Split Thread Mainstream vs. fringe science

All the time. The claims of hot fusion researchers are public knowledge. Their plans methods, and setbacks are openly discussed. The scientific basis for their work is no secret. The technical challenges they must overcome are well understood.

Hot fusion researchers operate in a spirit of transparency that puts Mills and his supporters to shame. Or would, if Mills and his supporters were capable of shame.

So it's ok to accomplish nothing with an unbelievable amount of money spent as long as you make no claims? Someone unwilling to even make claims should be a monumental red flag.
 
If you don't understand what they're talking about, how can you tell?

Because their outlandish extrapolations never lead to anything tangible. I said before it seems to me people thought they could be Einstein too because he also made outlandish extrapolations. But in his case he had talent/genius and was accurate.
 
We don't know. The entire model could be completely wrong and both the mainstream and Mills could be wrong.

Everything might be wrong. So what?

And the fact that mainstream theoretical physics is incredibly stagnant and continues to not lead to any major new discoveries or confirmation.

Fact? It's not even true at all. There are major discoveries all the time.

You might not know about them or be able to recognise them as such, but they are there.
 
Because their outlandish extrapolations never lead to anything tangible.

That's absolute nonsense.

If you lived in the 1920s and talking about quantum mechanics you'd say the exact same thing, and here we are in the next century using the fruits of that theory every day.

You are simply, fundamentally ignorant about science.
 
The pattern of people telling you that science is not only fallible but explicitly recognizes that fallibility and aims to correct it. As you repeatedly asserted they thought otherwise.

Yet how much is spent on these projects that bring little results based on theories that never produce anything?

Nice try sneaking that one on there...
 
That's absolute nonsense.

If you lived in the 1920s and talking about quantum mechanics you'd say the exact same thing, and here we are in the next century using the fruits of that theory every day.

You are simply, fundamentally ignorant about science.

I disagree with your assertion that all of quantum mechanics is responsible for advances in science.

We don't know what we might have accomplished if other theories had been allowed to prosper. You assume what was done is all that could have been done. We will never know because the system prevented that.
 
Can you explain why not?

You appear to be heading into trolling territory now.

How is it trolling to ask for an explanation?

I have already explained why I haven't. There are many factors here you aren't aware of.

There is key information in the information I am revealing that if I reveal it here and it begins to spread could prevent people from accepting my info widely when I release it on a wide scale.

It would be like a screenwriter giving away an incredible twist ending to a movie he was writing then trying to make the movie when people would already know the twist.

If many people on the internet start giving this info out as their own then I have a more difficult time trying to get attention later. There would be nothing special about what I represent.

That is because much of the info I am trying to convey is already out there. It's how the pieces fit together and key elements that people don't realize.

Plus many other factors related to this.

If i don't give away key information here to you all it actually allows me to explain my position to you more than if I gave it away. Being vague about the info allows me to give you more info.
 
Last edited:
I disagree with your assertion that all of quantum mechanics is responsible for advances in science.

Where did I say that?

We don't know what we might have accomplished if other theories had been allowed to prosper. You assume what was done is all that could have been done. We will never know because the system prevented that.

What are you even talking about? The fact that we have technology right now that works only because we used the principles of QM to make it work shows that QM works. There might be a better theory out there that can replace it but the fact remains that QM works in the real world.

The point, of course, is that you might not have seen the crucial use of QM back in the 20s.
 
Some words...

There is key information in the information I am revealing that if I reveal it here and it begins to spread could prevent people from accepting my info widely when I release it in a wide scale.

Some more words...


If i don't give away key information it actually allows me to explain my position more than if I gave it away.

Er hahahahahaha?...
 
I disagree with your assertion that all of quantum mechanics is responsible for advances in science.

We don't know what we might have accomplished if other theories had been allowed to prosper. You assume what was done is all that could have been done. We will never know because the system prevented that.

Wow, talk about moving the goalposts. You start by posting that theoretical physics has never led to anything tangible (scroll up and read where you said it before you post the knee-jerk denial) on the Internet, for crying out loud, which is carried over devices designed using the predictions of theoretical physics (I know this, I design them). As soon as you're pulled up on that self-refuting statement, you immediately retreat to the unfalsifiable position that there might be some other unspecified theory that might have done better. If you're so damned clever, tell us what that theory is, and take the Nobel prize that's on offer, as anyone who could have thought of one in the last century or so would inevitably have done. And if you don't know of a better 'ole, stop whingeing about the one you're in.

Science doesn't suppress better theories, it embraces them. Rather, it supersedes worthless theories; you know, the ones that don't lead to, for example, the greatest communications system in history.

Dave
 
I disagree with your assertion that all of quantum mechanics is responsible for advances in science.
That isn't what he said.

We don't know what we might have accomplished if other theories had been allowed to prosper. You assume what was done is all that could have been done. We will never know because the system prevented that.
Who knows what wonders dowsing/tarot/astrology/ouija boards/seances/remote viewing/PSI/ESP/telekinesis/homeopathy/kundalini and so forth might have achieved by now?

Everybody knows. The answer is nothing. And I speak from long experience of exploration of so-called "alternative" disciplines. Without exception, every single one turns out to be as useful as a chocolate crash helmet.

What you seem to be proposing is that every claim is deserving of equal status and funding. If you really believe that, then where is the research funding for flat earth?

Or, I claim that 14 billion years ago the universe popped into being thanks to the presence of universe forming pixies. Sadly, the pixies died in the effort. Good luck proving me wrong.

Or, I claim that Santa is real. Millions of people worldwide believe in him, every year tangible evidence in the form of presents show up, NORAD tracks his progress around the world by RADAR. Even God does not have such actual evidence.

Or, I could claim hollow earth whereby we all live on the inner surface of a sphere, prove me wrong.

Are you getting the picture? The burden of proof rests with the affirmative claimant.
 
Wow, talk about moving the goalposts. You start by posting that theoretical physics has never led to anything tangible (scroll up and read where you said it before

I am talking about the Solvay conference - quantum mechanics specifically and the same mentality that has continued since.

Human nature is try to control everything. I think that is why we see such a backlash against Mills.
 
That isn't what he said.

It would have to be for him to be against my position.

What you seem to be proposing is that every claim is deserving of equal status and funding. If you really believe that, then where is the research funding for flat earth?

This is a strawman. It doesn't have to be to that extreme. Just as it doesn't have to be to the extreme it is right now the other way.

Or, I claim that 14 billion years ago the universe popped into being thanks to the presence of universe forming pixies. Sadly, the pixies died in the effort. Good luck proving me wrong.

How are many current quantum theories different now?
 
Anything that works is 'allowed to prosper'. No one can stop it.

Some absolute garbage allows snake oil salesmen to prosper too, unfortunately.

Not everything works immediately.

The system now seems to be designed so that only the things that work mathematically prosper. Even if it works in the real world but not mathematically it can't be real.
 
Last edited:
Can you explain why?
Because you are wasting your time and our time. Nothing substantive can come of your absurd non-reveal, because, well, you're not actually saying anything. So you asked what you should do - either tell us what your big idea is or shut up.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom