Limiting God to the Big Bang universe.

If posters here do not however want to accept my fundamental concept of God in relation to the universe for Christians, namely, as the maker of everything that is not God Himself, please excuse yourselves because you are out of place in this thread.







Yrreg

You're making the rules here now? I wouldn't miss this for the world. Your garbled English amuses me. Now, when are you going to start providing some evidence instead of semantic pussyfootery?
 
I am trying to lay the foundation for the proof of God's existence. // . . .

. . //write with conciseness and precision.

Yrreg
Your "proof" pre-assumes that a god exists. Atheists/Sceptics are never going to accept such unsubstantiated "pre-proven proof".

Simply provide some credible evidence that a god does exist, then perhaps we could debate what that god may or may not do for kicks.
 
I am trying to lay the foundation for the proof of God's existence.
Yrreg

... by excluding consideration of the existence of god, then assigning a research project to others.

Sounds fair - here's my contribution:

I require you to establish a set of guidelines or rules on the following:
  1. what do you define as evidence? Provide examples consistent with your definition
  2. what do you define as proof? Provide examples consistent with your definition
  3. specify the criteria by which any evidence will be rated for relevance and weight. Clearly document these in advance so that any contributors or spectators may impartially apply these criteria and arrive at the same conclusion.
  4. please provide information on your experience, skills, qualifications and knowledge relating to analysing and evaluating data, and synthesising conclusions. Attach examples of your prior work.
  5. Specify in advance the weight of evidence or proof that will empirically establish the proof of the god postulate that you have established, so that any participant or spectator may by inspection of the weight of evidence and proof, establish whether that threshold has been reached.
  6. Describe the process whereby evidence will be assessed as being "for" or "against" your case, noting that one could contrive to later reinterpret proofs to suit one's own preconceptions.
  7. Noting that we all have a real life somewhere, specify the timeframe in which this exercise is proposed to take place.
  8. Specify the roles and responsibilites that will be required to be assigned, for this exercise to be done in the required timeframe.
 
Last edited:
I am trying to lay the foundation for the proof of God's existence.


Like this?
If God exists, then God is the cause of the universe.
<Argument for the universe having a cause>
Therefore ...
​
 
I already said that God as maker of the universe does not require faith.





Yrreg

Oh yes it does. It requires faith in your god,which god will depend on your cultural upbringing. It has nothing to do with reality.
 
I am trying to lay the foundation for the proof of God's existence.


Well, I'd very much like to hear your proof of the existence of God. In the past, the closest you've ever come is the statement that God's existence is self-evident to anyone who thinks about it. You've never defined the steps of that thinking. I look forward to you unpacking your reasoning.


give examples of evidence as of proof from science and from everyday's life, namely, things proven to exist from evidence and from proof in the domain of science, and also things proven to exist in the domain of everyday's life, again from evidence and from proof.


Excellent! I'd asked you to define the level of proof that you wanted to talk about, and given you half a dozen examples. Now you have defined it as scientific proof.

I am very glad to tell you that there are good, hard definitions of what constitutes proof sufficient to convince the scientific mind. Namely:

Any falsifiable hypothesis that is demonstrably, repeatedly and reliably supported by experiment.​

For example, one may hypothesize the existence of phlogiston - an element that exists in all things which is annihilated by fire. Then one may experiment by weighing things (wood, coal, Gary Shandling), burning them and weighing the remains. If the remains weigh less, the experiment is consistent with the existence of phlogiston. Phlogiston is scientifically proven to exist.

Then one burns iron. Iron does not lose weight when burned. Iron gains weight when burned. This is inconsistent with our definition of phlogiston. Repeated experiments by numerous people on iron confirm that it gains weight. More careful experiments which weigh both the solid and gaseous products of combustion show that wood gains weight as well. The existence of phlogiston, as defined, is not supported by experimentation. It no longer is scientifically proven.

Thank you for detailing that you wish to prove the existence of God to a scientific level of certainty.


Now, if you atheists want to set up the foundation for the disproof of the existence of God, do that in another thread, okay?


Actually, by stating that you want to talk about scientific proof, you have already welcomed in the foundation for disproof. Any proper experiment that falsifiably tests our definition of God has the chance to show a result that is inconsistent with our definition - just like in the case of phlogiston. So, I think anyone, no matter what their agenda, will be well-served by hearing your proposal for falsifiable experimentation of your definition of God.



Unless you are not into any connection with the fundamental concept of God in relation to the universe in the Christian faith, but into the sky daddy, the easter bunny, the flying spaghetti monster, the celestial teapot, the invisible pink unicorn, the tooth fairy, etc., and any of the deities of Greek and other non-Christian mythologies, etc.


You're right. These people are skipping an important step. They are assuming that your definition of God is non-falsifiable. You, however, have assured us that you have a proof of your definition that withstands scientific scrutiny. These people should kindly SHUT THEIR PIE HOLES and allow you to delimit the parameters of your experiment.


which evidence and proof establish them to be existing like the nose in your face, give me the links to your posts.


Hypothesis: I have a nose on my face.

Test: If I have a nose, I should be able to see it. If I can see it, I have a nose. If I can't see it, I may not have one.

Results: After closing my left eye, I can see the right side of my nose. After closing my right eye, I can see the left side of my nose. By crossing my eyes and looking downward, I can see a nose just before becoming dizzy. By looking in the mirror, I see a nose.

Conclusion: Test evidence shows that I have a nose on my face. Schedule further testing by going out in public and listening for horrified screams.
 
Why would the universe need to have a cause? Just because Yrreg says so?

Sorry, I think you are missing my point. yrreg said he was laying the foundations for some argument and I asked if it would look anything like my draft. As an aside, the universe having a cause is just a (possibly untrue) premise in an invalid argument. It may become clearer if instead of some vanilla God, you plug in the Christian God.

If the Christian Trinity, the Father, the Son, the Holy Spirit, exists, then it is the cause of the universe.
<Argument for the universe having a cause>
Therefore ...​

It really looks to me like yrreg were trying to pre-empt the charge of affirming the consequences, as he is busily trying to reduce the Christian concept of God to some sort of cause of the universe; and just that.
 
Last edited:
Yrreg knows what proof is. he has none,so he obfusitcates. I don't know what his purpose here is,unless it is in the hope of finding some converts. It won't work,he is one of the best anti christian propagandists that I have ever seen. Are we dealing with a closet atheist under deep cover?
 
Sorry, I think you are missing my point. yrreg said he was laying the foundations for some argument and I ask if it would look anything like my draft. As an aside, the universe having a cause is just a premise in an invalid argument. It may become clearer if instead of some vanilla God, you plug in the Christian God.

If the Christian Trinity, the Father, the Son, the Holy Spirit, exists, then it is the cause of the universe.
<Argument for the universe having a cause>
Therefore ...​

It really looks to me like yrreg were trying to pre-empt the charge of affirming the consequences, as he is busily trying to reduce the Christian concept of God to some sort of cause of the universe; and just that.

Got it. I was a bit slow on the uptake,it's nearly 3am here. I stay up this late sometimes,to chat to my American inamorata on Facebook. The things we do for love! Goodnight.
 
Always write with conciseness and precision.

:D [Where's the :lol: emoticon when I so desperately need it??]
You've GOT to be kidding! Have you read your own posts?

Look, yrreg, if you want to offer a proof of God's existence, then get on with it! You're not going to get a whole lot of "buy in" for your concept, which could apply to all sorts of non-godlike entities, but go ahead anyway and at least we might make some progress.

(And yes, this is my first yrreg thread.)
 
Now, since I know God and I am a Christian, I am laying the fundamental concept of God in relation to the universe for Christians as:

Easy peasy. It is claimed that the Christian god answers prayers.

I pray to the Christian god for Stephen Hawking to be cured of ALS. The Christian god's answer is no.

I pray to The Flying Spaghetti Monster for Stephen Hawking to be cured of ALS. The FSM's answer is no.

I pray to Santa Claus for Stephen Hawking to be cured of ALS. Santa Claus's answer is no.

Conclusion: The Christian god, The FSM and Santa Claus all have exactly the same evidence.
 
Atheists don't want people to come to the proof of the existence of God, so it is to their interest to not cooperate in the laying of the foundation for the proof of God's existence.
Why not? It would actually be very funny if your proof would actually prove that Odin exists rather that YHWH. :D Thus far, I haven't seen anything in this thread which distinguishes your god from any other.
and yes I'm aware in Norse mythology Odin wasn't the creator of the universe.


Now, since I know God
Really? When did you first meet? What colour eyes does he have? Does he really have long hair and a beard? How does he prefer to be called? What's his phone number?

and I am a Christian, I am laying the fundamental concept of God in relation to the universe for Christians as:

Maker of everything that is not God Himself.​
And what in that definition says that that God is actually YHWH and not a creator god from another mythology?

Always write with conciseness and precision.
So that's why you write such long rambling posts? :rolleyes:


Like this?
If God exists, then God is the cause of the universe.
<Argument for the universe having a cause>
Therefore ...
​
Bah, not again the cosmological argument, that's so five centuries ago.
 
Maker of everything that is not God Himself.

That's a great start. You're defining God as the being who created everything that is not himself.

My reply is that no such being exists. No single entity created the universe.

So, where do we go from here?
 
Gerry, these posts of your are nonsense. And the demeaning way you write, the non-subtle manner which you think will actually lead people along like sheep to accept your unfounded, silly ideas is (and always has been) insulting. The obnoxious way you type - is that the same way you talk ??
I certainly hope not - as I'm sure it would alienate anyone with half a brain.
Besides the sentence below you typed is total bull patties, due to the fact that reason & god -not your god, not any of the thousands of others human beings have created over the centuries - do not mix.:

"Of course Christians also know God by faith and from revelation, but still man with his reason can and does know the existence of God in His fundamental relation to the universe as maker of everything that is not God Himself."

I've highlighted some of the problems you have in the sentence above.

Your beliefs as stated here are unfounded and nonsensical - you have every right of course to keep them, but keep them to yourself.

That's yrreG, by golly!
 
Atheists do not have to prove anything. One chooses a god or one is brainwashed into believing in this or that sky daddy. Atheism is the default position,I would have thought that was obvious. Why do believers have such problems with it?

I'm on your side. Tell it to Yrreg.
 
That's a great start. You're defining God as the being who created everything that is not himself.

My reply is that no such being exists. No single entity created the universe.

So, where do we go from here?

Oh, c'mon, let's play along. Assume that such an entity exists. Also assume that it's not merely the collapse of a previous universe, or a quantum fluctuation in a metauniverse, or a collision of branes in a ten or eleven dimensional M-theory universe.

NOW, where do we go from here?
 
Oh, c'mon, let's play along. Assume that such an entity exists. Also assume that it's not merely the collapse of a previous universe, or a quantum fluctuation in a metauniverse, or a collision of branes in a ten or eleven dimensional M-theory universe.

NOW, where do we go from here?
Apparently to the Apostles Creed.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom