Split Thread Mainstream vs. fringe science

I think gravity is the biggest mystery because our model means that we are missing 90 percent of the universe. That means our understanding of gravity may be completely off base.

Unless there is some seeming error in our understanding of EM that is as large as the gravity model problem.
Bass-ackwards. It is our understanding of gravity that revealed dark matter.
 
I said that we don't know our understanding of gravity is accurate. So we don't know that dark matter is even necessary.

One again since the model doesn't predict dark matter then dark matter isn't necessary for the model. That we do have evidence of dark matter is also consistent with the model. So the simple existence of dark mater neither tends to confirm (since the model itself does not require it) nor refute (since the model is still consistent with dark matter) the model (GR). Are you perhaps confusing the existence of dark matter being inconstant with some estimations of mass (like say galaxies) with the existence of dark matter being inconstant with general relativity. The former is accurate the latter is not.


Where is your proof that that gravity is completely understood?

Where are the words "completely understood" in relation to gravity in what Roboramma posted? You want to make a claim that "gravity is completely understood" fine, then you provide the proof for what was demonstrably just your claim.
 
Bass-ackwards. It is our understanding of gravity that revealed dark matter.

Why do you assume our understanding of gravity is complete?

Why would our "understanding of gravity" have to be "complete" to reveal dark mater?

The assumption you assert is not required for the statement you quote. As such, the assumption is entirely yours.
 
Why would our "understanding of gravity" have to be "complete" to reveal dark mater?

The assumption you assert is not required for the statement you quote. As such, the assumption is entirely yours.

How can you know if dark matter exists if you are using our understanding of gravity as a reason to assume dark matter exists and we don't know that our understanding of gravity is complete?
 
How can you know if dark matter exists if you are using our understanding of gravity as a reason to assume dark matter exists and we don't know that our understanding of gravity is complete?

Because the reality is more complicated than the Rock/paper/scissors game you're trying to play.
 
How can you know if dark matter exists if you are using our understanding of gravity as a reason to assume dark matter exists and we don't know that our understanding of gravity is complete?

All scientific theories are provisional - subject to change pending arrival of better data and/or a better theory.
 
How can you know if dark matter exists if you are using our understanding of gravity as a reason to assume dark matter exists and we don't know that our understanding of gravity is complete?


Not an assumption but a conclusion from observational evidence. What do you project is lacking in our understanding of gravity or whatever that sufficiently accounts for the observational evidence? Whatever you might think it is, we actually already have a name for that, it's called, yep you guessed it, dark matter. As we find more out about dark matter we'll find more about what models may need to be revised and in what ways. However, as noted just above, its simple existence is currently compatible with GR.
 
Last edited:
I think a few people are talking at cross purposes here. I don't think there are any posters who would argue with the following:

When we look at, for example, galaxies rotating, we observe that they do so in a way which indicates that (if our current theory of gravity is correct) they contain considerably more matter than we are detecting by any other means. There are two possible explanations:

1. Our current theory of gravity is correct and there is indeed matter that we cannot detect other than by its gravitational attraction in these galaxies

2. There is no such otherwise undetectable matter, and our current theory of gravity is in error

Both possibilities are currently open and being explored.
 
Not an assumption but a conclusion from observational evidence.

Yes but out observational evidence of gravity is incredibly limited.

What do you project is lacking in our understanding of gravity or whatever that sufficiently accounts for the observational evidence? Whatever you might think it is, we actually already have a name for that, it's called, yep you guessed it, dark matter. As we find more out about dark matter we'll find more about what models may need to be revised and in what ways. However, as noted just above, its simple existence is currently compatible with GR.

Why call it dark matter and not a gravity anomaly?
 
Last edited:
Yes but out observational evidence of gravity is incredibly limited.

Can you quantitate that? Didn't think so.

See, we know enough to send spacecraft to all the outer planets and out of the solar system entirely. What other discipline than astrophysics has a better track record?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom