Mass shooting in small town Texas

Yes, yes they are. I was quite clear about that earlier on in the thread.



Who is saying that?



And a quite sound and correct one for laymen. He was mental, he killed 26 men, woman and children.

And of course the trick is was he crazy before he killed them, or is it only in killing a bunch of people that by definition makes him crazy.

This is not a terribly useful definition of crazy, it has no predictive power for one. It certainly isn't tied to any clinical definitions of mental illness and as such can not be treated before the mass murder.
 
Why does Donald Trump think the killer, Kelley, is 'mentally ill'?

How is that valid? He could just be 'mean'.

As much as it pains me to agree with Cheeto Mussolini about everything, that Kelley was "Mentally Ill" seems to be beyond dispute.

It is interesting we are not hearing any demands for the Death Penalty,though.......Guess the only goes for Muslims and people with Brown Skins.
 
And all you are doing is trying to stigmatize mental illness, and use it to scapegoat the real problems.

You couldn't be more wrong if you tried. I cannot unravel your way of thinking, although I feel you are simply looking for a fight.

Scapegoating mental illness?
 
As much as it pains me to agree with Cheeto Mussolini about everything, that Kelley was "Mentally Ill" seems to be beyond dispute.

It is interesting we are not hearing any demands for the Death Penalty,though.......Guess the only goes for Muslims and people with Brown Skins.

Executing a dead man seems excessive even for Trump. But as a white shooter it clearly is the kind of thing that must not be politicised, unlike when a brown shooter which must be used as political fodder right away.
 
Unless they are muslim then it is all clearly terrorism. We can dismiss it as that as soon as the event happens, see the president for examples of it. He best illustrates this, white shooter=mental illness, muslim killer=terrorism. This goes to the extent that they will happy blame the victims for being muslim and thus making it islamic terrorism when a white guy shoots them.

I'm afraid you'll have to take that up with your President.

Nobody, absolutely nobody but you is spouting that pish on this thread.
 
If no, then why shouldn't people state that it's quite probably a large part of the reason he calmly walked in to a church and killed 26 people. Why shouldn't anybody, even POTUS make such an observation?

Making that observation for all white mass shooters, while never making that observation for non-whites is the problem.
 
You couldn't be more wrong if you tried. I cannot unravel your way of thinking, although I feel you are simply looking for a fight.

Scapegoating mental illness?

Yes you are making it seem like the mentally ill are the real threat, when the only claim that the shooter was mentally ill is that he would have to be crazy to do that. So you are blaming mental illness without any evidence, let alone any kind of plan for treating the hypothetical mass murderer crazy that is he had to have had.

It has no proposed treatment plan as there is no diagnosis, there is no criteria being listed. All you have is argument from incredulity that someone who is not mentally ill could do this. Basing your entire position on a logical fallacy is not really the best position to take for a supposed skeptic.
 
... or is it only in killing a bunch of people that by definition makes him crazy.

Most likely, yes. I would agree that this would be the case

This is not a terribly useful definition of crazy, it has no predictive power for one. It certainly isn't tied to any clinical definitions of mental illness and as such can not be treated before the mass murder.

It's all I got and it's not on me to provide predictions of the next mass shooting based on **** all experience.

I am quite happy to classify it as an act of mental illness, after the fact, irrespective of the colour of the assailants skin or their cultural background. I will wallow in my perceived ignorance.

If others prefer to label it as Devin Patrick Kelley having a bad day, well that's another level of ignorance.
 
And the Orlando shooter? Mentally ill or terrorist or are you and I not quite qualified to know?

You're sure this guy was mentally ill? Aside from killing lots of undeserving folk, on what basis?

I'm afraid that you don't get to sweep the fact that he callously murdered men, women and children under the carpet in order to try and make whatever minor point you are trying to make.

If it wasn't for that we wouldn't be talking about Devin Patrick Kelley for ***** sake!

As for the Orlando shooter? I've got that one covered and have been explicitly clear about why I consider (correctly) that he will been have mentally ill.
 
Studies show that the evidence agrees with your assertion. The easy accessibility of having a gun is a catalyst to homicide. A heated altercation can easily, and too often, becomes deadly when either party has a gun.

This tirade is total and utterly BS. This kind of rhetoric is part of the problem. Please stop, but I fully realize that is a futile request.

What is wrong with it? Someone who can't control their temper in the UK might lash out and punch someone. The same person in the US might have a gun and instead of punching someone, shoot them.

Guns in general make the consequences of impulsive violence worse.
 
I'm afraid that you don't get to sweep the fact that he callously murdered men, women and children under the carpet in order to try and make whatever minor point you are trying to make.

If it wasn't for that we wouldn't be talking about Devin Patrick Kelley for ***** sake!

As for the Orlando shooter? I've got that one covered and have been explicitly clear about why I consider (correctly) that he will been have mentally ill.

Except that being a self hating homosexual is not a diagnosable mental illness. All you are doing it just dismissing these things as unknowable and lumping in the mentally ill with the stigma that they might kill a bunch of people at any time.
 
From what I have read so far, he was an angry man, rather than mentally ill.

By angry man I mean someone who has trouble containing their emotions, has reason (good and/or bad) to be angry at others and/or the world in general. I am sure most of us know people who are aggressive by nature, quick to fly off the handle, or are slow burners that you worry may lose the plot, even over something trivial.

I am basing that on the evidence of domestic violence, airforce discharge, the reported row with the mother in law and the act of mass shooting.
 

See the point I made earlier about trump instantly blaming mental illness for white shooters and terrorism for muslim ones? That is exactly what many americans do, Trump ran for president on it. That is why he ran on a muslim ban not on a mental illness ban.
 
Yes you are making it seem like the mentally ill are the real threat, when the only claim that the shooter was mentally ill is that he would have to be crazy to do that. So you are blaming mental illness without any evidence, let alone any kind of plan for treating the hypothetical mass murderer crazy that is he had to have had.

It has no proposed treatment plan as there is no diagnosis, there is no criteria being listed. All you have is argument from incredulity that someone who is not mentally ill could do this. Basing your entire position on a logical fallacy is not really the best position to take for a supposed skeptic.

Again, you are missing the point.

The real threat is mental illness, not the mentally ill. Start there.
 
Again, you are missing the point.

The real threat is mental illness, not the mentally ill. Start there.

Lets start with what mental illness you think Kelley had. Then show your evidence he had it.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom