Mass shooting in small town Texas

See the point I made earlier about trump instantly blaming mental illness for white shooters and terrorism for muslim ones? That is exactly what many americans do, Trump ran for president on it. That is why he ran on a muslim ban not on a mental illness ban.

That has nothing to do with this thread. That is not why Devin Patrick Kelley killed 26 people. Keep you personal agenda out of the discussion, it's a derail.
 
Again, you are missing the point.

The real threat is mental illness, not the mentally ill. Start there.

But it isn't a threat you can prepare for, because there are no diagnostic criteria for this. So how is this not just washing your hands of any effort to prevent it?

Why not apply this to all violent crime as well? What does that change anything?

You can't diagnose him and mass shooter like his as mentally ill until they have their killing spree so how is that supposed to be helpful?

It seems better to focus on violent people who have domestic violence crimes and make sure they don't get guns. But clearly domestic violence is also just mental illness or some such.
 
And of course the trick is was he crazy before he killed them, or is it only in killing a bunch of people that by definition makes him crazy.

This is not a terribly useful definition of crazy, it has no predictive power for one. It certainly isn't tied to any clinical definitions of mental illness and as such can not be treated before the mass murder.

Everyone is a responsible gun owner (and war hero) till they aren't. Does that help?
 
That has nothing to do with this thread. That is not why Devin Patrick Kelley killed 26 people. Keep you personal agenda out of the discussion, it's a derail.

It is really just an act of god, and as such there is nothing we can do and we just need to accept that these things happen. Mental Illness like this will strike without warning anywhere at anytime. But at least with white people.
 
Everyone is a responsible gun owner (and war hero) till they aren't. Does that help?

I think we just need to think of those killed as touched by god. It was an act of god that caused this guy to go crazy and there was nothing anyone could ever have done to prevent it. And crazy is better for this than mentally ill, it means you aren't even trying to give a psychiatric diagnosis, but rather depending on logical fallacies to do it.
 
We've already gone through that.

You guys are arguing the toss for the sake of it.

Sorry, I don't see anything from you as to what mental illness you think he had. Could you please either link to where you said which mental illness or repeat which one you think it is.
 
It is really just an act of god, and as such there is nothing we can do and we just need to accept that these things happen. Mental Illness like this will strike without warning anywhere at anytime. But at least with white people.

Have you any idea which mental illness he suffered from?
 
I would do a venn diagram, but I don't have the tech to do it, so....

The people who mass shoot tend to be;

1 - criminals (shooting during criminal acts including gangs)

2 - angry people (shooting out of revenge or rage, heat of the moment)

3 - scared people (shooting out of fear including self defence)

4 - planned terrorist acts (politically motivated)

5 - the mentally ill (but you need a diagnosis such as schizophrenia)

6 - youths (which covers the horrible instances of children getting hold of guns).

There are lots of overlaps between them. Many terrorists are also angry people and are acting in revenge. Many youths are also in gangs. Criminals often have mental health issues. There are others with no overlaps, like someone scared they are in mortal danger from a thief with a baseball bat, is not acting as a terrorist.

Kelley definitely was in the angry person category. There may be an overlap with mental illness, but it has to be medically diagnosed, not just claimed. There is also an overlap with criminal, as he was a convicted one and he used violence in his crimes.

To suggest one cause is certainly wrong and I think, on the evidence available, mental illness was either not a cause or it was a minor one.
 
Sorry, I don't see anything from you as to what mental illness you think he had. Could you please either link to where you said which mental illness or repeat which one you think it is.

Like I said, it's perfectly clear where I'm coming from. I have no need to diagnose an individual who murdered 26 men woman and children in cold blood with a specific illness just to indulge you in the contortions you're going to pull for absolutely no good end other than to argue across each other.

I think he was mentally ill, let that be the end of it. You can scrabble for a more specific diagnosis if it gives you a deeper understanding. Like I said I'm quite happy to wallow in my ignorance.


Have you any idea which mental illness he suffered from?

The guy was mad, mental, crazy, out of his *********** tree. He remorselessly killed these people without pause or warning. He planned, in advance, to enter the church and kill as many as he could without warning and was only stopped by an armed civilian. He fired indiscriminately and without compunction into the congregation not caring who his victims were. He watched his bullets entering the bodies of men,women and children and will have seen the chunks of body parts dislodged as they exited, he moved from victim to victim with cold intent. I can't begin to tell you what the illness that caused him to act in such a way might be called.
 
I would do a venn diagram, but I don't have the tech to do it, so....

The people who mass shoot tend to be;

1 - criminals (shooting during criminal acts including gangs)

2 - angry people (shooting out of revenge or rage, heat of the moment)

3 - scared people (shooting out of fear including self defence)

4 - planned terrorist acts (politically motivated)

5 - the mentally ill (but you need a diagnosis such as schizophrenia)

6 - youths (which covers the horrible instances of children getting hold of guns).

There are lots of overlaps between them. Many terrorists are also angry people and are acting in revenge. Many youths are also in gangs. Criminals often have mental health issues. There are others with no overlaps, like someone scared they are in mortal danger from a thief with a baseball bat, is not acting as a terrorist.

Kelley definitely was in the angry person category. There may be an overlap with mental illness, but it has to be medically diagnosed, not just claimed. There is also an overlap with criminal, as he was a convicted one and he used violence in his crimes.

To suggest one cause is certainly wrong and I think, on the evidence available, mental illness was either not a cause or it was a minor one.
Thanks for this, I think all this talk about mental illness is a bit of a red herring as it isn't mutually exclusive of anything. I would add to your list Hate crimes which could be a separate category or maybe it could be incorporated in the terrorism category.
 
Your explanation has reduced my terror somewhat. It looked from your argument that you were implying that ordinary private citizens were permitted to construct and use explosives - that there was a reasonable expectation that the person next door could be manufacturing explosives in their garage, the way there is a reasonable expectation (in America) that the person next door has a gun.

Thanks for clarifying.

No state that I'm aware of allows unrestricted manufacture and possession of primary or secondary high explosives, or even low order (blackpowder, flash powder, etc)

The binary types like those cited by RanB are impact sensitive and don't fall into either restricted category so are legal for civilian possession, but not here in California.

Storing lots of Tannerite seems like something that should be controlled - is it?


Building bombs for personal reasons (or merely storing lots of explosives) should be considered different from doing it as a regulated business.

I am talking about explosives like Tannerite.

Private sale. In most states there is no background check and no record of the sale.

Congress voted against closing this loophole after Sandy Hook because the NRA wants to keep it open.
Still illegal. We all know guns are available illegally, but the subject was legally acquiring the firearm.
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=12063827#post12063827


My understanding is that as long as the seller has no reason to suppose that they are selling to someone who is ineligible, then a private seller can do so perfectly legally.

If that is the case, then the purchaser might have bought a gun illegally, but the seller sold it legally - having mandatory background checks would close that, and put the onus on the seller to dispose of their weapon in a responsible manner.
 
Like I said, it's perfectly clear where I'm coming from. I have no need to diagnose an individual who murdered 26 men woman and children in cold blood with a specific illness just to indulge you in the contortions you're going to pull for absolutely no good end other than to argue across each other.

I think he was mentally ill, let that be the end of it. You can scrabble for a more specific diagnosis if it gives you a deeper understanding. Like I said I'm quite happy to wallow in my ignorance.




The guy was mad, mental, crazy, out of his *********** tree. He remorselessly killed these people without pause or warning. He planned, in advance, to enter the church and kill as many as he could without warning and was only stopped by an armed civilian. He fired indiscriminately and without compunction into the congregation not caring who his victims were. He watched his bullets entering the bodies of men,women and children and will have seen the chunks of body parts dislodged as they exited, he moved from victim to victim with cold intent. I can't begin to tell you what the illness that caused him to act in such a way might be called.

https://www.mind.org.uk/media/998781/Violence-and-mental-health-Mind-factsheet-2014.pdf

Other relevant factors

To try and understand why some people with schizophrenia might be violent, when the majority are not, researchers have looked at a number of other
factors.
These other experiences or situations can also be said to increase the risk of someone being violent, whether they have a mental health problem or not:
Being exposed to violence or abuse at an early age
Having unstable relationships
Experiencing employment problems
Struggling with substance misuse
Having been violent previously
Gender (with men more likely to be perpetrators of violent crime than women).

For people who are experiencing mental health problems and have behaved violently, the highest level of risk occurs when that person:
is experiencing psychosis or delusions
is not adhering to drug or therapeutic treatment
is misusing drugs and /or alcohol"

Unless it can be shown by medical diagnosis he has a mental health issue which caused the shooting, you are about as accurate as subscribing mental health as the cause, as you are claiming he was a scared juvenile acting in self defence.

I think and so should you, that we need an accurate and evidenced cause of why he did what he did.
 
Thanks for this, I think all this talk about mental illness is a bit of a red herring as it isn't mutually exclusive of anything. I would add to your list Hate crimes which could be a separate category or maybe it could be incorporated in the terrorism category.

I would put hate crimes into the angry person/terrorist overlap, in my pretend venn diagram.

I do not get why Trump and others have latched onto mental health as the cause, with no evidence and plenty of other reasons why people go on massacres.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom