Limiting God to the Big Bang universe.

Just take this essay type test topic, don't waste time.

I have just finished reading from post #201 to post #250, page 5 of this thread.

Please don't waste time, just take this essay type test topic [ no questions will be entertained, but you can excuse yourselves from this test ].


Originally Posted by Loss Leader

[...]

I am very glad to tell you that there are good, hard definitions of what constitutes proof sufficient to convince the scientific mind. Namely:

[ Etc. ]

​

Do it this way:

First define in not more than 20 words what is evidence.

Then define in not more than 20 words what is proof.

Now, give 5 concrete examples of what is evidence in not more that 100 words.

And also give 5 examples of what is proof in not more than 100 words.


That procedure will make you think carefully and verbalize precisely and also concisely.

Be systematic, first deal with evidence, and then with proof.


Suppose, you define the fundamental concept of evidence in relation to the universe, and also the fundamental concept of proof in relation to the universe, as I do with the fundamental concept of God in relation to the universe, for Christians.

When you examine everything in its fundamental concept in relation to the universe, then I guarantee you that you will be in a position to think better and more productively toward the advancement of genuine knowledge in your mind.


Here, I have already given to readers the fundamental concept of God in relation to the universe for Christians, namely:

Maker of everything that is not God Himself.​

Now, I will give also my fundamental concept of the universe in relation to the universe for everyone who knows what is the universe coming from astrophysicists of the Big Bang theory:
The totality of material existence that started with the Big Bang.​


You also follow me, define the fundamental concept of evidence in relation to the universe for atheists. and also the fundamental concept of proof in relation to the universe for atheists, both in not more than 20 words.


I like to continue our exchange, you are receptive to serious thinking though emotively rattled, still ideas come forth however confusedly.


You will do atheists a great favor to define evidence and to define proof each in not more than 20 words.

And I can use your definitions as guidelines in formulating my evidence and my proof for the existence of God, defined in fundamental concept in relation to the universe, for Christians, as the maker of everything that is not God Himself.


Recall the Latin axiom in regard to speech, from the speaker as to the listener and vice versa:

Sapienti pauca,​


I have already defined God and defined universe.

Now, I want atheists who are so vociferous with evidence and proof, to define in not more than 20 words what is for them evidence as for proof, and give 5 examples of each in not more than 100 words.


Then I will start a new thread of God existence from evidence and proof.




Yrreg
 
I have just finished reading from post #201 to post #250, page 5 of this thread.

Please don't waste time, just take this essay type test topic [ no questions will be entertained, but you can excuse yourselves from this test ].





I have already defined God and defined universe.

Now, I want atheists who are so vociferous with evidence and proof, to define in not more than 20 words what is for them evidence as for proof, and give 5 examples of each in not more than 100 words.


Then I will start a new thread of God existence from evidence and proof.




Yrreg
Another one? You have started many threads here and never presented a shred of evidence or proof. What is the point of yet another 'the bible is true because the bible is true' thread?
 
I

Now, I want atheists who are so vociferous with evidence and proof, to define in not more than 20 words what is for them evidence as for proof






Yrreg

God appearing before me,bringing my wife back to life along with Jimi Hendrix who would then play for us. Twenty words.
 
Last edited:
Do it this way:

First define in not more than 20 words what is evidence.

Then define in not more than 20 words what is proof.

[...]


Yrreg

Don't even try that again. It lead to you losing your composure, and getting yourself banned last time.
 
Then you continue thinking intelligently, what I should do is see how birds and mosquitoes do it, and do something similar.


... and quickly die because powered human flight has nothing whatsoever to do with the way birds or insects fly. (Some aspects of gliding are the same in birds as in airplanes.)

In any case, Gerry, I've answered you several times. You haven't indicated whether you accept my definition of scientific proof as adequate for your use.

I've already given examples of scientific proof, which you also haven't commented on.
 
Now, I want atheists who are so vociferous with evidence and proof, to define in not more than 20 words what is for them evidence as for proof, and give 5 examples of each in not more than 100 words.

I'll define it AGAIN in only fifteen words :

Evidence is something that will be present if god exists and absent if he doesn't.

Coming up with what that might be is up to you.
 
If you insist that I am making the assumption that God exists, then what you mean is that I do have the thought in my mind,* i.e., the concept that God as maker of everything that is not God Himself exists in relation to the universe, for Christians.

You cannot get that subtlety? that is why atheists are always into irrelevancies.

As an example of your impatience and unwillingness to be open in these threads, you dismiss the obvious things what people here already know about you: You are a hook,line, and sinker(Heart,soul and mind)believer in the Christian God; You've made that clear in previous threads. There is nothing subtle about your belief.
There is nothing irrelevant within me(an agnostic) asking you for the reason(s) that causes you to hold on to this belief.

About post #214, you have not given 5 examples each of evidence and of proof.
As far as post #214, my requests are relatively short, simple and to the point. This is where I would like to be convinced one way or the other.

*Thought in my mind, here means a proposition.

So, imagine that you want to think about a vehicle that can stay in the air and move in the air, you should put that thought into a proposition that is affirmative and not negative, because if you make a negative proposition that is silly for being of no use to any productive thinking.

So, here is the proposition in the affirmative formulation:

A vehicle can stay in the air space and move in it.​

Now, you use your intelligence and right away you say yes, because birds stay in the air and move, so also mosquitoes.

Then you continue thinking intelligently, what I should do is see how birds and mosquitoes do it, and do something similar.

When I was growing up on the farm, it was me who was given the chore of burning the garbage. So after I got the fire started, the thing that intrigued me the most was how the heat caused nearly everything to rise up; Especially above the flame. This made me wonder if there was someway to capture heat constantly, perhaps it may cause something even heavier to rise up or down if one can control the flame. This fascinated me more than wondering how much effort it would take to simulate a bird in flight. This total curiosity came full circle 36 years later when I took my first hot air balloon ride. The affirmative.

ETA: Could you respond to post #187 (did you skip this one?) and please, no tergiversating...
 
Last edited:
I have just finished reading from post #201 to post #250, page 5 of this thread.

Please don't waste time, just take this essay type test topic [ no questions will be entertained, but you can excuse yourselves from this test ].
You're not the boss of the internet and your ridiculous requirements are made even more ridiculous by the fact that you never adhere to them.

I have already defined God and defined universe.
Your definition of "God" is very vague. He alternates between an uncaring deity and a very specific Christian god.

Now, I want atheists who are so vociferous with evidence and proof, to define in not more than 20 words what is for them evidence as for proof, and give 5 examples of each in not more than 100 words.
Evidence is something observable which can be used to assess whether a claim is more likely to be true than not. I gave you a good example of evidence several pages ago.

I'll paraphrase again:

I'm the last person to leave my house in the morning. When I return, I notice that my husband's car is in the driveway. Upon entering the house, I see that there are breadcrumbs and a mayonnaise-encrused knife on the counter. I will take this as evidence that he has returned home and made himself a sandwich. It can't be proof, because it's possible that a car thief has driven my husband's car home and made a sandwich. It's possible that my husband made something other than a sandwich. It's also possible that he came home and then decided to sprinkle breadcrumbs on the counter, and stick a knife into the mayonnaise jar just for kicks. But based on past experience and knowledge of my husband's love for sandwiches, I'm going to assume that my first hypothesis is correct.

It's really not a difficult concept. You need to show some evidence that it's more likely that a god made the universe than not. Where's your evidence? There's no breadcrumbs or knife. There's no car in the driveway. There's no past experience to lead you to believe how a god would behave. But that's not my problem; it's yours.

Proof will be much harder to provide, so I advise you not to attempt it. Even in the somewhat easier case of my husband and the sandwich, I would be hard-pressed for 100% proof. Even if he were to tell me that he, in fact, came home from work and made a sandwich, I won't know that he's telling the truth because I didn't see it for myself. Maybe he's hiding something, maybe he was momentarily abducted by an alien and had the memory implanted. I may be 99% sure that he's telling the truth about something innocuous, but it won't be proof. His eyewitness account is simply further evidence.
 
I honestly think a moderated thread between just me and Gerry would be the best way to move a conversation with him forward. He gets very confused by multiple posts.
 
The concept of a god is an irrelevancy.


In particular, the concept of God that yrreg is using in this thread is an irrelevancy. If all God is is an entity that caused the Big Bang then there is no possible observable difference between a universe with a God and one without. Yrreg's God, as defined in the OP, is an irrelevant God.
 
Yrreg,
I am yet to be convinced that you have the intellect to comprehend any answers that may be given.

You are yet to meet the minimum requirements for engaging in this discussion as previously posted:

I require you to establish a set of guidelines or rules on the following:

what do you define as evidence? Provide examples consistent with your definition

what do you define as proof? Provide examples consistent with your definition

specify the criteria by which any evidence will be rated for relevance and weight. Clearly document these in advance so that any contributors or spectators may impartially apply these criteria and arrive at the same conclusion.

please provide information on your experience, skills, qualifications and knowledge relating to analysing and evaluating data, and synthesising conclusions. Attach examples of your prior work.

Specify in advance the weight of evidence or proof that will empirically establish the proof of the god postulate that you have established, so that any participant or spectator may by inspection of the weight of evidence and proof, establish whether that threshold has been reached.

Describe the process whereby evidence will be assessed as being "for" or "against" your case, noting that one could contrive to later reinterpret proofs to suit one's own preconceptions.

Noting that we all have a real life somewhere, specify the timeframe in which this exercise is proposed to take place.

Specify the roles and responsibilites that will be required to be assigned, for this exercise to be done in the required timeframe.
 
I honestly think a moderated thread between just me and Gerry would be the best way to move a conversation with him forward. He gets very confused by multiple posts.

That's sort of like saying that I'd have a better conversation with my friend's terrier if nobody else interfered.

Gerry doesn't want to have a conversation with you, or with anyone. He wants to have a Socratic dialogue in which you spout the required responses until he can exclaim HA HA GOTCHA!

(Incidentally, for those who are new to yrreg threads, I am not exaggerating. He has actually written "ha ha gotcha" in posts and even in thread titles.)

There is nothing to see here. yrreg's "argument" consists of:

1. Equivocate about the meaning of "god," using the usual first cause, god-of-the-gaps, cosmological deistic arguments.
2. Declare that since he has now established the existence of something called "god," one should "naturally" look to Christian apologetics because, hey, Christians have spent a lot of time writing about this god person. (Why one should ignore the writings of Islamic, Jewish, Hindu, Buddhist, Norse, and other religious scholars is left as an exercise for the reader.)
3. Scream "ANTHONY FLEW! ANTHONY FLEW!" many times. Because, you know, he was a "prominent atheist" who allegedly changed his mind, and that matters much much more than all the former Christians who changed their minds. (Putting aside the dubiousness of the "argument from conversion" to begin with.)

In the process of the above, yrreg will do all of the following:
1. Abuse the English language, while being persnickety and ostentatious about his own vocabulary. Yes, I know, he is supposedly a Filipino and probably speaks better English than I do Filipino -- so what? yrreg doesn't simply mangle the English language, he mangles it while lecturing us about how to speak it, and while using and abusing some Word of the Day like "tergiversating" that he saw somewhere. (Lately he seems to have moved on to Latin.)
2. Ignore any sincere efforts to engage with him -- sorry LL, you're wasting your time -- while complaining about posts like mine, and seizing upon any joking concession with a HA HA GOTCHA, only to whine later when it's pointed out that it's a joke.
3. Set out complicated "assignments" for everyone else (please define the following terms in 20 words or less and provide ten examples of each), demanding brevity and clarity while providing the exact opposite.

You can continue to believe that yrreg is some good faith discussant who just needs to have the right interlocutor, but I think that's a little like saying that Charles Manson just needs to meet the right woman. Also, yrreg will never stick with a moderated thread even if you can get him to agree to one, because he will get frustrated if his posts are not immediately visible on the site.

In the meantime, I will continue to point and laugh. yrreg does provide solid entertainment value.
 
Last edited:
God appearing before me,bringing my wife back to life along with Jimi Hendrix who would then play for us. Twenty words.

There's your twenty word answer edge,can you get in touch with your sky daddy and ask him to do that for me?
 
That's sort of like saying that I'd have a better conversation with my friend's terrier if nobody else interfered.

Gerry doesn't want to have a conversation with you, or with anyone. He wants to have a Socratic dialogue in which you spout the required responses until he can exclaim HA HA GOTCHA!

(Incidentally, for those who are new to yrreg threads, I am not exaggerating. He has actually written "ha ha gotcha" in posts and even in thread titles.)

There is nothing to see here. yrreg's "argument" consists of:

1. Equivocate about the meaning of "god," using the usual first cause, god-of-the-gaps, cosmological deistic arguments.
2. Declare that since he has now established the existence of something called "god," one should "naturally" look to Christian apologetics because, hey, Christians have spent a lot of time writing about this god person. (Why one should ignore the writings of Islamic, Jewish, Hindu, Buddhist, Norse, and other religious scholars is left as an exercise for the reader.)
3. Scream "ANTHONY FLEW! ANTHONY FLEW!" many times. Because, you know, he was a "prominent atheist" who allegedly changed his mind, and that matters much much more than all the former Christians who changed their minds. (Putting aside the dubiousness of the "argument from conversion" to begin with.)

In the process of the above, yrreg will do all of the following:
1. Abuse the English language, while being persnickety and ostentatious about his own vocabulary. Yes, I know, he is supposedly a Filipino and probably speaks better English than I do Filipino -- so what? yrreg doesn't simply mangle the English language, he mangles it while lecturing us about how to speak it, and while using and abusing some Word of the Day like "tergiversating" that he saw somewhere. (Lately he seems to have moved on to Latin.)
2. Ignore any sincere efforts to engage with him -- sorry LL, you're wasting your time -- while complaining about posts like mine, and seizing upon any joking concession with a HA HA GOTCHA, only to whine later when it's pointed out that it's a joke.
3. Set out complicated "assignments" for everyone else (please define the following terms in 20 words or less and provide ten examples of each), demanding brevity and clarity while providing the exact opposite.

You can continue to believe that yrreg is some good faith discussant who just needs to have the right interlocutor, but I think that's a little like saying that Charles Manson just needs to meet the right woman. Also, yrreg will never stick with a moderated thread even if you can get him to agree to one, because he will get frustrated if his posts are not immediately visible on the site.

In the meantime, I will continue to point and laugh. yrreg does provide solid entertainment value.

When Yrreg is planning a gotcha moment he seems to think that he is leading us up the garden path and that we have no idea what he is up to. In reality he is so transparent that a five year old child could see through it. His GOTCHA! moments are always such damp squibs. Comedy gold and as you say,solid entertainment.
 
I honestly think a moderated thread between just me and Gerry would be the best way to move a conversation with him forward. He gets very confused by multiple posts.
I fear your last three words are a redundancy.
 
In particular, the concept of God that yrreg is using in this thread is an irrelevancy. If all God is is an entity that caused the Big Bang then there is no possible observable difference between a universe with a God and one without. Yrreg's God, as defined in the OP, is an irrelevant God.

This.
 
So, imagine that you want to think about a vehicle that can stay in the air and move in the air, you should put that thought into a proposition that is affirmative and not negative, because if you make a negative proposition that is silly for being of no use to any productive thinking.

So, here is the proposition in the affirmative formulation:

A vehicle can stay in the air space and move in it.​

Now, you use your intelligence and right away you say yes, because birds stay in the air and move, so also mosquitoes.

Then you continue thinking intelligently, what I should do is see how birds and mosquitoes do it, and do something similar.
That's one approach, and it was tried, but you might note the next time you look up in the sky that none of the vehicles you see flying by are flapping their wings.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom