Split Thread Mainstream vs. fringe science

I am talking about the Solvay conference - quantum mechanics specifically and the same mentality that has continued since.

Human nature is try to control everything. I think that is why we see such a backlash against Mills.

This isn't the Mills thread but I'll answer anyway. The reason we see opposition to Mills is because his ideas are theoretically, empirically and practically rubbish, he has promised much and done nothing for 30 years apart from fraudulently relieving his investors of 10s of millions of dollars. That's why. [/derail]
 
Not everything works immediately.

The system now seemed to be designed so that only the things that work mathematically prosper. Even if it works in the real world but not mathematically it can't be real.
Can you give us one example of something that works in the real world but not mathematically. Just one thing.
 
Because you are wasting your time and our time. Nothing substantive can come of your absurd non-reveal, because, well, you're not actually saying anything. So you asked what you should do - either tell us what your big idea is or shut up.

How do you know nothing substantive can come of it? I am saying something. I am telling my position.

If you had world changing information that you needed to get out to a wide scale but no one in the media would listen to you what would you do?

Telling people here could damage my chances of getting this info out on a wide scale.
 
How do you know nothing substantive can come of it? I am saying something. I am telling my position.
No you're not. You're hinting that you have a big secret but you won't tell us anything about it. It's utterly childish.
If you had world changing information that you needed to get out to a wide scale but no one in the media would listen to you what would you do?
put up or shut up.
Telling people here could damage my chances of getting this info out on a wide scale.
Then you should shut up.
 
Last edited:
Can you give us one example of something that works in the real world but not mathematically. Just one thing.

Cold fusion and Mills' tech. Also, inventors who produced
"free energy tech" and died or disappeared.

I know of at least 3 other instances tied to the info I have.
 
No you're not. You're hinting that you have a big secret but you won't tell us anything about it. It's utterly childish.
.

You have no reasoning behind what you are saying. People like you telling people to shut up is why I can't post here.. and you wonder why.
 
How do you know nothing substantive can come of it? I am saying something. I am telling my position.

If you had world changing information that you needed to get out to a wide scale but no one in the media would listen to you what would you do?

Telling people here could damage my chances of getting this info out on a wide scale.

Since you are refusing to offer any evidence to back up your claims, your opinion means nothing.

Meaningless.

Incapable of swaying anyone.

You are going in circles of rhetorical wankery. You make unsupported assertions and then ask questions, rejecting the answers people give as "too lawyerly." What are you hoping to achieve with this behavior?
 
Cold fusion and Mills' tech. Also, inventors who produced
"free energy tech" and died or disappeared.

I know of at least 3 other instances tied to the info I have.
No.
I said one example of something that works in the real world but not mathematically. Neither of those examples work in the real world so they don't count. So far zero examples.
 
Since you are refusing to offer any evidence to back up your claims, your opinion means nothing.

Meaningless.

Incapable of swaying anyone.

You are going in circles of rhetorical wankery. You make unsupported assertions and then ask questions, rejecting the answers people give as "too lawyerly." What are you hoping to achieve with this behavior?

That's a vast over simplification. I have a very strong curiosity. I am trying to see how people here think. I am trying to convey my position and how I see things here with my insight.

Why is it necessary to reveal ALL my information? Why does it have to be all or nothing?

I am giving a vague sense of the info i have and a detailed explanation of the position I am in. It relates to Mills as well. it relates to skeptics.
 
That isn't what he said.

It would have to be for him to be against my position.
WOW, now you are not only going to tell Argumemnon what he said (despite the evidence in this very thread), you are also going to tell him what he thinks.

What you seem to be proposing is that every claim is deserving of equal status and funding. If you really believe that, then where is the research funding for flat earth?

This is a strawman. It doesn't have to be to that extreme. Just as it doesn't have to be to the extreme it is right now the other way.
Clearly, you have an issue understanding what a strawman is or is not. Let me reframe. Do you believe that flat earth researchers (and there are many) should be funded? Why or why not?


Or, I claim that 14 billion years ago the universe popped into being thanks to the presence of universe forming pixies. Sadly, the pixies died in the effort. Good luck proving me wrong.

How are many current quantum theories different now?
Have you counted the pixies?

Seriously, you claim to have a theory of something you decline to identify. Since that is an absence of a claim, according to your rules of engagement, I am free to insert whatever I like into that gap. It is therefore my claim that your hypothesis depends on pixies. Prove me wrong.

Since you are unable to prove me wrong, we can assume that you accept the universe creating pixies are fundamental to your hypothesis. You agree the universe creating pixies are real, created the universe and died in the effort. My evidence? How many pixies have you seen lately? That's right, extinct. They died giving birth to you.

All of that is complete and utter bollocks, but you see how easy it is? No?
 
No.
I said one example of something that works in the real world but not mathematically. Neither of those examples work in the real world so they don't count. So far zero examples.

Mills tech and cold fusion do work. It takes time to develop technology. Why wouldn't you explore that other than it not working mathematically?
 
Last edited:
You have no reasoning behind what you are saying. People like you telling people to shut up is why I can't post here.. and you wonder why.
But you are posting here. In a few days you have written half as many posts than I have in several years. The difference is that your posts are entirely content-free.

I have explained the reason why you should put up or shut up. The fact that you ignore that reason doesn't mean that I haven't given you one.
 
Last edited:
Mills tech and cold fusion do work. It takes time to develop technology. Why would you explore that other than it not working mathematically?
In order to persuade us here that those are examples of things that work in the real world but not mathematically, you'd have to 1) persuade us that they do work and 2) show how they fail to work mathematically. Good luck with that.
 
But you are posting here. In a few days you have written half as many posts than I have in several years. The difference is that your posts are entirely content-free.

You think asking questions isn't worthwhile content? I think you need to re-evaluate your life.

I have explained the reason why you should put up or shut up. The fact that you ignore that reason doesn't mean that I haven't given you one.

No, you really haven't.
 
Last edited:
In order to persuade us here that those are examples of things that work in the real world but not mathematically, you'd have to 1) persuade us that they do work and 2) show how they fail to work mathematically. Good luck with that.

People have been convinced cold fusion works even though it isn't consistent. Not being consistent doesn't mean they don't work. Mills tech works it just isn't commercializable. That doesn't mean it doesn't work...

All critics talk about here is that they don't work mathematically which is what current theory is based on.
 
People have been convinced cold fusion works even though it isn't consistent. Not being consistent doesn't mean they don't work. Mills tech works it just isn't commercializable. That doesn't mean it doesn't work...

All critics talk about here is that they don't work mathematically which is what current theory is based on.

If those things actually work, there IS math to describe how they work, even if it hasn't been discovered yet.
 
All critics talk about here is that they don't work mathematically which is what current theory is based on.


Try that line of argument with the IRS sometime. "The only arguments you make that I owe this tax are mathematical ones. You're using sums and products and percentages. But it's all just numbers on paper. How can we be sure any of that mathematics is valid in the real world?"

That might not be a fair comparison though. Reality is far stricter and far less forgiving than the IRS.
 
I disagree with your assertion that all of quantum mechanics is responsible for advances in science.

We don't know what we might have accomplished if other theories had been allowed to prosper. You assume what was done is all that could have been done. We will never know because the system prevented that.

Without quantum mechanics, we couldn't explain how semiconductors work, so the theoretical basis for developing the transistor wouldn't exist, so there would be no development of the microchip, so no computers or mobile phones, to take a couple of very obvious examples.

All you need to do to improve on quantum mechanics is to produce a theory that can predict better than quantum mechanics
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom