Split Thread Mainstream vs. fringe science

Guys... a word of warning.. don't ever try to out-argue an Aspie... it can only lead to your defeat.
So you're trolling. Well, that's obvious based on your almost four hundred posts so far within the past few days with nothing but short one-liners of drivel, baseless accusations, fantasy and off-topic pettifoggery.


It's over guys.. walk it off. :D
You wish. Keep spouting ignorant, paranoid, delusional nonsense and you'll get called on it again and again. For years. Literally.
 
So you're trolling. Well, that's obvious based on your almost four hundred posts so far within the past few days with nothing but short one-liners of drivel, baseless accusations, fantasy and off-topic pettifoggery.



You wish. Keep spouting ignorant, paranoid, delusional nonsense and you'll get called on it again and again. For years. Literally.

That's some serious irony right there...

What have I said that is trolling? It's the complete opposite.
 
In the Science section of the forum, fact less fantasies are deceitful. Your time would be better employed supporting your assertions with evidence.

And the real trolling continues...

You have been knocked out twice - Michio and then the D-K debacle.. What a glutton.

I don't blame you for changing the subject again as well.
 
Last edited:
And the real trolling continues...

You have been knocked out twice - Michio and then the D-K debacle.. What a glutton.

I don't blame you for changing the subject again as well.

He was responding to your post, so if there were a subject change, it was at your hand. He also accused you of deceit and backed his claim with evidence.

What specific evidence do you have for your apparently baseless "you have been knocked out twice" claim?
 
He was responding to your post, so if there were a subject change, it was at your hand. He also accused you of deceit and backed his claim with evidence.

What specific evidence do you have for your apparently baseless "you have been knocked out twice" claim?

Wow.. you guys have no shame. Have you ever been wrong about anything? It's unbelievable.

I refute his claim with his OWN source... he ignores it then you pretend it didn't happen.

I refute your claims with one of the most prestigious theoretical physicists in the world in Kaku and you also pretend it wasn't complete destruction.

And this is from people constantly twisting every argument and comment into a pissing match. And your fellow skeptics won't even call you on your own behavior.. they support it!

"In a time of universal deceit - telling the truth is a revolutionary act."
 
That's some serious irony right there...
Chalk up 'irony' as another word you grossly misunderstand.


What have I said that is trolling? It's the complete opposite.
Pretty much everything you've said equates to trolling. One-liners, insults, paranoid rants about science and skeptics, your constant flip-flopping on the things you say (by retracting or denying saying them a post or two later), refusal to substantively answer coherent questions put to you mainly by JAQing off, saying vague statements and expecting us all to understand and to give you credit when you have earned none.


In a time of universal deceit - telling the truth is a revolutionary act.
LOL First you compare yourself to Einstein and now to a truth-revolutionary! You've not told any truth, just made vague, paranoid comments about how everyone else is close-minded, lied to, duped, fooled, and on and on.

As I said, set yourself and your exceedingly biased opinions aside and let FACTS speak for you. So far, you've been all bark and no bite. That's all you got, apparently.

Why don't you try your luck at another forum as I suggested? You'll get the accolades you feel you deserve, after all. You aren't stuck with us meanie, lock-step skeptics by any means.
 
Wow.. you guys have no shame. Have you ever been wrong about anything? It's unbelievable.

I refute his claim with his OWN source... he ignores it then you pretend it didn't happen.

I refute your claims with one of the most prestigious theoretical physicists in the world in Kaku and you also pretend it wasn't complete destruction.

And this is from people constantly twisting every argument and comment into a pissing match. And your fellow skeptics won't even call you on your own behavior.. they support it!

"In a time of universal deceit - telling the truth is a revolutionary act."
Again, a theoretical physicist is no expert on the history of Einstein's personal life. Don't you get it yet?

Quote a legitimate historian regarding Einstein's personal life and what his father may or may not thought of him and then there will be no argument. You don't so you're gonna get grief.

Show us the facts. Come up with some evidence for once in your life.
 
Wow.. you guys have no shame. Have you ever been wrong about anything? It's unbelievable.

I refute his claim with his OWN source... he ignores it then you pretend it didn't happen.

You would need to be clearer about what you are talking about. You posted something about telling the truth and Reality Check provided evidence your posts were less than truthful.

You can either counter is claim with actual evidence, or leave us all to assume Reality Check is correct and you are deceitful.

I refute your claims with one of the most prestigious theoretical physicists in the world in Kaku and you also pretend it wasn't complete destruction.

I made no such claim, nor do I make any claims regarding destruction thereof.

And this is from people constantly twisting every argument and comment into a pissing match. And your fellow skeptics won't even call you on your own behavior.. they support it!

Perhaps if you supported your claims rather than ranting about them you'd get more traction.

"In a time of universal deceit - telling the truth is a revolutionary act."

Repeating a discredited claim does not change that it was discredited.
 
Again, a theoretical physicist is no expert on the history of Einstein's personal life. Don't you get it yet?

Why won't you backup your claim? Hypocrisy I have responded to this and you had no response.

Quote a legitimate historian regarding Einstein's personal life and what his father may or may not thought of him and then there will be no argument. You don't so you're gonna get grief.

Show us the facts. Come up with some evidence for once in your life.

Do you guys realize you talk out of both sides of your mouths? You claim mainstream science is the be all end all then you show no faith in your own religion when it suits you.

You guys pick and choose your claims to hide that the emperor has no clothes.....

Universal deceit...
 
You can either counter is claim with actual evidence, or leave us all to assume Reality Check is correct and you are deceitful.

I countered his claim with your own authority in Kaku.. I countered his own claim with his own source on D-K.

You guys make all the rules and don't follow them yourselves. You don't backup any of your own claims then say the opposition must backup their claims.

You are the epitome of bullies.

And you call yourselves skeptics.... You show the nature of your own dogma...

There is no greater example of D-K than someone accusing others of D-K and not even knowing what it means...! Even trying to refute their definition of D-K with a source that refutes their own claim and then pretending it never happened!

This is intellectual terrorism! This is a Jihad.
 
There is a fairy tale called "The Emperor's New Clothes." In the story the Emperor is a vain man and always wants the newest fashions. A couple of swindlers convince him that the clothes they are making him are of such fine quality that only the most elevated people can see them. He can't admit that he's not the most elevated person, so he wears the clothes in the palace, and everyone bows down and says what a fine set of clothes he has because they are afraid to contradict the Emperor. Then he goes out and leads a parade to show off his new clothes to the people (lack of foresight on his part, unless he thinks all his people are highly elevated.) Everyone pretends to admire the clothes except one little boy who yells out "But the Emperor has no clothes." The moral is that because of pretentiousness and social hypocrisy people pretend to know about or agree with certain things because it makes them look better. And also, I suppose, that the honesty of the innocent is best.

Edited by Agatha: 
When quoting from elsewhere, please enclose the quoted material in quote tags, ensure it is no more than one or two paragraphs and provide a link. This appears to have been sourced from https://www.quora.com/What-does-the-emperor-has-no-clothes-mean
 
Last edited by a moderator:
SkepticalTheorist: Fails to understand the Dunning–Kruger effect Wikipedia article

...I don't blame you for changing the subject again as well.
The subject of my post was the same as it has been for the last few days - your failure to back up your assertions with evidence.

But if you want a change from that subject:
15 June 2017 SkepticalTheorist: Fails to understand the Dunning–Kruger effect Wikipedia article.
This is the Dunning–Kruger effect
In the field of psychology, the Dunning–Kruger effect is a cognitive bias, wherein persons of low ability suffer from illusory superiority when they mistakenly assess their cognitive ability as greater than it is. The cognitive bias of illusory superiority derives from the metacognitive inability of low-ability persons to recognize their own ineptitude. Without the self-awareness of metacognition, low-ability people cannot objectively evaluate their actual competence or incompetence.[1]
The effect was seen in various studies but you believe that only half of each study was done :p!
The participants
  1. Ranked their own competence in a test
  2. Had their test scored.
The two values were compared. If everyone had a realistic evaluation of their competence then rank and score should be similar. Highly ranked participants will have high scores. Lowly ranked participants will have low scores. But some highly ranked participants had low scores - thus the D-K effect of "illusory superiority".
 
Last edited:
I countered his claim with your own authority in Kaku.. I countered his own claim with his own source on D-K.

Not sure where you did that, but how was that responsive to Reality Check's post? For your reference, here are his points:


You guys make all the rules and don't follow them yourselves. You don't backup any of your own claims then say the opposition must backup their claims.

You have again made an unsubstantiated claim. Where did I make a claim I have not supported?

You are the epitome of bullies.

You have again made an unsubstantiated claim. Where did I act as the epitome of a bully?

And you call yourselves skeptics.... You show the nature of your own dogma...

You have again made an unsubstantiated claim. Where did I make a claim I was a skeptic?

There is no greater example of D-K than someone accusing others of D-K and not even knowing what it means...!

Yes, you did that, and yes, it did appear you were unfamiliar with the term.

Even trying to refute their definition of D-K with a source that refutes their own claim and then pretending it never happened!

If you say so. I wouldn't agree, though.

This is intellectual terrorism! This is a Jihad.

Again, you have been given a simple request: Back up your claims. Not just one or two that you think you have covered; all of them. And when challenged on one claim, do not try to defend it by referring to a totally different claim.

It really is that simple. Make a claim. Provide support for the claim.
 
The subject of my post was the same as it has been for the last few days - your failure to back up your assertions with evidence.

But if you want a change from that subject:
15 June 2017 SkepticalTheorist: Fails to understand the Dunning–Kruger effect Wikipedia article.
This is the Dunning–Kruger effect

The effect was seen in various studies but you believe that only half of each study was done :p!
The participants
  1. Ranked their own competence in a test
  2. Had their test scored.
The two values were compared. If everyone had a realistic evaluation of their competence then rank and score should be similar. Highly ranked participants will have high scores. Lowly ranked participants will have low scores. But some highly ranked participants had low scores - thus the D-K effect of "illusory superiority".

You continue to show your hypocrisy and D-K.
 
I countered his claim with your own authority in Kaku..
It was you who made the claim, SkepticalTheorist. It was you who then tried to support the claim by citing a video that you may not have viewed and a book that you have probably not read. It is you now resorting to the logical fallacy of argument from authority.

In short: What you imagine that anyone states is not evidence that the statement exists.

ETA: Your next post does not address: 15 June 2017 SkepticalTheorist: Fails to understand the Dunning–Kruger effect Wikipedia article.
 
Last edited:
It was you who made the claim, SkepticalTheorist. It was you who then tried to support the claim by citing a video that you may not have viewed and a book that you have probably not read. It is you now resorting to the logical fallacy of argument from authority.

In short: What you imagine that anyone states is not evidence that the statement exists.

ETA: Your next post does not address: 15 June 2017 SkepticalTheorist: Fails to understand the Dunning–Kruger effect Wikipedia article.

Your entire position is argument from authority. Then you cast that away to save face... You are the king of D-K... and now your king has no clothes. I declothed your king!

Victory! How sweet it is! I love how the Algonquin roundtable ran to his aide as well. lol
 
Darwin - Kaku effect

D-K! LOL

Charles Darwin has been quoted as saying, “Ignorance more frequently begets confidence than does knowledge.”
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom