Mass shooting in small town Texas

you can make explosaives out of chemicals you can buy at any chemical storehouse,which have necessary and innocuous uses.
Hell, you can make an effective truck or car bomb out of some types of fertilizer and alcohol...

But you can't just walk into a fertilizer store anymore and walk out with large quantities of ammonium nitrate. I don't know what the restrictions are, but I know they were added after Tim McVeigh.
 
Summary so far: Serious anger management issues, history of severe domestic violence for which he spent a year in jail after injuring his infant stepson. The injuries included broken bones and a subdural hematoma, potentially life threatening and/or permanently disabling.

Bad conduct discharge which maybe should have put him on a no-gun-buy list and/or someone in the military failed to enter the data.

Apparently (based on another post) he purchased his weapon legally. Does a military domestic violence conviction not disqualify one from owning guns? If this is the case, it seems that is a loophole that needs to be closed.
Yes, but the data may not have been entered in the national data base.

I'm sorry, I can't see any point in this exchange if you persistently refuse to acknowledge that to shoot 26 people is linked to some form of mental illness unless I diagnose exactly what his condition was.

This isn't a case of extraordinary evidence.
Anyone who murders has some sort of mental disorder be it sociopathic, psychopathic, anger management failure, fanaticism, psychosis among other things. But in the legal sense of the word, only psychosis or some form of hallucinations are considered the kind of mental illness the court cares about. Everything else makes you a murderer with a mental disorder.

Making that observation for all white mass shooters, while never making that observation for non-whites is the problem.
Yes, and Trump amplifies this dangerous racism.

Again, you are missing the point.

The real threat is mental illness, not the mentally ill. Start there.
Always important to keep this in mind.

I would do a venn diagram, but I don't have the tech to do it, so....

The people who mass shoot tend to be;

1 - criminals (shooting during criminal acts including gangs)

2 - angry people (shooting out of revenge or rage, heat of the moment)

3 - scared people (shooting out of fear including self defence)

4 - planned terrorist acts (politically motivated)

5 - the mentally ill (but you need a diagnosis such as schizophrenia)

6 - youths (which covers the horrible instances of children getting hold of guns).

There are lots of overlaps between them. Many terrorists are also angry people and are acting in revenge. Many youths are also in gangs. Criminals often have mental health issues. There are others with no overlaps, like someone scared they are in mortal danger from a thief with a baseball bat, is not acting as a terrorist. ...
I would also split the anger management into two categories and like the rest of these, nothing prevents overlap. One is the violent domestic abuser, typically with a control issue over the partner: jealousy, sense of entitlement, possessiveness and so on.

The other is the guy (sorry but it's almost never a gal) who goes postal. Blames the world for his every failure and sets out to get even. A lot of workplace shooters fit in this group as well as that Santa Monica creep who blamed women.

I think for acts of terror that didn't arise out of religious indoctrination, there is overlap here. Did the guy in San Bernardino hate his coworkers? Was The Pulse shooter an antigay gay guy?

None of those shooters were mentally ill the way the Aurora Theater, Gabby Gifford or the Virginia Tech shooters were mentally ill.

I would put hate crimes into the angry person/terrorist overlap, in my pretend venn diagram.
So would I. But you have to have room on one side of the diagram for completely brainwashed.

I do not get why Trump and others have latched onto mental health as the cause, with no evidence and plenty of other reasons why people go on massacres.
Because, he's an ignorant racist who has a toddler's view of the world.
 
News conference: Suspect 'he who shall not be named' was shot twice by the good guy with the gun (leg and torso), and once in the head that was consistent with suicide.

Also there were ~15 magazines at the scene, all empty. Sounds like he ran out of ammo for the assault weapons but had at least one bullet left in a pistol.
 
Last edited:
I am talking about explosives like Tannerite.
There are most likely fire codes and other regs that have to be adhered to when storing flammables and explosives. It's been a while since I read them but they're usually at the local or state government level.
 
But you can't just walk into a fertilizer store anymore and walk out with large quantities of ammonium nitrate. I don't know what the restrictions are, but I know they were added after Tim McVeigh.

But those regulations are pretty easy to get around.
 
I'm afraid that you don't get to sweep the fact that he callously murdered men, women and children under the carpet in order to try and make whatever minor point you are trying to make.

If it wasn't for that we wouldn't be talking about Devin Patrick Kelley for ***** sake!

As for the Orlando shooter? I've got that one covered and have been explicitly clear about why I consider (correctly) that he will been have mentally ill.
If murdering men, women and children is sufficient evidence of mental illness, surely that applies to terrorists as well, no?

If you regard the Orlando shooter as mentally ill, that is certainly a point in favor for your consistency. I didn't know your opinion about him.
 
I would put hate crimes into the angry person/terrorist overlap, in my pretend venn diagram.

I do not get why Trump and others have latched onto mental health as the cause, with no evidence and plenty of other reasons why people go on massacres.

This is the stupidest semantic game I have seen in a while, trying to prove that Kelley was not "mentally ill".
Sorry, but people who are mentally ill do not do what he did.
I know it is painful to agree with the Orange Menace (and it would be hard to have a lower opinion of the idiot at 1600 Pennslyvania Avenue then I do) but he was right about Kelley;The guy had severe mental problems.and andy differend then those and being mentally Ill is just a matter of semantics.
 
If murdering men, women and children is sufficient evidence of mental illness, surely that applies to terrorists as well, no?

If you regard the Orlando shooter as mentally ill, that is certainly a point in favor for your consistency. I didn't know your opinion about him.

You know, this whole "If Trump says something, I have to disagree with him automatically" bit is silly.
Sorry, but Kelley was bat crap crazy. Go and argue in a bar room or restaurant that Kelley was not mentally Ill and see the weird looks you will get.
 
I think we just need to think of those killed as touched by god. It was an act of god that caused this guy to go crazy and there was nothing anyone could ever have done to prevent it. And crazy is better for this than mentally ill, it means you aren't even trying to give a psychiatric diagnosis, but rather depending on logical fallacies to do it.

Please, take you personal dislike of religion out of this discussion. It's totally irrevelent.
 
This is the stupidest semantic game I have seen in a while, trying to prove that Kelley was not "mentally ill".
Sorry, but people who are mentally ill do not do what he did.
I know it is painful to agree with the Orange Menace (and it would be hard to have a lower opinion of the idiot at 1600 Pennslyvania Avenue then I do) but he was right about Kelley;The guy had severe mental problems.and andy differend then those and being mentally Ill is just a matter of semantics.

Where is the evidence he had.mental illness?
 
You know, this whole "If Trump says something, I have to disagree with him automatically" bit is silly.
Sorry, but Kelley was bat crap crazy. Go and argue in a bar room or restaurant that Kelley was not mentally Ill and see the weird looks you will get.
I'm not committed to the claim that he wasn't mentally ill, but I wonder why the same reasoning wouldn't apply to the bulk of those we call terrorists.

I think it's plausible that most people who commit such heinous acts have a gross lack of empathy that might reasonably be called mental illness, and I include here those who did so for personal reasons as well as those who claim political motives.

It gets trickier when we consider uniformed soldiers who attack a civilian population, of course.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom