Lily the Muppet Loves Free Food

For every "evil" capitalist, you can find an "evil" socialist. Chavez comes to mind.
Weak example. I cannot see where anything he has done is evil. I do know of evils worked against him by Bush the Lesser.

I'm not a fan of the GOP's current positions. But I know a lot of Republicans who are not like the current leadership of the GOP. They are not all "loyal to the party" and will vote for whoever the best candidate is, (which is why Obama is likely to win the next election).

I would feel a lot more forgiving of the party if those people would rise up and run Grover and the Koch roaches and the people who have signed away their nads to them out of town and put up some candidates who are actually grown up enough to take on the responsibility of governing.
 
Please start another thread if you want to discuss Communism. This thread's divorced from reality enough as it is:covereyes.

If only we could make an experiment how productive capital is without labor...
Oh wait!
This experiment has been made, and quite frequently too!
It even has it's own name: Strike.
In a strike labor goes away, and capital stays.
And Tada: Suddenly nothing gets produced anymore.
 
If only we could make an experiment how productive capital is without labor...
Oh wait!
This experiment has been made, and quite frequently too!
It even has it's own name: Strike.
In a strike labor goes away, and capital stays.
And Tada: Suddenly nothing gets produced anymore.

Except in Right to Work states. And the capital and labor follow.
 
Capitalism works great when there is an abundance of resources. Socialism works great when there is a scarcity of resources. Neither is an all-purpose tool. Don't try to force them to be. Use the tool that best fits the job.

(BTW, the first legal document in the US was the Mayflower Compact, which is purely socialistic. It was more important to keep the whole colony alive than to make sure people could get rich.)

Capitalism works great because it creates and abundance of resources. Socialism fails because it creates a scarcity of resources.

And the Mayflower Compact was a proven socialistic failure -- an extremely important lesson in American History and the validity of Free Market Capitalism which the Government Schools in America fail to teach:

Mayflower Compact, The Puritans Experiment with Socialism


"...The theory of using a common-stock for the profitable operation of colonies was an accepted practice of the day, in spite of repeated failures due to human nature. The failure of this collective system was as evident in Plymouth as it was in other colonies where it had been used. Young unmarried men objected to having the fruits of their toil go to support other men’s wives and children. Married men disliked having their wives sew, cook, and wash for the others. Hard-working men thought it unfair that they should support the more idle or incapable. The older men, or those of the better class, declined to work for the younger or meaner. Because of severe famine in 1623, the colonists decided to set aside their collective agreement and allow everyone to raise their own food. The immediate result was a greatly increased production, so that many had a surplus and trading began among themselves, with corn as currency."


"...Seeing the failure of communal farming, the colony instituted a free enterprise system. Each colonist was given ownership to one acre of land and each colonist was challenged to better themselves and their land by working to their fullest capacity. The colony began to flourish. Many Christian historians and economists point to this fundamental economic change as one of the key reasons for the success of the Pilgrims at Plymouth."


http://goodnewstucson.wordpress.com...mpact-the-puritans-experiment-with-socialism/
 
Socialism fails because it creates a scarcity of resources.
This is a religious belief that little basis in fact. Socialism worked for thousands of years for hunter gatherers. It doesn't work so well for large groups.

Capitalism works great because it creates and abundance of resources.
Not necessarily and Laissez-faire capitalism typically creates unnecessary inequality. We have evidence that well regulated capitalism coupled with some degree of govt provided services and/or even some govt run businesses provide the most good for the most people. This results in rich people, healthy citizens and good societies.

Human Development Index
 
Welfare Pays Better Than Work, Study Finds

http://www.cato.org/research/pr-nd-st.html
Oddly enough people still work. Even in nations like Norway and Denmark with very high levels of taxation and social safety nets people want more than welfare can provide.

That said, my wife and I lost our jobs. We lost our health insurance. We lost our home, we went on food stamps and lived two years in hell. It's nothing most people even want to be in. I WANT MY JOB BACK. I WANT MY LIFE BACK.

I'm so sick of this religious devotion to social Darwinism.
 
So anybody else slightly confused how Robert wants, on the one hand, to give emploers the right to reduce the rate of pay as far as they like. Making people who have to work for any given employer as poor as the employer whims, while also complaining the poor are unproductive?

What he wants are Serfs, and what hopes to be is rich enough for them to toil and make him money so he can be "productive" himself.
 
So anybody else slightly confused how Robert wants, on the one hand, to give emploers the right to reduce the rate of pay as far as they like. Making people who have to work for any given employer as poor as the employer whims, while also complaining the poor are unproductive?

What he wants are Serfs, and what hopes to be is rich enough for them to toil and make him money so he can be "productive" himself.
It's just a lot of perspective.

When I was a conservative I believed that the best outcome for the most people required some sort of social Darwinism. And here lies the problem. Like creationism, for many people, conservationism is more about criticizing govt and social services than it is about viable economics.

  • "Something for nothing" is what many if not most people want but we ought to do everything in our power to stop such a pernicious practice.
  • Govt is inherently inefficient and corruptible.
  • Govt cannot create wealth.
  • Govt cannot create jobs.
  • Pointing to flaws in capitalism like inequality is to engage in class warfare and to use the "good" of the rich (self sufficiency, thrift, hard work, risk, etc.) against them.
  • Govt can only take (steal) from the "good" and decent people who do create wealth and then give that wealth to lazy malcontents.
  • Communism is per se evil and resulted in the death of 100 million and the languishing in prison of about as many.
  • Socialism is communism except when it isn't.
  • All govt programs are socialist except when they are not (like the military).
  • Freedom can only exist to the extent that people are allowed to keep the fruits of their labor (as if the poor can't be exploited and the fruits of their labor easily negotiated to near nothing if the the supply for labor is high).
There's more but I'm getting nauseated. Literally. Because of surgery I can't stay out of bed for long.
 
Last edited:
Capitalism works great because it creates and abundance of resources. Socialism fails because it creates a scarcity of resources.
That's one of the stupidest things you've ever said, though I admit the competition is pretty stiff. Capitalism does not create arable land. Capitalism does not create underground oil. Capitalism does not create mineral resources. When countries have those things, capitalism is a good way to make sure they are used efficiently, but if they don't have them, it doesn't matter if you burn Karl Marx in effigy, you're still going to be poor and hungry.
 
Welfare Pays Better Than Work, Study Finds

http://www.cato.org/research/pr-nd-st.html


UTTER. TOTAL. MONUMENTAL. FAIL.

Robert, it was already pointed out to you are quoting studies done before Welfare was reformed in 1996. Please note at the bottom of your linked article the line ... This article originally appeared in the November/December 1995 edition of Cato Policy Report.

How is it possible that you don't know welfare was fundamentally changed 16 years ago? Are you ignorant? Are you a liar? Are you a troll? Can you read? More importantly, can you comprehend what you read?

Please try to read and comprehend this. The following are excerpts from the Cato Institute Paper No.435 from May 7, 2002 ...


Welfare Reform That Works Explaining the Welfare Caseload Decline, 1996–2000

Perhaps the single biggest success of welfare reform has been the significant reduction in case- loads. Since passage of the Personal Responsibility and Work Opportunity Act of 1996, the number of people receiving federal cash welfare payments has dropped by roughly 58 percent. Moreover, that reduction in caseload has been accomplished without causing undue hardship for former wel- fare recipients. Indeed, poverty rates, including the childhood poverty rate, have declined along with welfare caseloads.

Welfare reform has been effective at reducing dependence on welfare, reducing poverty, and low- ering the rate of out-of-wedlock births.
​


Did you see that part: Personal Responsibility and Work Opportunity Act of 1996? I bolded it, underlined and highlighted it just for you. If I could make it blink, I would have. In 1996 Welfare fundamentally changed. So it's nuts to quote figures from before that. It makes no sense. But that's the world that Robert Prey inhabits: 16 years behind the times and clueless to what's happening in today's world.

Oh. And Happy Holidays.
 
Last edited:
I love capitalism. I really do. IMO, it's done more for the advancement of the human species than just about anything. I'm no fan of anarchy and seriously doubt it has any real world applications for societies as large as most western industrial ones.

That said, I've read the OP as bikerdruid suggests. While I don't agree with the points you are responding to, and while I don't advocate communism, given the OP I can only say that A.) a discussion of communism is entirely consistent with the OP. B.) the OP is a tired straw man to create a false dichotomy simply for political purposes. C.) to the extent that the thread is divorced from reality it is, IMO, due to some misbegotten notions of social Darwinism or some fear of govt funded/ran/regulated, etc., services.
Mea culpa. There's been so much talk of far-right capitalism that I forgot the thread's origin.

Welfare Pays Better Than Work, Study Finds

http://www.cato.org/research/pr-nd-st.html
Non-sequitur. It doesn't follow that just because something pays better, it becomes a desirable option. Sitting in a wheelchair is more comfortable than walking, yet I don't see people going out of their way to buy them.

It's been pointed out to you, repeatedly, that people do not want to be on welfare. We're human beings. We desire a feeling of being successful, of being as functional and contributing as everyone else. That is why people throw away crutches when their legs get better. It's why people don't like taking pills. It's why kids don't stick with training wheels for bicycles.

It's also why people don't want to remain on welfare.

I don't know if this has been brought up, but I find it an interesting paradox that being on welfare is so tempting and desirable to people... yet none of them seem to be willing to quit their current job and going over to receiving handouts. Funny, that.

And the Mayflower Compact was a proven socialistic failure -- an extremely important lesson in American History and the validity of Free Market Capitalism which the Government Schools in America fail to teach:
Argument by anecdote. I can give similar examples of capitalism having disastrous results. The potato famine in Ireland comes to mind.

People: Help! We're going to starve!'
Authority figure: Nobody lift a finger, the invisible hand of the market will take care of this.
:people start to die:
Authority figure: Wait for it...
:lots of people die:
Authority figure: Any time now...
:millions die:
Authorities: Whoops.
 
Last edited:
Erm, you realise the money Robin Hood stole was the taxes he considered to be unfair, taken by force from Serfs? Who were, by the very definition of being the men and women who produced for the free classes, productive?

Right-wingers are trying to rewrite the Bible to suit their politics. Why not spread out to other stories?
 
....

The potato famine in Ireland comes to mind.

People: Help! We're going to starve!'
Authority figure: Nobody lift a finger, the invisible hand of the market will take care of this.
: people start to die:
Authority figure: Wait for it...
:lots of people die:
Authority figure: Any time now...
:millions die:
Authorities: Whoops.
Let us know when that becomes reality in the US. I can see it happening after, say, an EMP attack loss of electricity, biowarefare megadeaths, or asteroid impact/supervolcano eruption.

Given any of those we will be under martial law for months, maybe years; I suspect starvation would be a problem that even socialism doesn't fix.
 
Mea culpa. There's been so much talk of far-right capitalism that I forgot the thread's origin.

Non-sequitur. It doesn't follow that just because something pays better, it becomes a desirable option. Sitting in a wheelchair is more comfortable than walking, yet I don't see people going out of their way to buy them.

It's been pointed out to you, repeatedly, that people do not want to be on welfare. We're human beings. We desire a feeling of being successful, of being as functional and contributing as everyone else. That is why people throw away crutches when their legs get better. It's why people don't like taking pills. It's why kids don't stick with training wheels for bicycles.

It's also why people don't want to remain on welfare.

I don't know if this has been brought up, but I find it an interesting paradox that being on welfare is so tempting and desirable to people... yet none of them seem to be willing to quit their current job and going over to receiving handouts. Funny, that.

Argument by anecdote. I can give similar examples of capitalism having disastrous results. The potato famine in Ireland comes to mind.

People: Help! We're going to starve!'
Authority figure: Nobody lift a finger, the invisible hand of the market will take care of this.
:people start to die:
Authority figure: Wait for it...
:lots of people die:
Authority figure: Any time now...
:millions die:
Authorities: Whoops.

Argument by anecdote? But it was the original poster who cited the Mayflower Compact as a successful socialist model. Nor was the potato famine in Ireland a failure of capitalism, but rather a failure government intervention -- socialist intervention.

What Caused the Irish Potato Famine?
Mises Daily: Tuesday, May 20, 2008 by Mark Thornton


"...In fact, the most glaring cause of the famine was not a plant disease, but England's long-running political hegemony over Ireland. The English conquered Ireland, several times, and took ownership of vast agricultural territory. Large chunks of land were given to Englishmen..."

"...Far from allowing the market to work, England launched a massive program of government intervention, consisting mainly of building workhouses, most completed just prior to the onset of the Famine..."

"...Ireland was swept away by the economic forces that emanated from one of the most powerful and aggressive states the world had ever known. It suffered not from a fungus (which English scientists insisted was just excessive dampness) but from conquest, theft, bondage, protectionism, government welfare, public works, and inflation..."

http://mises.org/daily/2978
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom