Mass shooting in small town Texas

What about when you look at actual statistics that show that it is better than it used to be? In the old days it was great, no one cared about shootings unless it was in their town so they could pretend that such things didn't happen. We need to stop reporting on these shootings to regain that kind of perspective.


You're not entirely wrong.
While street gangs were more West Side Story than Capone's Mob for a long time... gun violence is not new, and yes stats show improvement in many (most?) areas.
We're changing. Just painfully slowly, and idiotically disorganized (ed-ly? :confused: )

But yeah... pearl clutching and hand wringing not only doesn't, you know... help solve the issue, but I'm one who agrees that coverage encourages the next. And the next, etc, etc.
 
What reasoning do you have beyond the argument from incredulity?



You have been very clear about not referencing any kind of professional assessment, or engaging in a logical fallacy? Your argument boils down to either argument from incredulity or circular arguments. THose work fine to make any criminal action you want a mark of insanity. Basic reductio ad absurdum.




Make an actual logically valid argument.

The fact that you think quoting logical fallacies wins the day concerns me. This isn't a six form debating club and I'm not debating the issue with you. I'm stating my opinion and, as I've said repeatedly, I'm delighted to wallow in my ignorance.

My position is clear and if you find it untenable, then I really don't give a fig. We'll have to agree to disagree.

Mentally ill will suffice for me, I care not a jot about any further diagnosis.

The problem seems to be almost exclusively American these days, so as I've said, they should look at mental illness and start there. It can't hurt.
 
Presumably there are several times that number of injuries as well :(


Fair point.

I think 50 Cent brags about taking nine himself, several at one go.
It's tragic to have an accidental shooting fatality, when the damn things are so unreliable when that's an acceptable, intended outcome. :(
 
Aren't you the one who thought Kyle (that broken specimen himself) was sniping from the roof of the Superdome? :rolleyes:

I just brought that up as the acts one associates with a True American Hero(tm). His claims to have killed so many blacks then never exactly hurt his popularity. So he makes a useful mark of how inconsistent this view of what a proper gun owner must look like. Being a compulsive liar who brags about murders he committed is ok by most gun owners it seems.
 
I just brought that up as the acts one associates with a True American Hero(tm). His claims to have killed so many blacks then never exactly hurt his popularity. So he makes a useful mark of how inconsistent this view of what a proper gun owner must look like. Being a compulsive liar who brags about murders he committed is ok by most gun owners it seems.


It does? :confused:

Just shows how out of touch I am... I'll wait for others to agree with you.


-- Those Katrina claims, punching Ventura, god knows what else... are such crap, I can't quite imagine who believed half of what he published. Like I said... damaged specimen
 
Last edited:
I don't think an omnipotent being controls this anymore than it does the weather, but both must be treated as outside the control of man to be politically palatable in the republican controlled world. So no talk of global warming or fighting the scapegoating of the mentally ill.

You mentioned God, I'm confused and what has global warming got to do with a mentally ill man shooting 26 men, women and children?

It is difficult to control and mitigate the sudden onset of mental illness, I wholeheartedly agree. I think, that being the case, you might want to look at markers, such as say...... fracturing your own childs skull as indicating some form of imbalance. As I've said, mental illness, a good place to start
 
Last edited:
You mentioned God, I'm confused and what has global warming got to do with a mentally ill man shooting 26 men, women and children?

I mention acts of god. It is a basic part of the law and does not reference any belief in the existence of a god.

"Act of God
An event that directly and exclusively results from the occurrence of natural causes that could not have been prevented by the exercise of foresight or caution; an inevitable accident.
Courts have recognized various events as acts of God—tornadoes, earthquakes, death, extraordinarily high tides, violent winds, and floods. Many insurance policies for property damage exclude from their protection damage caused by acts of God."

https://legal-dictionary.thefreedictionary.com/act+of+god
 
I mention acts of god. It is a basic part of the law and does not reference any belief in the existence of a god.

"Act of God
An event that directly and exclusively results from the occurrence of natural causes that could not have been prevented by the exercise of foresight or caution; an inevitable accident.
Courts have recognized various events as acts of God—tornadoes, earthquakes, death, extraordinarily high tides, violent winds, and floods. Many insurance policies for property damage exclude from their protection damage caused by acts of God."

https://legal-dictionary.thefreedictionary.com/act+of+god

I know, I was yanking your chain.
 
Because it is a convenient scapegoat. They have to blame something, and as this was a white guy they can't blame immigration and other such issues used for non white shooters. So the options are thinking about gun control or blaming mental illness as if it was something that could not ever possibly have anything done about it. That makes saying it was a mental health issue the politically correct answer.

Like claiming self defence, when it clearly is not.

I just do not get why it is so hard for some to accept there are some very angry, aggressive, evil people in society, who should not be allowed access to guns
 
Last edited:
I just do not get why it is so hard for some to accept there are some very angry, aggressive, evil people in society, who should be allowed access to guns

You left out a NOT there.

Who is denying that? The problem is that the proposed solutions are not focused on people, but on the evil guns.

Do you not get that yet?
 
Last edited:
You left out a NOT there.

Who is denying that? The problem is that the proposed solutions are not focused on people, but on the evil guns.

Do you not get that yet?

I have edited my post to add in the not. :)

As for solutions, there is none. Like an amputee, the leg will not grow back, so the only option is to learn to live with mass shootings and excessive gun deaths.
 
You left out a NOT there.

Who is denying that? The problem is that the proposed solutions are not focused on people, but on the evil guns.

Do you not get that yet?

So why don't we see any republicans trying to address and improve mental health care instead of reducing people access to it? If it is a mental health problem why not try to do something about that?

The answer of course is that it isn't the real problem for this just the fig leaf they need for political correctness on it never being about guns or violent abusive people having them.
 
As for solutions, there is none. Like an amputee, the leg will not grow back, so the only option is to learn to live with mass shootings and excessive gun deaths.

What ever satisfies your obsession. Very probable I am of Scottish heritage like you and we have over come worse problems than this. Rest assured this will be over come. It's shame that most of our politicians think like you do that getting rid of guns will solve all problems. Maybe they'll get a clue some day apparently like you have...
 
As I mentioned earlier, mass shootings are nothing new, but started to really pick up after 1985, in 90s, and they are still on a rise. Why is that ?

Violent video game is only one reason for some who do not realize they are fiction, but not the only one. Lack of proper parenting is another. There are other reasons, but I'll leave it to prolific pundits to delineate those.
 
Violent video game is only one reason for some who do not realize they are fiction, but not the only one. Lack of proper parenting is another. There are other reasons, but I'll leave it to prolific pundits to delineate those.

I think the answer is gnash gnash... Trump, gnash gnash.... white equals, gnash gnash... brown skin, gnash gnash.... republicans, gnash gnash.... scapegoating...
 
Violent video game is only one reason for some who do not realize they are fiction, but not the only one. Lack of proper parenting is another. There are other reasons, but I'll leave it to prolific pundits to delineate those.

...and a significant loosening of gun controls :p
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom