Journalist attacked by violent mob

Expelling? Genocide isn't expulsion. These are different concepts. Please, tidy up your strawmen.

Well kind of we, are fine calling the Rohingya explushion a genocide even though the deaths are relatively minor compared to the expulsions. You have what 20K deaths vs 700K expulsions and that then hardly seems like a real genocide, just a bit of ethnic cleansing really.

As for the definition of genocide well Here it is

https://www.un.org/en/genocideprevention/genocide.shtml

"In the present Convention, genocide means any of the following acts committed with intent to destroy, in whole or in part, a national, ethnical, racial or religious group, as such:

Killing members of the group;
Causing serious bodily or mental harm to members of the group;
Deliberately inflicting on the group conditions of life calculated to bring about its physical destruction in whole or in part;
Imposing measures intended to prevent births within the group;
Forcibly transferring children of the group to another group."

So kind of like the Rwanda "genocide" we have to debate what is real genocide vs mere acts of genocide like we saw in Rwanda.
 
Racism is real and a very serious problem, but that does not mean that the term "Racism" is not used as a label to discredit your political opponent.
Communism was real in the McCarthy era;that does not mean everybody Tail Gunner Joe accused of being a Communist was one.

I get it wanting a white enthnostate and being afraid of the white genocide are real legitimate things and not markers of white supremacy in themselves. To suggest otherwise would mean people were happy to elect a white supremacist to be president.
 
Well kind of we, are fine calling the Rohingya explushion a genocide even though the deaths are relatively minor compared to the expulsions.

Who is "we"? I'm not fine calling it a genocide if it's primarily removal. That's ethnic cleansing, which is also pretty bad, but it's not genocide by any sensible definition.

And on that note, I wouldn't look to the UN to come up with sensible definitions of anything.
 
Except that it's still not even remotely a defining feature of nationalism, let alone the most defining feature as theprestige claimed. There can be multiple reasons for closed borders, none of which have anything to do with nationalism. Having a nation does not make one nationalistic. Go back and read the definitions again.

Kind of hard to have a nation without drawing a line and privileging those on the inside over those on the outside.

Anyway, I happily concede that I was not using any of the usual dictionary definitions of nationalism.

On the other hand, I'm not sure your claim, that nationalism is a defining feature of all the groups that have been assigned to the alt-right banner, is a correct claim. Or if it is, it is only a defining feature if we expand the definition to include viewpoints substantially similar to your own views on the value of having a sovereign nation that enforces its borders and privileges citizens over non-citizens.

Assuming you actually see value in this. If you're actually an open borders advocate or something, then that's a different story.
 
THIS.
There is little practical difference between a government taking over a business and an government regulating it so closely that the business owners need to get approval for anything more important then rearranging the office furniture.

I think you need some regulation to avoid abuses, but I am not a big fan of the government taking over and running businesses. Generally they do a pretty crappy job of it.This is where I disagree with a lot of "progressives" many of whom, I think, have a gut dislike of private business and want everything ran on a non profit basis. Won't work with human beings.

yea I mean in that kind of horrible system you wouldn't bill rape "victims" for their rape kits like is common practice now.

https://www.npr.org/sections/health-shots/2019/07/10/739925186/years-after-sexual-assault-survivors-hounded-to-pay-bills-for-the-rape-kit-exam

And the hate for pharma companies raising prices a mere 40,000% when they are morally required to do so for the benefits of their stockholders are really off putting.
 
At a point less than those who advocate genocide, but a point greater than ordinary bigots who don't advocate repression and enslavement.


So, intent to commit genocide is sufficiently over the line to take action against; but intent to repress and enslave isn't. Got it.

Personally, I think people and cultures should be held to somewhat higher standards.
 
So, intent to commit genocide is sufficiently over the line to take action against; but intent to repress and enslave isn't. Got it.

Personally, I think people and cultures should be held to somewhat higher standards.

At this point I'd be happy if the discussion centered around proving intent rather than inferring it.
 
Only in comparison with the American prison system.

...and only then when you choose very narrow criteria to compare.


And what famine would that be? I was talking about the 1933 famine, which obviously was not on purpose and definitely not to "subdue a population that isn't getting with the program."

Obviously not on purpose? I disagree strongly.

Stalin had already began the process of exiling Ukrainian farmers to Siberia who resisted his forced collectivization policies, his regime raised quotas to staggering levels, and then they literally went house to house taking their food. They used military blockades to prevent food from being imported and people from leaving to seek food.

They made gleaning, the practice of searching for leftover food from harvested fields, punishable by executions. Why would they do that except to force hungry people to starve?


If the contention were true then the mortality rates should be relatively stable and independent of the mortality rate in the country at large over the period of existence of the gulag system, the mortality rate being determined by the inherent nature of the gulags as opposed to external influence. Yet what we actually see is that these specific years are outliers, concurrent with outliers in mortality rate in the country at large, respectively due to famine in 1933 and the second world war in 1942-43. The evidence hence doesn't support the contention, it is rather merely cherry-picked and withdrawn from its larger context (ie the concurrent outliers in mortality rate in the country at large).

Uhm, no. There is no reason why the mortality rate shouldn't also be influenced by external factors in addition to the conditions purposefully created by the Stalinist regime.

ETA: I'm actually curious why one then wouldn't cherry-pick the 1938 peak in gulag mortality given that, although of course still not supporting the contention, this one was at least caused by overcrowding due to the Great Purge and can hence be much easier argued to be a political crime if that's what one would want to argue.

Because there is no reason to cherry-pick when the whole system from beginning to end was a political crime.
 
The United States federal government and its spinoffs had already normalized violence as an acceptable response to speech centuries earlier than that, and was quite happy to perpetuate that normalized violence during the Civil Rights era, at Stonewall, at Kent State and during the entire Vietnam War era, and so on.

And spectators who watched it in their homes on the evening news were rightly horrified by the government violence, and support of the non-violent protesters increased.

Blaming antifa for this just shows either how little you understand of history, or that you're being the hyperpartisan you're accusing others of being.

They should get blamed for what they do. Defending them by saying they're not as bad as the people they attack isn't much of a defense.

So you support fascism then? 'Cause if you actually oppose fascism to any degree, and don't support it actively or tacitly, then you're antifa as well.

Being anti-fascist isn't at all the same thing as being antifa.

Pretty much everyone is anti-fascist except people who are fascist, and even some of them are confused enough to be anti-themselves.

Being antifa, you know the guys with the red & black flags, the black hoodies with the red hankie face coverings, etc., there is a whole ideology there of anarchism & marxism that goes above and beyond just opposing fascism. If you claim antifa is only about opposing fascism, then you're either profoundly ignorant (which can be fixed) or you're lying.

There's a brain-exploding moment for you. Despite your and others attempts to re-define the term to fit your own straw men and well-poisoning, antifa is anyone and everyone who actively opposed fascism in any way. That what it has always meant.

No, that's wrong. I'm anti-fascist, and I assume you are too, but I am not antifa, nor will I ever be.
 
...and only then when you choose very narrow criteria to compare.

Got any criteria better than, say, comparison of the wages paid in relation to the wages in the country at large on the basis of which to determine whether a prison system is a corrective labour facility or a slave labour facility?

Obviously not on purpose? I disagree strongly.

Stalin had already began the process of exiling Ukrainian farmers to Siberia who resisted his forced collectivization policies, his regime raised quotas to staggering levels, and then they literally went house to house taking their food. They used military blockades to prevent food from being imported and people from leaving to seek food.

Yeah, you do realize that each and every one of your assertions isn't just false but demonstrably so, right? I could refer you back to my comment to theprestige in post 748 but there would probably be no point, so I'll just ask you the question again which you've ignored: Where do you get your information?

They made gleaning, the practice of searching for leftover food from harvested fields, punishable by executions. Why would they do that except to force hungry people to starve?

Interesting to see you share such a fundamental criticism of private, and state, property. I thought you didn't accept the criticism on the basis of "it's illegal to steal bread but it's legal to let someone starve while you have a warehouse full of food." It's genuinely good to see you support alegality.

Uhm, no. There is no reason why the mortality rate shouldn't also be influenced by external factors in addition to the conditions purposefully created by the Stalinist regime.

Oh but the conditions purposefully created by the regime do not support the contention that the system was a slave labour system where people were worked to death. Over 90% came back out after a couple of years, and of those who died most died in the 1933 and WW2 period, the actual percentage attributable to conditions purposefully created by the regime is hence even higher. Furthermore, almost all of those >90% who came back out did so through the regime ordering such, not through escape or something. Was the regime really so incompetent that in trying to create a slave labour system to work people to death, they failed so badly - against their own will - that they managed to release (not even "lose to escapes") >90% instead?

Because there is no reason to cherry-pick when the whole system from beginning to end was a political crime.

I know, if you can't go around killing Jews without being sentenced to a couple years of forced labour because of "counter-revolutionary activities" as "enemies of the workers" (article 58 of the Soviet Penal Code, commonly known as "political prisoners" in the West) then what freedom of thought do you even have, right? It's a political crime I tell ya.
 
Last edited:
So, intent to commit genocide is sufficiently over the line to take action against; but intent to repress and enslave isn't. Got it.

Personally, I think people and cultures should be held to somewhat higher standards.
I have not weighed in on when it is appropriate to take action. This is a figment of your fertile imagination. Got it?
</Groundhog Day>
 
In fact, some of the same people here demonstrate your point.



Ouch, the irony!



Yeah, people who don't pick one of two sides and stick to it dogmatically are idiots, amirite?

Do you even know what a centrist is, I wonder?



I'm not sure you understood what he meant by hiding behind a keyboard. But you needed to reply something.

If you don't pick a side between fascism and anti fascism? Yes, then you are a centrist idiot.
 
Nazis. The NAZIS were for nationalising industry and production.

Pay attention.

Lol. The term "privatization" was coined in the 1930's to describe what the NSDAP was doing.

You're not one of those "ackshully, the nazis were socialists" morons, are you? For the love of Chthulu, tell me you are not.
 
Last edited:
If you don't pick a side between fascism and anti fascism?

No, that's not what I said. Read it again.

You're not one of those "ackshully, the nazis were socialists" morons, are you?

You're not one of those "let's murder babies!" morons, are you?

Both those questions have exactly the same relevance to our respective contributions to this thread.
 
If antifa meant anti fascist, everyone would pronounce it, "ANTI-fa".

But they pronounce it "an-TIFA".

Checkmate, goons.

I think most families have an Auntie Fascist. My Auntie Fascist does double duty as she's also our Crazy Cat Lady. The ratio of cats to firearms is always fluctuating depending on what Auntie's seen on the news recently; last I heard she had nine cats and eleven guns, but two of the guns and one of the cats were rumored to be nonfunctional. She's very well known in her trailer park.
 
Unrelated to the larger topic that is now dominating this thread,

Ngo is getting roasted on Twitter for his bogus claim of having a brain hemorrhage. Many, many people are pointing out his miraculous and swift recovery from such a serious brain injury.

This doesn't really matter much in the larger scheme, but it's nice to know that everyone involved in this situation is a POS.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom