Split Thread Mainstream vs. fringe science

Again, I warned you about debating an Aspie.

Some people never learn though... Darwin-kaku - in effect.
 
Last edited:
To aspies arguing is like an art form... NTs - neurotypicals - are amateurs.

And you guys think I don't question my beliefs... aspies argue with themselves too. This is how we hone our arguing edge...

Aspie
A superior being, while deficient in chaotic morasses such as small-talk, inferior double-standard-laden customs and values trumpeted by Neurotypicals, and deciphering Neurotypical body-language, more than makes up for it with a sharp, penetrating mind that is highly adept at developing an intense focus on a subject giving them a near-savant level of proficiency, an inborn sense of principles that allows them to develop practically consistent characteristics and values, and an ability to reason independently, reducing their susceptibility to dogma, acceptance of groundless assertions, and the hazards of groupthink.
The eccentric man with the encyclopaedic knowledge, monotone voice, and static facial expression must be an Aspie.
 
SkepticalTheorist: List the posts where I used argument from authority

Your entire position is argument from authority
And now we have:
15 June 2017 SkepticalTheorist: List the posts where I used argument from authority.
FYI: Argument from authority is asserting that an authority is correct because they are an authority. There is correct and incorrect usage of the argument.
Valid forms
The valid form of argument is one in which a recognized and knowledgeable authority on the relevant subject is appealed to by citing a statement by that authority. This is a form of inductive reasoning in that the conclusion is not logically certain, but likely.[22] Examples include following the treatments prescribed by a medical doctor, or citing a respected author to establish claims of fact in a written work.[22]

Fallacious forms
When misused, the argument typically forms an informal fallacy.[23] This form of the argument occurs when the presumed authority appealed to is compromised in some way; such as being an expert in the wrong subject or is giving views from one side of an active controversy.[22] Some examples of this are citing a popular astrophysicist for claims about molecular biology; an Olympic athlete's endorsement of a product they do not use;[24][25] or a long retired professor's claims about a current debate in their field. This forms an informal fallacy because the first proposition is untrue.[22]
The fallacy part of your argument is citing a book by a theoretical physicist to support a historical or biographical statement. A historian is the correct authority. An author of a biography would also be correct.

P.S. Wikipedia is not an authority in itself but the sources it cites are.
 
Last edited:
Reality Check just got reality checked and he still ignores it.

Wow.. unbelievable.

Thank god I didn't reveal the information I have here. It would have been the biggest mistake I ever made.

Maybe as a society we deserve what we are going to get... that's how we have gotten to this point.
 
It's an opinion.
Thanks for the clarification.

It seems that you intended it as an opinion, but at least one ISF member (me) read it as a claim.

Maybe it might be important to make the distinction clear, in your future posts?

You could be lawerly and ignore that it is an opinion and nitpick it to death because of the wording. But then you turn a discussion into a hellish court debate.
Or ... (list a dozen or more plausible alternatives).

My impression is that you quite like trying to force false dichotomies ...
 
I have been reading this board for awhile. I have seen people like Michael Suede, Markie and Progrokker attacked and they couldn't be more congenial yet they are still attacked.
I too have been reading this board for a while.

I cannot comment on who might be "like" ms, markie, and PR.

However, for those three, my opinion is that I have seen nothing like what you describe (which is an opinion, right?)

Maybe we have been reading different threads?

I came on the board very respectfully as well.. but I did have issues with how people did things and noted their behavior. Is that really so bad? Then things escalated from there but it's hard to see myself as being at fault when these people were doing the same thing before I even arrived.
Really?

Myself, I have only just become aware of what seems to me to be a pretty big communication gap ... I had interpreted a great deal of what you wrote as claims, but it seems you intended them as opinions.
 
From the person who asked for a source on Einstein and Michio Kaku was insufficient...

That says it all.
Oh?

I may have missed it, but why do you think that Michio Kaku is a reliable source on Einstein (the person, not the theories he published)?
 
From what you write, that seems to happen a lot, wouldn't you say?

If so, why?

Because I think you are locked into a certain mentality here. It's an us versus them mentality.

Every comment I make is spun to the worst possible interpretation for me.

This is after I have said I didn't claim to be an expert in all areas.

This is after I repeatedly said this is my view etc. But I guess I have to put a disclaimer on every post...

Well... I'm not going to. I am not going to be involved in this. I can't imagine a worse place for discussing important topics.

I don't think you all realize what you are doing to your minds here. I find it funny so many have accused me of not questioning my beliefs...
 
<snip>

The definition of science is the study of nature.
That's your opinion, right?

What, in your opinion, is the definition of the scientific method?

How does the latter relate to the former?

Who fits that description better Mills or the people on this board? Or the high level people who oppose Mills even...
Mills is part of nature, ergo the study of Mills is science, per your definition, right? :D
 
I don't think you all realize what you are doing to your minds here. I find it funny so many have accused me of not questioning my beliefs...

That's because you don't seem to have any beliefs. You claim that you do, but have not disclosed any.:D
 
Disclaimer -

SkepticalTheorist's post is SkepticalTheorist's own and should never be taken as scientific claim/s
Opinions stated in this post are SkepticalTheorist's own and not the views of any cited source unless specifically stated in writing and notarized by SkpeticalTheorist
This post is based on SkepticalTheorist's opinions and personal experience and a composite of many sources which SkepticalTheorist has no intention of citing so read at your own risk
All views stated should be viewed as artistic interpretation and not a strict interpretation of reality
The views, opinions, positions or strategies expressed by SkepticalTheorist and his comments are SkepticalTheorist's alone, and do not necessarily reflect the views, opinions, positions or strategies of SkepticalTheorist, SkepticTheorist or any employee thereof. Makes no representations as to accuracy, completeness, correctness, suitability, or validity of any information on this post and will not be liable for any errors, omissions, or delays in this information or any losses, injuries, or damages arising from its display or use.
SkepticTheorist reserves the right to delete, edit, or alter in any manner SkepticalTheorist sees fit comments that SkepticalTheorist, in SkepticalTheorists sole discretion, deems to be obscene, offensive, defamatory, threatening, in violation of trademark, copyright or other laws, or is otherwise unacceptable.


That's your opinion, right?

https://www.google.com/search?q=sci...0j69i57j0l4.2712j0j8&sourceid=chrome&ie=UTF-8

the intellectual and practical activity encompassing the systematic study of the structure and behavior of the physical and natural world through observation and experiment.

What, in your opinion, is the definition of the scientific method?

I would say Einstein's method is a lot like my method... I hadn't really realized that until thinking about it now. But I am a very visual person... and I absorb information constantly and visualize everything. Creativity is also a huge part of it. I have an endless amount of ideas and I test these in my mind like Einstein's thought experiments.

How does the latter relate to the former?

“Imagination is more important than knowledge. For knowledge is limited to all we now know and understand, while imagination embraces the entire world, and all there ever will be to know and understand.”

https://youtu.be/UKhg68QJlo0?t=2m41s

This is how Einstein thought too.

To learn more about this in relation to aspergers watch this video -

https://youtu.be/NyK5SG9rwWI?t=6m40s


Mills is part of nature, ergo the study of Mills is science, per your definition, right? :D

That's like saying any activity is studying nature. It's true but it would be considered the lowest form of science.

The more unique the study I would think the more important the scientific work.
 
Last edited:
Edited by Agatha: 
Edited for rule 6. Please put this link into your signature if you want it to be referenced in every post.


That's because you don't seem to have any beliefs. You claim that you do, but have not disclosed any.:D

Why should I disclose them here? That's what I keep asking.. but people keep demonstrating why I shouldn't.

How should I use the scientific process to determine if I should post my information here or not?
 
Last edited by a moderator:
... How should I use the scientific process to determine if I should post my information here or not?

You do not. If you are actually looking to do any science, you submit your results to a scientific publication for review. A clear indicator of nonscience is the frequent attempt to do end-runs around disciplined peer review.
 
Edited by Agatha: 
Edited for rule 6. Please put this link into your signature if you want your 'disclaimer' to be referenced in every post.


You do not. If you are actually looking to do any science, you submit your results to a scientific publication for review. A clear indicator of nonscience is the frequent attempt to do end-runs around disciplined peer review.

What if the peers are corrupted though?
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Why won't you backup your claim? Hypocrisy I have responded to this and you had no response.



Do you guys realize you talk out of both sides of your mouths? You claim mainstream science is the be all end all then you show no faith in your own religion when it suits you.

You guys pick and choose your claims to hide that the emperor has no clothes.....

Universal deceit...
How in the name of Beelzebub can someone be ignorant of the difference between the disciplines of history and physics?
 
Your entire position is argument from authority. Then you cast that away to save face... You are the king of D-K... and now your king has no clothes. I declothed your king!

Victory! How sweet it is! I love how the Algonquin roundtable ran to his aide as well. lol

Working up to an empty declaration of victory followed by flouncing off into the undergrowth? We've seen it dozens of times before.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom