Journalist attacked by violent mob

Given that borders are one of the defining features of a nation, that seems rather implicit in the definition.


Except that it's still not even remotely a defining feature of nationalism, let alone the most defining feature as theprestige claimed. There can be multiple reasons for closed borders, none of which have anything to do with nationalism. Having a nation does not make one nationalistic. Go back and read the definitions again.
 
Last edited:
Yes, there is some overlap. But I like to make distinctions clear.

I'm super not a fan of calling every insurgent or mass murderer a terrorist or everyone accused of sex with minors as pedophiles. We have a tendency to conflate things for extra effect.

I agree with this, and I think it's a real problem in some cases.

Earlier, I referred to the Charlottesville protestors as Nazis, although I noted that they might not call themselves Nazis. In that case, though, I didn't feel very guilty about it. Some of the protestors carried flags which, although they did not have swastikas, had black and white artwork that was clearly reminiscent of Nazi era designs. Others chanted an actual Nazi slogan, "Blood and Soil". Therefore, I didn't feel too bad about simplifying the discussion by calling them "Nazis".


On the other hand, there are an awful lot of people who express a certain low level of racism in their actions (e.g. by moving away from schools where their kids might have to attend with black kids), and a fair number of people who openly express some sort of racist ideas. It would be inaccurate to call these people "Nazis" or "white supremacists", and often the distinction is important. The most obvious effect of that conflation is to alienate fellow citizens, and voters, and possibly push them into the other camp. If you call everyone who agrees with anything that the Proud Boys ever say a "white supremacist", some of those so named will respond with some variation of "If this be white supremacy, then let's make the most of it."
 
I agree with this, and I think it's a real problem in some cases.

Earlier, I referred to the Charlottesville protestors as Nazis, although I noted that they might not call themselves Nazis. In that case, though, I didn't feel very guilty about it. Some of the protestors carried flags which, although they did not have swastikas, had black and white artwork that was clearly reminiscent of Nazi era designs. Others chanted an actual Nazi slogan, "Blood and Soil". Therefore, I didn't feel too bad about simplifying the discussion by calling them "Nazis".


On the other hand, there are an awful lot of people who express a certain low level of racism in their actions (e.g. by moving away from schools where their kids might have to attend with black kids), and a fair number of people who openly express some sort of racist ideas. It would be inaccurate to call these people "Nazis" or "white supremacists", and often the distinction is important. The most obvious effect of that conflation is to alienate fellow citizens, and voters, and possibly push them into the other camp. If you call everyone who agrees with anything that the Proud Boys ever say a "white supremacist", some of those so named will respond with some variation of "If this be white supremacy, then let's make the most of it."

Low level? Ever heard of 'white flight'? I'd guess more white "liberals" do the fleeing than the white nationalists and racists they claim to abhor.

That's what bugs the **** out of people who have come to hold, shall we say, a realistic/pragmatic view of "open borders", mass immigration and the fantasy of "multiculturalism" - the phoniness of the 'tolerance' of liberals which evaporates the moment they're confronted with the with the reality of what they pretend to "believe in".

The worst are celebrities who virtue-signal for their countries, as if, for e.g., they'll ever get within several miles of a "refugee" in person, except as a photo op.
 
Low level? Ever heard of 'white flight'? I'd guess more white "liberals" do the fleeing than the white nationalists and racists they claim to abhor.

Suburban white people, mostly, but as Meadmaker says, there is subtle racism many people hold at some level. It's not limited to conservatives and how do you know how many of those fleeing white people are socially liberal? Your attempted appeal to hypocrisy flops.
 
I was not in time to see a poster;s response to my "a lot of people here who advocate violence are just interent loudmouths, who would run away from any actual fighting" because it got removed by the mods, but I take it as a sign I pretty much hit my target.

Oh sure, like the edge lord nazis. Just internet loudmouths and not remotely connected to any mass shooting.
 
And once again the problem is who decided who is a Nazi and who is not?
Let's be honest;a lot of the people here define Nazis as "anybody who is not as far to the left as I am".

And why is this important when one is making subtle distinctions between flavors of white supremacist? I mean other than not being able to call white supremacists deplorable.
 
So Mob Rule is the way to go?

Give up and enjoy the nazi run state is an option too. I mean you would never give issues to cops just because they are working with the nazis, I get that, but what is someone supposed to do?

For all your statements about the importance of guns in keeping america free you don't seem to actually want them used when it is only nazis as the threat.
 
I agree with this, and I think it's a real problem in some cases.

Earlier, I referred to the Charlottesville protestors as Nazis, although I noted that they might not call themselves Nazis. In that case, though, I didn't feel very guilty about it. Some of the protestors carried flags which, although they did not have swastikas, had black and white artwork that was clearly reminiscent of Nazi era designs. Others chanted an actual Nazi slogan, "Blood and Soil". Therefore, I didn't feel too bad about simplifying the discussion by calling them "Nazis".


On the other hand, there are an awful lot of people who express a certain low level of racism in their actions (e.g. by moving away from schools where their kids might have to attend with black kids), and a fair number of people who openly express some sort of racist ideas. It would be inaccurate to call these people "Nazis" or "white supremacists", and often the distinction is important. The most obvious effect of that conflation is to alienate fellow citizens, and voters, and possibly push them into the other camp. If you call everyone who agrees with anything that the Proud Boys ever say a "white supremacist", some of those so named will respond with some variation of "If this be white supremacy, then let's make the most of it."

Does spouting constant white supremacist talking points make one a white supremacist, like say Tucker Carlson?
 
"Mob Rule" is what we have

You're at least the third poster who seems to be painting the US as a Mad Max-style lawless wasteland. Seems to me like the rule of law is still quite in place.

I provided you a link, which you appear to have ignored.

Except that the link you've provided is irrelevant to what you just responded to. Eugenic isn't about one race being superior to another. That's just racism. Eugenics is about selective breeding and elimination of certain traits from the gene pool. As such your earlier comment about it is just wrong.

To provide people who are trying to ignore the argument something to nitpick about instead of actually addressing the point made.

First of all, thanks for responding to an honest question with snark, proving once again that you have zero respect for people you disagree with. Second, I did address it, since I responded, quite correctly, that eugenics wasn't the right word for what you were talking about.
 
Yes, there is some overlap. But I like to make distinctions clear.

I'm super not a fan of calling every insurgent or mass murderer a terrorist or everyone accused of sex with minors as pedophiles. We have a tendency to conflate things for extra effect.

To me, when I was posting my statement wrt comparing Nazi ideology to alt-right ideology I looked at it differently than others I guess. Some of us are pretty vague, and some of us require more granular definitions.

It's like dogs. Sometimes I'm at the pet store and I see a room full of dogs and I say, "Look at all the dogs!" They all share the common features of dogs, though you can list them by breed.

When I look at racist, misogynist, violent loudmouths that are putting forth effort to keep others down while mixed in with a bunch of people carrying Nazi flags...well.
 
And why is this important when one is making subtle distinctions between flavors of white supremacist? I mean other than not being able to call white supremacists deplorable.
While they're all deplorable, to advocate genocide crosses a line. It's an important distinction for non binary thinkers.
 
Nazis. The NAZIS were for nationalising industry and production.

Pay attention.


Except, of course, exactly the opposite of that.

There was a great deal of nationalizing of industry by the Weimar government; which was followed by a huge wave of privatization with government regulation when the Nazis took power. Most of the formerly-public companies and services went to supporters and cronies of the Nazi regime. Rather reminiscent of the GOP's current emphasis on privatization and corporate cronyism.

Nazi privatization in 1930s Germany

You really need to familiarize yourself with the history, you'd look much less ignorant if you did.
 

Do you really think that private businesses in Nazi Germany were independant of the government? The Nazis brought the media and production under their control quite readily.

You really need to familiarize yourself with the history, you'd look much less ignorant if you did.

Your only response to any kind of disagreement is to call other people ignorant. It might feel good for the ego, but it doesn't do you any favours, especially when you're wrong.
 
Nazis. The NAZIS were for nationalising industry and production.

No they weren't, on the contrary, they set up the first large-scale privatization policies in history. This is why, when the Economist wrote an article on their economic policy, they coined the word "privatization" to describe it in the first place.

ETA: I see I got beaten to it by luchog

Pay attention.

Oh the irony.
 
Last edited:
Where do those who advocate repression and enslavement of minorities fall with respect to that line?

This line is a red herring.

One of the big problems with "antifa" is that they have a lot of difficulty actually finding someone who advocates these things. Now, for reasonable people, the response to this difficulty would be something like, "those advocates, whoever they are, don't seem to be much of a problem; if they actually show their faces we'll deal with it then".

But for antifa, the response is to go find other people to beat up instead.
 
No they weren't, on the contrary, they set up the first large-scale privatization policies in history.

So I'll ask you, too: what's the difference between a company owned by the government and one under its complete control?

I'll even give you the answer: None whatsoever.

I suppose you could say that any ideologue in power would bring these under their control as well, and that's a fair point.
 
Last edited:
When I look at racist, misogynist, violent loudmouths that are putting forth effort to keep others down while mixed in with a bunch of people carrying Nazi flags...well.

Where are you seeing such mixtures?

I assume you're not literally seeing a group of people, some of whom are in the process of keeping others down, while others are carrying Nazi flags.

Obviously if you see a bunch of people grouped together in public, some of them carrying Nazi flags, it's reasonable to assume they're all Nazis.

One big problem I have with your overall methodology is that it seems to depend heavily on artificial groupings being fed to you in your online search results. You end up falling into a guilt-by-association trap, I think.
 
So I'll ask you, too: what's the difference between a company owned by the government and one under its complete control?

I'll even give you the answer: None whatsoever.

What makes you think the companies were under complete control of the government?

I suppose you could say that any ideologue in power would bring these under their control as well, and that's a fair point.

If you're going to claim that companies are nationalized due to being "under complete control" of the government if, during wartime, their productive capacity is directed at the war effort then you could equally claim that American companies were nationalized during WW2.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom