Split Thread Mainstream vs. fringe science

From the person who asked for a source on Einstein and Michio Kaku was insufficient...

That says it all.
Did you ever explain why in the world you think Kaku could possibly be a source for that. I don't mean that you didn't hear it from him, I mean why do you consider him the source? How can that even be possible? He's certainly not a first or even second hand source for that.
 
From the person who asked for a source on Einstein and Michio Kaku was insufficient...
That was a post from the person who knows what you asserted, who Michio Kaku is (not a historian) and what a sufficient source is (education does that to you!) :eye-poppi.

13 June 2017 SkepticalTheorist: Cite your sources stating that his father considered Albert Einstein a failure.
That is not a long video with no historian cited.
It is not a book on the scientific discoveries of Albert Einstein that you have not read (no quote)
 
Did you ever explain why in the world you think Kaku could possibly be a source for that. I don't mean that you didn't hear it from him, I mean why do you consider him the source? How can that even be possible? He's certainly not a first or even second hand source for that.

Why would another author on Einstein be considered a better source?
 
Knowledge, not cognitive ability.
SkepticalTheorist, this is the Dunning–Kruger effect
In the field of psychology, the Dunning–Kruger effect is a cognitive bias, wherein persons of low ability suffer from illusory superiority when they mistakenly assess their cognitive ability as greater than it is. The cognitive bias of illusory superiority derives from the metacognitive inability of low-ability persons to recognize their own ineptitude. Without the self-awareness of metacognition, low-ability people cannot objectively evaluate their actual competence or incompetence.[1]
D-K is an illusion that a person has better cognitive ability than they actually have.

The illusion that a person has more knowledge than they actually have would be called ignorance or maybe arrogance.
 
That was a post from the person who knows what you asserted, who Michio Kaku is (not a historian) and what a sufficient source is (education does that to you!) :eye-poppi.

Why does an author need to be considered a historian to be a valid source on Einstein?

Are we in school?

That seems to be where the confusion comes from.. and the brainwashing coincidentally.
 
SkepticalTheorist, this is the Dunning–Kruger effect

D-K is an illusion that a person has better cognitive ability than they actually have.

The illusion that a person has more knowledge than they actually have would be called ignorance or maybe arrogance.

https://www.psychologytoday.com/blog/head-in-the-cloud/201701/the-dunning-kruger-president

"The authors observed that you need skill and knowledge to judge how skilled and knowledgeable you are. A tone-deaf singer may be unable to distinguish her talent from that of the greatest stars. Why then shouldn't she believe she's their equal?"
 
SkepticalTheorist, this is the Dunning–Kruger effect

D-K is an illusion that a person has better cognitive ability than they actually have.

The illusion that a person has more knowledge than they actually have would be called ignorance or maybe arrogance.

From your own source

"he participants’ knowledge of geography was tested; some tests were intended to positively affect the participant’s self-view and some were intended to affect it negatively. The participants then were asked to rate their performances; the participants given tests with a positive intent reported better performance than did the participants given tests with a negative intent.[10]"
 
Why would another author on Einstein be considered a better source?
By being alive at the time the events occurred, having direct contact with the father of Einstein, actually being the Father of Einstein.

How can Kaku possibly be a good source? And what the heck is wrong with just looking at Einstein's situation for ourselves? We've got access to exactly the same reference info Kaku does.
 
By being alive at the time the events occurred, having direct contact with the father of Einstein, actually being the Father of Einstein.

Why would someone with less time to gather knowledge be superior? Why would that make their claims more reliable?

How can Kaku possibly be a good source? And what the heck is wrong with just looking at Einstein's situation for ourselves? We've got access to exactly the same reference info Kaku does.

Oh so now joe internet who has spent how much time studying Einstein is more valid than Kaku? One of the top theoretical physicists of our time who also wrote a book about Einstein?

D-K?
 
Why does an author need to be considered a historian to be a valid source on Einstein?
It is the book that is not a sufficient source for biographical details because:
It is a book on the scientific discoveries of Albert Einstein that you have not read (no quote)
Part 2 on the book

Common sense tells everyone except you that a book written by a theoretical physics is not the best source of biographical details.
How would someone know that Albert Einstein's father was disappointed in him? There must be a document stating that, e.g. a letter from his father (a reliable primary source), a letter from Albert or a relative (a less reliable secondary source), a letter from someone hearing about this (almost hearsay).
Who is most likely to have read through all of the literature involving Albert Einstein, e.g. his and his families letters? A historian.
 
Why would someone with less time to gather knowledge be superior?
They wouldn't. Good thing I didn't say that.
Oh so now joe internet who has spent how much time studying Einstein is more valid than Kaku? One of the top theoretical physicists of our time who also wrote a book about Einstein?
WTF does that have to do with knowing what Einstein and his father were doing and thinking in 1902?? He has access to no information that all the rest of us don't.
 
From your own source
Your quote including your highlight
"he participants’ knowledge of geography was tested; some tests were intended to positively affect the participant’s self-view and some were intended to affect it negatively. The participants then were asked to rate their performances; the participants given tests with a positive intent reported better performance than did the participants given tests with a negative intent.[10]"
 
Yet how much is spent on these projects that bring little results based on theories that never produce anything?

Nice try sneaking that one on there...

Such a foolish thing to say and once again something one would state whom has little comprehension why science is done. You realize you're saying let's throw the baby out with the bathwater. Without pure science applied science would not exist.
 
Last edited:
Such a foolish thing to say and once again something one would state whom has little comprehension why science is done. You realize you're saying let's throw the baby out with the bathwater. Without pure science applied science would not exist.

I think you are misinterpreting my comment.
 
Such a foolish thing to say and once again something one would state whom has little comprehension why science is done. You realize you're saying let's throw the baby out with the bathwater. Without pure science applied science would not exist.

I was just expressing my view that it seems there is a lot of bias against ideas that are out of the mainstream and the mainstream is much more critical of those ideas than the "popular" mainstream ideas. It seems to be a dogma issue to me.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom