If any thinkers today should be the ones most keen on what is evidence and what is proof, it should be atheists, but there are so far as I have searched in the web no systematic exposition by atheists on what is the fundamental concept of evidence as of proof in relation to the universe.
That's amazing to me, Gerry, because I have dedicated my entire professional life to the study of evidence and proof. I am, thus, aware that there is a phenomenal amount that has been written about the subject.
It is also amazing to me because I have already given you a definition of proof and evidence in this thread with examples ... several times. You have ignored me every time. To say that it has not been done is an insult to me and my efforts.
However, I'll do it all over again.
Proof, in general, is evidence sufficient to convince the mind of the truth of a proposition.
As is obvious, the crux of that definition is the word "sufficient." What is sufficient? Well, that depends on the type of circumstance and what we want to use our proof for.
If we want to use proof to make one guy pay $200.00 for knocking over your mailbox, we may require a very low level of proof. That would be a preponderance of the evidence. That means that some evidence may favor the defendant, but the majority of it favors the plaintiff. OJ Simpson was found liable for killing his wife by a prepoderance of the evidence.
If we want to use proof to send someone to jail and brand him for life as a criminal, we will only accept a higher level of proof. This is proof beyond a reasonable doubt. That is usually defined as a doubt that you can put into words. A mere "worry" that you might be wrong is not reasonable doubt. The fact that some evidence points to the guilt of someone else (and it cannot be explained in another way) is. OJ Simpson was found not guilty of murder beyond a reasonable doubt.
Scientists ask for another level of proof because they have another mission than the courts. Scientists are trying to build as accurate a model of the workings of the world as possible. They cannot tolerate any contradictory evidence whatsoever, because contradictory evidence means that they do not have a perfect picture of how the universe works. Thus, scientific proof is usually defined as repeatable, valid experiments consistent with a falsifiable hypothesis. As soon as an experiment contradicts the hypothesis, either the experiment must be explained or the hypothesis must be thrown out. This is far beyond a reasonable doubt - it is beyond any doubt whatsoever using current methods of analysis. It holds the door open, however, to new methods forever. Newtonian physics was demonstrated time and again for decade after decade until new experiments at high speeds and high energy showed it to be incorrect.
Mathematic or logical proof is a different sort of proof altogether. Mathematicians want to uncover fundamental rules which always work in all situations. A math or logic proof is necessarily true if the premises are true. No condition other than the truthfulness of the theorum could ever occur. This proof is intrinsic to the conditions themselves. There is no guesswork or leap of faith. A triangle has three sides. A line segment can be bisected into two parts, the sum of which is never less than the segment itself. Thus, any two sides of a triangle must together be longer than the third side.
There are many, many other types of proof that I have not discussed. Proof of the efficacy of a medication for FDA purposes is different than any of the above. Proof sufficient to stop and frisk a person on the street is different than any other. The central question is - what are we using the proof for? How important and far reaching are our goals? What happens if we're wrong? What will we do if we're right?
I am afraid that if you are waiting for a consensus of atheist opinions about the level of proof "in relation to the universe," you're going to be waiting a long time. First, there is no central organization of atheists. So, there's no way to even count atheists, let alone gather their opinions, let alone quantify them.
Second, there is no evidence that the average atheist has the training to discuss levels of proof. I have a doctorate in law (and I'm still out of my depth in the science and math department, as shown by my pitiful triangle example). Most people don't even have my training.
Third, as discussed, there are many, many different levels of proof. There is not one definition. So, asking for one definition is utterly useless.
I hope this clears things up.