Journalist attacked by violent mob

The ability of some people here to see evil only one one side of the political spectrum is truly astonishing.
When it comes to making people behave in stupid ways driven purely by emotion, religion has nothing on political ideology

Says the guy spamming antifa apologetics to the guy who rejects both violent extremes.
 
Either Ngo's a threat to civilization (warranting violent preprisals from vigilant antifascists) or he's a non-entity warranting nothing more than dismissal. Can't be both.

Since I said neither, we have yet another of your posts that is failing to make a point.
 
What is amusing is that 90% of the advocates of violence here would turn tail and run away if they actually got caught up in a violent protest. Being a brave, heroic revolutionary is very easy from behind a computer keyboard.
It's a sort of Left Wing phony Machismo, no better then the similar crap on the right.
And I love the guy who thinks Every violent incident involving someone calling themselves Antifa is the result of an agent provocateur. Just another guy who thinks that the Right has a monopoly on political evil and stupidity.
Edited by zooterkin: 
<SNIP>
Edited for rule 0 and rule 12.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
What point? That the alt.right was founded by neo-Nazis and is still closely linked to them?

Where did you see me make that point? :rolleyes:

If not, then what flavours of fascists and white supremacists do you consider to be acceptable enough to sanitized the alt.right's image and reputation?

I can't make heads or tails of that sentence, so I can't respond.

At this point, I'm not strictly sure what your point actually was

Even though I made that point a dozen times?

The point, which was very clear, is that alt-right <> Nazi. Lots of people may associate with those groups, but it doesn't make them members.

Antisemitism is almost universal amongst alt.right groups and individuals. Mind you, some of a more religious mindset support Israel, while still maintaining a (poorly disguised) hatred for or distrust of Jews.

That sounds contradictory.

Nationalism is pretty much the definition of all groups under the alt.right umbrella.

Nationalisation, I said. Again, pay attention.

Warmongering? This is a little more varied, but the majority, especially the religious nutcases, are perfectly happy to wage war against all they see as inferiour

Please show where they discuss war specifically.

Eugenics. Well, what need be said about that, except that the Nazis got most of their ideas about eugenics from American eugenicists and their supporters.

Irrelevant.

The overwhelming majority of alt.right ideologies believe in some form of eugenics, particularly those under the neo-Confederate banner, although the degree varies considerably.

Do you have specific examples?
 
You know, even if you decide to consider the set of neo-nazis distinct from the set of white nationalists, then it may very well be the case that the set of neo-nazis turns out to be more widespread than the set of white nationalists because of all the non-white neo-nazis (South American primarily, though also India has a significant number of them).

I guess, but I was more concerned about the US specifically.

I'm going to assume you meant to say nationalism rather than nationalisation, because if not then you're going to be in for some fun when you find out how the term "privatization" (ie the opposite of nationalisation) even got coined in the first place.

I meant what I said.
 
Yeah, the lynch mob mentality is not confined to the right, as much as some people here would like to believe that.

In fact, some of the same people here demonstrate your point.

For someone who engages in so much whiny hand-wringing and pearl-clutching (snip)

Ouch, the irony!

Edited by zooterkin: 
<SNIP>
Edited for rule 0 and rule 12.

Yeah, people who don't pick one of two sides and stick to it dogmatically are idiots, amirite?

Do you even know what a centrist is, I wonder?

Edited by zooterkin: 
<SNIP>
Edited for rule 0 and rule 12.

I'm not sure you understood what he meant by hiding behind a keyboard. But you needed to reply something.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Yeah, the lynch mob mentality is not confined to the right, as much as some people here would like to believe that.

Exactly anyone who would counter protest a nazi march is by definition terrorist scum. They are antifa and so violent terrorists. Simple really.
 
Why is it most of the time someone posts an event to show the violence of the alt-right, it ends up showing mass violence from counter protesters as well? It seems each example points out the obvious, two groups come to fight and the inevitable happens.

You would think a rational person would be able to place blame on both without being a 'nazi sympathizer'.

A person that places blame both on the group assaulting the other group and on the group defending themselves from said assault is either not rational or a "nazi sympathizer". Also, you forgot the events consistently showing mass violence ("arrests") from the third group - cops - as well, which is also specifically political since said third group only assaults the second group and not the first group which began the violence.
 
Last edited:
If they are, there are police for that. We don't need the "protection" of antifa.


Except that, as has so often been noted, the police commonly either side with the fascist thugs, or take a "hands off" approach to them. Throughout American history, minorities have had as much to fear from police harassment and brutality as they have from any other group.

Not to mention that the police in this country have no duty to protect citizens from anything; according to the highest court in the land.

I can't make heads or tails of that sentence, so I can't respond.


Seems pretty straightforward to me.

The point, which was very clear, is that alt-right <> Nazi. Lots of people may associate with those groups, but it doesn't make them members.


Alt.right is not an organization that has members, it's a blanket term used to describe a number of disparate but similar groups and movements that share a similar worldview.

That sounds contradictory.


Only if you don't understand the religious mindset. It would help to study the Bible, particularly the book of Revelations, to really understand why the Evangelical churches support the nation of Israel, but have no love for Jews. In a nutshell, Israel as a nation is necessary to end-times prophesy; but the Jews are not needed beyond that, and are considered by most Christian sects to be as worthy of damnation as any other non-Christian.

Further, you have to understand the Evangelicals' and Fundamentalists' view of themselves in relation to the abstract concept of Israel. There is a passage in scripture describing the Church (the body of believers, not any particular sect) as "the true Jews". Evangelicals in particular have latched onto this passage, out of context, and turned it into a sort of slogan, using it as a justification for a sense of elitism and separatism. They are the new "chosen people". Of course, what they fail to understand about it is that it's not intended to set them apart as somehow better than anyone else, but to set them apart as a people from home much more is expected, who are intended to live by a much more stringent set of moral principles. Quite the opposite of the elitism they assume; "He who would be greatest among you, must be the servant of all"; and "To whom much is given, much shall be expected". Something that few of those claiming to be the "chosen people" even understand, let alone live by.

It gets more complicated than that, of course, but trying to explain it further would be fruitless if you don't have the religious context it's founded on.

Nationalisation, I said. Again, pay attention.


Nationalization of industry? Is that what you mean? Because you are not being very clear about that at all. In any case, far-right groups are not interested in government takeover of industry, that's a far-left thing, Communists. The far-right is generally much more in favour of privatization of government agencies; and have done in every case that they've gained sufficient power. Fascists do not support nationalisation, they favour corporatism, something that is increasingly defining the American and world economy.

Do you have specific examples?


Seriously? You do know what white supremacism is, right? Some form of eugenics beliefs are inherent in the white supremacist worldview, it's kind of the point of the thing. Superior race vs. inferiour race.

For starters, you can read up on the history of eugenics in the US: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eugenics_in_the_United_States
 
Last edited:
If they are, there are police for that. We don't need the "protection" of antifa.

Exactly, the so called greensboro massacre was an example of how things should be done. The KKK and the police worked together and really showed those foolish communists what for at their death to the klan march. That is a perfect example of how such protests should be run.

And here they thought they would need protection, bah there is no protection available against both the police and the klan.
 
A person that places blame both on the group assaulting the other group and on the group defending themselves from said assault is either not rational or a "nazi sympathizer". Also, you forgot the events consistently showing mass violence ("arrests") from the third group - cops - as well, which is also specifically political since said third group only assaults the second group and not the first group which began the violence.

The counter protesters were the ones attacking. They started the violence, unless of course you think speech is violence..

Your statement is possibly the most ironic thing I've ever seen here.
 
A person that places blame both on the group assaulting the other group and on the group defending themselves from said assault is either not rational or a "nazi sympathizer". Also, you forgot the events consistently showing mass violence ("arrests") from the third group - cops - as well, which is also specifically political since said third group only assaults the second group and not the first group which began the violence.

Figuring out which is "the assaulting group" is often problematic.

Example: I saw some video of the May 1 confrontation in Portland outside of a bar. An Antifa crowd was there. Some Proud Boys (I think) started verbally harassing them. The Antifa folks, of course, responded. Then one of the Antifa crowd threw a drink at the Proud Boys. One of the Proud Boys responded with pepper spray. One of the Antifa people then pulled out a truly amazing pepper spray aerosol sprayer. This thing made a cloud that was huge. It covered a front that was about six people wide. I don't know where you could buy such a thing, because it sure as heck wasn't a personal defense device. Can you buy riot control gear for personal use? Or was it a homemade contraption? Anyway, at that, most of the Proud Boys dispersed, but on the edges of the camera view, outside of the pepper spray cloud, you could see that a few scuffles had broken out, and news reports indicated there were injuries.


So, who assaulted whom? The first verbal harassment was the Proud Boys. The first physical escalation was Antifa. The first pepper spray was Proud Boys, aimed specifically at the drink-thrower. Then there was the general pepper spray cloud from Antifa aimed at anyone near them. Who would a jury say was guilty in that scenario?


For my part, I would be generally more critical of the Proud Boys, because they had no reason to be there in the first place. They were looking for a fight. On the other hand, Antifa obliged. It's not straightforward to cast blame in that case.


By the same token, the more recent violence in Portland had the police telling people that the Proud Boys should go to one place, and Antifa should go to the other. Antifa defied the orders, and by most accounts, also engaged in physical attacks when they got there. Once again, I'm sure there is plenty of blame to be cast at both sides, but on balance, it seems to me that Antifa was more of an aggressor.


And what about the case where one group has a parade permit, and a different group physically blocks their way, preventing them from using the space for which they have a permit? Are those blocking the way valiantly defending the streets? It seems to me that they are breaking the law. I won't give a pass to people who initiate violence in order to continue through the blocked street, but what ought to happen in that case is that the "parade" ought to stop, and they ought to call on the local police, who ought then to order the people blocking the path to disperse or be arrested. If that doesn't happen, violence is inevitable.


And if that street-blocking only occurred when confronted with the neo-Nazis at Charlottesville, or the Proud Boys in Portland, I could at least have some sympathy. However, I've seen video of the same sorts of folks in Antifa-style clothing do that to pro-Trump marches. I'm not all that fond of Republicans, and even less so of the Trump wing of the party, but if they get a parade permit, people ought to get over it and get out of their way. Jeer at them from the sides of the road if you wish, as is your right, but stay within the law.
 
Last edited:
Figuring out which is "the assaulting group" is often problematic.

Example: I saw some video of the May 1 confrontation in Portland outside of a bar. An Antifa crowd was there. Some Proud Boys (I think) started verbally harassing them. The Antifa folks, of course, responded. Then one of the Antifa crowd threw a drink at the Proud Boys. One of the Proud Boys responded with pepper spray. One of the Antifa people then pulled out a truly amazing pepper spray aerosol sprayer. This thing made a cloud that was huge. It covered a front that was about six people wide. I don't know where you could buy such a thing, because it sure as heck wasn't a personal defense device. Can you buy riot control gear for personal use? Or was it a homemade contraption?

Sure there are lots of ways and reasons why fogg type dispensers are prefered over stream type, being more sure of a hit for one. And if it is say bear spray you don't want to miss.

This is of course subject to local state laws.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom