Lily the Muppet Loves Free Food

Nobody starved before 64? Was it called the great depression because of mental health reasons? Imsure all those people camping in central park were rolling in food really....
 
Why would an EMP cause a blight disease that kills the staple crop of your nation?
Loss of the electric grid and resultant inability to pump fuel would be the root cause leading to crop failures.

Couple that with transport systems that would no longer operate even when fueled.
 
Hong Kong exists because of its prime natural resource. One of the best deepwater ports in the world. And it exists today with:

Socialized Medicine
CSSA grants - not unemployment insurance but abject WELFARE!!!
No actual DEMOCRACY
By law, workers are allowed 2 sick days per month!!
Controlled Currency - the HK$ is pegged to the USD.
Also public housing projects in which half the population lives.

If you love Hong Kong's commie government so much Robert, why don't you go live there? :D
 
Loss of the electric grid and resultant inability to pump fuel would be the root cause leading to crop failures.

Couple that with transport systems that would no longer operate even when fueled.

Or a more likely scenario:

The common staples would be blighted by a disease. This could easily happen with out any particular requirements.
 
ftfy

Are you a complete ignoramus on world trade? Do you know where the goods we ship to the world come from? Mainland China. And are you aware that the Chinese ports in Shenzhen (ports of Shekour, Yantian, Chiwan, and Da Shan Bay) now ship more of those goods than Hong Kong does?

Hong Kong exists because of its prime natural resource. One of the best deepwater ports in the world. And it exists today with:

Socialized Medicine
CSSA grants - not unemployment insurance but abject WELFARE!!!
No actual DEMOCRACY
By law, workers are allowed 2 sick days per month!!
Controlled Currency - the HK$ is pegged to the USD.

That DEMOCRACY one is interesting - under the ebil commies Hong Kong now has more sufferage than it did under the benevolent British. Further, we have a very active civil courts system and more regulation of business than any of you freemen wannabes would ever admit to.

Still a higher degree of economic freedom than most other nations including the US. In the Heritage Foundations Index of Econ Freedom, Hong Kong ranks number one, the US number nine. And Hong Kong with few if any natural resources other than a port.

http://www.heritage.org/index/
 
Last edited:
"Continued dependence" upon welfare, "induces a spiritual disintegration fundamentally destructive to the national fiber. To dole our relief in this way is to administer a narcotic, a subtle destroyer of the human spirit." -- FDR


Robert, thank you for providing this quote from Franklin Delano Roosevelt's 1935 State of the Union Address. But I think we should provide a little more context, just to help you and others see what's behind the sound-bite. The full speech can be found here for anybody interested. I will excerpt some key passages below, which I believe will more accurately illustrate FDR's views on welfare.


We find our population suffering from old inequalities, little changed by vast sporadic remedies. In spite of our efforts and in spite of our talk, we have not weeded out the over privileged and we have not effectively lifted up the underprivileged. Both of these manifestations of injustice have retarded happiness. No wise man has any intention of destroying what is known as the profit motive; because by the profit motive we mean the right by work to earn a decent livelihood for ourselves and for our families.

We have, however, a clear mandate from the people, that Americans must forswear that conception of the acquisition of wealth which, through excessive profits, creates undue private power over private affairs and, to our misfortune, over public affairs as well. In building toward this end we do not destroy ambition, nor do we seek to divide our wealth into equal shares on stated occasions. We continue to recognize the greater ability of some to earn more than others. But we do assert that the ambition of the individual to obtain for him and his a proper security, a reasonable leisure, and a decent living throughout life, is an ambition to be preferred to the appetite for great wealth and great power.

Closely related to the broad problem of livelihood is that of security against the major hazards of life. Here also, a comprehensive survey of what has been attempted or accomplished in many Nations and in many States proves to me that the time has come for action by the national Government. I shall send to you, in a few days, definite recommendations based on these studies. These recommendations will cover the broad subjects of unemployment insurance and old age insurance, of benefits for children, form others, for the handicapped, for maternity care and for other aspects of dependency and illness where a beginning can now be made.

In that spirit I come to an immediate issue made for us by hard and inescapable circumstance—the task of putting people to work. In the spring of 1933 the issue of destitution seemed to stand apart; today, in the light of our experience and our new national policy, we find we can put people to work in ways which conform to, initiate and carry forward the broad principles of that policy.

More than two billions of dollars have also been expended in direct relief to the destitute. Local agencies of necessity determined the recipients of this form of relief. With inevitable exceptions the funds were spent by them with reasonable efficiency and as a result actual want of food and clothing in the great majority of cases has been overcome.

But the stark fact before us is that great numbers still remain unemployed.

A large proportion of these unemployed and their dependents have been forced on the relief rolls. The burden on the Federal Government has grown with great rapidity. We have here a human as well as an economic problem. When humane considerations are concerned, Americans give them precedence. The lessons of history, confirmed by the evidence immediately before me, show conclusively that continued dependence upon relief induces a spiritual and moral disintegration fundamentally destructive to the national fibre. To dole out relief in this way is to administer a narcotic, a subtle destroyer of the human spirit. It is inimical to the dictates of sound policy. It is in violation of the traditions of America. Work must be found for able-bodied but destitute workers.

About one million and a half of these belong to the group which in the past was dependent upon local welfare efforts. Most of them are unable for one reason or another to maintain themselves independently—for the most part, through no fault of their own. Such people, in the days before the great depression, were cared for by local efforts—by States, by counties, by towns, by cities, by churches and by private welfare agencies. It is my thought that in the future they must be cared for as they were before. I stand ready through my own personal efforts, and through the public influence of the office that I hold, to help these local agencies to get the means necessary to assume this burden.

There are, however, an additional three and one half million employable people who are on relief. With them the problem is different and the responsibility is different. This group was the victim of a nation-wide depression caused by conditions which were not local but national. The Federal Government is the only governmental agency with sufficient power and credit to meet this situation. We have assumed this task and we shall not shrink from it in the future. It is a duty dictated by every intelligent consideration of national policy to ask you to make it possible for the United States to give employment to all of these three and one half million employable people now on relief, pending their absorption in a rising tide of private employment.

It is my thought that with the exception of certain of the normal public building operations of the Government, all emergency public works shall be united in a single new arid greatly enlarged plan.

I am not willing that the vitality of our people be further sapped by the giving of cash, of market baskets, of a few hours of weekly work cutting grass, raking leaves or picking up .papers in the public parks. We must preserve not only the bodies of the unemployed from destitution but also their self-respect, their self-reliance and courage and determination. This decision brings me to the problem of what the Government should do with approximately five million unemployed now on the relief rolls.

The work itself will cover a wide field including clearance of slums, which for adequate reasons cannot be undertaken by private capital; in rural housing of several kinds, where, again, private capital is unable to function; in rural electrification; in the reforestation of the great watersheds of the Nation; in an intensified program to prevent soil erosion and to reclaim blighted areas; in improving existing road systems and in constructing national highways designed to handle modern traffic; in the elimination of grade crossings; in the extension and enlargement of the successful work of the Civilian Conservation Corps; in non-Federal works, mostly self-liquidating and highly useful to local divisions of Government; and on many other projects which the Nation needs and cannot afford to neglect.
​


The people FDR's quote referred to was the able-bodied, able-minded people who want to work, but couldn't find employment. Like most people they prefer to earn a livelihood, to use their skills, to better their lives through their labors ... if only they could find a job. So what does FDR do? He uses the power of the federal government to create the jobs. He implements on gigantic stimulus package to provide people employment so they aren't simply accepting government relief.

Thanks Robert, for helping me prove that the government can and has played a big role in providing economic stimulus during hard times, and is instrumental in seeing that the people's needs are met.
 
Still a higher degree of economic freedom than most other nations including the US.

That was the point that was being made. There is a degree of economic freedom INSPITE OF THE THINGS YOU CLAIM PREVENT IT.

You are against welfare- Honkong has it.
You are against socialised medicine. Hong Kong has it.
Sick days for the "unproductive" poor.

Everything you have been claiming prevents economic freedom is present in HK.

Have you forgoton your own posts again?
 
I've got all the commie govt. I could suffer under Obamaism.

Oh. Are you going to get around to showing which of his policies match those of the communist agenda yet? Are you sure he's communist as you said he had facist policies, which means he can't be communist.
 
Still a higher degree of economic freedom than most other nations including the US.
If the result is less well being, less contentment, more suffering in the aggregate then who the hell gives a damn? That my rich folk have more economic freedom than another countries rich folk is pointless.

If the rich can be rich and the poor can be better off then why the hell not?
 
Robert, thank you for providing this quote from Franklin Delano Roosevelt's 1935 State of the Union Address. But I think we should provide a little more context, just to help you and others see what's behind the sound-bite. The full speech can be found here for anybody interested. I will excerpt some key passages below, which I believe will more accurately illustrate FDR's views on welfare.


We find our population suffering from old inequalities, little changed by vast sporadic remedies. In spite of our efforts and in spite of our talk, we have not weeded out the over privileged and we have not effectively lifted up the underprivileged. Both of these manifestations of injustice have retarded happiness. No wise man has any intention of destroying what is known as the profit motive; because by the profit motive we mean the right by work to earn a decent livelihood for ourselves and for our families.

We have, however, a clear mandate from the people, that Americans must forswear that conception of the acquisition of wealth which, through excessive profits, creates undue private power over private affairs and, to our misfortune, over public affairs as well. In building toward this end we do not destroy ambition, nor do we seek to divide our wealth into equal shares on stated occasions. We continue to recognize the greater ability of some to earn more than others. But we do assert that the ambition of the individual to obtain for him and his a proper security, a reasonable leisure, and a decent living throughout life, is an ambition to be preferred to the appetite for great wealth and great power.

Closely related to the broad problem of livelihood is that of security against the major hazards of life. Here also, a comprehensive survey of what has been attempted or accomplished in many Nations and in many States proves to me that the time has come for action by the national Government. I shall send to you, in a few days, definite recommendations based on these studies. These recommendations will cover the broad subjects of unemployment insurance and old age insurance, of benefits for children, form others, for the handicapped, for maternity care and for other aspects of dependency and illness where a beginning can now be made.

In that spirit I come to an immediate issue made for us by hard and inescapable circumstance—the task of putting people to work. In the spring of 1933 the issue of destitution seemed to stand apart; today, in the light of our experience and our new national policy, we find we can put people to work in ways which conform to, initiate and carry forward the broad principles of that policy.

More than two billions of dollars have also been expended in direct relief to the destitute. Local agencies of necessity determined the recipients of this form of relief. With inevitable exceptions the funds were spent by them with reasonable efficiency and as a result actual want of food and clothing in the great majority of cases has been overcome.

But the stark fact before us is that great numbers still remain unemployed.

A large proportion of these unemployed and their dependents have been forced on the relief rolls. The burden on the Federal Government has grown with great rapidity. We have here a human as well as an economic problem. When humane considerations are concerned, Americans give them precedence. The lessons of history, confirmed by the evidence immediately before me, show conclusively that continued dependence upon relief induces a spiritual and moral disintegration fundamentally destructive to the national fibre. To dole out relief in this way is to administer a narcotic, a subtle destroyer of the human spirit. It is inimical to the dictates of sound policy. It is in violation of the traditions of America. Work must be found for able-bodied but destitute workers.

About one million and a half of these belong to the group which in the past was dependent upon local welfare efforts. Most of them are unable for one reason or another to maintain themselves independently—for the most part, through no fault of their own. Such people, in the days before the great depression, were cared for by local efforts—by States, by counties, by towns, by cities, by churches and by private welfare agencies. It is my thought that in the future they must be cared for as they were before. I stand ready through my own personal efforts, and through the public influence of the office that I hold, to help these local agencies to get the means necessary to assume this burden.

There are, however, an additional three and one half million employable people who are on relief. With them the problem is different and the responsibility is different. This group was the victim of a nation-wide depression caused by conditions which were not local but national. The Federal Government is the only governmental agency with sufficient power and credit to meet this situation. We have assumed this task and we shall not shrink from it in the future. It is a duty dictated by every intelligent consideration of national policy to ask you to make it possible for the United States to give employment to all of these three and one half million employable people now on relief, pending their absorption in a rising tide of private employment.

It is my thought that with the exception of certain of the normal public building operations of the Government, all emergency public works shall be united in a single new arid greatly enlarged plan.

I am not willing that the vitality of our people be further sapped by the giving of cash, of market baskets, of a few hours of weekly work cutting grass, raking leaves or picking up .papers in the public parks. We must preserve not only the bodies of the unemployed from destitution but also their self-respect, their self-reliance and courage and determination. This decision brings me to the problem of what the Government should do with approximately five million unemployed now on the relief rolls.

The work itself will cover a wide field including clearance of slums, which for adequate reasons cannot be undertaken by private capital; in rural housing of several kinds, where, again, private capital is unable to function; in rural electrification; in the reforestation of the great watersheds of the Nation; in an intensified program to prevent soil erosion and to reclaim blighted areas; in improving existing road systems and in constructing national highways designed to handle modern traffic; in the elimination of grade crossings; in the extension and enlargement of the successful work of the Civilian Conservation Corps; in non-Federal works, mostly self-liquidating and highly useful to local divisions of Government; and on many other projects which the Nation needs and cannot afford to neglect.
​


The people FDR's quote referred to was the able-bodied, able-minded people who want to work, but couldn't find employment. Like most people they prefer to earn a livelihood, to use their skills, to better their lives through their labors ... if only they could find a job. So what does FDR do? He uses the power of the federal government to create the jobs. He implements on gigantic stimulus package to provide people employment so they aren't simply accepting government relief.

Thanks Robert, for helping me prove that the government can and has played a big role in providing economic stimulus during hard times, and is instrumental in seeing that the people's needs are met.

The fallacy of the visible as versus the invisible -- the extending of what should have been a short lived recession to the Greatest Depression in US history caused in large part by the very socialist programs put in place by FDR.
 
Last edited:
Thanks Robert, for helping me prove that the government can and has played a big role in providing economic stimulus during hard times, and is instrumental in seeing that the people's needs are met.
Thank you. :) Knowing what I do know about FDR I assumed there was more to the story but was too lazy to find out. Now I know.
 
The fallacy of the visible as versus the invisible -- the extending of what should have been a short lived recession to the Greatest Depression in US history caused in large part by the very socialist programs put in place by first Hoover and then FDR.
And we would falsify your claim by......?

Aren't assertions easy? You just say what you want and its true.
 
ftfy

Are you a complete ignoramus on world trade? Do you know where the goods we ship to the world come from? Mainland China. And are you aware that the Chinese ports in Shenzhen (ports of Shekour, Yantian, Chiwan, and Da Shan Bay) now ship more of those goods than Hong Kong does?

Hong Kong exists because of its prime natural resource. One of the best deepwater ports in the world. And it exists today with:

Socialized Medicine
CSSA grants - not unemployment insurance but abject WELFARE!!!
No actual DEMOCRACY
By law, workers are allowed 2 sick days per month!!
Controlled Currency - the HK$ is pegged to the USD.

That DEMOCRACY one is interesting - under the ebil commies Hong Kong now has more sufferage than it did under the benevolent British. Further, we have a very active civil courts system and more regulation of business than any of you freemen wannabes would ever admit to.

All that means Hong Kong is not communist. Nor is communist China anymore communist which you should very well know. The commies have learned their lesson. If you want to learn all about Communism, Marxism, Socialism, come to America and visit our "Great Universities" or our mainstream media.
 
All that means Hong Kong is not communist. Nor is communist China anymore communist which you should very well know. The commies have learned their lesson. If you want to learn all about Communism, Marxism, Socialism, come to America and visit our "Great Universities" or our mainstream media.

Want to prove any of those to be communist?
Would that be the media paid for by advertising revenue and sponsorship?
 
The fallacy of the visible as versus the invisible -- the extending of what should have been a short lived recession to the Greatest Depression in US history caused in large part by the very socialist programs put in place by FDR.


The really funny thing is that you'd try to use FDR to prove your point, but when context is provided that refutes your point, then you disavow FDR.

That sir, is cherry picking at it's finest. Or just bad research. Maybe both.

And feel free to provide evidence that the Great Depression should have been a short-lived recession but for the "socialist" programs of FDR. Talk about invisible ... your evidence is nowhere to be found.
 
Last edited:
The really funny thing is that you'd try to use FDR to prove your point, but when context is provided that refutes your point, then you disavow FDR.

That sir, is cherry picking at it's finest. Or just bad research. Maybe both.

And feel free to provide evidence that the Great Depression should have been a short-lived recession but for the "socialist" programs of FDR. Talk about invisible ... your evidence is nowhere to be found.

The evidence is to be found in books. Do you read books? Then read "America's Great Depression" by F. Murray Rothbard.
 
The really funny thing is that you'd try to use FDR to prove your point, but when context is provided that refutes your point, then you disavow FDR.

That sir, is cherry picking at it's finest. Or just bad research. Maybe both.

And feel free to provide evidence that the Great Depression should have been a short-lived recession but for the "socialist" programs of FDR. Talk about invisible ... your evidence is nowhere to be found.

The evidence is to be found in books. Do you read books? Then read "America's Great Depression" by F. Murray Rothbard.
Books are all well and good but that's just a dodge. Your quote, given the context it was made in, doesn't support anything you are suggesting.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom