Split Thread Mainstream vs. fringe science

Can you quantitate that? Didn't think so.

Can you prove otherwise?

See, we know enough to send spacecraft to all the outer planets and out of the solar system entirely. What other discipline than astrophysics has a better track record?

You are comparing solar systems to galaxies? Ever considered that might be your problem?
 
Just for anyone who is drawn to this sadly derailed thread, the topic is, or should be, Mills's theories and his claim to be producing commercialised very cheap energy devices called Suncells using a below ground state form of hydrogen which he calls the hydrino. That is what this thread is about, not ST's secret knowledge, not his fears of being done in if he tells us his secrets, not the state of QM, not whether gravity is the most mysterious subject in physics, or the difference between solar systems and galaxies.

Mills has been carrying out this scam for 30 years and we have shown in this thread that his theory and practice is ridiculously flawed. So if you came here looking for what we think about Mills and his scam, you can find it in the hundreds of posts in this and the predecessor thread, with well-researched and presented detailed reasons for why ŵe think it's nonsense. Just ignore the last few days of attempted derailing.

ETA: Oh, and hydrinos don't exist.
 
Last edited:
Just for anyone who is drawn to this sadly derailed thread, the topic is, or should be, Mills's theories and his claim to be producing commercialised very cheap energy devices called Suncells using a below ground state form of hydrogen which he calls the hydrino. That is what this thread is about, not ST's secret knowledge, not his fears of being done in if he tells us his secrets, not the state of QM, not whether gravity is the most mysterious subject in physics, or the difference between solar systems and galaxies.

Mills has been carrying out this scam for 30 years and we have shown in this thread that his theory and practice is ridiculously flawed. So if you came here looking for what we think about Mills and his scam, you can find it in the hundreds of posts in this and the predecessor thread, with well-researched and presented detailed reasons for why ŵe think it's nonsense. Just ignore the last few days of attempted derailing.

ETA: Oh, and hydrinos don't exist.

Actually, I think you've got a bit lost. Since the 10th of June this is the mainstream vs fringe science thread, so all the secret cabal gwibble is probably on topic. The Mills thread is still grinding on elsewhere on the forum.
 
Yes but out observational evidence of gravity is incredibly limited.

Hardly, your own observational evidence of gravity is something you experience almost every second of every day.


Why call it dark matter and not a gravity anomaly?

Because it is not an anomaly in gravity, again the model is consistent with it there or not, as would be expected. Again it is a deviation, or even anomaly if you want, in some estimations of mass (that why it has the name matter). The lower estimations were based a lot on what matter we could see optically. Hence the name dark for what we already knew we wouldn't be able to find optically (one reason why its an estimate of mass even from the get go). If you're asking why one descriptive name and not some other that happens to include the word "anomaly" like Optical Mass Estimation Discrepancy Anomaly. Well other than what I've already laid out I couldn't say as I wasn't responsible for the name. Though I do think Massy McMass Face just wouldn't sound as descriptive.
 
Actually, I think you've got a bit lost. Since the 10th of June this is the mainstream vs fringe science thread, so all the secret cabal gwibble is probably on topic. The Mills thread is still grinding on elsewhere on the forum.

Ach! Thank you. Wrong thread. On a phone and hopelessly lost. :-)
 
I think gravity is the biggest mystery because our model means that we are missing 90 percent of the universe.
We are not "missing 90 percent of the universe".
We have measured 100% of the density of mass & energy in the universe. Basically we measure that the universe is flat and this gives us that the universe must be at the critical density for flatness.
24.9% of that density is normal matter. Half of that normal matter is actually "missing" :eek: (the missing baryon problem)
26.8% of that density is dark matter which we have measured - it is not missing :eye-poppi.
68.3% of that density is dark energy which we have measured - it is not missing :eye-poppi.
 
Last edited:
We are not "missing 90 percent of the universe".
We have measured 100% of the density of mass & energy in the universe. Basically we measure that the universe is flat and this gives us that the universe must be at the critical density for flatness.
24.9% of that density is normal matter. Half of that normal matter is actually "missing" :eek: (the missing baryon problem)
26.8% of that density is dark matter which we have measured - it is not missing :eye-poppi.
68.3% of that density is dark energy which we have measured - it is not missing :eye-poppi.

Where is the proof of dark energy?
 
How can you know if dark matter exists if you are using our understanding of gravity as a reason to assume dark matter exists and we don't know that our understanding of gravity is complete?
A rather ignorant question along with a sort of "god of the gaps argument". You do not understand dark matter so you do not want it to exist so you throw dark matter into an irrelevant "incomplete knowledge" gap.
Everyone else reads the observational evidence for dark matter and is confident that dark matter exists.
Everyone else reads the alternative theories for dark matter and sees that scientists do not assume that "gravity" is correct. Modified Newtonian dynamics is an attempt to change Newton's F=ma law to explain dark matter (works better than particles for galaxies, fails badly at higher scales). Extensions of GR are attempts to change GR to explain dark matter (works across a wider scale but has unfortunate side-effects such as star living for less than a second!)

In the real world science is always incomplete. Newton only knew about the motions of bodies in the Solar System and terrestrial experiments but his theory of gravitation explains the majority of observations throughout the universe even today.
 
Last edited:
SkepticalTheorist: Sources for "observational evidence of gravity is ... limited"

Yes but out observational evidence of gravity is incredibly limited.
14 June 2017 SkepticalTheorist: Give your sources for "observational evidence of gravity is incredibly limited".
The answer may be that it is just your imagination based on what you do not know about science (a couple of "I an not a scientist".
We have observed the gravity
  • Of the Earth on objects since antiquity. Galileo Galilei (15 February 1564 – 8 January 1642) performed experiment to test gravity.
  • Of the Sun on objects in the Solar System.
    Look up Isaac Newton and the many sources of data he used.
  • Between bodies in the lab.
  • Of stars.
    Gaia data release 1 contains data on 1.1 billion stars, proper motions for 2 million of them!
  • Of galaxies
  • Of galaxy clusters
  • etc.
We have seen gravitational lensing happening billions of light years away and thus billions of years in the past so there is no space or time limits to the observations.
 
A rather ignorant question along with a sort of "god of the gaps argument". You do not understand dark matter so you do not want it to exist so you throw dark matter into an irrelevant "incomplete knowledge" gap.
Everyone else reads the observational evidence for dark matter and is confident that dark matter exists.
Everyone else reads the alternative theories for dark matter and sees that scientists do not assume that "gravity" is correct. Modified Newtonian dynamics is an attempt to change Newton's F=ma law to explain dark matter (works better than particles for galaxies, fails badly at higher scales). Extensions of GR are attempts to change GR to explain dark matter (works across a wider scale but has unfortunate side-effects such as star living for less than a second!)

In the real world science is always incomplete. Newton only knew about the motions of bodies in the Solar System and terrestrial experiments but his theory of gravitation explains the majority of observations throughout the universe even today.

Thanks for the information.
 
Why call it dark matter and not a gravity anomaly?
When Fritz Zwicky in 1933 discovered that the Newtonian dynamics of the Coma Cluster could not be explained using the visible matter he named the not visible matter dunkle Materie 'dark matter'.

Leap forward to the 1960-70s and the same name is used for the not visible matter needed for the rotation of galaxies found by Vera Rubin and Kent Ford.
We have an extraordinary amount of observational evidence that Newtonian gravitation is correct in the appropriate regime which includes stars orbiting in galaxies and galaxies in clusters. So they did not consider it a "gravity anomaly". Modification to the laws of physics was suggested first in 1983 and has not made much progress in explaining all of the wide variety of evidence for dark mater since.
 
Give your sources for "observational evidence of gravity is incredibly limited".

You still haven't shown me that our observational evidence of gravity isn't limited.

You need to show evidence of that not the other way around. The universe is infinite. To think we know how gravity manifests itself all through the universe is incredibly naive.

Cite your evidence that "our gravity model" (GR) has been shown to be false.

https://www.forbes.com/sites/briank...he-battle-for-galactic-rotation/#3bfbe20e6ff5



It was a documentary. Why do I need to cite it again?

My source? Michio Kaku bruh.... LOL


https://youtu.be/NyK5SG9rwWI?t=2m51s
 
Last edited:
SkepticalTheorist: Cite your evidence that the universe is infinite

You need to show evidence of that not the other way around.
Wrong - you made the assertion, you have to defend the assertion. Out of the kindness of my heart I tried to educate you with list of observational evidence of gravity that covers millions of observations, billions of light years and billions of years.

ETA: You reply with another unsupported assertion of "The universe is infinite"!
14 June 2017 SkepticalTheorist: Cite your evidence that the universe is infinite.
The answer is extremely easy - there is none.
We cannot determine that the universe is infinite because it requires impossible measurements. For example, send a spacecraft off in a straight line and wait for an infinite amount of time to see if it comes back (assuming a closed universe). But infinite means without bounds. No matter how long we wait we sill have an infinite amount of time to wait!
More reasonably - an infinite universe could be perfectly flat. So if we measure that the universe was perfectly flat then the universe should be infinite. But measurements have errors. We will never be able to do that. The best we can do is measure the flatness of the universe and say that it is really, really big.

14 June 2017 SkepticalTheorist: Give your sources for "observational evidence of gravity is incredibly limited".

The word modified makes your answer wrong.
13 June 2017 SkepticalTheorist: Cite your evidence that "our gravity model" (GR) has been shown to be false.
Dark Matter Triumphs Over Modified Gravity In The Battle For Galactic Rotation is an article about Modified Gravity (MOND in this case) not being better than dark matter as particles. In short MOND makes a prediction that matched a recent observation. A new paper shows that dark matter also matches that observation.

That inability understand what you cite makes your next source dubious. And citing Michio Kaku - a theoretical physicist - makes it even more dubious. Where in that hour and a half long documentary is your source for:
13 June 2017 SkepticalTheorist: Cite your sources stating that his father considered Albert Einstein a failure.
 
Last edited:
If you don't consider Michio Kaku a source
A source for what? Kaku is a theoretical physicist. I'd consider him a source for theoretical physics.

What you're looking for is a historian or biographer who can cite original sources of information about Einstein's father. Failing such citations, you might try a historian or biographer whose reputation in their field is so highly regarded and widely accepted, that we can accept their claims even without citations of original sources.

Why would a theoretical physicist--even a celebrity physicist like Michio Kaku--be an expert on the personal life of Albert Einstein? Even Neil deGrasse Tyson gets things wrong. Why should we assume Michio Kaku knows what he's talking about, here? Maybe he heard the same bogus claim about Einstein's father that you did, and he's repeating it ignorantly just like you are.
 
If you don't consider Michio Kaku a source then I no longer need to bother citing sources for you and will notify everyone of this post the next time I see you ask someone for a source.
Could you look up Michio Kaku yourself and the explain to us how he could possibly be the source for this?

And we don't really need a source for that opinion. We have access to the records. We can see that Einstein was not a failure at the time his father died. It really is that simple. If his father judged Einstein to be a failure at that age then his father was simply wrong and possibly heartless (not that I'm accepting the claim that he actually did that).
 
Last edited:
Why would a theoretical physicist--even a celebrity physicist like Michio Kaku--be an expert on the personal life of Albert Einstein? Even Neil deGrasse Tyson gets things wrong. Why should we assume Michio Kaku knows what he's talking about, here? Maybe he heard the same bogus claim about Einstein's father that you did, and he's repeating it ignorantly just like you are.

We should we assume he is wrong? Why is ANOTHER historian more credible than Kaku? Because they wrote a book? So anyone who writes a book is a source? That's all it takes?

And no... this is where I heard it. That's how I found it. I knew this was the documentary when I heard him say that as well as other parts of the doc.
 
Could you look up Michio Kaku yourself and the explain to us how he could possibly be the source for this?

And we don't really need a source for that opinion. We have access to the records. We can see that Einstein was not a failure at the time his father died. It really is that simple. If his father judged Einstein to be a failure at that age then his father was simply wrong and possibly heartless (not that I'm accepting the claim that he actually did that).

Thanks but your internet research is not more credible than Kaku on Einstein. To suggest otherwise is ridiculous.

Kaku has written a book on Einstein -

https://www.amazon.com/Einsteins-Cosmos-Transformed-Understanding-Discoveries/dp/0393327000
 
Last edited:
Where is the proof of dark energy?
OMG!

This question is like "where is the proof of hydrogen?"

Dark Energy (DE) is a definition ... how do you prove a definition?

ST, may I suggest that you do some basic research before you post? I recommend that you use primary sources, rather than popsci pieces.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom