Limiting God to the Big Bang universe.

It was only later, when people started challenging your statements, you backed off on the confident language.

I didn't back off on confident language. I, perhaps, admitted that I was asserting conjecture; but my language is just as confident. Anywho, the point is still moot until I can verify what he was talking about.

Okay, let's move on, shall we?

What do you suppose is the probability of moving out of the way of an attack from behind; and at the exact time of the attack?
 
I didn't back off on confident language. I, perhaps, admitted that I was asserting conjecture; but my language is just as confident. Anywho, the point is still moot until I can verify what he was talking about.

Okay, let's move on, shall we?

What do you suppose is the probability of moving out of the way of an attack from behind; and at the exact time of the attack?

Pretty low. Are you going for the MDC? I'm sure a protocol could be worked out.
 
I didn't back off on confident language. I, perhaps, admitted that I was asserting conjecture; but my language is just as confident. Anywho, the point is still moot until I can verify what he was talking about.


Asserting conjecture? Is that like jumbo shrimp?

Okay, let's move on, shall we?


Okay, unless you pull a DOC and assert this same conjecture again in the future.

What do you suppose is the probability of moving out of the way of an attack from behind; and at the exact time of the attack?


I would need more context than that. For example, I have avoided being hit by a falling tree branch that I didn't see coming...

... because I started running after my dog. Low probability, but fortunate for me. If someone is constantly moving, the probability goes up.

And I would have to see what is meant by "at the exact time of the attack". There have been many experiments and studies that show that people's perception of simultaneity does not match reality. One of the classics being the one that demonstrates a person's brain makes a decision before they are consciously aware of it.

http://images2.wikia.nocookie.net/p.../f6/Haynes_et_al_on_decision_in_the_brain.pdf
 
Pretty low. Are you going for the MDC? I'm sure a protocol could be worked out.

I wouldn't be so quick to say "pretty low." Depending on the conditions, there are a lot of ways someone can figure out when an attack is coming. Shadows, peripheral vision, sound, air pressure, etc.
 
Asserting conjecture? Is that like jumbo shrimp?
No, jumbo prawns :D
Okay, unless you pull a DOC and assert this same conjecture again in the future.
Perhaps, but next time will be less assertive and more curious. For example, when I know what my friend was talking about, I will bring it up; but not before then, and probably not conclusively.
I would need more context than that.
From a kneeling position, from behind you. Three different attacks in random order with a stick [representing a sword]: Diagonal cut; Vertical cut; Horizantal cut. What is the probability of moving out of the way of each of these without knowing the order?

I have avoided being hit by a falling tree branch that I didn't see coming...

... because I started running after my dog. Low probability, but fortunate for me. If someone is constantly moving, the probability goes up.
Miraculous :)
And I would have to see what is meant by "at the exact time of the attack". There have been many experiments and studies that show that people's perception of simultaneity does not match reality. One of the classics being the one that demonstrates a person's brain makes a decision before they are consciously aware of it.

The exact time of the attack is actually relative depending on the specific incident. What I mean by it, though, in laymen's terms, is moving out of the way after the person has committed to the attack, and cannot change anymore based on Human Response, and before it makes contact. Very small window of opportunity.
 
Last edited:
Pretty low. Are you going for the MDC? I'm sure a protocol could be worked out.

No, I'm not :)

[eta]

I've considered it, though, but I haven't been able to find out if it would be considered, "supernatural;" I don't want to, though, anyway.
 
Last edited:
The exact time of the attack is actually relative depending on the specific incident. What I mean by it, though, in laymen's terms, is moving out of the way after the person has committed to the attack, and cannot change anymore based on Human Response, and before it makes contact. Very small window of opportunity.


Oh, if you are talking about martial arts, that is very easy. As Dunstan mentioned, there are many cues you can sense for if you are expecting to be attacked. But yeah, a window of opportunity, no matter how small, cannot be described as "the exact time of attack".
 
Oh, if you are talking about martial arts, that is very easy. As Dunstan mentioned, there are many cues you can sense for if you are expecting to be attacked.
Okee dokee.
But yeah, a window of opportunity, no matter how small, cannot be described as "the exact time of attack".

"The exact time of attack," takes up many moments, and, since that window of opportunity is within those moments, it can be. I didn't specify, "the exact moment the opponent committed to the attack," but that is just about when you have to begin moving to make the window of opportunity.
 
"The exact time of attack," takes up many moments, and, since that window of opportunity is within those moments, it can be. I didn't specify, "the exact moment the opponent committed to the attack," but that is just about when you have to begin moving to make the window of opportunity.


Maybe a better example would be baseball. A pitcher in the major leagues can throw a ball close to 100 mph. At that speed, the batter has less than half a second to actually swing and hit it. However, the pitcher definitely gives the batter clues as to what he will throw and when, which is why home runs off of fastballs happen often enough to be unremarkable. Similarly, many of the cues that someone will be attacking are sent prior to "the exact moment the opponent committed to the attack". In most martial arts engagements, an attack is expected (or else we would call it, I don't know, ballroom dancing or something), so the attackee will be looking for those clues.
 
Similarly, many of the cues that someone will be attacking are sent prior to "the exact moment the opponent committed to the attack".

Misinterpreted. "The exact moment a person committed to the attack," refers to the internal commitment of the attacker, not the external.

In most martial arts engagements, an attack is expected (or else we would call it, I don't know, ballroom dancing or something), so the attackee will be looking for those clues.
I have witnessed the opposite. 100% evasion when no attack was expected. There comes a point, one could assert, when your body recognizes the cues without your mind's interpretation of them, and moves on its own. I have witnessed this, often, as well.

It's similar to your tree branch incident. One needn't even know of a danger to avoid it.
 
Misinterpreted. "The exact moment a person committed to the attack," refers to the internal commitment of the attacker, not the external.


Then your "window of opportunity" can be 2 hours long. You will have to be more specific what you mean by an "internal commitment".

I have witnessed the opposite. 100% evasion when no attack was expected. There comes a point, one could assert, when your body recognizes the cues without your mind's interpretation of them, and moves on its own. I have witnessed this, often, as well.


No attack expected? Again, I will need context here. If it is a martial arts display, of course an attack is expected. It is the very nature of the sport! But sure, the paper I linked earlier is an actual study of the response time of the brain to decision making. This isn't anything surprising.

It's similar to your tree branch incident. One needn't even know of a danger to avoid it.


I didn't avoid it, I got lucky. My movement had nothing to do with the tree branch.
 
I was mainly referring to cards. Kou Ryuu conjecture?
There you go again. You criticize a comment about the odds in casinos, and when the measured response comes, it suddenly appears you weren't talking about what everyone thought you were talking about. If you really can't ever make your meaning clear the first time around, perhaps you should take more care before posting, so as to avoid the appearance that you're careless of the truth.
 
You guys better be careful. Yrreg's going to come along and upbraid you for wandering off topic. And, sadly, he'll be right.
 
I wouldn't be so quick to say "pretty low." Depending on the conditions, there are a lot of ways someone can figure out when an attack is coming. Shadows, peripheral vision, sound, air pressure, etc.

I'm not a bit convinced, but feel free to prove me wrong that the chance of someone moving out of the way of an attack at the exact same time it happens is not pretty low.
 
You cannot get that subtlety? that is why atheists are always into irrelevancies.

Originally Posted by yrreg

This thread is not about proving God's existence.

But about laying the foundation for the proof of God's existence, by setting up the fundamental concept of God in relation to the universe in the Christian faith, namely:
Maker of everything that is not God Himself.​

Hold it right there Gerry! You're attempting to move the goalposts again. If this thread is not about proving God's existence, then your OP makes the assumption of this god's existence to already exist. That is the thing you or other theists haven't proved, yet this is what we have been asking you to do. This tendency to ignore people with legitimate questions is the usual step you take on all your threads...It's predictable. Please respond to post #214



If you insist that I am making the assumption that God exists, then what you mean is that I do have the thought in my mind,* i.e., the concept that God as maker of everything that is not God Himself exists in relation to the universe, for Christians.

You cannot get that subtlety? that is why atheists are always into irrelevancies.


About post #214, you have not given 5 examples each of evidence and of proof.


*Thought in my mind, here means a proposition.

So, imagine that you want to think about a vehicle that can stay in the air and move in the air, you should put that thought into a proposition that is affirmative and not negative, because if you make a negative proposition that is silly for being of no use to any productive thinking.

So, here is the proposition in the affirmative formulation:

A vehicle can stay in the air space and move in it.​

Now, you use your intelligence and right away you say yes, because birds stay in the air and move, so also mosquitoes.

Then you continue thinking intelligently, what I should do is see how birds and mosquitoes do it, and do something similar.




[ I have not yet read all the posts since my last visit here, so if I should answer already the relevant posts with earlier replies before I get to them, I will not anymore attend to them when I read them as I come to them. ]​






Yrreg
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom