Split Thread Mainstream vs. fringe science

Einstein wasn't in the private sector. Mills seemed to have no choice but to go outside of academia which is why he has to do things differently.
Einstein certainly had his detractors even after the test of his theory via a solar eclipse on May 29 1919. Mills has had plenty of time to produce evidence, yet has none. It doesnt matter how evidence is gotten so long as its gotten.
 
I don't know what kind of evidence you are looking for. The claim of dark matter is mostly based on a theoretical model. Why should we assume the model is accurate and that there is in fact 90% of the universe missing?

Nope, the claim is based entirely on observational evidence. No "theoretical model" projected dark matter. So the "kind of evidence" Red Baron Farms would be looking for would be evidence that such observational evidence was somehow in error. Got any? Or perhaps you just don't know?
 
Einstein wasn't in the private sector. Mills seemed to have no choice but to go outside of academia which is why he has to do things differently.
Mills had plenty of choice. There was (and is) absolutely nothing stopping him submitting a paper to a peer reviewed scientific journal describing how to generate/isolate hydrinos and verify their nature. After nearly 30 years of trying (and failing) to produce a commercial product based on them he can't even reasonably offer the 'trade secret' excuse not to do so any more. Yet he continues to choose not to.
 
I don't know what kind of evidence you are looking for. The claim of dark matter is mostly based on a theoretical model. Why should we assume the model is accurate and that there is in fact 90% of the universe missing?

As I understand it, it is the opposite- the "claim" of dark matter arises from experimental observations, not a pre-existing theoretical model. Actual observations indicated that galaxies were not behaving as anticipated. The only "theoretical model" which led to the proposal of "dark matter" was the theory of gravity, which when applied to the actual observations suggested that there was more matter in the universe than expected or detected. There are many reasons to begin by assuming that the theory of gravity is correct. Therefore the simplest explanation would be that there is more matter in the universe than previously believed or observed; thus the loose and somewhat dry-humored name "dark matter." But physicists are very open to additional or alternative explanations as to what is the reason behind the actual observations, including changes to the theory of gravity itself (as they accepted the modifications to Newton's theory of gravity mandated by Relativity). But any changes have to help explain all the experimental observations- one can't propose a new theory of gravity to explain "dark matter" if that new theory would also predict that an apple would fall up from a tree. Or simply say- IT IS WRONG but I can't explain why other than that is what a cool rebel and anti-established hero should believe.
 
Last edited:
ST, what concrete examples can you cite of notable advances in physics or chemistry (including space science and astrophysics), made by non-mainstream folk, in the last century?
 
Ah so you don't know when you said "we don't even know what makes up 90 percent of the known universe.". Why don't you know the veracity of your own assertions?

You are being too vague. I don't know what you are saying here exactly. If you make a cryptic statement here I can't respond to then you can pretend I didn't have a response I guess.

What "entire model could be completely wrong", do try to be specific?

That's hypocritical.

Technically any model that conforms to observational data can't be "completely wrong". How much and in what ways a model may need to be revised depends on how well or poorly it comports with observational data.

We don't have all the data, so why pretend we have the right answers/theories?
 
I would disagree with your statement Einstein was mainstream. In order for a science to be mainstream it has to be well established; his theory was heretical up until it's first experimental proof in 1919. However, you are right on the money that Einstein vs Mills method of doing science have nothing in common.
I think there's some confusion here ...

Are you referring to General Relativity (GR)?

If so, the first experimental proof didn't come until Pound-Rebka (1957?).

1919 saw the results of the eclipse expeditions, confirming GR deflection of light. But the anomalous advance of the perihelion of Mercury was known well before that, and GR explained it nicely, well before 1919.
 
ST, what concrete examples can you cite of notable advances in physics or chemistry (including space science and astrophysics), made by non-mainstream folk, in the last century?

Why do you limit it to those disciplines? Those just so happen to be the most controlled for like 60 years at least..
 
I really don't understand why so many people outside academia think academia is a mind-controlled, highly restricted, anti-creativity, anti-new idea conservative establishment. As has been stated multiple times before: the absolutely best method of obtaining spectacular success in academia is to come up with a new theory that no one else thought of before. The only requirement: one has to prove it! And not unexpectedly, the more a new proposal calls into question the established way of looking at things, the more solid the proof expected (not too much to ask for as I see it- we ask as much in our day to day lives). It may take a little longer to have a truly radical ad novel concept widely accepted, but perhaps that is not bad. And it will be accepted if its predictions are confirmed experimentally.
 
I should have said quantum mechanics theories specifically - especially the wild claims from quantum mechanics. If there are major breakthroughs that prove these claims I think we would all be aware of them in this thread. So where are they?

<snip>
I guess it depends on what you mean by "quantum mechanics theories", but how about the Standard Model (of particle physics)? Resolution of the EPR paradox (Aspect's work, etc)? Superconductivity? Condensates (e.g. Bose-Einstein)? Why neutrinos are not massless?
 
You are being too vague. I don't know what you are saying here exactly. If you make a cryptic statement here I can't respond to then you can pretend I didn't have a response I guess.

I was specific.

That's hypocritical.

How is asking you "What "entire model could be completely wrong"" "hypocritical"? Don't you know what model your own assertion refers to? Do you think mainstream science only has one model for absolutely everything?


We don't have all the data, so why pretend we have the right answers/theories?

Not having "all the data" is not the same as having no data and we have data for dark matter.

Who exactly is pretending to "have the right answers/theories", again please be specific. How exactly does one "pretend" to get accurate data from wrong or just inaccurate models?
 
I would disagree with your statement Einstein was mainstream. In order for a science to be mainstream it has to be well established; his theory was heretical up until it's first experimental proof in 1919.

I note that this harks back to Skeptical Theorist's earlier post where he conceded that Einstein's work WAS mainstream, but that his career path was not.

Was Einstein taking the mainstream path of a world class theoretical physicist?

Again.. this is a lawyerly debate. Technically he was mainstream.. but was he mainstream for a revolutionary theoretical physicist?

Show me proof that Einstein was on the conventional path of a world class theoretical physicists. Unless you do that you aren't refuting the point I was making. You are refuting the point you imagine I made.

Let's take the last point first. What, exactly, is the conventional path of a world class theoretical physicist? And just how many of them constitute the statistical data base? It's true that most of the great physicists had straightforward academic careers, but how many of them were "revolutionary"? Take, for instance Einstein's Nobel-winning paper on the photoelectric effect. He built directly on the work of Max Planck, and Planck was a private tutor for 5 years after getting his degree. Einstein was a tutor for about 2 years, and the patent office job was a god-send to him. On the one hand, it let him get married and support a family, and on the other hand it gave him lots of time to think. Was Planck a "world class revolutionary theoretical physicist"? if not, who was?

Now the first point. Einstein was very much part of the mainstream - the questions he addressed were some of the burning questions of the day (if you were a physicist), and his ideas clearly accepted much of the existing mathematics and conceptualization. During the period 1901 through 1904 he published 5 papers in Annalen der Physik, a very well-known mainstream journal (although in 1907 he said the first two were worthless). Is this the mark of an outsider? Is this the mark of a heretic?

His first big paper, on Brownian Motion, dealt with what Einstein called the molecular-kinetic theory of heat, which was something of a hot issue at the time. At this remove in time it's hard to realize that (for physicists, rather than chemist) atoms and molecules were only really beginning to be accepted, and the implications for issues such as energy and heat were still evolving. And, it's worth noting, Einstein references one of his earlier papers in it, showing that self-citation is hardly a new phenomenon.

His Nobel winner on the photoelectric effect used Planck's idea of quantization of light, but it avoided the pitfall of associating it with the corpuscular theory of light, which would have been a big problem. Again, this showed considerable awareness of mainstream thought and experiment.

Finally, the theory which Steven calls "heretical" must be GR, which was supported in 1919 by the observations of the transit of Mercury. GR was proposed in 1915, and while much argued was hardly heretical. What Einstein was noted for prior to that time was Special Relativity, which was generally well-received, but sufficiently revolutionary that it took some years to be entirely accepted. However, revolutionary or not, it explained a whole raft of issues associated with areas such as electrodynamics and astronomy, and was never met with derision or knee-jerk rejection.
 
Last edited:
We don't have all the data, so why pretend we have the right answers/theories?
Within the last couple of years we have seen significant vindications of mainstream theories (the discoveries of the Higgs Boson and gravitational waves). Yes there are things we still don't know, but that is not an excuse to wilfully ignore what we do know. And we do know that Mills theories are inconsistent with no supporting evidence, and that he has utterly failed to produce a commercial product based on them after nearly 30 years of trying.
 
The only "theoretical model" which led to the proposal of "dark matter" was the theory of gravity

That just happens to maybe be the biggest mystery in science - how gravity works. The entire model relies on our non existent understanding of how gravity works.

If we don't understand gravity then how can we assume that our model is correct? Why would we even think that is the right decision to make? It seems unbelievably arrogant to me. Our first step should be to completely re-evaluate our understanding of gravity rather than just assume we are right and that we just can't find 90% of the universe.

This is one of the reasons I have zero faith in mainstream science because it fits all the flaws I see throughout society and mainstream science. It's blind group think.

This is also why I tend to trust Mills. Because he seems to see the same thing. Mills has an autistic like view of the world as well IMO.

This is just some random persons view on aspergers but it fits my life and how Mills and Einstein seemed to think.

"People with aspergers are more likely than others to
-think outside the box
-resist peer pressure
-overcome childhood indoctrination
-make important discoveries and inventions
How is that disabled?"
 
Last edited:
I really don't understand why so many people outside academia think academia is a mind-controlled, highly restricted, anti-creativity, anti-new idea conservative establishment. As has been stated multiple times before: the absolutely best method of obtaining spectacular success in academia is to come up with a new theory that no one else thought of before. The only requirement: one has to prove it! And not unexpectedly, the more a new proposal calls into question the established way of looking at things, the more solid the proof expected (not too much to ask for as I see it- we ask as much in our day to day lives). It may take a little longer to have a truly radical ad novel concept widely accepted, but perhaps that is not bad. And it will be accepted if its predictions are confirmed experimentally.

Because you have to paint the opposition as deficient, defective, or defunct in some manor. Otherwise that your soundly structured arguments for your steadfast position have not surely swayed them means the problem is just in your position and/or arguments.
 
I would disagree with your statement Einstein was mainstream. In order for a science to be mainstream it has to be well established; his theory was heretical up until it's first experimental proof in 1919.

I note that this harks back to Skeptical Researcher's earlier post where he conceded that Einstein's work WAS mainstream, but that his career path was not.

Was Einstein taking the mainstream path of a world class theoretical physicist?

Again.. this is a lawyerly debate. Technically he was mainstream.. but was he mainstream for a revolutionary theoretical physicist?

Show me proof that Einstein was on the conventional path of a world class theoretical physicists. Unless you do that you aren't refuting the point I was making. You are refuting the point you imagine I made.

Let's take the last point first. What, exactly, is the conventional path of a world class theoretical physicist? And just how many of them constitute the statistical data base? It's true that most of the great physicists had straightforward academic careers, but how many of them were "revolutionary"? Take, for instance Einstein's Nobel-winning paper on the photoelectric effect. He built directly on the work of Max Planck, and Planck was a private tutor for 5 years after getting his degree. Einstein was a tutor for about 2 years, and the patent office job was a god-send to him. On the one hand, it let him get married and support a family, and on the other hand it gave him lot's of time to think. Was Planck a "world class revolutionary theoretical physicist"? if not, who was?

Now the first point. Einstein was very much part of the mainstream - the questions he addressed were some of the burning questions of the day (if you were a physicist). During the period 1901 through 1904 he published 5 papers in Annalen der Physik, a very well-known mainstream journal (although in 1907 he said the first two were worthless). Is this the mark of an outsider? Is this the mark of a heretic?

His first big paper, on Brownian Motion, dealt with what Einstein called the molecular-kinetic theory of heat, which was something of a hot issue at the time. And, it's worth noting, Einstein references one of his earlier papers in it, showing that self-citation is hardly a new phenomenon.

His Nobel winner on the photoelectric effect used Planck's idea of quantization of light, but it avoided the pitfall of associating it with the corpuscular theory of light, which would have been a big problem. Again, this showed considerable awareness of mainstream thought and experiment.

Finally, the theory which Steven calls "heretical" must be GR, which was supported in 1919 by the observations of the transit of Mercury. GR was proposed in 1915, and while much argued was hardly heretical. What Einstein was noted for prior to that time was Special Relativity, which was generally well-received, but sufficiently revolutionary that it took some years to be entirely accepted. However, revolutionary or not, it explained a whole raft of issues associated with areas such as electrodynamics and astronomy, and was never met with derision or knee-jerk rejection.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom