Mass shooting in small town Texas

Why is there such an interest in Private Sales of firearms? I asked someone earlier to name an incident involving a firearm that was acquired via private sale illegally. He couldn't answer. That question is open for anyone to answer as I know of NONE.
...


Can I just do this in bulk and name every backroom private transfer in any city (ex. NYC) where such is illegal?

Why is that a blind spot for you?

I have no problem with private sales among responsible shooters.
Our problem is once it gets into the wild and the new owner is more concerned with not being caught with it, another five transfers down the road and city cops are seizing it up in a raid... or worse, tagging it at the scene of a fatality.

Right now, I'm not even sure I trust the FFL system, it's all so bolloxed.
I sold a couple pistols to a known, long established shop in the Bay Area ~20 years ago. The next year I got a call from an LA area detective (Orange Cty maybe)... one of them had been used in a felony (burglary, robbery... don't recall TBH, I was pretty shook by the call).

Paperwork filled out and signed at time of sale... never filed I guess.
I was still the registered owner. :rolleyes:

Legal sale... it still got into the wild and into the hands of a bad actor. :mad:
 
Last edited:
I have no problem with private sales among responsible shooters.

Then let's make laws again armed robbery, murder and other things that bad guys do. All the current proposals do is punish normal folks from doing the things they should be allowed to do in a free society.

Anyway, this is the first time I've heard of an incident like this, but at least it wasn't murder.

BTW, the FFL Dealer should have been in a lot of trouble once you proved you had sold them the firearm. What's up with that or did you follow up on it. I'd have been really pissed...
 
I am not playing semantics. I have clearly stated that unless a medical professional can show a diagnosis and attribute a named mental health illness to him, he is not mentally ill. I do accept forum members shouting repeatedly he was mental, as evidence, let alone proof he had an actual illness.

I have shown the evidence as to why he was an angry man hell bent on some sort of revenge against other members of his family.

I have to agree with this.

Common sense seems to always seek a relationship between how bad an act is and how sick the perpetrator.

There's going to be a range of people -- people who really seem to have been psychotic like ?Holmes the movie theater shooter, to those who are just angry ideologically-motivated jerks like the white supremacist shooter of that black church.

We almost need to go back to the old psychiatric notion of "moral insanity".
 
Then let's make laws again armed robbery, murder and other things that bad guys do. All the current proposals do is punish normal folks from doing the things they should be allowed to do in a free society.

Anyway, this is the first time I've heard of an incident like this, but at least it wasn't murder.

BTW, the FFL Dealer should have been in a lot of trouble once you proved you had sold them the firearm. What's up with that or did you follow up on it. I'd have been really pissed...


I just did a quick check and the store's not listed anymore.
Probably there for fifty years... maybe I caught 'em on the downward slide.

And did you miss Sid's explanation of the Czech system?
We could manage something like that... have a registration/license card that says you're good to go. Not tracking the guns, just a way for a seller to verify a buyer's at least recently (5 ys? 10?) cleared to purchase.
It might even bring back some of our lost traditions of teaching skills and respect for a firearm if you want to be able to have one... not the way they're seen now as some abomination to be feared, lest it jump up and bite. :rolleyes:
 
The minority of tables sell guns, some are FFL's while some are private collections. This is what I've seen in WA, CA and HI for the most part.
.

As I said, facilitating private transactions. (Never said quantity or ratio).

You can see old men walking with placards trying to sell guns. You don't need a table.
 
Last edited:
How do you propose the buyer do that?



I believe you're assuming there is a licensing requirement to purchase a firearm. That is true in only a very few States. In most there is no license requirement.



The only way to determine for certain an individual is not a prohibited person is to access the NICS database. Currently, only FFL Dealers can do this.

The first requirement is to convince people like me that private sales are a problem. I don't think they are. Most private transactions are between people who know one another, not at gun shows. They are simply not the problem that some politicians would have you believe.

Look, I have gone to lots of gun shows in the past. Most of the private sales there are hunting type rifles or shotguns just prior to hunting season. It's rare to see an AR-15 or one of the other so called "assault rifles" or pistols in my "neck of the woods".

Investigators try to determine the original of every firearm used in a crime. I've never heard of one acquired in a private sale. There could be a few, but I've never heard of any.

I know the US doesn't have some kind of licensing for firearms like we do here, but apparantly there is some kind of database where your name is entered when you're not allowed fire arms anymore, albeit now only accessible by gun dealer (and police etc, etc).
If people can ask for an extract concerning their own status in said database that would help the buyer to prove he is allowed to buy a firearm.

The seller is responsible for any fire arm he owned, unless he can prove he got rid of it in a legal way (if stolen that would mean declaring it to the police), meaning having a form for the sale and proof he sold it to a person who was allowed to own that firearm at the moment of sale.

If acces to the database by anybody not of official gun shops, it would be possible to have private gun sales to go through an official gundealer, for the check on the validity of the buyers allowance.
The first way puts the onus and the cost on the buyer though, which would be more fitting, I think.
 
And did you miss Sid's explanation of the Czech system?
We could manage something like that... have a registration/license card that says you're good to go. Not tracking the guns, just a way for a seller to verify a buyer's at least recently (5 ys? 10?) cleared to purchase.
It might even bring back some of our lost traditions of teaching skills and respect for a firearm if you want to be able to have one... not the way they're seen now as some abomination to be feared, lest it jump up and bite. :rolleyes:

I did miss your reference. That sounds like something I could support. That sounds unobtrusive and legitimate. I do have a handgun carry permit and this would be similar and something that is not too intrusive....

I think anything that focuses on people as opposed to firearms is alright. The devil is in the details tho'....
 
Last edited:
If acces to the database by anybody not of official gun shops, it would be possible to have private gun sales to go through an official gundealer, for the check on the validity of the buyers allowance.
The first way puts the onus and the cost on the buyer though, which would be more fitting, I think.

That's the problem. People won't support an intrusive scheme that requires and FFL for private transactions. It simply won't sell. As I explained below I don't think I have a problem with schemes that focus on the individual.

It is an added cost, but I think most folks would support a scheme like that. Again, the details are important....

Anything that goes after guns is a non-starter. Proposals that focuses on an individual would be supported by most folks, I think...
 
Last edited:
I did miss your reference. That sounds like something I could support. That sounds unobtrusive and legitimate. I do have a handgun carry permit and this would be similar and something that is not too intrusive....


See... there's lots of room for us shooting enthusiasts to work the problem, we just either lack the will, or find the effort blocked by absolutists.
But if we don't work the problem, rest assured... it'll just be taken away from us. And I'd rather the changes over the next thirty years be crafted by us, than by the Brady Bunch.
We can fix it... or we can lose it.

We've lost the environment of yore, when kids could bring their plinkers to school for an afternoon session with their friends, keeping them for the day in a locker or an office. They might be late for dinner, but they weren't often shooting each other (oddly... we managed to use just the BB guns for that).

Nowadays it's video game violence porn all around the world, amplifying the fascination of firearms especially among those who've never spent time with them.
But unlike the rest of the Western world... we have a tragically abundant supply of the real things, either conveniently unlocked at home, or carried illicitly by one's street buddies in the city.

This is not a good recipe. Not for an ever more urbanized twenty first century. :(
 
Last edited:
This is not a good recipe. :(

Well, I see you're an old fart like me longing for the days when this was not an issue...

The problem that I've seen for a long time is that the anti-gun idgits in Congress want to go after guns or accessories. This is very, very stupid. It's a non-starter among Americans like me and I think for you too. Count me as a supporter of an individual licensing system that licenses an individual. Again, let's keep the tools off the table and concentrate on people. Guns are not the problem, people are.
 
Well, I see you're an old fart like me longing for the days when this was not an issue...

The problem that I've seen for a long time is that the anti-gun idgits in Congress want to go after guns or accessories. This is very, very stupid. It's a non-starter among Americans like me and I think for you too. Count me as a supporter of an individual licensing system that licenses an individual. Again, let's keep the tools off the table and concentrate on people. Guns are not the problem, people are.


I agree.

High emotion by the absolutists, on both sides (don't give me that look) are killing any chance for reasonable change as we move forward.

The shooter side won't accept anything, thinking it'll mean confiscation becomes ten years down the road (as if).

The grabbers (and there really are only a few hard liners) don't really wan't to abolish private ownership... they just want the killing to stop. That one's harder to argue against.

While the rest of the world either... face-palms, eye-rolls, or holds down the rising bile as they wonder how the hell did we allow so many to become so irresponsible?

And that's hard to argue against as well. :(
 
See... there's lots of room for us shooting enthusiasts to work the problem, we just either lack the will, or find the effort blocked by absolutists.
But if we don't work the problem, rest assured... it'll just be taken away from us. And I'd rather the changes over the next thirty years be crafted by us, than by the Brady Bunch.
We can fix it... or we can lose it.

We've lost the environment of yore, when kids could bring their plinkers to school for an afternoon session with their friends, keeping them for the day in a locker or an office. They might be late for dinner, but they weren't often shooting each other (oddly... we managed to use just the BB guns for that).

Nowadays it's video game violence porn all around the world, amplifying the fascination of firearms especially among those who've never spent time with them.
But unlike the rest of the Western world... we have a tragically abundant supply of the real things, either conveniently unlocked at home, or carried illicitly by one's street buddies in the city.

This is not a good recipe. Not for an ever more urbanized twenty first century. :(

What about when you look at actual statistics that show that it is better than it used to be? In the old days it was great, no one cared about shootings unless it was in their town so they could pretend that such things didn't happen. We need to stop reporting on these shootings to regain that kind of perspective.
 
Well only someone crazy would do that. Same reasoning as you like so much.

That's not my line of reasoning at all. Having said that, there are some instances where domestic violence may be a clear sign on mental illness.

Here what I said to you. Yet, having been clearly spelled out for you, you insist on making stuff up and misrepresenting me.

I would posit that, outside of spur of the moment, single suspect(meant victim) crimes of passion, anybody who plans to kill one or more people in a culture where such an action is an absolute anathema must be mentally ill, even if only momentarily.

I understand that you don't agree with me but this is a tiresome habit.
 
That's not my line of reasoning at all.

What reasoning do you have beyond the argument from incredulity?

Here what I said to you. Yet, having been clearly spelled out for you, you insist on making stuff up and misrepresenting me.

You have been very clear about not referencing any kind of professional assessment, or engaging in a logical fallacy? Your argument boils down to either argument from incredulity or circular arguments. THose work fine to make any criminal action you want a mark of insanity. Basic reductio ad absurdum.


I understand that you don't agree with me but this is a tiresome habit.

Make an actual logically valid argument.
 
Exactly act of god, nothing to be done, just accept it and move on in ignorance.

I'm sorry you feel that nothing can be done and I'm disappointed that you think that some omnipotent being controls events such as these.

Lets see what I said about "nothing to be done".

The real threat is mental illness, not the mentally ill. Start there

I've highlighted my very general advice to you Americans. I'm not in any position to help you any further. I feel that it's a good place to start looking at what can be done.
 
On the plus side, for those who imagine all we do all day is shoot at each other...

We do kill a lot of our own, a damn lot, far too many.
About 40,000 a year with a quarter or so being true homicides.

But...

We're a pretty big country, with a pretty big population. 300 some-odd million.
And damn near that many guns (~240 million or so IIRC).

But we shoot a stunningly large number of rounds.
It's really hard to pin down figures, but a decade or so ago, I came under the impression that a rough figure on sales was between one and two billion total rounds a year. Every year.
And those are being shot. Private stockpiles don't jump up year to year... if you're used to having 15 thousand rounds on hand, you probably have had that on average for several years or more.

So yes... a tragically large number of people keep getting murdered.
But it's a minuscule fraction of the number of shots we're firing every year.

The people who actually enjoy firearms and shoot so many of those rounds, tens of millions of us, aren't shooting each other.

Please keep the "responsible until he wasn't" rhetoric to oneself.
It's not wrong... I just don't need to hear it.
I've had this oddity rolling around my head for years and just wanted to put it out there. No agenda behind it.


---
* I've seen guesstimates of more like ten billion in annual sales, but that's so far from what's been stuck in my head... I'd rather lowball the number and wait for one of our handful with close ties to the sport to correct me.
 
On the plus side, for those who imagine all we do all day is shoot at each other...

We do kill a lot of our own, a damn lot, far too many.
About 40,000 a year with a quarter or so being true homicides.

Presumably there are several times that number of injuries as well :(
 
I'm sorry you feel that nothing can be done and I'm disappointed that you think that some omnipotent being controls events such as these.

I don't think an omnipotent being controls this anymore than it does the weather, but both must be treated as outside the control of man to be politically palatable in the republican controlled world. So no talk of global warming or fighting the scapegoating of the mentally ill.


I've highlighted my very general advice to you Americans. I'm not in any position to help you any further. I feel that it's a good place to start looking at what can be done.

All the people in the US who say it is about mental illness are simply doing that because it gives them something to blame that they can safely do nothing about, well maybe cut back on more requirements for insurance to cover mental health coverage. It isn't like these republicans have some great universal mental health system they are proposing that even if it was mental health issues causing this would resolve anything.

Funny how that if it is a brown person doing this it is all suddenly not mental health but immigration that needs to be fixed.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom