Split Thread Mainstream vs. fringe science

Isn't everyone here proclaiming their higher intelligence or superior mode of thinking? Yet you only single out one group.

Also, what have the skeptics produced? Why do you expect so much from others but not yourselves?

First highlight- no, your "opponents" here are saying that what science accepts is based on solid experimental evidence that supports the current ideas, but that we are very open to changing our ideas as new evidence is gathered. As has indeed happened for hundreds or thousands of years. You are just arguing "Well science can't explain everything so it explains nothing! Here is an idea without evidence that is therefore is as legitimate as anything science does accept" Not true at all- probably the most important aspect of science is that it recognizes its own limitations. And demands evidence for all ideas- both the ones it currently accepts as likely to be true, and new ideas as they arise. Science applies the same criteria to all groups, including itself.

As to the second highlight- surely you are kidding!!?!! Did you die of some childhood disease before your teenage years, as did one of three people before scientific medicine? Are you right now typing on the Internet on a computer? Ddi you drive a car today, or take public transportation? Did you have to hunt a wild creature with your bare hands to find food for dinner? I cannot even begin to list what the skeptics (what established science as you call it) has produced.

You are invalidating your own arguments by making such inaccurate and easily disproven statements.
 
Last edited:
It assumes nothing of the sort. The scientific method doesn't have to be perfect to be better than any other methodology yet invented.

What she said- repeated!

Science makes errors. But it knows that and seeks to correct these errors. Peer-reviewed publications are not placed in sacrosanct boxes once accepted and only questioned at risk of death to the questioner. Other researchers are encouraged (and do) test out and try to build on the foundations of these prior publications and are only too happy to publish if there are problems or errors in these earlier conclusions. Only when lots of researchers independently find the same types of results do they become more confident that they are on to something real. When there is only one publication on a topic it is usually viewed as "well worth to keep in mind for now but it has not been confirmed yet. I will wait before forming a strong conclusion" When a single publication with important implications goes year after year without independent confirmation, it is viewed with increasing suspicion. "Odd that no one else has confirmed that yet- I wonder if it is real or not."
 
I think the biggest issue now is corruption. How can that be stopped? I think it can be stopped by people like skeptics groups learning to realize when they have been manipulated.


"corruption"? Is that the "different approach" you would like to try or consider? It's been done.

Your response doesn't seem to even attempt to address what you quoted.

Anyway, someone who is corrupt knows they are being manipulated that's the whole point of being corrupt.

If you are talking about the corruption of say a word, idea or concept. Meaning changing it to something different, generally with negative connotations. Then as long as it is applied consistently in that new application it then carries the same representative meaning as whatever else you would use to express that word, idea or concept.

The word "bad" now carries the connotation of "good" in certain contexts. Language and ideas change and evolve. The real problem comes when one tries to retroactively change a word, idea or concept that was predicated on some other context. Then the meaning or usage become inconsistent.
 
Last edited:
As to the second highlight- surely you are kidding!!?!!

I was referring to the skeptics on this board not in their entirety... I consider myself skeptical. I don't think the scientific process is at fault. It's how it is being implemented and a kind of paranoia rampant within. I think there is a reason for this paranoia.
 
That's not the point though.. the point is it can be improved. How has it improved over time?

There are so many ways this has happened! Probably the most important is the enormous expansion of the number of scientists and their funding in the past decades, allowing independent confirmation of results. Peer review itself is a relatively recent addition and there have been a lot of efforts to improve even this.

And once again you are back tracking on one of your blatantly incorrect broad misstatements to try to make it seem more reasonable. Sure peer-review can be improved- would anyone argue otherwise. But was that really the point you were first trying to make? Or was it more, as I read it, that peer review is imperfect so science is crap, ha, ha you skeptics?

Whatever your actual intent I have other things I must do right now rather than continue in this particular discussion. Bye for now.
 
Whatever your actual intent I have other things I must do right now rather than continue in this particular discussion. Bye for now.

I thought it was obvious that my view was that the system is corrupt and misguided. The scientific process isn't the problem.

I think you got this idea because others conflated skepticism with the scientific process. When I referred to skeptics it was the skeptics on messageboards etc. Not the concept of skepticism. I consider myself skeptical. I consider conspiracy theorists more skeptical than "skeptics" on these boards.
 
This assumes that the scientific method is flawless.
It assumes nothing of the sort. The scientific method doesn't have to be perfect to be better than any other methodology yet invented.


That's not the point though.. the point is it can be improved. How has it improved over time?

It was however the point you asserted.

As to how it has improved over time, the thing that spring to my mind are the use of controls in experiments, double blind studies and other methods to help bring a greater degree of objectivity to primarily subjective subjects. Like say pain management and other things that rely on subject self reporting.
 
I was referring to the skeptics on this board not in their entirety... I consider myself skeptical. I don't think the scientific process is at fault. It's how it is being implemented and a kind of paranoia rampant within. I think there is a reason for this paranoia.

"the scientific process is" "how it is being implemented". That's what makes it a process, you implement it to do something.
 
SkepticalTheorist: Sources stating that his father considered Albert a failure

Then why did his father consider him a failure? Why couldn't he get a job as a teacher?
It is only your unsupported assertion that his father considered Albert a failure :eye-poppi!
13 June 2017 SkepticalTheorist: Cite your sources stating that his father considered Albert a failure.
We do not know why Einstein could not get a teaching post. It may be in one of his biographies or letters.
It could be one or more of
  1. there were no posts available.
  2. his 2 worthless (his words) papers.
  3. there were better candidates.
    The equivalent of a bachelor's degree is the bottom of the rung for teachers - masters or PhDs are preferred.
  4. concerns with him taking time working on his thesis.
  5. maybe his religion - not sure how widespread anti-Semitism was in 1900 though.
  6. his personality
    You report the rumors of autism - autistic people are not generally socially proficient.
  7. etc.
 
Last edited:
I don't know what kind of evidence you are looking for. The claim of dark matter is mostly based on a theoretical model. Why should we assume the model is accurate and that there is in fact 90% of the universe missing?
With the exception of a few "local" galaxies, the claim that galaxies contain lots of stars like those in the Milky Way is "mostly based on a theoretical model".

It seems you want to take us back to the science of the ancient Chinese and Indians, right?
 
With the exception of a few "local" galaxies, the claim that galaxies contain lots of stars like those in the Milky Way is "mostly based on a theoretical model".

It seems you want to take us back to the science of the ancient Chinese and Indians, right?

That model hasn't been shown to be false as our gravity model has.
 
I was referring to the skeptics on this board not in their entirety... I consider myself skeptical. I don't think the scientific process is at fault. It's how it is being implemented and a kind of paranoia rampant within. I think there is a reason for this paranoia.

I will make one last comment for now. How you think established science works is not how it actually works. You are criticizing an entity that does not exist in the way you think it does- a very inaccurate construct that you made that helps you (IMO) justify your anger with how certain ideas have ben treated, but that is not the actual basis behind why your favored ideas have been rejected.
 
I will make one last comment for now. How you think established science works is not how it actually works. You are criticizing an entity that does not exist in the way you think it does- a very inaccurate construct that you made that helps you (IMO) justify your anger with how certain ideas have ben treated, but that is not the actual basis behind why your favored ideas have been rejected.

Science isn't supposed to work that way. That is why it is corrupted.

When i say science I am talking about the scientific community. Scientific institutions.
 
I doubt you have ever had to explain anything remotely like this. <snip>
Like what?

Again, you skeptics continually show a lack of imagination. I think that may be what causes skepticism. An inability to accomplish something of value themselves and then schadenfreude.
Rather an over-generalization, no?

I've asked you this before, but don't recall getting a straight answer: in your view of the core aspects of science, what role does objectivity play? Independent verifiability?
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom