Lily the Muppet Loves Free Food

Trooooollllllll. Troll in the dungeons!

Robert Prey started a thread praising Peter Popoff. He's either a troll or sufficiently loopy that we can ignore him.
 
No. My criticism of socialism is that it is by its nature authoritarian, even if tyranny of the majority and based on the Robin Hood ethos of stealing from the productive rich, in favor of the non-productive poor. On the other hand, I admire the character in "Atlas Shrugged" who is a reverse Robin Hood. He steals from the un-deserving, non-productive poor to reclaim and restore that which has been stolen from the productive rich.

Erm, you realise the money Robin Hood stole was the taxes he considered to be unfair, taken by force from Serfs? Who were, by the very definition of being the men and women who produced for the free classes, productive?

Just saying... (Oh and your criticism of socialism is now that it is authoritarian, while in other posts admiring equally authoritarian right wing policies. So the point still staands and I am no longer wondering if you are ill read in history and political science, I am absoluteley convinced you are ill read in history and political science).
 
Trooooollllllll. Troll in the dungeons!

Robert Prey started a thread praising Peter Popoff. He's either a troll or sufficiently loopy that we can ignore him.

But then he wouldn't make himself look any stupider and I wouldn't have anything to laugth at.
 
Erm, you realise the money Robin Hood stole was the taxes he considered to be unfair, taken by force from Serfs? Who were, by the very definition of being the men and women who produced for the free classes, productive?


Please ... don't bore Prey with details.

That's so left-wing of you. ;)
 
Please ... don't bore Prey with details.

That's so left-wing of you. ;)

Yes, basic facts I learned at the age of seven at primary school should not be the downfall of a grown mans discourse. And yet so foten they are with Robert. Clearly he was never ready for his teacher to arrive.
 
No. My criticism of socialism is that it is by its nature authoritarian, even if tyranny of the majority and based on the Robin Hood ethos of stealing from the productive rich, in favor of the non-productive poor. .

robert,
the rich produce NOTHING.
all capital, all production, is created by LABOUR.
the ONLY ones that produce anything are the WORKERS.
 
robert,
the rich produce NOTHING.
all capital, all production, is created by LABOUR.
the ONLY ones that produce anything are the WORKERS.
Some of the "rich" are also "workers". You can't just look at someone's bank account and determine how productive someone is. There are productive poor and productive rich people, and there are also non-productive rich and non-productive poor people.
 
Some of the "rich" are also "workers". You can't just look at someone's bank account and determine how productive someone is. There are productive poor and productive rich people, and there are also non-productive rich and non-productive poor people.


I highlighted the people Robert thinks don't exist.
 
No. My criticism of socialism is that it is by its nature authoritarian, even if tyranny of the majority
"Tyranny of the majority" being another word for a democracy:rolleyes:?

Edit: oh, didn't see this:
Democracy is, after all, best exemplified as 3 wolves and a sheep deciding by majority vote what they shall eat for dinner.
So now not only against the welfare system, but also a supporter of anarchy or dictatorship. Beautiful.

and based on the Robin Hood ethos of stealing from the productive rich, in favor of the non-productive poor. .
Sigh... as the Norse idiom goes, in one ear, out the other... this is hopeless.

robert,
the rich produce NOTHING.
all capital, all production, is created by LABOUR.
the ONLY ones that produce anything are the WORKERS.
Please start another thread if you want to discuss Communism. This thread's divorced from reality enough as it is:covereyes.
 
Last edited:
Wow. Talk about naivete. Many single women have babies because Uncle Sugar pays her to have babies.

In your world, are there unicorns?

In our world, welfare families live at or below the poverty line:

"In California,single parent with one child will get $480.00 cash and $230.00 food stamps per month. Each child about $78.00 each per month depending on what county they live in."

Yep, just so many teenagers trying to get pregnant to make those big welfare bucks.

You know, I am honestly beginning to suspect you aren't really this uninformed...
 
Please start another thread if you want to discuss Communism. This thread's divorced from reality enough as it is.
I love capitalism. I really do. IMO, it's done more for the advancement of the human species than just about anything. I'm no fan of anarchy and seriously doubt it has any real world applications for societies as large as most western industrial ones.

That said, I've read the OP as bikerdruid suggests. While I don't agree with the points you are responding to, and while I don't advocate communism, given the OP I can only say that A.) a discussion of communism is entirely consistent with the OP. B.) the OP is a tired straw man to create a false dichotomy simply for political purposes. C.) to the extent that the thread is divorced from reality it is, IMO, due to some misbegotten notions of social Darwinism or some fear of govt funded/ran/regulated, etc., services.
 
Last edited:
I love capitalism. I really do. IMO, it's done more for the advancement of the human species than just about anything. I'm no fan of anarchy and seriously doubt it has any real world applications for societies as large as most western industrial ones.

That said, I've read the OP as bikerdruid suggests. While I don't agree with the points you are responding to, and while I don't advocate communism, given the OP I can only say that A.) a discussion of communism is entirely consistent with the OP. B.) the OP is a tired straw man to create a false dichotomy simply for political purposes. C.) to the extent that the thread is divorced from reality it is, IMO, due to some misbegotten notions of social Darwinism or some fear of govt funded/ran/regulated, etc., services.

Capitalism works great when there is an abundance of resources. Socialism works great when there is a scarcity of resources. Neither is an all-purpose tool. Don't try to force them to be. Use the tool that best fits the job.

(BTW, the first legal document in the US was the Mayflower Compact, which is purely socialistic. It was more important to keep the whole colony alive than to make sure people could get rich.)
 
Last edited:
Capitalism works great when there is an abundance of resources. Socialism works great when there is a scarcity of resources. Neither is an all-purpose tool. Don't try to force them to be. Use the tool that best fits the job.

(BTW, the first legal document in the US was the Mayflower Compact, which is purely socialistic. It was more important to keep the whole colony alive than to make sure people could get rich.)
Agreed, and BTW, while I think it follows from what you said, I also think it worthy to note, we can actually use more than one tool at any given time. And not every tool that is associated with the govt is de facto communism or even de facto socialism (neither of which are de facto bad).

What particularly raises my hackles is that these discussions are often ruled by tired old propaganda cooked up during the cold war.
 
Last edited:
What particularly raises my hackles is that these discussions are often ruled by tired old propaganda cooked up during the cold war.

I know. McCarthy would have been proud to see that he left a legacy of people who think that shouting "Commie!" ought to make our capitalistic knees jerk and kick them in the butt. Stop the branding, folks (you too, Lefty) and address the issues, not your strawmen and bogymen. Neither capitalists nor socialists are inherently evil. They both want what is best for humanity. If they worked together, they might actually come closer to acheiving it.
 
Last edited:
Neither capitalists nor socialists are inherently evil.

Quite a lot of inherently evil capitalists have ascended to power in my life time. Pinochet and his fans here is a good example. Most of the last administration here were overtly evil. (Abu Ghraib.)

They both want what is best for humanity.

I do not see that in the actions of the Koch roaches or most of the GOP congress critters. If they actually wanted what is good for America, they have to be some of the most abyssmally stupid creratures to walk upright, thinking that feeding the rich helps the poor.

If they worked together, they might actually come closer to acheiving it.

The greed, pettiness, arrogance and superstition of the GOP as it now exists are an effective barrier to that.
 
Quite a lot of inherently evil capitalists have ascended to power in my life time. Pinochet and his fans here is a good example. Most of the last administration here were overtly evil. (Abu Ghraib.)
For every "evil" capitalist, you can find an "evil" socialist. Chavez comes to mind. It is not the philosophy that is evil, it is the people who abuse it to take power.

I do not see that in the actions of the Koch roaches or most of the GOP congress critters. If they actually wanted what is good for America, they have to be some of the most abyssmally stupid creratures to walk upright, thinking that feeding the rich helps the poor.
Again, you are taking example of excess to condemn the whole idea. Capitalists like Henry Ford helped America become one of the biggest success stories in the world. Capitalists like Bill Gates continue the tradition of competition being beneficial to the common man. We can find good guys and bad guys in every camp. I'd rather separate things into good and bad rather than capitalist and socialist.

The greed, pettiness, arrogance and superstition of the GOP as it now exists are an effective barrier to that.
I'm not a fan of the GOP's current positions. But I know a lot of Republicans who are not like the current leadership of the GOP. They are not all "loyal to the party" and will vote for whoever the best candidate is, (which is why Obama is likely to win the next election). I'd do (and have done) the same as those moderate Republicans, crossing party boundaries to vote for the candidates who I thought would do a better job. I think people like you are what is wrong with both parties. Your decision is made before you even listen to issues and is based purely on partisanship. You know what that makes you? Yes, a drongo.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom