Split Thread Mainstream vs. fringe science

Holistic? Perhaps you can explain how Einstein's approach was holistic? In many ways he simply explored the implications of what was already known. These implications were startlingly, but flowed out of very established physics.

well he put the “whole” together, so it could be called wholistic
 
I should have said quantum mechanics theories specifically - especially the wild claims from quantum mechanics. If there are major breakthroughs that prove these claims I think we would all be aware of them in this thread. So where are they?

If you want proof, we can start with the semiconductors in the very computers we're using to have this discussion. Unlike Mills, Quantum theory has lead to actual technology that works.

As for your laughable claim that the field is stagnant:

New method improves stability of perovskite quantum dots

New Support for Alternative Quantum View

An experiment claims to have invalidated a decades-old criticism against pilot-wave theory, an alternative formulation of quantum mechanics that avoids the most baffling features of the subatomic universe.

Science Daily has a whole "Quantum Physics" section:
https://www.sciencedaily.com/news/matter_energy/quantum_physics/
And that's just the stuff that hits the pop since cycle.

Yeah, TOTALLY stagnant field.

Totally :rolleyes:
 
That just happens to maybe be the biggest mystery in science - how gravity works. The entire model relies on our non existent understanding of how gravity works.

By all means please show the factor in the model that represents "our non existent understanding of how gravity works."?

If we don't understand gravity then how can we assume that our model is correct?

Same way we test every model, by how well it comports to observational evidence.

Why would we even think that is the right decision to make? It seems unbelievably arrogant to me. Our first step should be to completely re-evaluate our understanding of gravity rather than just assume we are right and that we just can't find 90% of the universe.

Again observational evidence indicates that "90% of the universe" interacts by gravity. That's how we notice it. So our "understanding of gravity" isn't at issue in that regard.

This is one of the reasons I have zero faith in mainstream science because it fits all the flaws I see throughout society and mainstream science. It's blind group think.

OK, great, I'm aware of no current physical model that requires "faith" as a relevant factor.


This is also why I tend to trust Mills. Because he seems to see the same thing. Mills has an autistic like view of the world as well IMO.

If both you and Mills were, say, both kleptomaniacs would you trust Mills simply because of that?
 
That just happens to maybe be the biggest mystery in science - how gravity works. The entire model relies on our non existent understanding of how gravity works.
Really?

While it may seem mysterious to some, GR provides an extraordinarily precise understanding of "how gravity works".

What is, as yet, not known is how GR and QM play nice together, in "the strong field" limit. It'd be wonderful to test physical regimes in which both have large effects, but as we don't have any black holes to hand (thank goodness!), we'll have to wait a century or two before technology gives us an opportunity to do such tests in our labs.

If we don't understand gravity then how can we assume that our model is correct?
Aside from the fact that we do seem to understand gravity pretty well, we don't :jaw-dropp

All theories in physics (etc) are provisional; the best that can be said is that they are consistent with all relevant experimental and observatinal results within their domain of applicability.

Why would we even think that is the right decision to make? It seems unbelievably arrogant to me. Our first step should be to completely re-evaluate our understanding of gravity rather than just assume we are right and that we just can't find 90% of the universe.
I guess you will be astonished to learn that hundreds, if not thousands, of mainstream scientists (physicists, but also mathematicians, astrophysicists, ...) spend much/most/all of their time doing exactly what you suggest.

This is one of the reasons I have zero faith in mainstream science because it fits all the flaws I see throughout society and mainstream science. It's blind group think.
Now that you know your premise is wrong, maybe your faith will be altered? ;)

This is also why I tend to trust Mills. Because he seems to see the same thing. Mills has an autistic like view of the world as well IMO.
As has been amply demonstrated in the other thread, Mills is more like a scam artist than a revolutionary physicist. Not least because his ideas are demonstrably nonsense.

This is just some random persons view on aspergers but it fits my life and how Mills and Einstein seemed to think.

"People with aspergers are more likely than others to
-think outside the box
-resist peer pressure
-overcome childfood indoctrination
-make important discoveries and inventions
How is that disabled?"
All cats are black.
This animal is black.
Therefore it is a cat.

Is that the sort of logic you subscribe to?
 
If we don't understand gravity then how can we assume that our model is correct?

Define "model."

Are you talking about the mathematical framework for predicting gravitational phenom?

Newtonian Physics?

Are you talking about theoretical gravitons conveying gravitational force?

Are you talking about the description of spacetime as curved as a way of explaining the behavior of objects in relation to their mass?

You keep talking in vagueries like a Creationist and then using those vague observations to leap to absurd conclusions. "We don't know EVERYTHING, therefore, HYDRINOS!" is about as valid a line of reasoning as "We don't know EVERYTHING, therefore JESUS!"

You are ignoring the fact that there are a great many things we DO know through experimental verification. Mills contradicts nearly 150 years of not just theory but observed phenomena. Arguing that gaps in our current knowledge mean Mills could be right is equivalent to claiming that the lack of a definitive answer to the Goldbach Conjecture means 4+2 can equal 42.
 
SkepticalTheorist, revolutionary theories that have been accepted in, say, the last 150 years have built upon or added to, our understanding. They did not make obsolete entire bodies of science. GR explained phenomena Newton's gravity did not. The prion theory of disease has not displaced those of bacterial and viral infection.

"Alternative" scientiests often want us to accept that virtually all we know about a given field of science is wrong and needs to be discarded. Yet the accepted theories have borne much fruit both in terms of applications and further advancements of theories.

Alternative Science that works is called science.
 
That just happens to maybe be the biggest mystery in science - how gravity works. The entire model relies on our non existent understanding of how gravity works.

If we don't understand gravity then how can we assume that our model is correct? Why would we even think that is the right decision to make? It seems unbelievably arrogant to me. Our first step should be to completely re-evaluate our understanding of gravity rather than just assume we are right and that we just can't find 90% of the universe.

This is one of the reasons I have zero faith in mainstream science because it fits all the flaws I see throughout society and mainstream science. It's blind group think.
This is also why I tend to trust Mills. Because he seems to see the same thing. Mills has an autistic like view of the world as well IMO.

This is just some random persons view on aspergers but it fits my life and how Mills and Einstein seemed to think.

"People with aspergers are more likely than others to
-think outside the box
-resist peer pressure
-overcome childhood indoctrination
-make important discoveries and inventions
How is that disabled?"
But what you see as "flaws" are not flaws, as has been shown over and over again in this very thread! You severely misunderstand the science and how new ideas have been widely accepted. You have made many incorrect statements only to have to desperately backpedal when the actual facts were presented.

As to the theory of gravity- it is legitimate to assume that such a well documented theory is correct when trying to first make sense of new data. But science doesn't limit itself to that assumption- certainly there are theories of dark matter that are willing to question even the theory of gravity as we currently understand it. This willingness to accept well documented experimental observations and change theory, even long accepted and "beloved" theory, to match the reality is what makes science so successful. If anything the approach of physics to dark matter strongly negates your proposal that science is a group think endeavor that refuses to consider novel ideas.

As to your last sentence: no one here has suggested that people with Aspergers are disabled. They may be more creative in certain ways. But that does not make them inherently more likely to be correct than others, and it certainly doesn't mean that theories arising from people with Asperger's symptoms need not be tested, as are all theories, against actual experimental evidence
 
You keep talking in vagueries like a Creationist and then using those vague observations to leap to absurd conclusions. "We don't know EVERYTHING, therefore, HYDRINOS!" is about as valid a line of reasoning as "We don't know EVERYTHING, therefore JESUS!"

You are ignoring the fact that there are a great many things we DO know through experimental verification. Mills contradicts nearly 150 years of not just theory but observed phenomena. Arguing that gaps in our current knowledge mean Mills could be right is equivalent to claiming that the lack of a definitive answer to the Goldbach Conjecture means 4+2 can equal 42.

If we don't know how gravity actually works then what do we know about theoretical physics?

We know how gravity behaves to an extent. Our theories seemed to work as far as we had discovered. But what does that prove? Science is at its absolute infancy. So what do we really know about how gravity or the universe works?

I didn't say our lack of understanding meant hydrinos. Hydrinos may not even be necessary because there may not be dark matter in my view.

I might be wrong but that is my interpretation of the info I have seen. And it ties into things I have discovered.

But as I said I don't think the way most people do. I am someone who looks at the big picture rather than getting locked into the details and getting lost in them. I think that is how you find the the answers we are missing.

Define "model."

By model I meant the mathematics we use to predict how the universe should work which we then used to make a computer model of how the universe operated and then determined that something was horribly wrong.
 
Last edited:
But as I said I don't think the way most people do. I am someone who looks at the big picture rather than getting locked into the details and getting lost in them. I think that is how you find the the answers we are missing.

By ignoring the core details, you are building a flawed "big picture" based not upon reality but upon misinformation. You are looking at a car, speculating on how it runs and how to make it more efficient, but refusing to learn anything about the engine.

If you cracked the hood and learned a thing or two about the engine, you'd see why Mills is wrong when he tells you it's full of hamsters.

You're being too "big picture" to contribute anything of value. You need to do some more learning about the world around you.
 
You're being too "big picture" to contribute anything of value. You need to do some more learning about the world around you.

I think you have that totally backwards. I have been proven right on too many things.

Just to give you an idea of where I am coming from. I got in touch with a relative of a famous scientist who passed away and told this person things I felt I discovered and they thought I was way ahead of anyone they had talked to before. This person said I should write a book. This relative also knows more about this subject than nearly everyone on the planet because they witnessed what happened to their relative first hand.
 
But as I said I don't think the way most people do. I am someone who looks at the big picture rather than getting locked into the details and getting lost in them. I think that is how you find the the answers we are missing.

I wish I had a nickel for every crackpot I've heard make that claim about topics they don't understand.

There is even a crackpot index: http://math.ucr.edu/home/baez/crackpot.html
 
I think you have that totally backwards. I have been proven right on too many things.

Citation needed.

Just to give you an idea of where I am coming from. I got in touch with a relative of a famous scientist who passed away and told this person things I felt I discovered and they thought I was way ahead of anyone they had talked to before. This person said I should write a book. This relative also knows more about this subject than nearly everyone on the planet because they witnessed what happened to their relative first hand.

Cool story! It proves NOTHING!

But hey, you and Mills keep talking about better ways to feed the hamsters in your Honda. I'm sure you'll make a fortune once he brings his new Automotive Hamster Food(tm) to market.
 
I think you have that totally backwards. I have been proven right on too many things.

Just to give you an idea of where I am coming from. I got in touch with a relative of a famous scientist who passed away and told this person things I felt I discovered and they thought I was way ahead of anyone they had talked to before. This person said I should write a book. This relative also knows more about this subject than nearly everyone on the planet because they witnessed what happened to their relative first hand.

I would like to hear more about this.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom