Split Thread Mainstream vs. fringe science

Einstein's Cosmos: How Albert Einstein's Vision Transformed Our Understanding of Space and Time
The year 2005 marks the 100th anniversary of the publication of the paper that launched Einstein's career, made E=mc2 famous, and ushered in a revolution in science―the paper that announced the theory of special relativity. And there's no better short book that explains just what Einstein did than Einstein's Cosmos. Keying Einstein's crucial discoveries to the simple mental images that inspired them, Michio Kaku finds a revealing new way to discuss these ideas, and delivers an appealing and always accessible introduction to Einstein's work.
This is a book on the scientific discoveries of Albert Einstein, not specifically the life of Albert Einstein. It will go through the basics (he was born, went to university, worked at a patent office, married, etc.). The book is not a biography of Albert Einstein.
The Booklist review implies that this book starts with the 1905 papers.
 
Last edited:
Einstein's Cosmos: How Albert Einstein's Vision Transformed Our Understanding of Space and Time

This is a book on the scientific discoveries of Albert Einstein, not specifically the life of Albert Einstein. It will go through the basics (he was born, went to university, worked at a patent office, married, etc.). The book is not a biography of Albert Einstein.
The Booklist review implies that this book starts with the 1905 papers.


Reality Check - I think you may be suffering from confirmation bias and Dunning-Kruger here.

Your stance on this is a bit bizarre.

I see you constantly posting messages like this. As if you have researched everything under the sun and are an expert on it. You seem to be locked into a certain state of mind where only one way of thinking is legitimate.
 
Has hot fusion owned up to it?
All the time. The claims of hot fusion researchers are public knowledge. Their plans methods, and setbacks are openly discussed. The scientific basis for their work is no secret. The technical challenges they must overcome are well understood.

Hot fusion researchers operate in a spirit of transparency that puts Mills and his supporters to shame. Or would, if Mills and his supporters were capable of shame.
 
If I'm not mistaken the term "dark matter" is known as a place holder name. It's called that because its nature is unknown.
It's now used with quite a number of different, often distinct, sometimes overlapping meanings.

The placeholder one is still relatively ominous, AFAIK.
 
Reality Check - ....
Insults do not make a book magically contain whatever you want. You did not cite a biography of Einstein. You probably have not read the book otherwise you would quote the appropriate passage. The description and review of the book suggests that it contains little biography.
 
Could you tell me the theoretical explanation for dark energy?
Sorry, no I can't.

I don't know how to give a "theoretical explanation" for a definition.

Certainly not without first understanding what you think a "theoretical explanation" is.

Could you elaborate please?
 
If you were in my situation how would you go about this?
I would state my hypothesis clearly, set out the evidence and reasoning that led me to postulate it, describe the additional evidence which the hypothesis predicted, explain how I went about gathering it, and describe what I discovered and my conclusions.

Then why would they ignore certain groups failures and attack others who go against the mainstream?
We have not ignored anyone's failures, or attacked anyone simply for going against the mainstream. Everyone is held to the same standard. Mills' failures are simply more egregious than, say, the failure to design a working fusion reactor, or identify the nature of dark matter and dark energy.

Why do you ignore Mills' failures? Why do you attack a methodology which has so greatly advanced our understanding of the universe and brought so many tangible benefits?
 
Reality Check - I think you may be suffering from confirmation bias and Dunning-Kruger here.

Your stance on this is a bit bizarre.

I see you constantly posting messages like this. As if you have researched everything under the sun and are an expert on it. You seem to be locked into a certain state of mind where only one way of thinking is legitimate.

I am familiar with RC from here and elsewhere. He is almost always right on the money and on those rare occasions he is wrong, gladly concedes. Your characterisation could not be further wrong.
 
Could you tell me the theoretical explanation for dark energy?

Look it up. Took me less than a second.


https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dark_energy#Theories_of_dark_energy

If you are really interested I recommend going to the references. As those are the sources for the articles explanations.

Just one at random

https://arstechnica.com/science/201...-the-universe-is-still-weird-and-interesting/

As always in science there are a number of theories and more to come.

How we sort through them is again how well they comport to the observational evidence.


For one who asserts some due diligence for others, you seem to be lacking.
 
I think a few people are talking at cross purposes here. I don't think there are any posters who would argue with the following:

When we look at, for example, galaxies rotating, we observe that they do so in a way which indicates that (if our current theory of gravity is correct) they contain considerably more matter than we are detecting by any other means. There are two possible explanations:

1. Our current theory of gravity is correct and there is indeed matter that we cannot detect other than by its gravitational attraction in these galaxies

2. There is no such otherwise undetectable matter, and our current theory of gravity is in error

Both possibilities are currently open and being explored.

It's not as simple as that. You know about the bullet cluster?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bullet_Cluster
 
I have never said that because mainstream science is clueless - which they are IMO. That that means I am right or that my claims can't be debunked.

Again regardless of whatever you might think of mainstream science they can't be clueless. Just in general terms this would mean all the carp you have and use everyday would be, well, crap and wouldn't work at all. So that's some clues there.

Alternatively, for your asserted corrupt conspiratorial scientific cabal to work, they gots to have some clues there as well. Again, seriously, you need to think about how your latter assertions impact your former. As currently, given enough time your latter assertion directly contradict your former.


My point is that you skeptics give too much credit to mainstream science and assume they are right because they are the authority. Like by ignoring hot fusion.

Well tell us, what happens when anti-mainstream becomes mainstream (the Trump/Mills comparison you made in the other thread)? Does it just implode? Or do they just feast on the bones of each other over time until the fringe of the fringe of the fringe...is all that's left?



That doesn't mean Mills or anyone else is right.. but it shows an incredibly flaw in your position that you don't attack them.

Ah, so positions are 'flawed' unless they do what your position dictates. You do understand that other positions are not your position?

This ties into my feeling that people on these skepticism board may have NPD because it seems you are picking easy targets to boost your own ego without realizing it. I think a lot of blind skepticism stems from this character trait.

You came here, no one picked you. Again, my recommendation remains the same. If you don't what to be such an easy target then put in the effort to make better arguments. Again, some effort to not directly contradict your own argument immediately or over time would be the first step.
 
Last edited:
Well, given that evidence it's certainly possible that our theory of gravity is in error, however any new theory would still have to include dark matter of some sort.

Well, it would certainly have to include the observational evidence that we call "dark matter" but what that actually entails we don't know. Other than what the observational evidence demonstrates. The problem is GR is fundamentally so simplistic (but has far reaching implications), In, if I recall, Einstein's own terms 'Matter tells space how to bend and space tells matter how to move'.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Einstein_field_equations

Changes have significant impact at different scales (the problems RealityCheck noted). So you take care of this there (some observational data) but lose that over here (other observational data). For some GUT we expect gravity, space-time, whatever to be quantitized (discrete states) in some way. As QM simply ain't continuous. However, Quantum Field Theory give us a road map to quantitize a continuous field. Though no one's been able to work out the particulars (half pun intended) for gravity yet.
 
Last edited:
Interesting. I hadn't heard that. Thanks!

Holy crap, for someone who purports to see patterns you miss a lot here.

The pattern of people specifically telling you their level of confidence in hydrinos and Mills. As you asked.

The pattern of people telling you that science is not only fallible but explicitly recognizes that fallibility and aims to correct it. As you repeatedly asserted they thought otherwise.

Now the pattern of people telling you "dark matter" is the name given to a particular set of observational evidence.
 
Then why would they ignore certain groups failures and attack others who go against the mainstream?

I don't know what you mean by "certain groups failures" so I can't answer that. But your second question I can. Take for exampke the thread "stellar metamorphosis" that certainly goes against the mainstream theory of how *stars form into planets. What characterizes that thread is assertions without evidence. That is the hallmark of all pseudoscience. That is precisely what Mills does.

*There is no such theory. Stars don't become planets.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom