Mass shooting in small town Texas

How is wanting to kill a bunch of strangers not mental illness by definition?

The desire to kill might be because somehow, in one's twisted mind, these strangers or what they represent are to blame for the negatives in your life- personal or political. It might be because you think somehow this will be an example to others to help your "cause." It might be because you wish to become famous through the event. It might be because you believe them to be Venusians implanting evil thoughts into your brain by ESP. But in all these cases I see killing a bunch of strangers as inherently mental illness.

What to do about these forms of mental illness is much more complicated.

No, it is not 'mental illness' by definition. You are falling into the same trap as the Soviets, who declared dissidents and investigative journalists 'mentally ill'.

It's a basic mistake to confuse fully conscious and deliberate behaviour with illness.
 
No links between the Nice mass murderer and fundalmentalist jihadism were ever found (apart from the ISIS claim as in Las Vegas).

ETA: The Nice mass murderer had a history of mental illness btw.

Being a fundamentalist jihadist or other type of terrorist is not mutually exclusive with also being mentally ill.

If this Kelley guy has never been diagnosed as mentally ill, nor got a medical history of it, then it is simply using 'mentally ill' as a slur in the same way people used to talk about 'spastics' as an intended insult.
 
Apparently (based on another post) he purchased his weapon legally. Does a military domestic violence conviction not disqualify one from owning guns? If this is the case, it seems that is a loophole that needs to be closed.

I'm sure the murder loving republicans in congress and the NRA will get right on that after they square away bump stocks.
 
And you have some of the strictest knife laws in the first world.

What does that say?
That easy access to knives contributes to the knife problem. Unfortunately knives due to their every day utility are a lot more difficult to restrict than guns.
 
No links between the Nice mass murderer and fundalmentalist jihadism were ever found (apart from the ISIS claim as in Las Vegas).

There's significantly more reason to believe that the Nice murderer acted on behalf of Islam than the Las Vegas shooter.


But but but, Brown=terrorist!!!!!

No muslim could ever possibly just go on a mass murder spree for no reason like a proper white man does.

Do you really have to spout your "theories" about racism on every thread?
 
Wow, Vixen and I are in agreement, *twice*!

The vast majority of mentally ill people are far more in danger of being the victims of violence than the attackers. Yes, there are a few whose delusions are uncontrollable enough I feel uncomfortable about them having weapons, but remember, mentally ill includes depression, anxiety, etc, not just major mood disorders. That's why the usual definition of mentally ill for weapons purposes has been involuntary commitment of a certain duration. Unfortunately, the system is so overburdened that there are no beds available, so they're medicated and turfed after 72 hours, and nothing goes into the system.

This guy fractured a baby's skull. He served time for it. Nobody that knew him said he was crazy, just creepy or angry. Unless he left a manifesto somewhere saying he was ridding the world of mind-controlling demons, I think it's safer to say he was just plain mean.
 
You don't understand mental illness. Mentally ill people are very rarely dangerous.

I know, can you quote me saying that I though they were? I've been very clear about why I insist that mental illness plays a part in events such as these.

The dangerous guys are the psychopaths.

Yeah, and that will be a mental illness.
 
So what diagnosis did various shooters have? This shooting seems to be pretty basic domestic violence. He went there because it was the church of his mother-in-law who he was threatening.

Mental illness does is not an answer it is at best a class of answer, so you need to be more specific. The only mass shooter who had a history of mental illness I know about was the Virginia Tech and that was treatment for depression. That is not exactly a key marker to kill a lot of people.

I'm sorry, I can't see any point in this exchange if you persistently refuse to acknowledge that to shoot 26 people is linked to some form of mental illness unless I diagnose exactly what his condition was.

This isn't a case of extraordinary evidence.
 
How is wanting to kill a bunch of strangers not mental illness by definition?

Because the definition of "mental illness" doesn't include (even obliquely) the desire to kill a bunch of strangers?

Let's please not abuse the term "by definition". Thanks.
 
I'm sorry, I can't see any point in this exchange if you persistently refuse to acknowledge that to shoot 26 people is linked to some form of mental illness unless I diagnose exactly what his condition was.

This isn't a case of extraordinary evidence.

It is a case of a proposed logical tautology, you are reasoning in a circular manner. To do this he has to be crazy so he must be crazy to do this. Of course then defining crazy becomes not a case of saying having X kind of mental illness but rather describing the act of killing a bunch of people. So now all mass murders are crazy.

And up next using it to say that say a father who kills his son for being gay is mentally ill too. Where does this end? It isn't using the kinds of definitions that mental health professions use in diagnosing people, it is just a gut reaction.
 
It is not considered a mental illness, but a personality subtype or disorder, depending on severity.

I should have entered my expectancy of this reply in to the MDC.

To the layman, the man/woman in the street, "mental illness" is more than adequate.

You are playing semantics.
 
Er, you/they seem to have left out the bit about his fracturing his stepson's skull.

And his handedness. They should discuss whether he is right- or left-handed.

Or the article wasn't about the domestic violence charge but about something else instead, so there is no harm in leaving out that charge. Sometimes, people talk about one thing and sometimes they talk about another.

I know. Conversation is weird.

ETA: Who gives a damn what the Post says? They are a half-step above the Enquirer. (Oh, yeah, so the President of the United States might care.)
 
Last edited:
Your explanation has reduced my terror somewhat. It looked from your argument that you were implying that ordinary private citizens were permitted to construct and use explosives - that there was a reasonable expectation that the person next door could be manufacturing explosives in their garage, the way there is a reasonable expectation (in America) that the person next door has a gun.

Thanks for clarifying.

you can make explosaives out of chemicals you can buy at any chemical storehouse,which have necessary and innocuous uses.
Hell, you can make an effective truck or car bomb out of some types of fertilizer and alcohol...
 
I should have entered my expectancy of this reply in to the MDC.

To the layman, the man/woman in the street, "mental illness" is more than adequate.

You are playing semantics.

Unless they are muslim then it is all clearly terrorism. We can dismiss it as that as soon as the event happens, see the president for examples of it. He best illustrates this, white shooter=mental illness, muslim killer=terrorism. This goes to the extent that they will happy blame the victims for being muslim and thus making it islamic terrorism when a white guy shoots them.
 
It is a case of a proposed logical tautology, you are reasoning in a circular manner. To do this he has to be crazy so he must be crazy to do this. Of course then defining crazy becomes not a case of saying having X kind of mental illness but rather describing the act of killing a bunch of people. So now all mass murders are crazy.

Yes, yes they are. I was quite clear about that earlier on in the thread.

And up next using it to say that say a father who kills his son for being gay is mentally ill too. Where does this end?

Who is saying that?

It isn't using the kinds of definitions that mental health professions use in diagnosing people, it is just a gut reaction.

And a quite sound and correct one for laymen. He was mental, he killed 26 men, woman and children.
 
I should have entered my expectancy of this reply in to the MDC.

To the layman, the man/woman in the street, "mental illness" is more than adequate.

You are playing semantics.

And the Orlando shooter? Mentally ill or terrorist or are you and I not quite qualified to know?

You're sure this guy was mentally ill? Aside from killing lots of undeserving folk, on what basis?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom