Split Thread Mainstream vs. fringe science

I am talking about the Solvay conference - quantum mechanics specifically and the same mentality that has continued since.

Funny that you never mentioned that before, then. Where did you put those goalposts? But of course it's equally a lie to say that quantum mechanics has never led to anything tangible, and a self-refuting lie to post it on the Internet.

Human nature is try to control everything. I think that is why we see such a backlash against Mills.

No, it's because there's no actual substance there for there to be a backlash against, yet he keeps on taking people's money.

Dave
 
Cold fusion and Mills' tech.

No, those are things that can be mathematically described and don't work in the real world.

Also, inventors who produced
"free energy tech" and died or disappeared.

Right, because real people never actually die unless there's something nefarious going on. Please name them, and substantiate your claims about them. But of course, those are not physical phenomena that occur in the real world and cannot be mathematically described, they're specific, and disputed, events, so that's not an answer.

I know of at least 3 other instances tied to the info I have.

But of course you're not going to say what they are because reasons.

Dave
 
ST, some erroneous assumptions are in play:

- The truth of a statement is the final arbiter. Wrong. Consensus is the final stage, the process by which any discovery, statement, insight, or choice among alternatives is identified as having greatest use, owing to its repeatable results or newer explanatory power regarding natural behaviors. Outside science, the same is the case. No dogma/teaching/discipline can exist without being defined, and the act of definition can only result from a consensus of opinion. Therefore, to complain about "mainstream" vs "maverick" ideas -- providing all are elaborated properly using science -- is to confuse the stage of factual discovery from that of its later incorporation into a reliable body of knowledge, always under careful review, which is what science is.

- Mathematics has no inherent superiority to language for doing science. Wrong. You cannot take two metaphors, add similes to each side of an equivalence, and have both sides remain equal. Because of the precision of mathematics, among other things, this ability to retain statements of equal value through many transformations lends it a power way beyond spoken language. You can also take a known equation and turn it around to see what that reveals to your perspective, such as m = e/c2. (For me, this drives home the fact that matter is energy. (I'm slow.))

Science is not just content; it is primarily method. This is what allows the body of knowledge to improve continuously while remaining close to fact and observation. New facts and results are not any sort of problem. However, nonscience, results that cannot repeated, or methods using rational speculation without grounding in observation, just do not cut it in the end. And that is how it should be.
 
Can you give us one example of something that works in the real world but not mathematically. Just one thing.

Cold fusion and Mills' tech. Also, inventors who produced
"free energy tech" and died or disappeared.

I know of at least 3 other instances tied to the info I have.

If those things actually work, there IS math to describe how they work, even if it hasn't been discovered yet.


So when you offered them as examples of things that work in the real world but not mathematically, you were lying.

Dave
 
How is it trolling to ask for an explanation?
Because of several reasons: you don't ask intelligent or meaningful questions and you don't pay attention to the answers; you rapid-fire questions as distractions and smokescreens in order to avoid substantive discussion.

I mean, Jesus, your posts remind me of a twelve year old.


There is key information in the information I am revealing that if I reveal it here and it begins to spread could prevent people from accepting my info widely when I release it on a wide scale.

It would be like a screenwriter giving away an incredible twist ending to a movie he was writing then trying to make the movie when people would already know the twist.

If many people on the internet start giving this info out as their own then I have a more difficult time trying to get attention later. There would be nothing special about what I represent.

That is because much of the info I am trying to convey is already out there. It's how the pieces fit together and key elements that people don't realize.

Plus many other factors related to this.

If i don't give away key information here to you all it actually allows me to explain my position to you more than if I gave it away. Being vague about the info allows me to give you more info.
Yawn.



Human nature is try to control everything. I think that is why we see such a backlash against Mills.
No, it's just that you feel such a special affinity for Mills because you've said that you think you both suffer from Aspergers. It's obvious you've tied yourself to a sinking raft and thus explains your posting style here quite nicely.


Telling people here could damage my chances of getting this info out on a wide scale.
Then, by all means, don't do it. Stop talking about it here and discuss something else.


That's a vast over simplification. I have a very strong curiosity. I am trying to see how people here think.
You most certainly are not. Not when post after post of yours here denigrates, insults, and belittles skeptics, scientists, and members of the ISF; you've already made lots of claims about how "people here think." Don't even try to pretend you're all innocent now.


I am trying to convey my position and how I see things here with my insight.
I haven't gotten that vibe through your posts at all. I doubt anyone else sees it either.


Why is it necessary to reveal ALL my information? Why does it have to be all or nothing?
YOU'RE the only one here posting ALL or NOTHING; you've even twisted several posts into an ALL or NOTHING response and have been called out on it.


I am giving a vague sense of the info i have and a detailed explanation of the position I am in. It relates to Mills as well. it relates to skeptics.
Ever hear of the story of the boy who cried wolf? Yeah...



You think asking questions isn't worthwhile content?
No, he said YOUR questions are content-free.


I think you need to re-evaluate your life.
Flinging insults again are you?



They do work.. maybe not as well as you would like but they do work. If we scrapped anything that wasn't productive immediately there would be no science.
Almost thirty years is not "immediate." Mills' science is bunk, his machines are junk.
 
Why is it necessary to reveal ALL my information? Why does it have to be all or nothing?

You like this particular straw man. Lying and accusing others of an all-or-nothing approach. Why? have you found that it works for you in other contexts, or do you just enjoy making your opponent clarify the scope of a discussion or claims? I never said you had to provide all your evidence, I merely criticized your failure to provide any.

You have offered your opinions and NOTHING to support them other than vague claims of evidence you refuse to produce. That's not participating in a discussion. That's yacking to hear yourself talk.

What are you actually trying to accomplish here other than your own amusement?
 
Here's an analogy that might make the "skeptic" and "mainstream scientist" position more understandable.

I've invented a method of obtaining free apples, without having to grow them on trees. And it doesn't involve any complex biotechnology either. It's based on my discovery that what we think of as one apple—that is, an apple in its least possible discrete unary quantity state—is actually more than one apple in a state of superposition.

(But not quantum superposition. No Q word! Strictly classical!)

Our eyes, hands, and apple counting machines can't detect this hidden inherent plurality, but the right conditions and catalysts can cause the apple in its normal superimposed state to collapse into two or more apples (up to a theoretical maximum of 137). Each of the new apples is in a deeper unary state. Note that this is a change of quantity, not a change in mass, density, chemical composition, or any other significant measure (although, minor differences such as are normal between one apple and another do seem to occur). All of the un-superimposed apples are just as large, massive, delicious, and nutritious as the original(s).

To exploit this hitherto unknown property of apples, I've developed a series of prototype free-apple machines that convert apples into more apples. They're large opaque boxes in a variety of shapes and materials, but they all have an intake port at the top, a delivery port near the bottom, and a large crank on the side. You put in some number of apples, turn the crank, and after a slight delay and some funny noises, a greater number of apples comes out the bottom.

(As a note on terminology, "free apple machine" is not really an accurate description, as the machine does not actually create additional apples. As I've explained, it converts existing apples to actualize their previously undetectable but already inherent multiplicity, using a secret process. (Did I mention it's secret?) But people who don't know the secret operating principle which I refuse to reveal because it's secret persist in associating this technology with claimed methods of making apples appear from nothing, such as conjuring them out of hats or wishing for them from a genii, and as a result, the description has stuck. I understand the difference, so do not be misled.)

I've had several models of these machines independently verified by third parties. In one case, they reported that they observed eight apples coming out after seven were put in, for two trials each day for a 20-day period, after which the machine broke down and the test was declared a triumphant success. In another case, the apples multiplied ninefold, from five apples to forty-five, though in that run the stress of the transformation understandably caused the machine to break down immediately. Of course, the independent third parties were not permitted to examine the inner workings of any of the machines, in order to protect my trade secrets.

Closed-minded so-called skeptics have argued that what I am claiming is impossible, but their arguments are all based on mere mathematics. They have not studied and do not accept my superior mathematics that shows it is indeed possible. They cling to 1 + 1 = 2, even though it took Whitehead and Russell 378 pages of nearly incomprehensible and highly speculative mathematics to supposedly "prove" that dubious assertion. Today, first graders who dare to opine that three apples plus four apples equals eight apples, or that five apples equals forty-five apples, are ruthlessly suppressed and punished until they toe the party line. No wonder you doubt a priori that my free apple machines can possibly work, without even having done a thorough assessment of them (which I will under no circumstances permit you to do)!

Now, I know what you're thinking. "My gosh, if this principle works for apples, it should also work for gold bars, or barrels of oil, or Lamborghinis! You are the greatest scientific genius in the history of the world!" And my advanced math suggests that all of that is indeed the case, and the solution for all of the world's materials shortage problems is at hand, once I get around to revealing it. Maybe after I've perfected the free apple machine and sold one to every greengrocer in the world. I like apples.


Now, the point of the analogy, in case anyone missed it. To scientists and skeptics who are familiar with physics and its mathematical foundations, Mills' hydrino machines are not one iota more plausible than my free-apple machines, and for exactly the same reasons.
 
Last edited:
How is it trolling to ask for an explanation?

I have already explained why I haven't. There are many factors here you aren't aware of.

There is key information in the information I am revealing that if I reveal it here and it begins to spread could prevent people from accepting my info widely when I release it on a wide scale.

It would be like a screenwriter giving away an incredible twist ending to a movie he was writing then trying to make the movie when people would already know the twist.

If many people on the internet start giving this info out as their own then I have a more difficult time trying to get attention later. There would be nothing special about what I represent.

That is because much of the info I am trying to convey is already out there. It's how the pieces fit together and key elements that people don't realize.

Plus many other factors related to this.

If i don't give away key information here to you all it actually allows me to explain my position to you more than if I gave it away. Being vague about the info allows me to give you more info.

Well, you replied.:D

WHY do you care if your information is widely accepted or not?
 
Yet how much is spent on these projects that bring little results based on theories that never produce anything?
Producing results is what elevates a hypothesis to a theory in the first place, so by definition all theories produce results. If you mean something more along the lines of “economically beneficial results” whatever the number of $ spent on theories that don’t produce economically beneficial results, it’s miniscule in comparison to the economic benefits of theories that do “produce results”.
I disagree with your assertion that all of quantum mechanics is responsible for advances in science.

We don't know what we might have accomplished if other theories had been allowed to prosper. You assume what was done is all that could have been done. We will never know because the system prevented that.
We do know that we would not have any of the things which require understanding QM as part of their design. Eg anything with a transistor in it, or anything who’s design or production depends on something with a transistor in it.
 
Well, you replied.:D

WHY do you care if your information is widely accepted or not?

Because there are many elements tied together. I worry that others will get the pieces wrong or that the people hiding this info will spread more disinfo preventing me from getting this info out even more. This is already happening to an extent.
 
Because there are many elements tied together. I worry that others will get the pieces wrong or that the people hiding this info will spread more disinfo preventing me from getting this info out even more. This is already happening to an extent.

Could you be a little vaguer?
 
You like this particular straw man. Lying and accusing others of an all-or-nothing approach. Why?

I am giving information about my situation. So where is the problem? Why does it only have to be factual information that can be verified or not? I haven't gotten to that stage yet. Another way of saying it is - why is there such a rush? Why can't I start preparing people mentally for what I am going to present?

have you found that it works for you in other contexts, or do you just enjoy making your opponent clarify the scope of a discussion or claims? I never said you had to provide all your evidence, I merely criticized your failure to provide any.

It's my interpretation of yours and others actions.

You have offered your opinions and NOTHING to support them other than vague claims of evidence you refuse to produce. That's not participating in a discussion. That's yacking to hear yourself talk.

What are you actually trying to accomplish here other than your own amusement?

I don't necessarily refuse it. Again - why the rush? Consider this the road to revelation.

I am trying to determine best how to do this. Let me also say that this may be a final ditch attempt to get this info out. I have tried to come up with any way I could to do it.. tried to look for any avenue to do it. Spent years trying to write something that might do it and realizing it's going to take a lot of time to do that the way I want.

Recently it dawned on me that the last place I thought of trying to reveal this info might actually work - a skeptic community.

But in seeing how you all respond to this it's not looking good.. I am getting second thoughts. But again it might be my last ditch effort. And depending how you all respond it could prevent me from ever getting this info out. You may vindictively try to shut this down from ever getting out. That is a definite possibility it seems.
 
Because there are many elements tied together. I worry that others will get the pieces wrong or that the people hiding this info will spread more disinfo preventing me from getting this info out even more. This is already happening to an extent.

But why is it important to YOU that the information gets out?
 
Yet how much is spent on these projects that bring little results based on theories that never produce anything?

Nice try sneaking that one on there...

What projects are you thinking of, you need to try to be specific? If they were publicly funded their budgets would be a matter of public information.

Sneaking what in where? People were repeatedly telling you that science is explicitly fallible but you kept missing it. There was no sneaking involved.
 
I am giving information about my situation. So where is the problem? Why does it only have to be factual information that can be verified or not? I haven't gotten to that stage yet. Another way of saying it is - why is there such a rush? Why can't I start preparing people mentally for what I am going to present?



It's my interpretation of yours and others actions.



I don't necessarily refuse it. Again - why the rush? Consider this the road to revelation.

I am trying to determine best how to do this. Let me also say that this may be a final ditch attempt to get this info out. I have tried to come up with any way I could to do it.. tried to look for any avenue to do it. Spent years trying to write something that might do it and realizing it's going to take a lot of time to do that the way I want.

Recently it dawned on me that the last place I thought of trying to reveal this info might actually work - a skeptic community.

But in seeing how you all respond to this it's not looking good.. I am getting second thoughts. But again it might be my last ditch effort. And depending how you all respond it could prevent me from ever getting this info out. You may vindictively try to shut this down from ever getting out. That is a definite possibility it seems.
It certainly isn't looking good, no. You have clearly already decided that this idea of yours, whatever it is, is correct and important. If we do not agree you are obviously not going to listen when we explain why, no matter how politely and patiently we do so.
 
It certainly isn't looking good, no. You have clearly already decided that this idea of yours, whatever it is, is correct and important. If we do not agree you are obviously not going to listen when we explain why, no matter how politely and patiently we do so.

There is an immense amount of info. If someone looked at all of it then gave me valid criticism I would listen.

But I don't claim I have ever detail right.. and some things i am more certain of than others.
 
Just a suggestion:

Accept that you alone can't control how others react or think nor "mentally prepare" them in any way. You can't foresee the subsequent actions of anyone after they hear this mysterious information.

So, spread to as many available venues simultaneously and see what happens. Be prepared for both negative and positive results. You may find help in advancing your "cause" with others or it may fall flat on its face. Either way you would never be able to control it and if it is a last ditch effort - go for it.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom