Here's an analogy that might make the "skeptic" and "mainstream scientist" position more understandable.
I've invented a method of obtaining free apples, without having to grow them on trees. And it doesn't involve any complex biotechnology either. It's based on my discovery that what we think of as one apple—that is, an apple in its least possible discrete unary quantity state—is actually more than one apple in a state of superposition.
(But not quantum superposition. No Q word! Strictly classical!)
Our eyes, hands, and apple counting machines can't detect this hidden inherent plurality, but the right conditions and catalysts can cause the apple in its normal superimposed state to collapse into two or more apples (up to a theoretical maximum of 137). Each of the new apples is in a deeper unary state. Note that this is a change of quantity, not a change in mass, density, chemical composition, or any other significant measure (although, minor differences such as are normal between one apple and another do seem to occur). All of the un-superimposed apples are just as large, massive, delicious, and nutritious as the original(s).
To exploit this hitherto unknown property of apples, I've developed a series of prototype free-apple machines that convert apples into more apples. They're large opaque boxes in a variety of shapes and materials, but they all have an intake port at the top, a delivery port near the bottom, and a large crank on the side. You put in some number of apples, turn the crank, and after a slight delay and some funny noises, a greater number of apples comes out the bottom.
(As a note on terminology, "free apple machine" is not really an accurate description, as the machine does not actually create additional apples. As I've explained, it converts existing apples to actualize their previously undetectable but already inherent multiplicity, using a secret process. (Did I mention it's secret?) But people who don't know the secret operating principle which I refuse to reveal because it's secret persist in associating this technology with claimed methods of making apples appear from nothing, such as conjuring them out of hats or wishing for them from a genii, and as a result, the description has stuck. I understand the difference, so do not be misled.)
I've had several models of these machines independently verified by third parties. In one case, they reported that they observed eight apples coming out after seven were put in, for two trials each day for a 20-day period, after which the machine broke down and the test was declared a triumphant success. In another case, the apples multiplied ninefold, from five apples to forty-five, though in that run the stress of the transformation understandably caused the machine to break down immediately. Of course, the independent third parties were not permitted to examine the inner workings of any of the machines, in order to protect my trade secrets.
Closed-minded so-called skeptics have argued that what I am claiming is impossible, but their arguments are all based on mere mathematics. They have not studied and do not accept my superior mathematics that shows it is indeed possible. They cling to 1 + 1 = 2, even though it took Whitehead and Russell 378 pages of nearly incomprehensible and highly speculative mathematics to supposedly "prove" that dubious assertion. Today, first graders who dare to opine that three apples plus four apples equals eight apples, or that five apples equals forty-five apples, are ruthlessly suppressed and punished until they toe the party line. No wonder you doubt a priori that my free apple machines can possibly work, without even having done a thorough assessment of them (which I will under no circumstances permit you to do)!
Now, I know what you're thinking. "My gosh, if this principle works for apples, it should also work for gold bars, or barrels of oil, or Lamborghinis! You are the greatest scientific genius in the history of the world!" And my advanced math suggests that all of that is indeed the case, and the solution for all of the world's materials shortage problems is at hand, once I get around to revealing it. Maybe after I've perfected the free apple machine and sold one to every greengrocer in the world. I like apples.
Now, the point of the analogy, in case anyone missed it. To scientists and skeptics who are familiar with physics and its mathematical foundations, Mills' hydrino machines are not one iota more plausible than my free-apple machines, and for exactly the same reasons.