Life or no-life after death - Is it an Objective reality?

Fair enough. On a more polite tone: There is no contradiction. Materialism accepts that there are feelings and that they are irrational.

I don't know that feelings are irrational. Not for this or anything else. Back in our evolutionary history, and right now for that matter, teletransporters did not exist. It is entirely rational that evolution has created in us strong responses to avoid death. In fact even if prehistory had somehow equipped us with such devices I'm not clear we would have developed differently.

Therefore, a materialist can be as sure as hell that his copy will be exactly as him, but he still accepts he has feelings and doesn't want to die. No contradiction: Feelings are real and they're not precisely rational. This statement is supported by materialism in the same way that the "copies" hypothesis is accepted.

The feeling that something subjective is going to be lost can be overcome in two ways, as I see it. Belief in science or Awareness. If your belief in materialism is strong you can see that, despite how it feels, nothing is being lost. If your awareness is high then you know that this "experiencing self" is anyway illusory.

But to do that out of merely proving that I believe in materialism? I don't feel the need to do something I don't want to do (kill myself) to prove a point. If that means some people want to believe that that means I don't believe in materialism, I think I can live with that. But I do wanna live.

Fair enough.

Nick
 
I don't know that feelings are irrational.

But they are. Because I can, in fact, continue not wanting to break up with a girl who I know is doing nothing but hurting me, but yet I still want to be with her.

Because I could in fact be a cigarette smoker who's trying to quit, who knows all the rational reasons why I should quit, and yet I can't.

Because feelings are there, regardless of how irrational, illogical it is to feel them. And they are real. And materialism accepts them.
No contradiction.

Not for this or anything else. Back in our evolutionary history, and right now for that matter, teletransporters did not exist. It is entirely rational that evolution has created in us strong responses to avoid death. In fact even if prehistory had somehow equipped us with such devices I'm not clear we would have developed differently.

You've answered your own question then.
My inability to accept my own death even if I am 100% sure that my copy will have the same memories as I do, has its traces in evolution, which is of course supported by materialism.

The feeling that something subjective is going to be lost can be overcome in two ways, as I see it. Belief in science or Awareness.

No. I disagree. That's your personal opinion (Refer also to the "Why hate anyone" thread in which someone claims that you can just rationalize feelings such as hate and permanently eliminate them "from the root").

"Belief" in science has nothing to do with it either, and what you're suggesting sounds more like a Cult-type of brainwashing in which we try to modify our natural feelings (such as fear of death) by subjecting us to a "belief" in science as if it was a blind faith. Not too different from the Religious Terrorist who is so self deluded that he's going to heaven after he dies, that he's willing to kill himself in a terrorist act.

I think that any mindset that tries to hyptnotize the self into a feeling of "absolute certainty" (even if in fact, the clone hypothesis is true), is not a healthy mindset at all.

Normal people are afraid to die. It's a natural, instinctual feeling. And it doesn't respond to rational arguments.

If your belief in materialism is strong you can see that, despite how it feels, nothing is being lost. If your awareness is high then you know that this "experiencing self" is anyway illusory.

Nick, my belief in materialism has nothing go to do/does not enter in conflict with my personal desire to stay alive.

To give you another example: I know for certain that nothing's gonna happen to me if I go into a roller coaster or a haunted house (such as the one in NY which I hear is terrifying). I know nothing bad is ever gonna happen to me. I know this scientifically speaking. But I still don't like to go because roller coasters and haunted houses scare the living **** out of me.
No contradiction.
 
Last edited:
No. I am not saying that at all. Consciousness emerges from brain activity. Selfhood, the kind of self which appears to experience, emerges from aspects of this consciousness and is not what it appears to be. This means that, under materialism, you cannot believe that something subjective would be lost if you push the teleport button. The subjectivity, given identical location, is identical - original to copy. Absolutely nothing, subjectively, is lost.
Yup.The process is EXACTLY the same. Nothing is lost except the original.

The new process is exactly the same as the old process. I've been saying that since the very beginning.
As writers like Blackmore and Parfit have pointed out, if you uphold materialist views on consciousness you must push the teleport button. If you don't then you're creating a logical inconsistency. You're effectively saying that materialism applies to the world outside... but not to you!
No.
I'm saying that "I" don't want to cease to exist and that no matter how often you claim otherwise, this emotional response, as irrational and crazy as it can be(what if "I" die, what if the teleporter fails, what if, what if, what if) will always hesitate and resist because this "I" does not want to die.

This desire to not "die" is every bit consistent with "materialism" because it is physiological. You keep saying it is illogical. Why yes. It is. That's what emotions are, illogical, physiologic based responses evolved to protect this "illusionary" thing called the "I" that you claim does not exist.
 
But they are. Because I can, in fact, continue not wanting to break up with a girl who I know is doing nothing but hurting me, but yet I still want to be with her.

Because I could in fact be a cigarette smoker who's trying to quit, who knows all the rational reasons why I should quit, and yet I can't.

Because feelings are there, regardless of how irrational, illogical it is to feel them. And they are real. And materialism accepts them.
No contradiction.

Okay, maybe rational is not the best word. Has too many sub meanings. But, logical. Feelings are logical. Maybe there is something with this girl. A deeper line of thinking of which you're not aware, trying to become conscious. Maybe something psychological. Maybe she reminds you of someone. Maybe the situation has symbolic elements that need to be resolved. With smoking, is it perhaps not the desire to suppress a feeling that creates the urge to smoke?

I mean, I don't know. But what I see is that feelings are mostly logical. It's just that the logic isn't always immediately evident. Behaviourism daddy, is it OC Cummins, said "feelings are the executors of evolutionary will" or something similar. I think he was right. They're short cuts.


No. I disagree. That's your personal opinion (Refer also to the "Why hate anyone" thread in which someone claims that you can just rationalize feelings such as hate and permanently eliminate them "from the root").

It's not about rationalising. It's more about awareness. There are usually psychological roots in hatred, and with awareness it can often be overcome.

"Belief" in science has nothing to do with it either, and what you're suggesting sounds more like a Cult-type of brainwashing in which we try to modify our natural feelings (such as fear of death) by subjecting us to a "belief" in science as if it was a blind faith.

Well, not blind faith. There are many people who study the brain. They didn't find any little selves that were experiencing yet. If you study something enough, you can predict the outcome. You can overcome fear.

Not too different from the Religious Terrorist who is so self deluded that he's going to heaven after he dies, that he's willing to kill himself in a terrorist act.

I don't personally see that as so comparable.

I think that any mindset that tries to hyptnotize the self into a feeling of "absolute certainty" (even if in fact, the clone hypothesis is true), is not a healthy mindset at all.

Well, there aren't teletransporters yet. And if and when there are, I think it will just be how it's presented that makes the difference whether people travel or not. Same as anything. Like I said, if Scotty copied Kirk to the planet and then shot the original dead, the TV series wouldn't have lasted so long, I'll warrant. But making it look like he's moving him and it's cool.

Normal people are afraid to die. It's a natural, instinctual feeling. And it doesn't respond to rational arguments.

It can respond to rational arguments. And it can respond to awareness.

Nick, my belief in materialism has nothing go to do/does not enter in conflict with my personal desire to stay alive.

To give you another example: I know for certain that nothing's gonna happen to me if I go into a roller coaster or a haunted house (such as the one in NY which I hear is terrifying). I know nothing bad is ever gonna happen to me. I know this scientifically speaking. But I still don't like to go because roller coasters and haunted houses scare the living **** out of me.
No contradiction.

Yeah, but if you could get to say Ko Phi-Phi beach for $10 in 10ms, as opposed to $1100 round trip taking 22 hours and suffering airline food?

Nick
 
Last edited:
Okay, maybe rational is not the best word. Has too many sub meanings. But, logical. Feelings are logical. Maybe there is something with this girl. A deeper line of thinking of which you're not aware, trying to become conscious. Maybe something psychological. Maybe she reminds you of someone. Maybe the situation has symbolic elements that need to be resolved. With smoking, is it perhaps not the desire to suppress a feeling that creates the urge to smoke?

No, Nick, sorry but you're losing the point completely. The point is a feeling cannot be rationalized, even if you know it's wrong to do a certain thing that your gut still pulls you towards. Please don't try to outsmart the argument by playing around with the example I'm giving you. It's very simple: Guy is in love with this girl, but he realizes the relationship is hurting both of them. He knows this rationally but he still can't let go of her because feelings cannot be rationalized. It doesn't work that way.

I mean, I don't know. But what I see is that feelings are mostly logical. It's just that the logic isn't always immediately evident. Behaviourism daddy, is it OC Cummins, said "feelings are the executors of evolutionary will" or something similar. I think he was right. They're short cuts.

Sorry but you lost me. I don't even know what you mean by "feelings are logical". Besides, that's not what I'm arguing. What I'm arguing is that feelings cannot be rationalized intellectually. They can be worked over time through therapy and other means, but they can't be rationalized through mere logical arguments.

Yeah, but if you could get to say Ko Phi-Phi beach for $10 in 10ms, as opposed to $1100 round trip taking 22 hours and suffering airline food?

What in the BLUE HELL are you talking about, Nick?

My example about the haunted house and the roller coaster still stands: I am terrified to go into one of those haunted houses. Does that mean that I believe something is going to happen to me? Does that mean that I secretly believe in ghosts? No. I don't. I'm still scared because I have a knee-jerk reaction in my emotions when I see something scary. No contradiction.

No contradiction, Nick.
 
Last edited:
No, Nick, sorry but you're losing the point completely. The point is a feeling cannot be rationalized, even if you know it's wrong to do a certain thing that your gut still pulls you towards.

I agree. That is why I said that "rational" is not the best word to use, because it has too many connotations. But feelings do still have an inner logic. They exert a pull and it is not totally irrational.


Please don't try to outsmart the argument by playing around with the example I'm giving you. It's very simple: Guy is in love with this girl, but he realizes the relationship is hurting both of them. He knows this rationally but he still can't let go of her because feelings cannot be rationalized. It doesn't work that way.

I am not saying that feelings can or should be rationalised away. But just because something appears irrational does not mean that it is happening without logic.

So, there is pain, and rationally it appears that it would be good not to have pain. But there is also something else. What is it about? Is there awareness? Is it clear for both parties why there is this attraction that leads to pain? Just because there is pain does not mean that there is inevitably not logic.

Feelings developed through evolution, same as everything else. They are there for a reason. Sometimes that reason is not consciously accessible. Sometimes it is and they're still a drag, but there is still logic. They don't just come randomly.


Sorry but you lost me. I don't even know what you mean by "feelings are logical". Besides, that's not what I'm arguing. What I'm arguing is that feelings cannot be rationalized intellectually. They can be worked over time through therapy and other means, but they can't be rationalized through mere logical arguments.

Well, feelings can be rationalised intellectually. That is an option. But the end result is that you end up disconnected from them, and "in your head." A better option imo would be to self-examine, to express the emotions and move towards greater self-awareness.


What in the BLUE HELL are you talking about, Nick?

Sorry, I thought it would be obvious. You are scared about the haunted house and the fairground ride, but there is not so much incentive to go there. So, for sure, why not stay scared?

With the teleporter, I mean, it could be useful. A balance will inevitably be set up in the mind. What do you get from haunted house or roller coaster? Not so much. But teleporter? You could travel the world in zero time, maybe very cheap. It clearly has commercial possibilities, should it ever be developed. Big time.

So, like I say, a balance will be set up in the mind - pros vs cons. OK, I will have to drop my illusory notion of persisting selfhood, but then again I will get dirt cheap travel planet-wide. I mean, it's not necessarily all bad.

Nick
 
Last edited:
Yup.The process is EXACTLY the same. Nothing is lost except the original.

The original exists only when viewed from outside. It is objective. We're talking subjective here. Nothing is lost.

No.
I'm saying that "I" don't want to cease to exist

"I" does not have any persisting existence anyway. There is merely the belief that it does. And this will be recreated!

and that no matter how often you claim otherwise, this emotional response, as irrational and crazy as it can be(what if "I" die, what if the teleporter fails, what if, what if, what if) will always hesitate and resist because this "I" does not want to die.

It's not irrational and it's not crazy, but it can be overcome by awareness or by logic.

This desire to not "die" is every bit consistent with "materialism" because it is physiological. You keep saying it is illogical.

No I don't. I'm saying it can be overcome by logic, it can be overcome by awareness. It's totally logical to resist death.

Nick
 
Why not just put your hands over your eyes and refuse to look? That would at least be more honest.



No, it doesn't. That's correct. But it does deny that there is a self which experiences this consciousness. Therefore the question you keep asking is invalid under materialism.

You seem to think that if the teletransporter malfunctioned and we ended up with 2 Belzes that somehow "you" would be receiving inputs from two separate sensory systems. But this cannot happen according to materialism, because the whole notion of there being a self which could do such a thing is illusory.

Nick

Who's typing on your keyboard?
 
I don't know that feelings are irrational. Not for this or anything else. Back in our evolutionary history, and right now for that matter, teletransporters did not exist. It is entirely rational that evolution has created in us strong responses to avoid death. In fact even if prehistory had somehow equipped us with such devices I'm not clear we would have developed differently.



The feeling that something subjective is going to be lost can be overcome in two ways, as I see it. Belief in science or Awareness. If your belief in materialism is strong you can see that, despite how it feels, nothing is being lost. If your awareness is high then you know that this "experiencing self" is anyway illusory.


Fair enough.

Nick

Do you have this strong belief and high awareness?
 
I have one comment to make on this, I was certainly not alive before I was born, so whatever state I was in before I was born is the exact same state I will be in after I die, so that gives way to a logical reasoning that there is a possibility that I will be of some sort of consciousness again.

As an atheist, this is my only argument for a logical process of reincarnation. If anyone can discharge this idea I will gladly accept it. There is no reason one's personal beliefs should get in the way of reality.
 
Why not just put your hands over your eyes and refuse to look? That would at least be more honest.

Improving your reading skills would help, Nick. I'm saying that I don't care much for materialism. Science is not about the "stuff" of reality, but how it works: its function.

No, it doesn't. That's correct.

Thank you. Your argument has been falsified.

But it does deny that there is a self which experiences this consciousness.

It does ? I must've missed the last decree on that. How do you define "self", and how does "materialism" "deny" that ?

Therefore the question you keep asking is invalid under materialism.

The **** materialism, and answer under REALISM.

You seem to think that if the teletransporter malfunctioned and we ended up with 2 Belzes that somehow "you" would be receiving inputs from two separate sensory systems.

What I think is irrelevant, because I am asking YOU. But for the sake of moving the discussion forward: NO, I specifically SAID that you wouldn't, and this is why you are wrong about continuity of "self" when the teleporter DOES work.
 
My inability to accept my own death even if I am 100% sure that my copy will have the same memories as I do, has its traces in evolution, which is of course supported by materialism.

Not only that: I don't see why I should be glad to die just because some clone of me has been manufactured. I kinda like my "illusion" of "self", thank you very much.
 
The original exists only when viewed from outside. It is objective. We're talking subjective here. Nothing is lost.

How can you simultaneously claim that consciousness is not shared between Belz1 and 2, and then claim that nothing is lost when Belz1 is destroyed ? If I have two identical apples, and I eat one, don't I lose that apple ?

And another thing: subjectivity exists. And in the teleporter case, it is LOST.
 
What I think is irrelevant, because I am asking YOU. But for the sake of moving the discussion forward: NO, I specifically SAID that you wouldn't, and this is why you are wrong about continuity of "self" when the teleporter DOES work.

Belz,

There is no continuity of experiencing self anyway. This is the whole point. The body is relatively continuous, but the purely subjective state has no actual owner.

The illusion is.... if I push the teleport button so I will not experience what Me#2 is experiencing. It's great for Me#2 but what about Me#1 - I'm dead!? (This is the illusion)

The reality is... there is not an experiencing self anyway. It is illusory.

Nick
 
Last edited:
Sorry, I thought it would be obvious. You are scared about the haunted house and the fairground ride, but there is not so much incentive to go there. So, for sure, why not stay scared?

If I refuse to go into the haunted house, any person can claim "Ahhh.... so that means you secretly do believe that there are ghosts and that something will happen to you"

The claim you make applies in the same way to this example: It's actually not true that the reason I don't wanna go into the haunted house is because I secretly believe in ghosts. The reason is that regardless of how certain I am that there are no ghosts, I still have a knee-jerk fear reaction to scary things. No contradiction.

It's not true that the reason I don't wanna kill myself and be replaced by another copy that I secretly fear that "something is lost". I just don't want to go through the experience of dying. I have a fear of death like any other living creature. Both the statement that "nothing is lost" and the statement that "Still though, we have irrational feelings that we abide by" are accepted by materialism. No contradiction.
 
The original exists only when viewed from outside. It is objective. We're talking subjective here. Nothing is lost.
So the original actually ceases to exist objectively but does not matter subjectively.

Yeah...that's essentially what I said, it still doesn't change the fact that the original is gone.
 
If I refuse to go into the haunted house, any person can claim "Ahhh.... so that means you secretly do believe that there are ghosts and that something will happen to you"

Sure. As I see it you also don't have so much incentive.

The claim you make applies in the same way to this example: It's actually not true that the reason I don't wanna go into the haunted house is because I secretly believe in ghosts. The reason is that regardless of how certain I am that there are no ghosts, I still have a knee-jerk fear reaction to scary things. No contradiction.

Well, if I look at myself in this kind of situation, I would say that it is rather that I am scared of the unknown. Creepy house, middle of the night, strange noise from the cellar - do I go down there? No, not unless there's a big incentive, and ideally some kind of weaponry.

It's not true that the reason I don't wanna kill myself and be replaced by another copy that I secretly fear that "something is lost". I just don't want to go through the experience of dying.

Well, you won't go through it. It will be instantaneous. So, assuming you don't believe in corridors with a light at the end of them or whatever, one body will cease to be and that's it.

I have a fear of death like any other living creature. Both the statement that "nothing is lost" and the statement that "Still though, we have irrational feelings that we abide by" are accepted by materialism. No contradiction.

Well, as I've said, the feelings are entirely logical. However, for me the "no teleporting" position is still "talking the talk but not walking the walk" with materialism. If you really believe something, you will stand behind it.

Nick
 
So the original actually ceases to exist objectively but does not matter subjectively.

Yes, the original is gone in an instant and replaced by the copy. However, since it is instantly gone and replaced there is no subjective awareness of this. If I were instantly disintegrated 10mS ago and replaced by a copy I would not know about it.

Yeah...that's essentially what I said, it still doesn't change the fact that the original is gone.

No, doesn't change that.

Nick
 
Belz,

There is no continuity of experiencing self anyway. This is the whole point. The body is relatively continuous, but the purely subjective state has no actual owner.

The illusion is.... if I push the teleport button so I will not experience what Me#2 is experiencing. It's great for Me#2 but what about Me#1 - I'm dead!? (This is the illusion)

The reality is... there is not an experiencing self anyway. It is illusory.

Nick

Claims claims claims.

Running is not an illusion, it is a process. Why would counsciousness be any different ?

In the end, though, it's all irrelevant: the illusion is there, and I want to keep it that way.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom