Split Thread Mainstream vs. fringe science

World history, science, technology, ancient history, our understanding of the way this country (US) is run now and in the past - the world too.

Truly everything we think we understand is not as we thought.

But I will be the first to admit that many of these things i am not certain of and the whole thing could be one immense charade but the chances seem minute to me.


Great, so it will change everything, even history but perhaps just nothing.

How would you actually tell if it was indeed just "one immense charade"? Seem that would be the first avenue of investigation rather than how you might best disseminate it.
 
OK, so the ratio of truth to unanswered questions actually goes down to an infinitesimal level. Clicheic statements don't really do much to indicate you have actually thought about this.

It answers old questions and creates new ones.. isn't that how science works? I didn't say anything about ratios...

While I too have an insatiable curiosity, I really don't mind some things being kept from me. Having worked at sewage treatment plants I wish knowledge of what people will actually flush down a toilet was still kept from me. Talk about mind boggling.

It might be bad and it might be good or both... I can't control my curiosity so not much I can do.
 
Last edited:
Great, so it will change everything, even history but perhaps just nothing.

How would you actually tell if it was indeed just "one immense charade"? Seem that would be the first avenue of investigation rather than how you might best disseminate it.

I would need help to answer that question. There are things I can't do myself.
 
I suspect that, to ST, "the theoretical explanation" has a special, idiosyncratic meaning, one that differs significantly from what you or I might have.

It's all part of the "mainstream" vs not "paradigm", and likely includes a great many inconsistencies, at many levels ... just look at all the inconsistencies you've pointed out, for example.

Naturally "the theoretical explanation" is shame story told to keep the sheople in the dark.

While those interested in actual mainstream science know there are always a number of competing theories as well as efforts to continually test the veracity of those theories we do regularly employ.
 
Here's an analogy that might make the "skeptic" and "mainstream scientist" position more understandable.<snip>
This is absolutely beautiful. Love. It!


Because there are many elements tied together. I worry that others will get the pieces wrong or that the people hiding this info will spread more disinfo preventing me from getting this info out even more. This is already happening to an extent.
Ever think that due to your abrasive and combative manner, you're just self-fulfilling your own prophecy?



I am giving information about my situation. So where is the problem? Why does it only have to be factual information that can be verified or not?
How else is anyone else to determine a truth-value of the subject or that what you're saying is an accurate reflection of reality?

You've already ignored posters who have confronted you with this very thing. So, stop ignoring them and really pay attention.


I haven't gotten to that stage yet. Another way of saying it is - why is there such a rush? Why can't I start preparing people mentally for what I am going to present?
YOU chose when to post and what to post. If you really need a huge amount of time, then, by all means, take it. Don't try to blame us for your vague, semi-nonsensical statements which say nothing; which explain nothing; which really mean nothing.



It's my interpretation of yours and others actions.
Your interpretations don't match what's really being said though. This is clearly evidenced by your immediate interpretations of ALL or NOTHING while quoting posts which say nothing close to an all-or-nothing point of view.



Recently it dawned on me that the last place I thought of trying to reveal this info might autually work - a skeptic community.

But in seeing how you all respond to this it's not looking good.. I am getting second thoughts. But again it might be my last ditch effort. And depending how you all respond it could prevent me from ever getting this info out. You may vindictively try to shut this down from ever getting out. That is a definite possibility it seems.
Go to an empty-headed, no-thinking website then. I guarantee you that you'd receive a warm, uncritical welcome at literally anything you care to spew. But don't come to a site like ISF where evidence and critical thinking is the foundation of these discussions and expect us to just take your word for... anything at all.

I mean, have you even read other threads here? Regarding proof of immortal souls, or that our reality is actually a Matrix-like simulation (complete with God thrown in for good measure I suppose) or the existence of Bigfoot or the moon landing is a hoax. At least some of them claim to have evidence and present it here which is far better than your track record.


I see what you are saying and I agree. But the nature of this info makes that difficult. People think they already understand these elements. But the key is in the details and how they all fit together.

Think of it like looking at a very complex painting long enough and finally making sense of the chaos. I think anyone could have done what I did if they had the motivation and patience to look.

No one had any motivation to look at this. If I knew someone famous to present this info then that could work.

Also, people wonder why i don't just come out and tell them - this is why. Because if i told you what this was about you would think you already know all this so there is no reason to look. But looking is the key... so how do I manage that?

People need to understand all this before they look.. if nothing else me building it up accomplishes that.
You cannot control what others will think or say so my unasked-for advice is to just ignore that part. If you're right, the evidence will show it and then you have no worries. It's really that simple. Don't let your personal struggles get in the way — make your evidence speak for you and I guarantee you, people WILL listen.


When you know what I know the little things don't really matter anymore.

Also, as someone with asperger syndrome I am used to people laughing at me.
People who laugh at you because of your Asperger Syndrome are ********* and should be driven from normal human company.

I've been around ISF and the JREF long enough to say that I'm confident that no one here laughs at you because of your struggles. You will probably be mocked for claiming paranormal events (for example) with no real evidence, though.


I think that's what a lot of you all don't realize. It's difficult for me to just communicate with people like this. So it puts me at a very big disadvantage and creates more problems for me being understood. But I don't have a choice.
Then demonstrate a little more humbleness and demonstrate a willingness to learn from others first. So far, you've come out swinging and believe me, that does in no way endear you to anyone.


All of you are great at arguing but that doesn't make you right. That's one of the reasons I wonder if it is pointless posting here.
Come here to learn. Ask legitimate questions and accept what people are saying rather than knee-jerk defenses or attacks.

If you came here to teach, then teach it! But you're gonna have to teach with evidence if you want anyone to take you seriously.


You need to remember that I have tried to reveal this info before but didn't reveal all the info. So it's not like this is my first rodeo. Maybe that's a big part of the reason I don't care if people mock me for doing things the way I am. I know that the alternative is equally as bad if not worse.

People have been systematically conditioned to ignore these subjects. For decades and decades if not forever...
You've already decided then. Good luck in your future posting at other non-skeptical, non-scientific sites.
 
It answers old questions and creates new ones.. isn't that how science works? I didn't say anything about ratios...

That's OK, I did. Now you can consider such ratios.

Actually no, experiments are intended to limit variables so you actually only address the question at hand. That other questions may be raised is a matter of happenstance and not a specific requirement of "how science works". The goal of science is to actually reduce the number of question that need to be asked or at least the number of answers that need to be given. For example a grand unified theory would be a single answer to a multitude of physical questions.


It might be bad and it might be good or both... I can't control my curiosity so not much I can do.

So there is nothing you might consider that you really don't want to know? Myself, I'd really rather not know what it feels like to be on fire.
 
So there is nothing you might consider that you really don't want to know? Myself, I'd really rather not know what it feels like to be on fire.

Would you like to know how to prevent yourself from being set on fire in the future?

If we don't find these answers we could be leaving ourselves exposed to something like that.

Actually no, experiments are intended to limit variables so you actually only address the question at hand.

The definition of science is the study of nature. Who fits that description better Mills or the people on this board? Or the high level people who oppose Mills even...
 
Last edited:
I would need help to answer that question. There are things I can't do myself.

So again, that would be the place to start. My curiosity includes questioning the veracity of my own assertions and beliefs. One of the reason I post here is to have my own assertions challenged if I haven't done my due diligence. In the past I've had my arse handed to me here as well. I learned to temper my assertions to limit the extraneous implications and when in doubt say it in the post or check it out before posting.
 
Ever think that due to your abrasive and combative manner, you're just self-fulfilling your own prophecy?

I have been reading this board for awhile. I have seen people like Michael Suede, Markie and Progrokker attacked and they couldn't be more congenial yet they are still attacked.

I came on the board very respectfully as well.. but I did have issues with how people did things and noted their behavior. Is that really so bad? Then things escalated from there but it's hard to see myself as being at fault when these people were doing the same thing before I even arrived.
 
Would you like to know how to prevent yourself from being set on fire in the future?

I've already had extensive fire and safety training and am in fact our company's site safety coordinator.

If we don't find these answers we could be leaving ourselves exposed to something like that.

Unless of course it is just one big charade. You've already lit yourself on fire before checking if the extinguisher you're counting on actually works.
 
Last edited:
Come here to learn. Ask legitimate questions and accept what people are saying rather than knee-jerk defenses or attacks.

Why have skeptics come here to teach rather than to learn? why are they not expected to ask legitimate questions? Legitimate to who? This is part of the brainwashing i see here. People have been conditioned to be so skeptical they seem to be incapable of opening their minds.. Do you see how easy it is to keep people from hidden truths that way?

If you came here to teach, then teach it! But you're gonna have to teach with evidence if you want anyone to take you seriously.

Have you ever seen a teacher try to teach students who have no desire to learn? Is it the teachers fault if they don't try? That's what this place seems like to me.. a bunch of kids who are too cool for school.. I don't mean to throw everyone under that bus but these are the most vocal. I have seen some cool people too but the vocal ones poison the well.
 
My point is that you skeptics give too much credit to mainstream science and assume they are right because they are the authority.
That point is more that is that you seem to not know what a skeptic is, SkepticalTheorist.
Skeptics take the position that assertions without evidence are not correct until that evidence is provided. This is standard practice in in science, i.e. this section of the forum. They ask for evidence when unsupported assertions are made. They know that mainstream science can be given a lot of credit because there is an enormous amount of evidence supporting mainstream science.
Skeptics know about the logical fallacy of argument from authority and so do not use it. They especially know that generally "they are not the authority". There are some working scientists here though who are authorities in their fields. I can think of 1 poster who publishes papers on comets and I would ask them questions about comets, expecting answers backed up with evidence.
 
(for ETA)



The definition of science is the study of nature. Who fits that description better Mills or the people on this board? Or the high level people who oppose Mills even...

Well, Mills certainly seems to be an apt student of human nature. Other than that, without some more well defined criteria and information on the specific people in question, I won't be able to answer. I other words I would need to actually study how and if they study nature and then apply that information to some defined criteria. Then I could at least answer the question within that criteria. That's how science works.
 
How is it trolling to ask for an explanation?
It is trolling when the explanation is readily available and already given to you several times. Here it is yet again - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dark_energy.
Making assertions about dark energy means that you must already know about dark energy, otherwise that is basically the definition of argument from ignorance.
Reminds me of a comedy show I watched recently where he is going through Internet funnies, including people posting questions on a web site that a few seconds of Google would answer or that they should already know. It takes them longer to write and post the question than it would for them to find the answer!
 
It is trolling when the explanation is readily available and already given to you several times. Here it is yet again - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dark_energy.
Making assertions about dark energy means that you must already know about dark energy, otherwise that is basically the definition of argument from ignorance.
Reminds me of a comedy show I watched recently where he is going through Internet funnies, including people posting questions on a web site that a few seconds of Google would answer or that they should already know. It takes them longer to write and post the question than it would for them to find the answer!

This doesn't make sense though because everyone is arguing from ignorance on some level.. Considering every past era was shown to be completely in the dark we should assume the same about this era...
 
I am talking about the Solvay conference ....
Look at the bottom of your screen. See the "Search this Thread:" field? Put Solvay in that field and press the Go button. This post of yours is the first mention of the Solvay conference.
A conference is not your all of quantum mechanics, imaginary outlandish extrapolations, theoretical physicists are flailing around in the dark, etc.

It is Solvay conferences (plural). They are supposed to be held every 3 years and started in 1912. The October 1927 Fifth Solvay International Conference on Electrons and Photons is famous because many of the attendees went on to win Nobel Prizes.
 
<snip>

In, if I recall, Einstein's own terms 'Matter tells space how to bend and space tells matter how to move'.

<snip>
"Spacetime tells matter how to move; matter tells spacetime how to curve."

The late great John Archibald Wheeler.
 
Look at the bottom of your screen. See the "Search this Thread:" field? Put Solvay in that field and press the Go button. This post of yours is the first mention of the Solvay conference.
A conference is not your all of quantum mechanics, imaginary outlandish extrapolations, theoretical physicists are flailing around in the dark, etc.

It is Solvay conferences (plural). They are supposed to be held every 3 years and started in 1912. The October 1927 Fifth Solvay International Conference on Electrons and Photons is famous because many of the attendees went on to win Nobel Prizes.

What purpose does it serve to nitpick and attack any perceived minute error in a conversation other than to derail it?
 
Last edited:
Why have skeptics come here to teach rather than to learn? why are they not expected to ask legitimate questions? Legitimate to who? This is part of the brainwashing i see here. People have been conditioned to be so skeptical they seem to be incapable of opening their minds.. Do you see how easy it is to keep people from hidden truths that way?
You see you're wrong about this too. I have learned a lot from other members of the forum about a variety of topics. Most of us have some special expertise which we bring to bear on various topics on the forum, and members gobble up each other's knowledge. In our world there is the possibility of showing that a proposition is likely to be true or untrue, and the arguments used to arrive at that conclusion are often erudite and educational for others on the forum. In your world, not so much.
 
I guess I will try once more, although getting quite boring.

No assumptions, no authority fallacies, no assertions without evidence.

You have evidence for anything you need to say? Include that evidence or you can be shot down in flames at this site. End of story.

Since so far I have yet to see a single solitary post of yours on any subject that actually included evidence with the statement, I would suggest you stop posting, learn how critical thinking works, then come back and make your case...with evidence.

Just because you have evidence doesn't mean you will always be right. Nor are posts without evidence always wrong. But any CLAIM without evidence will be shot down here until you come back with good evidence and a cognizant interpretation of said evidence.

That's the minimum requirement to be taken seriously and THEN the opposing side will line up with their evidence and that's when people argue it out.

Barring that you will simply be criticized for making bad posts. Me too. If I do it I will be criticised too. Everyone here is subject to this dynamic.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom