Limiting God to the Big Bang universe.

Well, the vibrations I'm picking up from the collective consciousness in this thread are telling me that it's nonsense...

Oh. Well, what about the scientific view-point, as opposed to your sarcastic one?

I'm genuinely curious. My friend told me about an experiment close to this one [except the way he worded it made it seem like the test involved only one person at a time, and attempting to project specifically a, "1," or, "0," so I'm not sure it's the same RNG experiment], but I haven't researched it. I find that if I just throw enough out there, the overwhelming amount of falsifying response is likely to have some evidence of the contrary somewhere in it.
 
Unfortunately random number generators aren't actually completely random, and the more complicated they are the more difficult it is to predict the non-randomness.

I'm just wondering how good this experiment is at handling that problem.
 
Unfortunately random number generators aren't actually completely random, and the more complicated they are the more difficult it is to predict the non-randomness.

I'm just wondering how good this experiment is at handling that problem.

I'm not sure? I haven't found what he was talking about, and he didn't answer when I called him today; I'll just have to wait and see what he says, I suppose.
 
What? How on earth can quantum mechanics be involved in prayer (god or no god)?

I agree that prayer isn't a product of god, but of man.

For the rest, I think your side note slipped, fell, and bumped its metaphor on every step on the way down. I look forward to your explanation of the scientific roots of prayer...
:popcorn6

Ah,the woolly minded new age misuse of the word energy.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=G9jUXFJ9gE4

Please explain the "scientific roots" of that.

Please explain how you mean it, does thought focus, what exactly?

You mean the reklease of ATP by organelles?

So, by your definition, does thought/intention not produce energy?

And, if it does, then wouldn't strong intention, as opposed to lax intention, provide a more, "focused," energy?
 
Oh. Well, what about the scientific view-point, as opposed to your sarcastic one?

Do you seriously think it's likely that a random number generator would be influenced by something as vaguely defined as "global consciousness"? I don't see any demonstration that there is even an effect to explain, let alone a likely mechanism. One response is here.
 
Do you seriously think it's likely that a random number generator would be influenced by something as vaguely defined as "global consciousness"? I don't see any demonstration that there is even an effect to explain, let alone a likely mechanism. One response is here.

That wasn't the inference I was purporting; my understanding of the RNG test was that a subject would focus on a number, and, due to probability, prove that intention had an outward affect on the physical realm directly, based on the fact that the number focused on would appear more often than was probable.
 
Last edited:
This thread is not about proving God's existence.

Yes it is. You say so yourself, look :

I am inviting atheists who insist on evidence and proof to give their fundamental concept for evidence

This thread IS about evidence. You keep saying it is, and then you say it actually isn't, then you say it is again only to go on and say it isn't.

I and others have told you what would be needed to prove that god exists. YOU need to do so.

You can contribute from your part as I presume as an atheist of the insistence attitude that God must be proven to exist from evidence, contribute namely by giving your concepts and your examples on evidence as on proof.

Atheists cannot give you evidence for god. Atheists don't think there is any. You are the believer, it is up to you to say what you believe and why you believe it.
 
Never heard of him.

...Okay.

[Kou ryuu means, approximately, "War-time school (of martial arts)," from Jap. to English.

It's usually seen as, "Koryu," in search engines and the like.]

eta

As opposed to, "Gendai," lit., "Sport martial arts."
 
Last edited:
Yes it is. You say so yourself, look :



This thread IS about evidence. You keep saying it is, and then you say it actually isn't, then you say it is again only to go on and say it isn't.

I and others have told you what would be needed to prove that god exists. YOU need to do so.



Atheists cannot give you evidence for god. Atheists don't think there is any. You are the believer, it is up to you to say what you believe and why you believe it.

I think Gerry just wants you to repeatedly cycle through the definitions of, "evidence," and, "proof," according to Atheists, as was mentioned by someone else earlier, until he sees one that he can support his claim with.
 
That wasn't the inference I was purporting;
Well, it was the one there was a link to, and you said it was close enough.

my understanding of the RNG test was that a subject would focus on a number, and, due to probability, prove that intention had an outward affect on the physical realm directly, based on the fact that the number focused on would appear more often than was probable.

Again, without any actual data, do think this is likely?
 
So, by your definition, does thought/intention not produce energy?.


Thought does not produce energy. Thought is the result of electro-chemical energy. With very, very sensitive equipment places on or very near the skull, this tiny bit of electricity can be measured.

However, it doesn't leave the brain. There's no closed circuit outside the body for electrons to follow. The chance that human intention can have an effect on external events is exactly zero.
 
Observer effects wouldn't translate as thought effects, in my mind. I was referring to the experiment of the Random Number Generator.

You mean the one that doesn't show anything. Thoughts DO not effect RNGs.

There is no 'small effect' found through meta-analysis. That is hooey.

You have to have a signal that rises above the noise ratio to have an effect.
 
Last edited:
Oh. Well, what about the scientific view-point, as opposed to your sarcastic one?

I'm genuinely curious. My friend told me about an experiment close to this one [except the way he worded it made it seem like the test involved only one person at a time, and attempting to project specifically a, "1," or, "0," so I'm not sure it's the same RNG experiment], but I haven't researched it. I find that if I just throw enough out there, the overwhelming amount of falsifying response is likely to have some evidence of the contrary somewhere in it.

The scientific viewpoint is its hooey, until you can show that it rises past the noise level, it is hooey and wishful thinking. You will notice that they never dsicuss the standard deviation, but just throw out p values.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom