Limiting God to the Big Bang universe.

So, imagine that you want to think about a vehicle that can stay in the air and move in the air, you should put that thought into a proposition that is affirmative and not negative, because if you make a negative proposition that is silly for being of no use to any productive thinking.

So, here is the proposition in the affirmative formulation:

A vehicle can stay in the air space and move in it.​

Now, you use your intelligence and right away you say yes, because birds stay in the air and move, so also mosquitoes.

Then you continue thinking intelligently, what I should do is see how birds and mosquitoes do it, and do something similar.
Yrreg

But that would not work, no matter how affirmatively you dreamed about it. You'd just be starting at the beginning, and repeating the mistakes of others.

Da Vinci thought that way, and genius though he was, he did not fly. It's true, you can design a toy ornithopter and it will flap across a room, but in case you had not noticed, the successors of Da Vinci who thought intelligently enough to stay up in the air did so by ignoring the designs of nature, learning from the failures of others, and inventing something entirely new. The Wright brothers were not just tinkerers and mechanics: they were scientists and they learned not only from dreams but from experiments, which include repeated failure. No doubt it helps to think what you want to achieve, in fact it's inherent in any goal, but after determining goal it's also helpful to think about what you want to avoid (e.g. failure to launch, uncontrolled landing, falling out of the sky, etc.) and to study the mistakes of those who have come before you.
 
That's sort of like saying that I'd have a better conversation with my friend's terrier if nobody else interfered.[/quoote]


I will disagree with you, sir, regarding some specifics:


Gerry doesn't want to have a conversation with you, or with anyone. He wants to have a Socratic dialogue in which you spout the required responses until he can exclaim HA HA GOTCHA!


Actually, I've never seen a Yrreg thread progress to that point, or progress much past the OP. However, I agree with you that his goals are not to have a "discussion" as humans would normally define it. I will disagree that we shouldn't let him play his thinking completely out. I find that letting some people lead me to their mistaken conclusions is sometimes the best way to then correct them. They appreciate having been heard.

yrreg's "argument" consists of:

1. Equivocate about the meaning of "god," using the usual first cause, god-of-the-gaps, cosmological deistic arguments.
2. Declare that since he has now established the existence of something called "god," one should "naturally" look to Christian apologetics because, hey, Christians have spent a lot of time writing about this god person. (Why one should ignore the writings of Islamic, Jewish, Hindu, Buddhist, Norse, and other religious scholars is left as an exercise for the reader.)
3. Scream "ANTHONY FLEW! ANTHONY FLEW!" many times.


I disagree in terms of this thread only. So far, Gerry has only advanced a definition of God that he would like to prove. He has not (in this thread) said that such a God does exist. He has said that he believes in such a God, that such definition is consistent with the Christian God, and that he believes he will successfully prove the existence of the same. But the only debate he foreclosed is arguing about the definition he wishes to test.


In the process of the above, yrreg will do all of the following:
1. Abuse the English language
2. Ignore any sincere efforts to engage with him
3. Set out complicated "assignments"


Yup.


You can continue to believe that yrreg is some good faith discussant who just needs to have the right interlocutor, but I think that's a little like saying that Charles Manson just needs to meet the right woman.


I think it's more like saying Charles Manson just needs to meet the right psychiatrist.


Also, yrreg will never stick with a moderated thread even if you can get him to agree to one, because he will get frustrated if his posts are not immediately visible on the site.


On the other hand, being at the center of a moderated thread might be the very thing for an ego like his. He watches the view count very, very carefully. The replies are far less important.


yrreg does provide solid entertainment value.


As does bear baiting.
 
Fundamental concept of evidence for man in relation to the universe.

Here is my fundamental concept of evidence for man in relation to the universe:


Anything man knows leading him to know another thing.​

What do you guys say?




Yrreg
 
I have no idea what you are talking about. What exactly are you trying to prove with your evidence?
 
And once again, Gerry creates yet another thread after abandoning previous ones. He's simply convinced that if he just can trick someone enough with his mangled english and lead-by-stupidity posts, that they'll fall over screaming "amen I have found the lawd!!!"
I don't think so :)
 
Here is my fundamental concept of evidence for man in relation to the universe:


Anything man knows leading him to know another thing.​

What do you guys say?




Yrreg

Oh, please stop it. What point are you trying to make? I'm sure you've been asked this a hundred times.


In my estimate, you're trying to use sophistry to trap people into accidentally agreeing with you so you can claim some rhetorical triumph.

This strategy hasn't work well for you, has it?


You, epix, phenix, and DOC should compare notes.
 
Here is my fundamental concept of evidence for man in relation to the universe:


Anything man knows leading him to know another thing.​

What do you guys say?




Yrreg

Do you mean 'Anything man knows leads him to know another thing.'? It's still gibberish,but it's better English. You have abandoned yet another thread. Don't you ever get tired of losing?
 
No, I have not abandoned any of my threads, just put them in abeyance.

No, I have not abandoned my immediately preceding thread, and not any of my previous threads, but all of them are held in abeyance, for the clearance of concepts which are in fundamental relation to the universe needed for man to come to the consensus of knowledge in regard to some matter of dissent.



Yrreg
 
No, I have not abandoned my immediately preceding thread, and not any of my previous threads, but all of them are held in abeyance, for the clearance of concepts which are in fundamental relation to the universe needed for man to come to the consensus of knowledge in regard to some matter of dissent.


Go look up the definition of "gibberish". That word describes perfectly what you've written above.

What do you guys say?
 
No, I have not abandoned my immediately preceding thread, and not any of my previous threads, but all of them are held in abeyance, for the clearance of concepts which are in fundamental relation to the universe needed for man to come to the consensus of knowledge in regard to some matter of dissent.



Yrreg

You are confused. 'In abeyance' does not mean 'never'.
 
No, I have not abandoned my immediately preceding thread, and not any of my previous threads, but all of them are held in abeyance, for the clearance of concepts which are in fundamental relation to the universe needed for man to come to the consensus of knowledge in regard to some matter of dissent.



Yrreg

I have absolutely no idea what you just said.



:confused:
 
for the clearance of concepts which are in fundamental relation to the universe needed for man to come to the consensus of knowledge in regard to some matter of dissent.



Yrreg

Come,the fundamental knowledge in consensus in relation to the universe for the clearance to regard concepts needed which are in dissent to some matter in man.
You can put those words in any order,they will make equal sense.
 
The main concept wouldn't be that your sky daddy exists,would it Yrreg? Just guessing.
 
And once again, Gerry creates yet another thread after abandoning previous ones. He's simply convinced that if he just can trick someone enough with his mangled english and lead-by-stupidity posts, that they'll fall over screaming "amen I have found the lawd!!!"
I don't think so :)
I really miss Fiona and her little red wagon...
 
Meh, he's merely trying to redefine "evidence" as to include stuff you just "know". That is, a gut feeling would then be classified as "evidence". Then he can sneak in his personal revelation as "evidence".
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom