Mass shooting in small town Texas

There are parts of the UK which are so difficult to get to and, unless you're there to visit specific people, have so little to see if you're a tourist that thy're really not worth the time and effort to get there.

For example IMO it would make very little sense to go all the way to Alston in Cumbria unless you're already in the area. Yes it has a narrow gauge railway (but there are a lot of those in the UK) and the scenery is nice (but there's a lot more that's easily accessible) but it's a chore to get there.

I was in Alston a coupleo f weeks ago. Went for a ride on the Duke, Up Teesdale,up from Middleton to Alston, across the moors and down to Penrith. Back along the A66 and through Barnard Castle on the way home.
We had lunch in Alston
 
What is racist about attributing mental illness to this tragedy?

The Orlando night club shooter showed signs of mental instability. There is evidence that he was having trouble reconciling his homosexual desires with his religious upbringing. But, because he was brown the first response was "terrorist" not mental illness.

It is not racist to look into the mental health of any shooter. In fact, I think most mass shootings involve a mental health component. It is racist for that determination to be made without investigation completely based on the race of the shooter.
 
There is a will to change gun laws in the USA, it's just that the NRA has a choke hold on those in government. Until the NRA loses power, these gun massacres will continue.

There is a substantial fraction of the US public (I won't say a majority, but it might be. It is certainly a large enough fraction to swing elections) that support the views of the NRA. It is very much a grass-roots organization. While it is popular among gun control advocates to make the NRA the bogeyman, it is more a symptom of the problem (if you believe it is a problem) than the cause.
 
I was in Alston a coupleo f weeks ago. Went for a ride on the Duke, Up Teesdale,up from Middleton to Alston, across the moors and down to Penrith. Back along the A66 and through Barnard Castle on the way home.
We had lunch in Alston

Was here visiting Daddy Don this last weekend....
 
This is such nonsense. Terrorism is defined as "the unlawful use of violence and intimidation, especially against civilians, in the pursuit of political aims." There is no evidence that this attack was politically motivated. When an attack is politically motivated, we call it terrorism regardless of the skin color of the attacker. We call the Oklahoma bombings terrorism. We call 1984 Rajneeshee bioterror attack terrorism and so on. If we are going to call mass shootings "terrorism" regardless of motive then why not also call it a "hate crime"? These things have real meanings. We treat hate crimes differently because of how they affect and intimidate and coerce the people still living. It greatly expands the set of victims. If this guy did this act on the behalf of a political group with the implicit threat to other church goers that they better stop going to Baptists churches or this fate might happen to them too, then we'd call it an act of terrorism. Similarly with a hate crimes.
Can you provide some examples where we labeled a shooter as a terrorist or not a terrorist based not on the shooter's motivations or affiliations but instead based on their skin color?

I agree. The idea that the fundalmentalist jihadist truck driver in Nice is of the same category as say, the Las Vegas killer is intellectually dishonest.

OTOH Calling the latter guy, 'mentally ill' is a cop out. ISTM he inherited psychopathic tendencies from his wanted-by-FBI robber father. The Sutherland Springs killer is more likely to have a personality disorder IMV than any specific mental illness.

We'll see. It's a slur on people with mental illnesses that they somehow therefore lack ethics, can't control themselves and commit criminal acts.

I know two people with serious mental illness, one is bipolar and the nicest person in the world. When she is on a manic high, she is the most fantastic company. The other is someone who hears voices and says strange things in conversation. He neither is likely to go on a killing spree with a gun. If anything, he avoids people.
 
Please elaborate on the licensing and registration. I've had several safety training and defensive training courses. I've had background checks with no problem. I passed the requirements for a handgun carry permit (but I don't carry).

What next?

Gun licenses. Before every purchase you ask for the license. It should be issued quickly, cheaply, and on 'shall issue' basis. Only after you have the license, you can take the gun from the shop. Any change in ownership of the gun must work the same. Transfer first. Also holder of the license is held responsible for the gun, and must report immediately if it's lost or stolen, and face penalty, if it was caused by irresponsibility on his side. License holder must also be able to present the gun for inspection, when requested.
That's how it works here in Czech Republic. Idea is you can't buy gun legally and resell it illegally, and when needed, the guns can be taken away from you.
We actually have to let inspectors into our houses and demonstrate the guns are correctly secured (the law defines required level of security based on how many guns you have .. like for example for 3-10 guns you need metal cabinet with lock, fixed to the wall). But that's kinda minor issue, and could be problematic in US.
And of course .. if you get convicted, you loose gun holder license and all gun licenses. You have to transfer them, or you face charge of unlawfully arming yourself.
 
We'll see. It's a slur on people with mental illnesses that they somehow therefore lack ethics, can't control themselves and commit criminal acts.

I don't think you fully understand mental illness.

I know two people with serious mental illness, one is bipolar and the nicest person in the world. When she is on a manic high, she is the most fantastic company. The other is someone who hears voices and says strange things in conversation. He neither is likely to go on a killing spree with a gun. If anything, he avoids people.

With respect, you have absolutely no way of knowing that, any more than I know how a future mental illness might end up with me going on a rampage.
 
A misdemeanor DV conviction is all it takes to disqualify you in the USA.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Domestic_Violence_Offender_Gun_Ban

That's my understanding. However, apparently the perp of this mass shooting was somehow able to purchase a firearm from a licensed seller. I'm not sure at this point whether that's due to a defect in the law or a defect in the background check process. I any case, I'd like to see the defect corrected.
 
I don't think you fully understand mental illness.



With respect, you have absolutely no way of knowing that, any more than I know how a future mental illness might end up with me going on a rampage.

So what diagnosis did various shooters have? This shooting seems to be pretty basic domestic violence. He went there because it was the church of his mother-in-law who he was threatening.

Mental illness does is not an answer it is at best a class of answer, so you need to be more specific. The only mass shooter who had a history of mental illness I know about was the Virginia Tech and that was treatment for depression. That is not exactly a key marker to kill a lot of people.
 
That's my understanding. However, apparently the perp of this mass shooting was somehow able to purchase a firearm from a licensed seller. I'm not sure at this point whether that's due to a defect in the law or a defect in the background check process. I any case, I'd like to see the defect corrected.

It seems to be the way the military charged him, it was simple assault not domestic assault.
 
http://nypost.com/2017/11/06/texas-church-shooter-tried-to-bribe-underage-girls-to-date-him/

Texas church shooter tried to bribe underage girls to date him

“He was very sick in the head,” Katy Landry, a former girlfriend of Devin Patrick Kelley, told NBC News. “Years after dating me he would try to bribe me to hang out with him. He ended up assaulting me.”

Landry said she met Kelley in church as a teenager, but it was not immediately clear when their relationship began or ended.

Another girl, Brittany Adcock, 22, said Kelley dated her for two months around 2009 when he was 18 and she was just 13.

“At the time I didn’t think much into it being so young but now I realize that there’s something off about someone who is 18 with someone who is 13,” she said.

After she dumped him, Kelley pursued her relentlessly, offering her money to take him back and even disgustingly suggesting she live with him and his wife as a topless maid.

“One time he told me I should move in with him and his wife and that he would take care of me as long as I walked around topless,” Adcock said. “Not long after, his wife messaged me and asked why I’m talking to her husband and I told her what he was saying and sent her screenshots and she then apologized and then I was blocked from speaking to her.”
 
I agree. The idea that the fundalmentalist jihadist truck driver in Nice is of the same category as say, the Las Vegas killer is intellectually dishonest...
No links between the Nice mass murderer and fundalmentalist jihadism were ever found (apart from the ISIS claim as in Las Vegas).

ETA: The Nice mass murderer had a history of mental illness btw.
 
Last edited:
No links between the Nice mass murderer and fundalmentalist jihadism were ever found (apart from the ISIS claim as in Las Vegas).

But but but, Brown=terrorist!!!!!

No muslim could ever possibly just go on a mass murder spree for no reason like a proper white man does.
 
What is racist about attributing mental illness to this tragedy?
The cause might well be mental illness. We'll see.

But the concern is that the default position among white shooters is mental illness, whereas Islamic shooters are bad people. Why not suppose that Islamic shooters are also suffering from mental illness, which would explain their self radicalization?

Anyway, let's see what evidence comes up.
 
I don't think you fully understand mental illness.



With respect, you have absolutely no way of knowing that, any more than I know how a future mental illness might end up with me going on a rampage.

You don't understand mental illness. Mentally ill people are very rarely dangerous.

The dangerous guys are the psychopaths.
 
How is wanting to kill a bunch of strangers not mental illness by definition?

The desire to kill might be because somehow, in one's twisted mind, these strangers or what they represent are to blame for the negatives in your life- personal or political. It might be because you think somehow this will be an example to others to help your "cause." It might be because you wish to become famous through the event. It might be because you believe them to be Venusians implanting evil thoughts into your brain by ESP. But in all these cases I see killing a bunch of strangers as inherently mental illness.

What to do about these forms of mental illness is much more complicated.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom