Split Thread Mainstream vs. fringe science

Something that can't be easily explained in a brief paper or even a book. Something that requires people to a lot of digging and research on their own and isn't easily spelled out. Something that requires going against common beliefs.
Non-answer/dodge duly noted.

If you're not prepared to defend what you write, may I suggest that you refrain from writing it?

How many times have you called your fellow skeptics on over-generalizations?
Non-answer/deflection duly noted.

Could you elaborate here?
Sure, be happy to (see my next post) ...
 
Elaboration, per ST's request:

ST, you have said, in several posts here, that the scientific method isn't a problem for you (that's paraphrase).

How central a role do you think objectivity plays in the scientific method?

In your view, how critical is it, when employing the scientific method, to require independent verification?
 
That just happens to maybe be the biggest mystery in science - how gravity works. The entire model relies on our non existent understanding of how gravity works.

If we don't understand gravity then how can we assume that our model is correct? Why would we even think that is the right decision to make?

From this I'm guessing that you do think that we understand how electromagnetism works. If that's correct, what demonstrates that we understand how electromagnetism works, where an equivalent demonstration is lacking for gravity?
 
From this I'm guessing that you do think that we understand how electromagnetism works. If that's correct, what demonstrates that we understand how electromagnetism works, where an equivalent demonstration is lacking for gravity?

I didn't say gravity was the only mystery.
 
I didn't say gravity was the only mystery.

You said how gravity works is maybe the biggest mystery of science. Is there some reason that how gravity works is a bigger mystery than how electromagnetism works? Or does the "maybe" mean that it's possible that how electromagnetism works is the bigger mystery? If the latter, then how would one go about determining which is the bigger mystery?

Also, in physics there has to be something which "just is", or there'll be an infinite regression of one thing explaining another. If X is how gravity works and Y is how electromagnetism works, well, how do X and Y work? You have to stop somewhere.
 
Let me guess: You're going to say that since science doesn't know everything, all ideas are equally valid. Or did you say that already?

I am pretty certain that is the main point of his thread. Except for the times he has walked that back by stating that he accepts the scientific method but not the scientific establishment. Or that the skeptics here do not represent the scientific establishment, or stuff like that. But yes, the overall point of his posts in this thread appears to be: if you don't know everything you known nothing. So any theory pulled out of... the air.. is equally legitimate as any theory documented by loads of experimental evidence.

Seems firmly in the "Tides go in. Tides go out.... You can't explain why..." and "*********** magnets how do they work? And I don't want to talk to a scientist Y'all ***************** lying and getting me pissed" category.
 
You said how gravity works is maybe the biggest mystery of science. Is there some reason that how gravity works is a bigger mystery than how electromagnetism works? Or does the "maybe" mean that it's possible that how electromagnetism works is the bigger mystery? If the latter, then how would one go about determining which is the bigger mystery?

Also, in physics there has to be something which "just is", or there'll be an infinite regression of one thing explaining another. If X is how gravity works and Y is how electromagnetism works, well, how do X and Y work? You have to stop somewhere.

I think gravity is the biggest mystery because our model means that we are missing 90 percent of the universe. That means our understanding of gravity may be completely off base.

Unless there is some seeming error in our understanding of EM that is as large as the gravity model problem.
 
I think gravity is the biggest mystery because our model means that we are missing 90 percent of the universe. That means our understanding of gravity may be completely off base.

Unless there is some seeming error in our understanding of EM that is as large as the gravity model problem.


Once again the model doesn't predict dark matter, but observational evidence demonstrates it, so we specifically aren't "missing" it.



I think gravity is the biggest mystery because our model means that we are missing haven't yet figured out how to detect 90 percent of the universe.

FTFY.

Dave


Actually we do detect it, by its gravitational effect on other bodies. Again that's how we know it is there.
 
FTFY.

Dave

The funny thing is that even like that it's still wrong. We can detect dark matter, via gravity. Which shows that not only is gravity not the biggest mystery, it's actually one of the most well understood things in the universe.

What we don't have is a model that predicts exactly what sort of particles make up the dark matter, or experiments that describe those particles. But we still know quite a bit about it and most of what we do know has been illuminated through our understanding of gravity.
 
The funny thing is that even like that it's still wrong. We can detect dark matter, via gravity. Which shows that not only is gravity not the biggest mystery, it's actually one of the most well understood things in the universe.

I said that we don't know our understanding of gravity is accurate. So we don't know that dark matter is even necessary.

What we don't have is a model that predicts exactly what sort of particles make up the dark matter, or experiments that describe those particles. But we still know quite a bit about it and most of what we do know has been illuminated through our understanding of gravity.

Where is your proof that that gravity is completely understood?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom