Limiting God to the Big Bang universe.

Title of new thread [that is merged by the admin with the previous thread not abandoned but put on abeyance]:

Fundamental concept of evidence for man in relation to the universe.
​

Here is my fundamental concept of evidence for man in relation to the universe, and an example [already transmitted earlier]:








Just read the title of the [new] thread which I will keep at the top my posts, and also the two posts [in links] from me above for your orientation.

I will not read after the first words any posts that do not convey the poster's fundamental concept of evidence in relation to the universe in not more than than 20 words, and then an example in not more than 100 words.

For guys who have given your definition and what you think is an example, do it again, the definition in not more than 20 words, namely, what is your fundamental concept of evidence in relation to the universe, and give one example plus the explanation in not more than 100 words.

I will not read any posters who on first words of the post already reveal themselves to be into irrelevancies.


My purpose now is to find out whether atheists can think their way into the fundamental concept of evidence in relation to the universe, and give one example with explanation on the how and why of their concept of evidence.

Honestly, so far I have not found any exposition on evidence from atheists that is worth the bandwidth it is written on.

And atheists are the most vociferous about evidence in the issue of God or no God.


So, when I have already come to their fundamental concept of evidence in relation to the universe, I will use it to prove that God as the maker of everything that is not God Himself exists in objective reality outside the realm of concepts in man's mind.


If anyone posts nothing but irrelevancies, when I see his name, I will just omit reading his posts.




Yrreg

It sounds like you think intelligence is in inverse proportion to the number of words used.

You used 554 words.
 
Why oh Why.....

Title of new thread [that is merged by the admin with the previous thread not abandoned but put on abeyance]:

Fundamental concept of evidence for man in relation to the universe.
​

Here is my fundamental concept of evidence for man in relation to the universe, and an example [already transmitted earlier]:





Just read the title of the [new] thread which I will keep at the top my posts, and also the two posts [in links] from me above for your orientation.

I will not read after the first words any posts that do not convey the poster's fundamental concept of evidence in relation to the universe in not more than than 20 words, and then an example in not more than 100 words.

For guys who have given your definition and what you think is an example, do it again, the definition in not more than 20 words, namely, what is your fundamental concept of evidence in relation to the universe, and give one example plus the explanation in not more than 100 words.

I will not read any posters who on first words of the post already reveal themselves to be into irrelevancies.


My purpose now is to find out whether atheists can think their way into the fundamental concept of evidence in relation to the universe, and give one example with explanation on the how and why of their concept of evidence.

Honestly, so far I have not found any exposition on evidence from atheists that is worth the bandwidth it is written on.

And atheists are the most vociferous about evidence in the issue of God or no God.


So, when I have already come to their fundamental concept of evidence in relation to the universe, I will use it to prove that God as the maker of everything that is not God Himself exists in objective reality outside the realm of concepts in man's mind.


If anyone posts nothing but irrelevancies, when I see his name, I will just omit reading his posts.




Yrreg

You have yet again failed to establish a basis for a rational discussion. You keep saying "I want this" and "I want that", without once demonstration that you are capable of correctly interpreting any response you may receive.

When are you going to answer the questions?


  1. what do you define as evidence? Provide examples consistent with your definition
  2. what do you define as proof? Provide examples consistent with your definition
  3. specify the criteria by which any evidence will be rated for relevance and weight. Clearly document these in advance so that any contributors or spectators may impartially apply these criteria and arrive at the same conclusion.
  4. please provide information on your experience, skills, qualifications and knowledge relating to analysing and evaluating data, and synthesising conclusions. Attach examples of your prior work.
  5. Specify in advance the weight of evidence or proof that will empirically establish the proof of the god postulate that you have established, so that any participant or spectator may by inspection of the weight of evidence and proof, establish whether that threshold has been reached.
  6. Describe the process whereby evidence will be assessed as being "for" or "against" your case, noting that one could contrive to later reinterpret proofs to suit one's own preconceptions.
  7. Noting that we all have a real life somewhere, specify the timeframe in which this exercise is proposed to take place.
  8. Specify the roles and responsibilites that will be required to be assigned, for this exercise to be done in the required timeframe.
 
Gerry:

I've provided definitions of evidence and proof.

I've asked you to clarify your meaning of "proof."

I've given a very thorough critique of your proposed definition of evidence.

You have almost completely ignored everything I've written. I won't rewrite it all. I will, however, take offense at your statement that my posts are not worth the bandwidth consumed. First of all, text takes up very little bandwidth. Second, I've actually answered you.

In any case, on behalf of the universe, I am honestly very sorry for the abuse you suffered as a child. Either at the hands of your father or the church, you were very badly mistreated when you were young. Today, you are absolutely torn apart between loyalty to and defiance of authority. It has affected every aspect of your life, including your ability to form and keep relationships. And I think that is an utter shame. I hope the people who love you can get you the help you need.
 
[*]what do you define as proof? Provide examples consistent with your definition

[*]Specify in advance the weight of evidence or proof that will empirically establish the proof of the god postulate that you have established, so that any participant or spectator may by inspection of the weight of evidence and proof, establish whether that threshold has been reached.


To my mind, these two items are basically the same.
 
I will not read after the first words any posts that do not convey the poster's fundamental concept of evidence in relation to the universe in not more than than 20 words, and then an example in not more than 100 words.

For guys who have given your definition and what you think is an example, do it again, the definition in not more than 20 words, namely, what is your fundamental concept of evidence in relation to the universe, and give one example plus the explanation in not more than 100 words.

You have not yet responded to my post. I require from you examples of what you mean by evidence. You are to post five examples, each in no more than 329 words and no less than 327.

At least three of the five examples must include cats. This is essential, responses which do not have cats in the thread will be assumed false.

Once you have done this, we will be ready to move on with the discussion in further threads.

Failure to comply will indicate that you have converted to atheism.
 
So, when I have already come to their fundamental concept of evidence in relation to the universe, I will use it to prove that God as the maker of everything that is not God Himself exists in objective reality outside the realm of concepts in man's mind.


Finally! People have been asking you to do that, and you have more or less claimed that you would do that for well over five years now. You've had every opportunity in your almost 2000 posts here, and still have never come close to showing that any sort of gods exist, and certainly by extension you've been unable to show that that/those god(s) made anything at all.

So would it be presumptuous to ask when you intend to begin that process of objectively proving the existence of your god thing?
 
<snip>

I will not read after the first words any posts that do not convey the poster's fundamental concept of evidence in relation to the universe in not more than than 20 words, and then an example in not more than 100 words.

<snip>


I stopped reading here.
 
I will not read after the first words any posts that do not convey the poster's fundamental concept of evidence in relation to the universe in not more than than 20 words, and then an example in not more than 100 words.

Why Gerry? Why ask for evidence in not more than 20 words and ignore all posts that have done so?? That says everything that needs to be said about how you conduct yourself. Then you ask for an example of not more than 100 words. Why don't you read the posts with the concept of evidence first? (One step at a time...Just repeating what you have said earlier)

I will not read any posters who on first words of the post already reveal themselves to be into irrelevancies.
This is always, ALWAYS an excuse of yours. You haven't proven them to be irrelevant.



Honestly, so far I have not found any exposition on evidence from atheists that is worth the bandwidth it is written on.

Nothing that suits you?....Not our problem; That's your problem.


If anyone posts nothing but irrelevancies, when I see his name, I will just omit reading his posts.

Once again, can you prove them to be irrelevant?
 
I am giving you an idea, but you are the ones to tell me what is the fundamental...

I am giving you an idea, but you are the ones to tell me what is for you atheists the fundamental concept of evidence and of proof in relation to the universe.

So that I can be guided to prove the existence of God according to your exposition on what is evidence and what is proof, and also your examples.

Otherwise you atheists as usual will insist that I don't have the correct ideas about evidence and proof.


Anyway, I found a website from atheists which invites people to ask them questions.

And here is my question to them:

What is your concept of evidence and proof?

Please give five examples of evidence as of proof.

By stating what five things are evidenced by what evidence.

And what five things are proved by what proof.

I understand there is a difference between evidence and proof, of course they are connected.

http://asktheatheist.com/?page_id=31
.

.
​
No, the question is not reproduced in their website, and I hope they will answer it in public.


It is useless to talk with you people here, because you are always beating about the bush, evading the business on hand.

If any thinkers today should be the ones most keen on what is evidence and what is proof, it should be atheists, but there are so far as I have searched in the web no systematic exposition by atheists on what is the fundamental concept of evidence as of proof in relation to the universe.


Tell you what, atheists, go to very well-stocked libraries and read up on evidence and proof, and give readers here the gist of what you find in published bibliography outside the web.

That will be a great service to the cause of atheists, and also to the advancement of knowledge for mankind in the field of what is evidence and what is proof.


Or do some very personal constructive thinking on what is evidence and what is proof, and verbalize your mental fruits concisely, precisely, and clearly, giving examples of evidence as of proof.

Here in this thread.



Yrreg
 
Since you are the one asking, you go to a library and read up for your own personal edification. Then come back here and concisely state your evidence that caused you to believe in your personal god.

You may only use a maximum of 20 words. No more of your over-wordy nonsense phrases. Then you will be into genuinely thinking and not beleiving.

Also, you may only type in cyan text. All else will be believer nonsense.
 
I am giving you an idea, but you are the ones to tell me what is for you atheists the fundamental concept of evidence and of proof in relation to the universe.

So that I can be guided to prove the existence of God according to your exposition on what is evidence and what is proof, and also your examples.

Otherwise you atheists as usual will insist that I don't have the correct ideas about evidence and proof.


Anyway, I found a website from atheists which invites people to ask them questions.

And here is my question to them:


.

.
​
No, the question is not reproduced in their website, and I hope they will answer it in public.


It is useless to talk with you people here, because you are always beating about the bush, evading the business on hand.

If any thinkers today should be the ones most keen on what is evidence and what is proof, it should be atheists, but there are so far as I have searched in the web no systematic exposition by atheists on what is the fundamental concept of evidence as of proof in relation to the universe.


Tell you what, atheists, go to very well-stocked libraries and read up on evidence and proof, and give readers here the gist of what you find in published bibliography outside the web.

That will be a great service to the cause of atheists, and also to the advancement of knowledge for mankind in the field of what is evidence and what is proof.


Or do some very personal constructive thinking on what is evidence and what is proof, and verbalize your mental fruits concisely, precisely, and clearly, giving examples of evidence as of proof.

Here in this thread.



Yrreg

No.
 
No.

I'm curious to know if anyone has at least researched them, so that I can judge whether to base my response in laymen's terms, or in practitioner's terms.

Hit us with your best shot.
 
Just do some personal thinking instead of plagiarising, okay?

Read the last paragraph below put in bold by yours truly.

I am giving you an idea, but you are the ones to tell me what is for you atheists the fundamental concept of evidence and of proof in relation to the universe.

So that I can be guided to prove the existence of God according to your exposition on what is evidence and what is proof, and also your examples.

Otherwise you atheists as usual will insist that I don't have the correct ideas about evidence and proof.


Anyway, I found a website from atheists which invites people to ask them questions.

And here is my question to them:

Quote:
What is your concept of evidence and proof?

Please give five examples of evidence as of proof.

By stating what five things are evidenced by what evidence.

And what five things are proved by what proof.

I understand there is a difference between evidence and proof, of course they are connected.

http://asktheatheist.com/?page_id=31

​

.
.
​
No, the question is not reproduced in their website, and I hope they will answer it in public.


It is useless to talk with you people here, because you are always beating about the bush, evading the business on hand.

If any thinkers today should be the ones most keen on what is evidence and what is proof, it should be atheists, but there are so far as I have searched in the web no systematic exposition by atheists on what is the fundamental concept of evidence as of proof in relation to the universe.


Tell you what, atheists, go to very well-stocked libraries and read up on evidence and proof, and give readers here the gist of what you find in published bibliography outside the web.

That will be a great service to the cause of atheists, and also to the advancement of knowledge for mankind in the field of what is evidence and what is proof.


Or do some very personal constructive thinking on what is evidence and what is proof, and verbalize your mental fruits concisely, precisely, and clearly, giving examples of evidence as of proof.

Here in this thread.

Or do some very personal constructive thinking on what is evidence and what is proof, and verbalize your mental fruits concisely, precisely, and clearly, giving examples of evidence as of proof.
​


So, are you guys going to do some personal thinking instead of plagiarizing by the hand scoops?


Yrreg
 
If any thinkers today should be the ones most keen on what is evidence and what is proof, it should be atheists, but there are so far as I have searched in the web no systematic exposition by atheists on what is the fundamental concept of evidence as of proof in relation to the universe.


That's amazing to me, Gerry, because I have dedicated my entire professional life to the study of evidence and proof. I am, thus, aware that there is a phenomenal amount that has been written about the subject.

It is also amazing to me because I have already given you a definition of proof and evidence in this thread with examples ... several times. You have ignored me every time. To say that it has not been done is an insult to me and my efforts.

However, I'll do it all over again.

Proof, in general, is evidence sufficient to convince the mind of the truth of a proposition.

As is obvious, the crux of that definition is the word "sufficient." What is sufficient? Well, that depends on the type of circumstance and what we want to use our proof for.

If we want to use proof to make one guy pay $200.00 for knocking over your mailbox, we may require a very low level of proof. That would be a preponderance of the evidence. That means that some evidence may favor the defendant, but the majority of it favors the plaintiff. OJ Simpson was found liable for killing his wife by a prepoderance of the evidence.

If we want to use proof to send someone to jail and brand him for life as a criminal, we will only accept a higher level of proof. This is proof beyond a reasonable doubt. That is usually defined as a doubt that you can put into words. A mere "worry" that you might be wrong is not reasonable doubt. The fact that some evidence points to the guilt of someone else (and it cannot be explained in another way) is. OJ Simpson was found not guilty of murder beyond a reasonable doubt.

Scientists ask for another level of proof because they have another mission than the courts. Scientists are trying to build as accurate a model of the workings of the world as possible. They cannot tolerate any contradictory evidence whatsoever, because contradictory evidence means that they do not have a perfect picture of how the universe works. Thus, scientific proof is usually defined as repeatable, valid experiments consistent with a falsifiable hypothesis. As soon as an experiment contradicts the hypothesis, either the experiment must be explained or the hypothesis must be thrown out. This is far beyond a reasonable doubt - it is beyond any doubt whatsoever using current methods of analysis. It holds the door open, however, to new methods forever. Newtonian physics was demonstrated time and again for decade after decade until new experiments at high speeds and high energy showed it to be incorrect.

Mathematic or logical proof is a different sort of proof altogether. Mathematicians want to uncover fundamental rules which always work in all situations. A math or logic proof is necessarily true if the premises are true. No condition other than the truthfulness of the theorum could ever occur. This proof is intrinsic to the conditions themselves. There is no guesswork or leap of faith. A triangle has three sides. A line segment can be bisected into two parts, the sum of which is never less than the segment itself. Thus, any two sides of a triangle must together be longer than the third side.

There are many, many other types of proof that I have not discussed. Proof of the efficacy of a medication for FDA purposes is different than any of the above. Proof sufficient to stop and frisk a person on the street is different than any other. The central question is - what are we using the proof for? How important and far reaching are our goals? What happens if we're wrong? What will we do if we're right?


I am afraid that if you are waiting for a consensus of atheist opinions about the level of proof "in relation to the universe," you're going to be waiting a long time. First, there is no central organization of atheists. So, there's no way to even count atheists, let alone gather their opinions, let alone quantify them.

Second, there is no evidence that the average atheist has the training to discuss levels of proof. I have a doctorate in law (and I'm still out of my depth in the science and math department, as shown by my pitiful triangle example). Most people don't even have my training.

Third, as discussed, there are many, many different levels of proof. There is not one definition. So, asking for one definition is utterly useless.

I hope this clears things up.
 
That's amazing to me, Gerry, because I have dedicated my entire professional life to the study of evidence and proof. I am, thus, aware that there is a phenomenal amount that has been written about the subject.

*snip for size*

I hope this clears things up.

Pearls before swine...
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom