Split Thread Mainstream vs. fringe science

Much of Einstein's life indicates the opposite- he was a very socially adept person (even to the point of some unseemly enthusiasms in regard to sexual liaisons). I probably am autistic in many ways myself and I fully appreciate people who are even more so than I am, but there is no reason to bring this up here. Red herring.

Many people with autism can fake being normal for short periods of time. Einstein made a contract with one of his wives about daily duties and her behavior. If that doesn't sound like autism then what does? In fact I think they stole that and used it in the show The Big Bang theory with one of the characters roommates. And the character who made the contract is known to likely be based on someone with autism.

How is this a red herring?
 
Last edited:
And the fact that mainstream theoretical physics is incredibly stagnant and continues to not lead to any major new discoveries or confirmation.

That's not true and I think you know it. Even a cursory review of recent publications in physics will reveal your claim is at odds with reality.

If you're going to engage in a debate, at least have the decency to do so without deliberate lying.
 
I think his point is that the alleged Einstein quote you posted is not evidence of Einstein being autistic in any way, shape or form.

I said that in my comment. But those are autistic traits. I didn't say they were only autistic traits though. Those traits happen to be traits that helped me discover things I have. I was just trying to show common traits I feel I have with Einstein.
 
That's not true and I think you know it. Even a cursory review of recent publications in physics will reveal your claim is at odds with reality.

I should have said quantum mechanics theories specifically - especially the wild claims from quantum mechanics. If there are major breakthroughs that prove these claims I think we would all be aware of them in this thread. So where are they?


If you're going to engage in a debate, at least have the decency to do so without deliberate lying.

If you are going to expect me to carry on a debate with as many people as I am in these threads at least have the decency to no nitpick my posts and force me to write like a lawyer to prevent being attacked for any trumped up error...

At least have the courtesy to consider the context of the discussion here rather than accuse me of lying.
 
Yes he was mainstream science, used the way and avenue of the time to publish, and even proposed way to falsify his own hypothesis, and while he revolutionned physic, he was wrong on some points, and i contend that seeing at the way physic was evolving at the epoch, it was a question if time before somebody else was going this direction too.

There is simply no comparison between einstein and mills.

And for one einstein there are many hundreds of schrödinger, gibbs, pasteur, and so forth.
I would disagree with your statement Einstein was mainstream. In order for a science to be mainstream it has to be well established; his theory was heretical up until it's first experimental proof in 1919. However, you are right on the money that Einstein vs Mills method of doing science have nothing in common.
 
I would disagree with your statement Einstein was mainstream. In order for a science to be mainstream it has to be well established; his theory was heretical up until it's first experimental proof in 1919. However, you are right on the money that Einstein vs Mills method of doing science have nothing in common.

Einstein wasn't in the private sector. Mills seemed to have no choice but to go outside of academia which is why he has to do things differently.
 
Last edited:
I said that in my comment. But those are autistic traits. I didn't say they were only autistic traits though. Those traits happen to be traits that helped me discover things I have. I was just trying to show common traits I feel I have with Einstein.

Well, ...

Right off hand, I can think of one very significant thing that both you and Einstein have in common.
 
We don't know. The entire model could be completely wrong and both the mainstream and Mills could be wrong.

Ah so you don't know when you said "we don't even know what makes up 90 percent of the known universe.". Why don't you know the veracity of your own assertions?

What "entire model could be completely wrong", do try to be specific?

Technically any model that conforms to observational data can't be "completely wrong". How much and in what ways a model may need to be revised depends on how well or poorly it comports with observational data.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom