Mass shooting in small town Texas

I think gun show loophole is an appropriate term as they are literally conventions meant to facilitate these transactions. If I made a law that regulated concussions in sports, it would be totally appropriate to call it the NFL law even though other sports are affected.

No, they're not. Obviously, you've never been to one or else you're being sarcastic.
 
I think gun show loophole is an appropriate term as they are literally conventions meant to facilitate these transactions. If I made a law that regulated concussions in sports, it would be totally appropriate to call it the NFL law even though other sports are affected.
Not sure what kinds of gun shows you'e used to attending, but here is my take on them. A vendor pays a fee to rent a table on which to display their wares. Some of the tables are not actually gun related; food, books, clothes. A large portion of the tables selling gun stuff are selling accessories only. The minority of tables sell guns, some are FFL's while some are private collections. This is what I've seen in WA, CA and HI for the most part.

FFL's are allowed to sell guns at their licensed place of business and at a gun show; nowhere else.
 
He has a moral obligation to do that. How do you suggest that be done?

I think the other posters have it mostly covered. I'm selling a weapon privately, I can choose to ask the person buying the weapon to demonstrate that they are legally entitled to do so, but I am under no obligation to check.

What if I know for certain that the person is ineligible to own a weapon, for example I know that they have been convicted of a major felony in the past or I know that they have just had their licence revoked ? Under those circumstances is it still legal for me to sell that weapon ?
 
I am consider visiting England again. I lived there for 3 years in the 80's. I was in East Anglia, but in London many times. Where or whom should I avoid.

The places you would avoid at home, run down inner city estates after dark. Do not go down dark alley ways because someone offers to sell you something.
 
I think the other posters have it mostly covered. I'm selling a weapon privately, I can choose to ask the person buying the weapon to demonstrate that they are legally entitled to do so, but I am under no obligation to check.

What if I know for certain that the person is ineligible to own a weapon, for example I know that they have been convicted of a major felony in the past or I know that they have just had their licence revoked ? Under those circumstances is it still legal for me to sell that weapon ?

I suspect that some ask and some don't. I don't know for certain. It's likely no one does know. I have never sold a firearm privately or otherwise. I have bought two hunting rifles privately because I wanted models that were not being currently produced, therefore not available from a dealer, but were available from a private individual. No, I was not asked if I was a prohibited person.

I am certain it is illegal for a prohibited person to buy a weapon privately or otherwise. I pretty sure that if someone knowingly sold to a prohibited person they could be prosecuted, but that likely would be impossible to prove.

The problem with prohibiting private sales is one of expense, significant inconvenience and questionably Constitutionally legal. Firearms would need to only be sold by an FFL because only they have access to the NICS database. Currently, a lot of folks swap or trade firearms among their friends and/or relatives. Some will likely continue doing that regardless of the law and that would make them victimless criminals. What about passing firearms to ones descendants? How would that be handled? I'm not sure that kind of system would be Constitutional as it is definitely infringement.

The NICS definitely needs refinement. There are too many errors in it and one needs to be able to question a erroneous ruling.
 
I suspect that some ask and some don't. I don't know for certain. It's likely no one does know. I have never sold a firearm privately or otherwise. I have bought two hunting rifles privately because I wanted models that were not being currently produced, therefore not available from a dealer, but were available from a private individual. No, I was not asked if I was a prohibited person.

I am certain it is illegal for a prohibited person to buy a weapon privately or otherwise. I pretty sure that if someone knowingly sold to a prohibited person they could be prosecuted, but that likely would be impossible to prove.

The problem with prohibiting private sales is one of expense, significant inconvenience and questionably Constitutionally legal. Firearms would need to only be sold by an FFL because only they have access to the NICS database. Currently, a lot of folks swap or trade firearms among their friends and/or relatives. Some will likely continue doing that regardless of the law and that would make them victimless criminals. What about passing firearms to ones descendants? How would that be handled? I'm not sure that kind of system would be Constitutional as it is definitely infringement.

The NICS definitely needs refinement. There are too many errors in it and one needs to be able to question a erroneous ruling.

Thank you for the clarification.
 
I think the other posters have it mostly covered. I'm selling a weapon privately, I can choose to ask the person buying the weapon to demonstrate that they are legally entitled to do so, but I am under no obligation to check.

What if I know for certain that the person is ineligible to own a weapon, for example I know that they have been convicted of a major felony in the past or I know that they have just had their licence revoked ? Under those circumstances is it still legal for me to sell that weapon ?

"Don't ask, don't tell"?
 
This is the stupidest semantic game I have seen in a while, trying to prove that Kelley was not "mentally ill".
Sorry, but people who are mentally ill do not do what he did.
I know it is painful to agree with the Orange Menace (and it would be hard to have a lower opinion of the idiot at 1600 Pennslyvania Avenue then I do) but he was right about Kelley;The guy had severe mental problems.and andy differend then those and being mentally Ill is just a matter of semantics.

I am not playing semantics. I have clearly stated that unless a medical professional can show a diagnosis and attribute a named mental health illness to him, he is not mentally ill. I do accept forum members shouting repeatedly he was mental, as evidence, let alone proof he had an actual illness.

I have shown the evidence as to why he was an angry man hell bent on some sort of revenge against other members of his family.
 
What if I know for certain that the person is ineligible to own a weapon, for example I know that they have been convicted of a major felony in the past or I know that they have just had their licence revoked ? Under those circumstances is it still legal for me to sell that weapon ?

Why is there such an interest in Private Sales of firearms? I asked someone earlier to name an incident involving a firearm that was acquired via private sale illegally. He couldn't answer. That question is open for anyone to answer as I know of NONE.

Is it the catchy "gun show loophole" meme that anti-gun politicians like to use? Of course, they won't use the correct term of private sales because most folks wouldn't appreciate Govt interference into their private activities. I love it when they invent these terms that hide the real intent.. like this one and "Assault weapon", which is another good example.

I just noticed something in your post that I overlooked the first time. Licensing - A few States require a license to acquire a firearm, but most don't.
 
Like I said, it's perfectly clear where I'm coming from. I have no need to diagnose an individual who murdered 26 men woman and children in cold blood with a specific illness just to indulge you in the contortions you're going to pull for absolutely no good end other than to argue across each other.

I think he was mentally ill, let that be the end of it. You can scrabble for a more specific diagnosis if it gives you a deeper understanding. Like I said I'm quite happy to wallow in my ignorance.

Exactly act of god, nothing to be done, just accept it and move on in ignorance.
 
Thanks for this, I think all this talk about mental illness is a bit of a red herring as it isn't mutually exclusive of anything. I would add to your list Hate crimes which could be a separate category or maybe it could be incorporated in the terrorism category.

Look the problem is always mental illness or immigration because otherwise the problem might be guns. As we know from first principles it can never be guns it must be mental illness, though of course not the kind that needs any change or improvement to our mental health system. But we need a scapegoat and when we can't blame immigration we have to blame mental illness.
 
I do not get why Trump and others have latched onto mental health as the cause, with no evidence and plenty of other reasons why people go on massacres.

Because it is a convenient scapegoat. They have to blame something, and as this was a white guy they can't blame immigration and other such issues used for non white shooters. So the options are thinking about gun control or blaming mental illness as if it was something that could not ever possibly have anything done about it. That makes saying it was a mental health issue the politically correct answer.
 
Please, take you personal dislike of religion out of this discussion. It's totally irrevelent.

I am not using it in a religious sense. I am using it in the legal sense, as an disaster outside of human control. This is exactly what this shootings are in american politics.
 
Why is there such an interest in Private Sales of firearms? I asked someone earlier to name an incident involving a firearm that was acquired via private sale illegally. He couldn't answer. That question is open for anyone to answer as I know of NONE.

Is it the catchy "gun show loophole" meme that anti-gun politicians like to use? Of course, they won't use the correct term of private sales because most folks wouldn't appreciate Govt interference into their private activities. I love it when they invent these terms that hide the real intent.. like this one and "Assault weapon", which is another good example.

I just noticed something in your post that I overlooked the first time. Licensing - A few States require a license to acquire a firearm, but most don't.

Coming from a different country with an entirely different attitude towards firearms and completely different laws pertaining to the sale, storage and use of them, I was trying to learn something about the private sale process.

edited to add.....

I had no idea that it was so easy and IMO if people are happy with the process then it would make sense for waiting periods and background check requirements to be removed from licensed firearms dealers so they can compete on a level playing field with private sellers.
 
Last edited:
He has a moral obligation to do that. How do you suggest that be done?

I think an obligation of the buyer to give proof he is allowed to buy a gun would be appropriate.

If an extract of the buyers license can be obtained by the buyer (say by using his/her Social security number, to make sure only that person can obtaine the extract) and the seller has to keep that proof (which also absolves the sellers responsibility of said firearm from that moment on) this would close that loophole.

Can be finetuned of course, but you got the picture.
 
I think an obligation of the buyer to give proof he is allowed to buy a gun would be appropriate.

How do you propose the buyer do that?

If an extract of the buyers license can be obtained by the buyer (say by using his/her Social security number, to make sure only that person can obtaine the extract) and the seller has to keep that proof (which also absolves the sellers responsibility of said firearm from that moment on) this would close that loophole.

I believe you're assuming there is a licensing requirement to purchase a firearm. That is true in only a very few States. In most there is no license requirement.

Can be finetuned of course, but you got the picture.

The only way to determine for certain an individual is not a prohibited person is to access the NICS database. Currently, only FFL Dealers can do this.

The first requirement is to convince people like me that private sales are a problem. I don't think they are. Most private transactions are between people who know one another, not at gun shows. They are simply not the problem that some politicians would have you believe.

Look, I have gone to lots of gun shows in the past. Most of the private sales there are hunting type rifles or shotguns just prior to hunting season. It's rare to see an AR-15 or one of the other so called "assault rifles" or pistols in my "neck of the woods".

Investigators try to determine the original of every firearm used in a crime. I've never heard of one acquired in a private sale. There could be a few, but I've never heard of any.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom