Lily the Muppet Loves Free Food

Argument by anecdote? But it was the original poster who cited the Mayflower Compact as a successful socialist model. Nor was the potato famine in Ireland a failure of capitalism, but rather a failure government intervention -- socialist intervention.

What Caused the Irish Potato Famine?
Mises Daily: Tuesday, May 20, 2008 by Mark Thornton


"...In fact, the most glaring cause of the famine was not a plant disease, but England's long-running political hegemony over Ireland. The English conquered Ireland, several times, and took ownership of vast agricultural territory. Large chunks of land were given to Englishmen..."

"...Far from allowing the market to work, England launched a massive program of government intervention, consisting mainly of building workhouses, most completed just prior to the onset of the Famine..."

"...Ireland was swept away by the economic forces that emanated from one of the most powerful and aggressive states the world had ever known. It suffered not from a fungus (which English scientists insisted was just excessive dampness) but from conquest, theft, bondage, protectionism, government welfare, public works, and inflation..."

http://mises.org/daily/2978

robert, there were potatoes grown in ireland during the famine, but they all went to the english, leaving the irish nought to eat.
that has ZERO to do with socialism.
that's just plain old imperialism, which is a lot more closely allied with capitalism than socialism.
 
UTTER. TOTAL. MONUMENTAL. FAIL.

Robert, it was already pointed out to you are quoting studies done before Welfare was reformed in 1996. Please note at the bottom of your linked article the line ... This article originally appeared in the November/December 1995 edition of Cato Policy Report.

How is it possible that you don't know welfare was fundamentally changed 16 years ago? Are you ignorant? Are you a liar? Are you a troll? Can you read? More importantly, can you comprehend what you read?

Please try to read and comprehend this. The following are excerpts from the Cato Institute Paper No.435 from May 7, 2002 ...


Welfare Reform That Works Explaining the Welfare Caseload Decline, 1996–2000

Perhaps the single biggest success of welfare reform has been the significant reduction in case- loads. Since passage of the Personal Responsibility and Work Opportunity Act of 1996, the number of people receiving federal cash welfare payments has dropped by roughly 58 percent. Moreover, that reduction in caseload has been accomplished without causing undue hardship for former wel- fare recipients. Indeed, poverty rates, including the childhood poverty rate, have declined along with welfare caseloads.

Welfare reform has been effective at reducing dependence on welfare, reducing poverty, and low- ering the rate of out-of-wedlock births.
​


Did you see that part: Personal Responsibility and Work Opportunity Act of 1996? I bolded it, underlined and highlighted it just for you. If I could make it blink, I would have. In 1996 Welfare fundamentally changed. So it's nuts to quote figures from before that. It makes no sense. But that's the world that Robert Prey inhabits: 16 years behind the times and clueless to what's happening in today's world.

Oh. And Happy Holidays.

The Cato piece is dated, but total welfare payouts are undoubtedly even higher today if you count unemployment benefits extended ad infinitum, paid for with other people's money just like traditional welfare, plus Pell Grants, WIC payments, Sec. 8 subsidies and the fact that fully one sixth of Americans today are on food stamps (snap). And that's just counting those who receive payments legally. So once again, it's a situation where figures don't lie, but liars figure. The national average unemployment benefit payment per week is $293.00.

http://www.ehow.com/info_7755556_average-unemployment-benefits.html
 
Last edited:
The Cato piece is dated, but total welfare payouts are undoubtedly even higher today if you count unemployment benefits extended ad infinitum, paid for with other people's money just like traditional welfare, plus Pell Grants, WIC payments, Sec. 8 subsidies and the fact that fully one sixth of Americans today are on food stamps (snap). And that's just counting those who receive payments legally. So once again, it's a situation where figures don't lie, but liars figure.
"Snap"? Heaven forbid that we help people. But your figures don't really tell us much. So we reduce the suffering of people? It's good for society. Being able to exploit people doesn't make for a good society.
 
That's one of the stupidest things you've ever said, though I admit the competition is pretty stiff. Capitalism does not create arable land. Capitalism does not create underground oil. Capitalism does not create mineral resources. When countries have those things, capitalism is a good way to make sure they are used efficiently, but if they don't have them, it doesn't matter if you burn Karl Marx in effigy, you're still going to be poor and hungry.

Arable land? Oil?, minerals? Hong kong has none of these, but Hong Kong does have one thing the Pilgrims under the original Mayflower Compact did not have -- free enterprise capitalism. Until the Pilgrims saw the failings of socialism and changed their ways. Then people stopped starving and resources were developed.
 
Arable land? Oil?, minerals? Hong kong has none of these, but Hong Kong does have one thing the Pilgrims under the original Mayflower Compact did not have -- free enterprise capitalism. Until the Pilgrims saw the failings of socialism and changed their ways. Then people stopped starving and resources were developed.
(emphasis mine) The native Americans seemed to do just fine with socialism. Regardless, I don't give a damn either way. It's an anecdote. Yes, I realize you didn't bring up the anecdote. In the end it doesn't matter. We have a lot of history to draw on. Capitalism is a good economic engine but it has a lot of problems. It needs regulation and oversight. The problem with that is that it can be too regulated or the regulations can be poorly written. Further, govt can use regulations to further political purposes.

Bottom line we need to stop dogmatically buying into simplistic notions like capitalism is self regulating because of the invisible hand. People who run business are just as corruptible as people who run govt. People can and will work to gain the upper hand to get rid of the invisible hand.
 
Arable land? Oil?, minerals? Hong kong has none of these, but Hong Kong does have one thing the Pilgrims under the original Mayflower Compact did not have -- free enterprise capitalism. a natural port to the biggest markets in the world.
By the way, Hong Kong is doing just fine under Communism too.

Until the Pilgrims saw the failings of socialism and changed their ways. Then people stopped starving and resources were developed.
You mean until the Pilgrims got enough land cleared to start having reliable crops. If not for the socialistic Mayflower Pact, many would have died in the first winter. That is what I'm saying about different systems working under different situations.

(But you need to study your history. The Pilgrims stayed very socialistic. It was important of them that they keep their numbers steady, and to do that, they had to share.)
 
Last edited:
Arable land? Oil?, minerals? Hong kong has none of these, but Hong Kong does have one thing the Pilgrims under the original Mayflower Compact did not have -- free enterprise capitalism.
It also had a sea port where merchants from all countries could do business. Had the Chinese decided not to trade with them, the capitalists would have had no markets, nor could they have made anything profitably.
 
It also had a sea port where merchants from all countries could do business. Had the Chinese decided not to trade with them, the capitalists would have had no markets, nor could they have made anything profitably.

Nonsense. The entire world trades with Hong Kong, a city that has no natural resources but does have economic freedom to a degree much higher than that of the US.
 
By the way, Hong Kong is doing just fine under Communism too.


You mean until the Pilgrims got enough land cleared to start having reliable crops. If not for the socialistic Mayflower Pact, many would have died in the first winter. That is what I'm saying about different systems working under different situations.

(But you need to study your history. The Pilgrims stayed very socialistic. It was important of them that they keep their numbers steady, and to do that, they had to share.)

Governor Bradford's history seems to refute that:

"The experience that was had in this commone course and condition, tired sundrie years, and that amongst godly and sober men, may well evince the vanitie of that conceite of Platos and other ancients, applauded by some of later times; --that the taking away of propertie, and bringing in communitie into a comone wealth would make them happy and florishing; as if they were wiser than God. For this comunitie (so farr as it was) was found to breed much confusion and discontente, and retard much imployment that would have been to their benefite and comforte. For the yong-men that were most able and fitte for labour and service did repine that they should spend their time and streingth to worke for other mens wives and children, with out any recompense... "

"...By this time harvest was come, and instead of famine, now God gave them plentie, and the face of things was changed, to the rejoysing of the harts of many, for which they blessed God. And in the effect of their perticular planting was well seene, for all had, one way and other, pretty well to bring the year aboute, and some of the abler sorte and more industrious had to spare, and sell to others, 50 as any generall wante of famine hath not been amongest them since to this day."

Source: William Bradford, History of Plymouth Plantation, 1620-1647
 
"Snap"? Heaven forbid that we help people. But your figures don't really tell us much. So we reduce the suffering of people? It's good for society. Being able to exploit people doesn't make for a good society.

Prior to 1964 there were no food stamps. And nobody starved.

"Continued dependence" upon welfare, "induces a spiritual disintegration fundamentally destructive to the national fiber. To dole our relief in this way is to administer a narcotic, a subtle destroyer of the human spirit."
-- FDR
 
Prior to 1964 there were no food stamps. And nobody starved.
********. Actual causes of death among older people may have varied, but poor nutrition was a frequnet secondary or primary cause.

A lot of children wound up malnourished and mentally impaired as well.

"Continued dependence" upon welfare, "induces a spiritual disintegration fundamentally destructive to the national fiber. To dole our relief in this way is to administer a narcotic, a subtle destroyer of the human spirit."
-- FDR

Which is why he wanted to build infrastructure that would stimulate ecconomic growth and provide such regulations as would keep all the national treasure from flowing into the money vaults of a few non-productive jerks like the ones who tanked the ecconomy.
 
Prior to 1964 there were no food stamps. And nobody starved.

"Continued dependence" upon welfare, "induces a spiritual disintegration fundamentally destructive to the national fiber. To dole our relief in this way is to administer a narcotic, a subtle destroyer of the human spirit."
-- FDR

Tell that to my dad who still suffers from numerous physical conditions caused by constant malnutrition while he was a child back in the glorious 50's.
 
Nonsense. The entire world trades with Hong Kong, a city that has no natural resources but does have economic freedom to a degree much higher than that of the US.
If Hong Kong has no natural resources, exactly what does it trade?

Don't be ridiculous. A deep-water port with access to many markets IS a resource. You can bet they don't let ships dock there for free.
 
Nonsense. The entire world trades with Hong Kong China, which allows its goods to transit Hong Kong because it suits them to do so a city that has no natural resources but does have economic freedom to a degree much higher than that of the US.

ftfy

Are you a complete ignoramus on world trade? Do you know where the goods we ship to the world come from? Mainland China. And are you aware that the Chinese ports in Shenzhen (ports of Shekour, Yantian, Chiwan, and Da Shan Bay) now ship more of those goods than Hong Kong does?

Hong Kong exists because of its prime natural resource. One of the best deepwater ports in the world. And it exists today with:

Socialized Medicine
CSSA grants - not unemployment insurance but abject WELFARE!!!
No actual DEMOCRACY
By law, workers are allowed 2 sick days per month!!
Controlled Currency - the HK$ is pegged to the USD.

That DEMOCRACY one is interesting - under the ebil commies Hong Kong now has more sufferage than it did under the benevolent British. Further, we have a very active civil courts system and more regulation of business than any of you freemen wannabes would ever admit to.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom