Mass shooting in small town Texas

Then phiwum was right. Murdering many people is your evidence for mental illness. That would suggest the 9/11 hijackers were mentally I'll.

You don't think believing that there is a magical man in the sky that will give you 40 virgins if you murder innocent people, is a sign of mental illness? I sure do.
 
You don't think believing that there is a magical man in the sky that will give you 40 virgins if you murder innocent people, is a sign of mental illness? I sure do.

I'm not arguing any murderer is insane either way. (Except for Jared loughner). My concern is lack of consistency.
 
I'm not arguing any murderer is insane either way. (Except for Jared loughner). My concern is lack of consistency.

I would totally accept a medical diagnosis that Islamist suicide attackers who believe their jihad will lead to rewards in heaven are suffering from brainwashing and temporary insanity.
 
Wonder if this is the result of some sort of systemic problem with record-keeping or just the sort of fluke that sometimes happens even in a well-run system.
Based on the number of complaints I read and hear about concerning delays or false positives in the system, I'd say it's not exactly well run.
 
There will continue to be these mass murders until the NRA is de-fanged, which will only happen when Republicans are voted out of power.
 
Based on the number of complaints I read and hear about concerning delays or false positives in the system, I'd say it's not exactly well run.

That actually seems like a problem that could be worked on without immediately degenerating into a partisan nightmare.
 
I would totally accept a medical diagnosis that Islamist suicide attackers who believe their jihad will lead to rewards in heaven are suffering from brainwashing and temporary insanity.

And Trump's combination of lack of self reflection on this question hurts the US response.
 
if (WHITE_DUDE) goto DO_NOT_POLITICIZE

Nothing to see here, carry on.

That's because white dude who do this are outliers

http://www.news.com.au/world/north-...e/news-story/f51929d601fb0ea256d39f373003e598
Following the charges, his wife divorced him and the air force kicked him out for bad conduct, but he showed problematic signs well before that said a former girlfriend of Kelley’s.
According to the Post, Kelley tried to bribe girls as young as 13 to date him.
“He was very sick in the head,” Katy Landry, a former girlfriend of Kelley, told NBC News. “Years after dating me he would try to bribe me to hang out with him. He ended up assaulting me.”

Kelley was described as “creepy” and “weird” by former schoolmates.

Muslim dudes are mainstream

http://www.news.com.au/world/north-...v/news-story/61bcb7be932d227cb307859a0a85145d

The neighbour said he often saw Saipov around the neighbourhood with his wife and two children. The neighbour also said he saw Saipov standing on the corner talking to friends and frequently invited them into his home.
...
Saipov was “very friendly” and was an Uber driver, a friend of the suspect was quoted as saying by the New York Post.
Kobiljon Matkarov, 37, told the newspaper he met Saipov in Florida five years ago and the two bonded over their background.
“He is very good guy, he is very friendly… he is like little brother… he look at me like big brother,” Mr Matkarov said.
 
You don't think believing that there is a magical man in the sky that will give you 40 virgins if you murder innocent people, is a sign of mental illness? I sure do.
Yes, believing that murdering folk for a mere forty virgins was a good choice would be mental illness.

But once it reaches 72, well, then the benefits start to seem substantial enough that you'd have to consider it.

I mean 72. And they're virgins. Right?
 
That's sadly argument against registration. US seems to be simply unable to run such system.

Bingo! I only have anecdotal evidence from acquaintances that false positives occur. It's not that uncommon apparently. The worst part is there is nothing one can do about it, except appeal to a non-human. Even then there is never an answer regarding the reason for the erroneous refusal.

There seems to be no rhyme or reason for the erroneous refusals when a Social Security number is given. How can there be confusion with someone who is prohibited? It's not a good system...
 
This is the stupidest semantic game I have seen in a while, trying to prove that Kelley was not "mentally ill".
Sorry, but people who are mentally ill do not do what he did.
I know it is painful to agree with the Orange Menace (and it would be hard to have a lower opinion of the idiot at 1600 Pennslyvania Avenue then I do) but he was right about Kelley;The guy had severe mental problems.and andy differend then those and being mentally Ill is just a matter of semantics.

I don't believe anyone is trying to say the creep wasn't mentally ill. We (I) are merely saying it's not useful to lump all mental illness into one bag.
 
You know, this whole "If Trump says something, I have to disagree with him automatically" bit is silly.
Sorry, but Kelley was bat crap crazy. Go and argue in a bar room or restaurant that Kelley was not mentally Ill and see the weird looks you will get.
Not sure this the the best place to stand with Trump. But suit yourself.
 
Sorry, but Kelley was bat crap crazy.

You are a licensed Psychologist? Psychiatrist? Psychotherapist?

Go and argue in a bar room or restaurant that Kelley was not mentally Ill and see the weird looks you will get.

All people that hang out in bars and restaurants are qualified to determine the mental state of a person they have never meet nor interacted with?
 
This is the stupidest semantic game I have seen in a while, trying to prove that Kelley was not "mentally ill".
Sorry, but people who are (sic) mentally ill do not do what he did.

This is what we call a circular argument fallacy.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom