lupus_in_fabula
Graduate Poster
- Joined
- Nov 10, 2006
- Messages
- 1,631
But they're not identical. The transporting person has a set of experiences that lead up to a certain point and then cease. The transported man has a set of experiences that go up to that same point, and then continue.
From a physical point of view they would be identical. To make it two, you have to apply an outside perspective. But from a personal perspective nothing but a change in scenery would have happened. The continuation of experiences would not make a difference to the process of subjective identity.
The big problem here is some form of philosophical equivocation. On one hand, we want to treat the two (original and copy) as distinct beings. On the other hand, some want to treat them as identical. Pick one and stick with it.
Seems that way. The problem seems to relate to our tendency to mix 1st and 3rd person perspectives all the time?