Fair enough. On a more polite tone: There is no contradiction. Materialism accepts that there are feelings and that they are irrational.
I don't know that feelings are irrational. Not for this or anything else. Back in our evolutionary history, and right now for that matter, teletransporters did not exist. It is entirely rational that evolution has created in us strong responses to avoid death. In fact even if prehistory had somehow equipped us with such devices I'm not clear we would have developed differently.
Therefore, a materialist can be as sure as hell that his copy will be exactly as him, but he still accepts he has feelings and doesn't want to die. No contradiction: Feelings are real and they're not precisely rational. This statement is supported by materialism in the same way that the "copies" hypothesis is accepted.
The feeling that something subjective is going to be lost can be overcome in two ways, as I see it. Belief in science or Awareness. If your belief in materialism is strong you can see that, despite how it feels, nothing is being lost. If your awareness is high then you know that this "experiencing self" is anyway illusory.
But to do that out of merely proving that I believe in materialism? I don't feel the need to do something I don't want to do (kill myself) to prove a point. If that means some people want to believe that that means I don't believe in materialism, I think I can live with that. But I do wanna live.
Fair enough.
Nick