the talking point thousands of times. Lawbreakers don’t obey laws, so what’s the point of having laws? It must be anarchy in the streets because those lawbreakers are just running around doing whatever they want; rape, murder, setting people on fire, littering, and all kinds of things.

Only not. The reality is most people, even lawbreakers, obey most of the laws most of the time, and if the goal of perfect compliance is unattainable that doesn’t mean we should just give up. There are still things we can do differently and things we can do better than can make a difference. Your talking point is designed to shut down discussion when we need to have a discussion.

You obviously haven't read the thread. Many proposals have been discussed at length throughout the thread. These haven't been addressed quite as much as our leftist friends from across the ocean telling us how stupid we are and how much superior they are to the Colonials.

Those leftists overseas sure are annoying, aren’t they? Always judging, always looking down at us, flaunting their health-care, being horrified at our casual acceptance of death, turning their noses up at our inferior chocolates all the while knowing that if the SHTF it’s going to be the U.S. of A. that will save the day with our F-35’s and M1 Abrams riding in to spend our blood and treasure to stamp out fascism and/or halt the spread of communism by force. Those guys overseas just don’t have the testosterone levels to do it themselves, do they?

I’m proud to be an American. I’m openly nationalist in the face of people who think “nationalism” is a dirty word akin to fascist. I get it if you think just because things are done in a certain way in the United Kingdom or the EU it doesn’t in itself mean we should do it that way here. We are different, we have a different culture, and we can come up with different solutions to problems. At the same time, if we ignore what they're doing when it works, then we're stupid.

I believe in American Exceptionalism, but I believe American Exceptionalism is a responsibility we’ve taken on ourselves and not a state of grace conferred by a higher power. If we want to be the “City upon a Hill” then we need to recognize that cities need infrastructure and rebuilding and that complacency leads to deterioration and decay. If we allow that complacency then someone else will assume that role of leadership, as they should.

The so called "gun show loophole" meme is misnamed. In reality it's private sales. Only FFL's have access the the NICS for background checks. Individuals don't.

Look, you’ve just identified a problem that can be fixed. More people need access to the NICS to do background checks. Can that be discussed by our legislatures, or is it too soon? Also, is it impossible to distinguish between gun shows that draw tens of thousands as opposed to me buying my neighbors gun? It seems to me it should be possible to legislate one and not the other. Am I wrong?

So, even tho' according to polls Universal Background checks are supported nation wide, I suspect most voters don't really know what that means. It's tantamount to the Govt interfering in private commerce between citizens because private sales likely would be prohibited with everything bought and sold through an FFL Dealer. There is an alternative with a License to show an individual has passed an NICS background check, but no legislation has been proposed AFAIK. Instead we get such things as Finestein's ban on AR-15's. It's tantamount to the "black rifle" bans that have been proposed and defeated in the past. As has been pointed out many voters vote based on single issues. One of the largest is gun rights. So, these voters are fed up with the nonsense and will vote any legislator out of office in the pro gun areas of the Country if they perceive them as anti-gun rights. This is mostly in the Heartland, the South and Southwest. Note, anyone who brings up proposed legislation is generally from the left or right coast in liberal districts and it's usually a stupid proposal that won't sell to the voters not in their districts. Consequently, nothing ever gets done.

You suspect? Likely?

You can’t complain about how the discussion might go if you refuse to participate. If all the proposals from the left don’t make sense, then people from the right should make proposals that do make sense. I agree banning “black rifles” or AR-15s isn’t the answer, but that highlighted section seems to contain a proposal that could make a difference. That some ideas don’t make sense is not an excuse to block all ideas all the time.
 
Last edited:
Once again a slippery slope logical fallacy rears it's ugly head.

Colorado implemented universal background checks ....
In 2014 I was told that the law was good for Colorado, so why not WA? If it was that good they would have written something the same as that in Colorado instead of the crap that got passed in WA.

The Democrats and Republicans are slowing eroding away the requirements of WA's bkgd check law amended by I-594. During the 2017 session SB 5552 was passed which allows me to hand a gun to a person at a rifle range so I can teach them to shoot. This was illegal unless I kept the gun at the range at all times; now I just need to be there while they use it.

WA's bkgd check bill was poorly written to say the least. The latest amendment to 9.41.113 passed with no one opposing it at all. When even the anti-gun legislators vote to change the bkgd check law, you know the law sucked or there was some serious deal making going on behind the scenes. Seeing as how everyone voted yes, I tend to lean towards "they thought the law sucked and needed to be changed" attitude.

SB 5552; http://lawfilesext.leg.wa.gov/bienn...aws/Senate/5552-S.SL.pdf?cite=2017 c 264 § 2;

SB 5552 history; http://app.leg.wa.gov/billsummary?BillNumber=5552&Year=2017
 
Once again a slippery slope logical fallacy rears it's ugly head.

Colorado implemented universal background checks after the Aurora Theater shootings. It's a minor inconvenience and a minor expense for those buying from a private seller. It's a major barrier for those who can't pass a background check who want to buy a gun anyway.

Taking a quick gander at the Colorado law, it looks to be a good model for how I'd like to see universal background checks work. It sets a low maximum cost for the service and allows for a variety of reasonable exceptions. Also makes a point of treating short-term transfers differently which makes sense to me. Seems like the type of law you'd pass to make it harder to buy guns illegally while only minimally burdening legal buyers and sellers.
 
Taking a quick gander at the Colorado law, it looks to be a good model for how I'd like to see universal background checks work. It sets a low maximum cost for the service and allows for a variety of reasonable exceptions. Also makes a point of treating short-term transfers differently which makes sense to me. Seems like the type of law you'd pass to make it harder to buy guns illegally while only minimally burdening legal buyers and sellers.

The legislative process is supposed to generate this kind of result. Ranb is correct that Washington's law wasn't as well considered. But that was a citizen initiative, not a law passed by the legislature. Why didn't the legislature act first instead of waiting for a citizen's initiative to force the issue?

I suspect that compliance with Colorado's universal background check law is far from 100%. Colorado has lots of gun rights activists who despise what those damn city dwelling leftists in the legislature have done. But even these people are going to be more careful about selling firearms under the table. Helping a stranger avoid the small fee for a background check puts you at risk of losing your right to own firearms.
 
The legislative process is supposed to generate this kind of result. Ranb is correct that Washington's law wasn't as well considered. But that was a citizen initiative, not a law passed by the legislature. Why didn't the legislature act first instead of waiting for a citizen's initiative to force the issue?
The Democrats killed the bkgd check bill (1588-2014) in committee by refusing to give it an executive hearing. I suspect that the initiative passed partly due to the "pink unicorn, everyone's going to love this" summary in the WA voter's guide which didn't have the key words "all transfers without limitation" in it.

Based on my conversations with people, most don't bother to read beyond the summary in the voter's guide prior to voting yes. I've voted no on various initiatives without going further than the guide, but a yes vote gets more research on my part.

I suspect that compliance with Colorado's universal background check law is far from 100%. Colorado has lots of gun rights activists who despise what those damn city dwelling leftists in the legislature have done. But even these people are going to be more careful about selling firearms under the table. Helping a stranger avoid the small fee for a background check puts you at risk of losing your right to own firearms.
I know it is the case in WA. Soon after I-594 passed a bunch of people gathered Olympia to opening violate the ban in front of the police; no arrests were made. As far as I know only one arrest for a violation of the new law has been made; it got lots of press. I think we'd hear more about it if there were others. Much has been made about criminals who were foolish enough to test the system at a gun store and were denied; no arrests made even though the 4473 is a written confession for the most part.
 
No, you're right. I got my figures by asking my phone and got a global figure of 1.3 million instead of the national figure. Using your figure one is only about 3 1/2 times more likely to die in a car crash in a year.

No, you've moved the goalposts - deaths from guns and death in vehicles are approximately the same.

What are the relative odds of being murdered by a vehicle and by a gun?
 
No, you've moved the goalposts - deaths from guns and death in vehicles are approximately the same.

What are the relative odds of being murdered by a vehicle and by a gun?
Thread back and you will see you are the one who is moving the goalposts, or at least misidentifying them.

The question was about how safe do you feel, and if it's rational to feel so unsafe that you need to carry a gun to protect yourself from hostile shooters, such as the church shooting that started this thread. My opinion is if you think the one in ten thousand odds per year is a significant threat, then you are too paranoid for me to feel comfortable with you having a gun.

I have no doubt far more people are murdered with guns than with cars, and that probably holds true for almost any lethal weapon.



Sent from my LG-LS997 using Tapatalk
 
Is Czech society that violent?
Do you carry a gun when you nip to the shop for a pint of milk or go to work?

Couldn't you be 'shot like a chicken' anyway? How would a potential shooter know you were carrying a concealed weapon?

Czech is perfectly fine. In Prague at night, I might get robbed. I most probably would be. Stabbed if I had really bad luck. But shot ? Hardly. Not our sport.
I'm talking about US. Where the sport of shooting people is very popular.
I can't imagine living in US, and have my family shot in front of my eyes, in calm and methodical way, the way it was done in this church shooting, being just unable to do anything. Sure, you can't prepare for everything. But you can prepare for something. I'd rather spend the money, spend the time, risk the chance of accident, risk the chance of suicide.
 
Pair arrested after harassing pastor in Sutherland Springs

Two conspiracy theorists who have pushed the idea that the mass shooting at Sutherland Springs on Nov. 5 didn’t happen were arrested Monday at First Baptist Church, the site of the massacre, after the church’s pastor accused them of repeatedly harassing the community.
“He said, ‘Your daughter never even existed. Show me her birth certificate. Show me anything to say she was here,’” Pomeroy said. “I just told him there was enough evidence already visible, so if he chooses not to see that, how would I know he would believe anything else?”

The website’s homepage features a photo of a United States map with the words: “Truth is treason in the empire of lies.” It presents videos purporting to show Sutherland Springs residents practicing the shooting as “nothing but a staged drill.” There is audio of a victim’s family calling him and angrily demanding he leave her family alone.

The most recent post is a video of David Hogg, a student activist at the Florida high school, with the words “EXPOSED” superimposed on his forehead. The description: “100% proof of another staged drill.”

“Before talking to him today, I thought he was trying to play some angle,” Pomeroy said. “But I think he’s truly demented. I think he truly believes his own rhetoric. I can’t explain it.”

:mad:Distasteful CTers.:mad:
 

I heard a snippet about this on the radio and both of the people on the radio commented that the pastor showed more restraint than polite society has any right to expect from the father of teenaged shooting victim. I think part of his restraint may be due to the fact that he knew of them and likely expected they would show up eventually. Still, the man has been through too much already.
 
I heard a snippet about this on the radio and both of the people on the radio commented that the pastor showed more restraint than polite society has any right to expect from the father of teenaged shooting victim. I think part of his restraint may be due to the fact that he knew of them and likely expected they would show up eventually. Still, the man has been through too much already.

The man showed more restraint, dignity and class than we as a society should have to expect.

It's also a said commentary on society that if the pastor had reacted in an understandably less restrained manner that some CT'ist would cite that as "proof that they were getting close to the truth."
 
The man showed more restraint, dignity and class than we as a society should have to expect.

It's also a said commentary on society that if the pastor had reacted in an understandably less restrained manner that some CT'ist would cite that as "proof that they were getting close to the truth."
Whereas the fact that he DIDN'T react violently is also proof they were close to the truth.
 
I heard a snippet about this on the radio and both of the people on the radio commented that the pastor showed more restraint than polite society has any right to expect from the father of teenaged shooting victim. I think part of his restraint may be due to the fact that he knew of them and likely expected they would show up eventually. Still, the man has been through too much already.
Shedload more strength of restraint than I think I would be able to summon.

Poor bloke.
 
The man showed more restraint, dignity and class than we as a society should have to expect.

It's also a said commentary on society that if the pastor had reacted in an understandably less restrained manner that some CT'ist would cite that as "proof that they were getting close to the truth."


Probably a sadder commentary that it is unlikely there is anything that some CTist wouldn't cite as "proof that they were getting close to the truth."

Irrefutable evidence that it really happened?

"Just shows how well planned the false flag operation was!"

They got to everybody!!!" :jaw-dropp​
 
Shedload more strength of restraint than I think I would be able to summon.

Poor bloke.

It is all his training in acting that let him do that of course. You have to keep up with NRA views on the "victims" of such mass shootings.
 
God, I clicked on this thread expecting, really knowing, what I would be reading. And still somehow this pastor having to put up with these ******** really gets to me. Can a man not grieve his unfathomable loss in some semblance of peace?

I'm really restraining myself from falling into a fuelair inspired tirade. The sadness of the situation overpowers my anger, though.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom