...and only then when you choose very narrow criteria to compare.
Got any criteria better than, say, comparison of the wages paid in relation to the wages in the country at large on the basis of which to determine whether a prison system is a corrective labour facility or a slave labour facility?
Obviously not on purpose? I disagree strongly.
Stalin had already began the process of exiling Ukrainian farmers to Siberia who resisted his forced collectivization policies, his regime raised quotas to staggering levels, and then they literally went house to house taking their food. They used military blockades to prevent food from being imported and people from leaving to seek food.
Yeah, you do realize that each and every one of your assertions isn't just false but demonstrably so, right? I could refer you back to my comment to
theprestige in post 748 but there would probably be no point, so I'll just ask you the question again which you've ignored: Where do
you get your information?
They made gleaning, the practice of searching for leftover food from harvested fields, punishable by executions. Why would they do that except to force hungry people to starve?
Interesting to see you share such a fundamental criticism of private, and state, property. I thought you didn't accept the criticism on the basis of "it's illegal to steal bread but it's legal to let someone starve while you have a warehouse full of food." It's genuinely good to see you support alegality.
Uhm, no. There is no reason why the mortality rate shouldn't also be influenced by external factors in addition to the conditions purposefully created by the Stalinist regime.
Oh but the conditions purposefully created by the regime do not support the contention that the system was a slave labour system where people were worked to death. Over 90% came back out after a couple of years, and of those who died most died in the 1933 and WW2 period, the actual percentage attributable to conditions purposefully created by the regime is hence even higher. Furthermore, almost all of those >90% who came back out did so through the regime ordering such, not through escape or something. Was the regime really so incompetent that in trying to create a slave labour system to work people to death, they failed so badly - against their own will - that they managed to
release (not even "lose to escapes") >90% instead?
Because there is no reason to cherry-pick when the whole system from beginning to end was a political crime.
I know, if you can't go around killing Jews without being sentenced to a couple years of forced labour because of "counter-revolutionary activities" as "enemies of the workers" (article 58 of the Soviet Penal Code, commonly known as "political prisoners" in the West) then what freedom of thought do you even have, right? It's a political crime I tell ya.