Lily the Muppet Loves Free Food

IMO, our scale up in manufacturing prior to and after our entry into WWII is what finally ended the depression.

That's a true statement. However, that's true with a few caveats.

1) The infrastructure support that allowed that ramp up in manufacturing was due, in a very large part, to FDR's New Deal.
2) A massive increase in spending is a stimulus, whether it's spent on military equipment or on infrastructure. The difference is that infrastructure gives back (see point 1) whereas military equipment is single purpose/time use so there it is less effective in strengthening an economy.
3) In conjunction with point 2, it's important to understand that the reason the military manufacturing ended the depression was not due to what was being manufactured but how much was being spent on manufacturing it. In other words, "a massive increase in spending is a stimulus".
 
The part about how it's OK when it is for a war where 99.9% of what is spent will become scrap, but NOT OK when you spend a fraction of that amount and the product will be dams and roads and railroads and bridges and canals and other public works projects many of which are still in daily use?
FDR left some valid infrastructure courtesy of fed expenditures but the depression continued; damn shame Obama etal have accomplished nothing similar so far other than the depression, or should I say slow-down, continues unabated and unemployment remains too high.
 
Glad to hear we are taking advantage of your politicians, although I doubt you know what anyone is actually paying $us / bbl.
 
Glad to hear we are taking advantage of your politicians, although I doubt you know what anyone is actually paying $us / bbl.

it is well documented.
actually, alberta just reduced our royalties on gas and oil prices. (january 2011)
alberta sells natural gas to you at 20% of world price, and oil at 15%, down from 25% and 20%, respectively.
 
IMO, our scale up in manufacturing prior to and after our entry into WWII is what finally ended the depression.
And without the TVA and BPA projects, we would not have been able to build half enough aircraft, so, in a sense, FDR won WWII before it started.

We also had more healthy young men to send to fight because their parents could feed them, thanks to make-work projects that actually left some odds and ends that we later found useful, like enough electricity to support an aircraft industry.
 
And without the TVA and BPA projects, we would not have been able to build half enough aircraft, so, in a sense, FDR won WWII before it started.

We also had more healthy young men to send to fight because their parents could feed them, thanks to make-work projects that actually left some odds and ends that we later found useful, like enough electricity to support an aircraft industry.

;)

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=7896929&postcount=981
 
How does one cite "voices in my head"?
like this:
"But for Canada’s oil patch, which exports more than two million barrels a day to the U.S., the $20 or more price discount that has prevailed all year amounts to $40 million a day, or about one and a quarter billion dollars a month in lost petro-dollars."

Oil currently around $100/bbl.
 
It's an article in a newspaper anyway; whether that beats 'voices in head' is another question.

And we are talking about refinery slates. Why didn't someone (like our hermit) say so?
 
How does one cite "voices in my head"?

like this:
"But for Canada’s oil patch, which exports more than two million barrels a day to the U.S., the $20 or more price discount that has prevailed all year amounts to $40 million a day, or about one and a quarter billion dollars a month in lost petro-dollars."

Oil currently around $100/bbl.

i got the numbers i quoted from cbc radio.
however, here is the alberta government site:
http://www.energy.gov.ab.ca/Oil/573.asp

it is all there.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom