Split Thread Mainstream vs. fringe science

On the evidence of this thread, I know infinitely more about Mills history and his claims including the mighty tome than you do.

Who is more likely to suffer from D-K - someone who asks questions all the time or someone telling people what the answers are all the time?
 
I have studied Mills work and related information for almost a decade - full time. ...
Mostly a derail into the thread this one was spilt from but there is a bit of relevance to "Mainstream vs. fringe science".
Almost blind faith in a theory is a signature of fringe science, e.g. we believe in X even though we do not have the skills to evaluate X or what other people say about X.
Part of mainstream science is that to believe in X, the skills to evaluate X are needed. For example a person with only first year undergraduate quantum mechanics should not be evaluating whether quantum mechanics is correct. The main reason in this case is that modern QM is not the Schrödinger equation!

You state that you have been studying X for "almost a decade - full time". A decade of full time work is enough to get a PhD in some subjects! Thus by now you must either have the skills to see that X is invalid (see the other thread) or are expressing an opinion based on faith, not knowledge.
 
This is one massive strawman because I haven't made any claims.. I have mainly asked questions related to how I perceive things.
Lets see just off the top of my head...you claimed Mills work was equivalent to work with hot fusion. You defended a few other Mills claims regarding hydrinos being as plausible as simple exothermic reactions, when clearly they are not plausible at all. You claimed Einstein wasn't mainstream science. Then you went into this gnostic/conspiracy phase which made vague claims for God only knows what, since you were so vague in both the claim and the evidence. First off what pattern? Secondly what evidence for the pattern? You provided neither.
 
You state that you have been studying X for "almost a decade - full time". A decade of full time work is enough to get a PhD in some subjects! Thus by now you must either have the skills to see that X is invalid (see the other thread) or are expressing an opinion based on faith, not knowledge.

I think you are suffering from Dunning-Kruger here since you are speaking on a subject you don't really know anything about - me.
 
Lets see just off the top of my head...you claimed Mills work was equivalent to work with hot fusion. You defended a few other Mills claims regarding hydrinos being as plausible as simple exothermic reactions, when clearly they are not plausible at all. You claimed Einstein wasn't mainstream science. Then you went into this gnostic/conspiracy phase which made vague claims for God only knows what, since you were so vague in both the claim and the evidence. First off what pattern? Secondly what evidence for the pattern? You provided neither.

You are getting lawerly again... so anytime I relate information I am know of it's a claim?

It sounds like a conversation to me. I said from the beginning I am not an expert on all these subjects. Do I have to make that statement before every comment?

Then will you accept that as not being a claim? From now on I will simply copy and paste a disclaimer before every comment clearing me of all lawerly arguments.
 
This is one massive strawman because I haven't made any claims.. I have mainly asked questions related to how I perceive things.

Red Baron Farms didn't accuse you of making claims. You don't appear to know what a straw man argument is. Dunning-Kruger either, for that matter.
 
Last edited:
You are getting lawerly again... so anytime I relate information I am know of it's a claim?

It sounds like a conversation to me. I said from the beginning I am not an expert on all these subjects. Do I have to make that statement before every comment?

Then will you accept that as not being a claim? From now on I will simply copy and paste a disclaimer before every comment clearing me of all lawerly arguments.
Time to redefine in your mind what lawyerly means and what skeptic means. They are related only in so much as both require evidence and an interpretation of said evidence. If your brain shuts down each and every time the paradigm presents itself, then you really can't master the critical thinking required to be a lawyer, or a scientist, or even a skeptic.:boxedin:
 
Looks like an inability to understand English is becoming more likely, e.g. "But you can write coherent English :eye-poppi!" is not about legal language and is that we can understand what you write.
cited[/URL].

From the person who asked for a source on Einstein and Michio Kaku was insufficient...

That says it all.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom