Split Thread Mainstream vs. fringe science

OMG!

This question is like "where is the proof of hydrogen?"

Dark Energy (DE) is a definition ... how do you prove a definition?

ST, may I suggest that you do some basic research before you post? I recommend that you use primary sources, rather than popsci pieces.

I was talking about dark energy in the context of our discussion. Nice try though.
 
I was talking about dark energy in the context of our discussion. Nice try though.
Right back at you ... DE has the same status as hydrogen, in context ... it is a shorthand for a diverse set of observations (you know what some of the observations that are part of the definition of hydrogen are, don't you?)
 
Right back at you ... DE has the same status as hydrogen, in context ... it is a shorthand for a diverse set of observations (you know what some of the observations that are part of the definition of hydrogen are, don't you?)

Are you talking about spectra?
 
Bump.
Elaboration, per ST's request:

ST, you have said, in several posts here, that the scientific method isn't a problem for you (that's paraphrase).

How central a role do you think objectivity plays in the scientific method?

In your view, how critical is it, when employing the scientific method, to require independent verification?
This is a fast moving thread, so perhaps you overlooked this, ST?

I'm looking forward to your response.
 
Right back at you ... DE has the same status as hydrogen, in context ... it is a shorthand for a diverse set of observations (you know what some of the observations that are part of the definition of hydrogen are, don't you?)

Could you tell me the theoretical explanation for dark energy?
 
Could you elaborate here?
I didn't really think it necessary to elaborate. You are engaging in the all too familiar "god of the gaps" gambit in the naive belief that you can insert whatever your belief-du-jour might happen to be all the while ignoring that science does not care.

Science simply states that "I don't know" is a valid answer. Inserting your woo of choice into that gap is not a valid answer.
 
I didn't really think it necessary to elaborate. You are engaging in the all too familiar "god of the gaps" gambit in the naive belief that you can insert whatever your belief-du-jour might happen to be all the while ignoring that science does not care.

Science simply states that "I don't know" is a valid answer. Inserting your woo of choice into that gap is not a valid answer.

Could you translate that? I'm not familiar with your skeptic jargon and double speak.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom