Journalist attacked by violent mob

Slightly ironic, don't you think? :)

I don't personally think so, but to each their own.

I still stand by what I said. If someone were to draw up a Venn Diagram, I don't think I'm that far off. That isn't guilt by association since that's defined as:

guilt ascribed to someone not because of any evidence but because of their association with an offender.

I gave several examples of their worldview and how they believe the same thing in several instances. Which would mean it is based on evidence, not merely the fact that they were in the same place at the same time. They were in the same place at the same time because they have the same beliefs and worldviews, for the most part.

You implied that they were all together because they had a common enemy. I don't believe that.
 
Seems pretty straightforward to me.

Obviously, since our own points seem pretty clear to us. However since I don't know what you mean, how about you tell me?

Alt.right is not an organization that has members, it's a blanket term used to describe a number of disparate but similar groups and movements that share a similar worldview.

And?

Only if you don't understand the religious mindset.

That's condescending in more ways than one, but the point is conceded.

Nationalization of industry? Is that what you mean? Because you are not being very clear about that at all.

What else could I possibly be talking about?

Seriously? You do know what white supremacism is, right? Some form of eugenics beliefs are inherent in the white supremacist worldview, it's kind of the point of the thing. Superior race vs. inferiour race.

That's not what eugenics are.

Also, entirely off topic, why do you write superior with no "u" but inferior with one?
 
I just don't like mob rule. Nip it in the bud. Better the bad guy gets isolated from the rest of society and punished lightly than giving lynch mobs free reign to do whatever to whoever. **** that.

Exactly, you never know when the mob will turn on you!
 
Last edited:
I was not in time to see a poster;s response to my "a lot of people here who advocate violence are just interent loudmouths, who would run away from any actual fighting" because it got removed by the mods, but I take it as a sign I pretty much hit my target.
 
And once again the problem is who decided who is a Nazi and who is not?
Let's be honest;a lot of the people here define Nazis as "anybody who is not as far to the left as I am".
 
If they are, there are police for that. We don't need the "protection" of antifa.

You know, there's a reason why "cops and Klan go hand in hand". We've seen this not only in Portland and Charolettesville, but also in Baltimore where police isolated teenagers trying to go home, and then fired tear gas and rubber bullets at them, thus setting off a major riot, and in Ferguson where police responded to a grieving community with riot gear and military equipment (and several activists have mysteriously been found in burned-out cars with bullets in the backs of their heads).

There are also the pipelines out in the Midwest, where police attacked Native protestors (and their sympathisers) when they protested pipelines that had been rerouted onto their lands to move them away from white communities.

"there are police for that"...no, there are police for you, so long as you don't push against the system. There have never been police for me.
 
Figuring out which is "the assaulting group" is often problematic.

Example: I saw some video of the May 1 confrontation in Portland outside of a bar. An Antifa crowd was there. Some Proud Boys (I think) started verbally harassing them. The Antifa folks, of course, responded. Then one of the Antifa crowd threw a drink at the Proud Boys. One of the Proud Boys responded with pepper spray. One of the Antifa people then pulled out a truly amazing pepper spray aerosol sprayer. This thing made a cloud that was huge. It covered a front that was about six people wide. I don't know where you could buy such a thing, because it sure as heck wasn't a personal defense device. Can you buy riot control gear for personal use? Or was it a homemade contraption? Anyway, at that, most of the Proud Boys dispersed, but on the edges of the camera view, outside of the pepper spray cloud, you could see that a few scuffles had broken out, and news reports indicated there were injuries.


So, who assaulted whom? The first verbal harassment was the Proud Boys. The first physical escalation was Antifa. The first pepper spray was Proud Boys, aimed specifically at the drink-thrower. Then there was the general pepper spray cloud from Antifa aimed at anyone near them. Who would a jury say was guilty in that scenario?


For my part, I would be generally more critical of the Proud Boys, because they had no reason to be there in the first place. They were looking for a fight. On the other hand, Antifa obliged. It's not straightforward to cast blame in that case.


By the same token, the more recent violence in Portland had the police telling people that the Proud Boys should go to one place, and Antifa should go to the other. Antifa defied the orders, and by most accounts, also engaged in physical attacks when they got there. Once again, I'm sure there is plenty of blame to be cast at both sides, but on balance, it seems to me that Antifa was more of an aggressor.


And what about the case where one group has a parade permit, and a different group physically blocks their way, preventing them from using the space for which they have a permit? Are those blocking the way valiantly defending the streets? It seems to me that they are breaking the law. I won't give a pass to people who initiate violence in order to continue through the blocked street, but what ought to happen in that case is that the "parade" ought to stop, and they ought to call on the local police, who ought then to order the people blocking the path to disperse or be arrested. If that doesn't happen, violence is inevitable.


And if that street-blocking only occurred when confronted with the neo-Nazis at Charlottesville, or the Proud Boys in Portland, I could at least have some sympathy. However, I've seen video of the same sorts of folks in Antifa-style clothing do that to pro-Trump marches. I'm not all that fond of Republicans, and even less so of the Trump wing of the party, but if they get a parade permit, people ought to get over it and get out of their way. Jeer at them from the sides of the road if you wish, as is your right, but stay within the law.

I saw Antifa in action in Berkely in 2017, and I saw them fight fascism by trashing and looting some small businesses in Berekely.
Not an inspiring sight.
Hopefully some of the more intelligent anti fascists will distance themselves from the Antifa label as it becomes more toxic. But your description that its often two groups looking for fight is right.
The scary think is the discussion here about Antifa in Berkelty, you had a couple of people who basically said that looting a small business was a legititmate form of protest.
 
You know, there's a reason why "cops and Klan go hand in hand". We've seen this not only in Portland and Charolettesville, but also in Baltimore where police isolated teenagers trying to go home, and then fired tear gas and rubber bullets at them, thus setting off a major riot, and in Ferguson where police responded to a grieving community with riot gear and military equipment (and several activists have mysteriously been found in burned-out cars with bullets in the backs of their heads).

There are also the pipelines out in the Midwest, where police attacked Native protestors (and their sympathisers) when they protested pipelines that had been rerouted onto their lands to move them away from white communities.

"there are police for that"...no, there are police for you, so long as you don't push against the system. There have never been police for me.


So Mob Rule is the way to go?
 
Really? Seems to me like their common enemies are liberals and immigrants.

Right, that is absolutely a common enemy. I was aiming a little deeper as to why they are a common enemy? Because all of those people that gathered on their "side" share a mutual hatred of liberals and immigrants based on their shared beliefs. Their beliefs overlap to such an extent that those people have become a common enemy.

So, you're not wrong, just not as right as I think you could be.
 
And once again the problem is who decided who is a Nazi and who is not?
Let's be honest;a lot of the people here define Nazis as "anybody who is not as far to the left as I am".

That's odd, the people I've seen on this thread have all pointed to that whole"wants to turn their country into a white ethnostate where freedoms are heavily curtailed, and men run things while women are consigned to bearing and raising children."

Y'know, the groups that fall under the "alt-right" umbrella.

Oddly, what I have seen are a few people that insist that "antifa" refers solely to Black Bloc anarchists (who, to be fair, are well known for smashing windows and starting fires, and generally being aggressive), rather than the large number of nonviolent protestors, doxxers, and so forth who understand that the "alt Right" groups who openly desire genocide are inherently violent, and are thus prepared to fight if need be.
 
I wouldn't even call a true far-rightist a Nazi if they weren't, and chances are they aren't.

A Nazi is a Nazi. We have a bunch of right wingers of various stripes with their own designations.

It's in no way intended to lessen the severity of anyone's crimes or anything. Call it tone policing or whatever, idc.
 
So Mob Rule is the way to go?

"Mob Rule" is what we have, and I have no choice in the matter. And when groups like BLM tried to propose something better, folks lost their minds, screaming that they were terrorists and cop killers (to date, groups like BLM have attempted to kill 0 cops, and 0 people at all, and 0 attempted terrorist attacks*)

*: anyone who wishes to point to some incident or other (not just dudalb), I suggest doing research before posting. And if I don't respond, I probably got sick of your racist crap and put you on ignore years ago.
 
Last edited:
I wouldn't even call a true far-rightist a Nazi if they weren't, and chances are they aren't.

A Nazi is a Nazi. We have a bunch of right wingers of various stripes with their own designations.

It's in no way intended to lessen the severity of anyone's crimes or anything. Call it tone policing or whatever, idc.

Ok, but would you agree that there are people with common outlooks as Nazis? Take for instance, as I mentioned earlier, you make a Venn Diagram of Nazi's and alt-right folk. Would you say that it would significantly overlap? Notice I'm not saying Hitler, I'm saying...you know. Your average Nazi soldier.
 
Nationalism is pretty much the definition of all groups who don't want open borders.

Do you want open borders? No? Then you're a nationalist.


I'm guessing that you're not a native English speaker; because the only other options are that you're being deliberately dishonest or you're an idiot. Since it's obvious you're not an idiot, I'll be charitable and assume you're not a native speaker.

From the online Oxford Dictionary of the English Language:

nationalism
NOUN
mass noun
1Identification with one's own nation and support for its interests, especially to the exclusion or detriment of the interests of other nations.
‘their nationalism is tempered by a desire to join the European Union’

1.1Advocacy of or support for the political independence of a particular nation or people.
‘Scottish nationalism’

Nothing in there about the state of the borders.

Let's try another dictionary, Merriam Webster

nationalism noun
na·​tion·​al·​ism | \ ˈnash-nə-ˌli-zəm , ˈna-shə-nə-ˌli-zəm\
Definition of nationalism
1 : loyalty and devotion to a nation
especially : a sense of national consciousness (see CONSCIOUSNESS sense 1c) exalting one nation above all others and placing primary emphasis on promotion of its culture and interests as opposed to those of other nations or supranational groups
Intense nationalism was one of the causes of the war.
2 : a nationalist movement or government
opposing nationalisms

So, the two most prestigious dictionaries in the English-speaking world say nothing about the state of borders being necessary to the definition of nationalism. It's all about cultural chauvinism and elitism.

This is what is know as the "redefinition fallacy", redefining words to fit your idiosyncratic meaning, rather than relying on the standard accepted meaning of the words, in order to attempt to "win" a debate that you cannot otherwise answer with evidence or logic.
 
That's condescending in more ways than one, but the point is conceded.


Sorry, wasn't mean to be. I meant to say "their" religious mindset; and if you haven't grown up in those communities inundated with their propaganda (which I have), it's very difficult to understand the breadth and depth to which that belief system permeates their entire decision-making processes.

That's not what eugenics are.


I provided you a link, which you appear to have ignored.

Also, entirely off topic, why do you write superior with no "u" but inferior with one?


To provide people who are trying to ignore the argument something to nitpick about instead of actually addressing the point made.
 
Ok, but would you agree that there are people with common outlooks as Nazis? Take for instance, as I mentioned earlier, you make a Venn Diagram of Nazi's and alt-right folk. Would you say that it would significantly overlap? Notice I'm not saying Hitler, I'm saying...you know. Your average Nazi soldier.

Yes, there is some overlap. But I like to make distinctions clear.

I'm super not a fan of calling every insurgent or mass murderer a terrorist or everyone accused of sex with minors as pedophiles. We have a tendency to conflate things for extra effect.
 
So, the two most prestigious dictionaries in the English-speaking world say nothing about the state of borders being necessary to the definition of nationalism.

Given that borders are one of the defining features of a nation, that seems rather implicit in the definition.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom