Journalist attacked by violent mob

Puppycow

Penultimate Amazing
Joined
Jan 9, 2003
Messages
34,628
Location
Yokohama, Japan
https://twitchy.com/brettt-3136/201...ng-attacked-by-antifa-protesters-in-portland/

On Saturday, Antifa had organized what it called “Community Self-Defense Against Proud-Boy Attack” and specifically called out “far-right Islamophobic journalist” Andy Ngo.

https://twitter.com/MrAndyNgo/status/1144716047901028352

I am nervous about tomorrow’s Portland antifa rally. They’re promising “physical confrontation” & have singled me out to be assaulted. I went on Tucker Carlson last year to explain why I think they’re doing this: They’re seeking meaning through violence.

I'm kinda wondering if Antifa shouldn't be treated as a terrorist organization?
 
I'm kinda wondering if you understand that there's no uppercase A in antifa, no membership card and no organization, per se, but a bunch of disparate groups variously referring to themselves as antifa.

Plus, like various White Nationalists, any group you decide to identify as "terrorist" is going to say, "Oh, we're not THAT antifa, we're the ones with the family picnics and the school breakfast programs.

You probably can't even attribute membership in the same antifa clique to everyone who was there on Saturday. The ***** who attacked him should be arrested and prosecuted.
 
Hmm. Whether it's spelled with a capital letter or a lower-case letter seems like a weird point to focus on. Wikipedia spells it with a capital letter last time I checked.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Antifa_(United_States)

Like the bullets at Balaklava!

The point is figuring out who is Antifa or antifa. If you're seriously proposing to name a group as terrorists, you have to be able to identify that group. People what act up in demonstrations are already subject to various laws. Can we name All Bigots as terrorists?

My point is not that they're right or wrong, but that with no formal organization, rules, by-laws, etc... WHO ARE YOU GOING TO "NAME" AS A TERRORIST ORGANIZATION. It's a group heading an encompasses all sorts of splinter groups around the world.

There are laws against what just happened in Portland. Naming one side in a political fracas as Terrorists is absurd.
 
Bunch of people dressed in black with their faces covered attack some right-wing noddy, who claims it was Antifa.

How do we know they were Antifa? Did they show their business cards? Announce themselves and show ID? Flash an Antifa badge? They look pretty hefty and older for Antifa teenager rapscallions, don't they. Much more like rent-a-thugs, to be honest.

So how do we know this wasn't all a setup?

We don't.

Get skeptical.
 
Last edited:
They should be classified as terrorists because they are terrorists. They claim to be anti-fascists but they act just like Nazis when they break store windows and loot and destroy property and assault people on the street that disagree with them.

The looting looks like Krystalnach
 
They should be classified as terrorists because they are terrorists. They claim to be anti-fascists but they act just like Nazis when they break store windows and loot and destroy property and assault people on the street that disagree with them.

The looting looks like Krystalnach

Terrorists don't break store windows and loot and assault people, they blow up buildings and hijack planes and kill people. Not all political violence is terrorism, you don't have to misapply the term "terrorism" in order to condemn bad behavior.
 
What losers. Making a martyr out of the person to whom they object. Nicely done, guys.

Now we get to hear the triumphant whinging of the dude's supporters, which will surely echo for months.

Also, Cain, it's Kristallnacht.
 
Last edited:
I think we can pretty much conclude that this bunch would associate themselves with the name antifa being a loose collection of individuals who clearly and demonstrably believe in active, aggressive opposition to what they perceive as far right-wing players/supporters. I can't see why the reluctance to on here?
 
I've always objected to antifa's aggressive tactics (even though I obviously agree with their general sentiments about fascists and violent nationalist pigs). I think they do more harm than good. I don't think violence solves anything, and I definitely don't think throwing milkshakes at people does anything. It's just crude, and it makes it very easy for rightwingin' jerks to come up with martyrs and whatabouts (all while not really solving anything).

That being said, I've had a milkshake thrown at me before, and it is really not a big deal. Like, cry me a river. But still, they're giving the "other side" ammo, and they're not accomplishing anything positive to offset that fact.

This is only my opinion, of course. It's also tinged by the fact that I know some people who now consider themselves antifa (they used to be "anarchists," and before that, "punks") and they are just awful people. I may agree with them politically on some VERY basic principles, but I still despise them and I think they are ultimately misguided.
 
Hmm. Whether it's spelled with a capital letter or a lower-case letter seems like a weird point to focus on. Wikipedia spells it with a capital letter last time I checked.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Antifa_(United_States)

The point of the "upper case letter", if I may speak for Foolmewunz, is not the capitalization. It's the question of whether there is actually an organization that goes by the name "Antifa" with or without capitals, punctuation, or any other idiosyncratic style of writing or logos.

Is there an actual group, with bank accounts, membership cards, meetings, etc. In order to designate something as a terrorist group, or to bring racketeering charges, or conspiracy charges, or anything else that you might do to a group, there has to be a group to do it to. There can't be "a bunch of folks who respond to calls on Twitter to assemble somewhere, possibly wearing black clothing because it's awesome."

If a group of people can be found who organized rallies and conspired to incite violence , then that group of people could be designated as a criminal organization. (I'm not sure if they meet the definition of "terrorist" organization, but that's really a secondary issue.)

What we can and should do, is identify specific individuals who are engaging in violence, and throw the book at them. They are truly awful people, engaging in behavior that every single American ought to condemn.
 
Daily Mail says that in addition to being punched and kicked - he was "milkshaked".
Milkshakes are harmless they said.
Portland Police
@PortlandPolice
4:08 pm - 29 Jun 19
Police have received information that some of the milkshakes thrown today during the demonstration contained quick-drying cement. We are encouraging anyone hit with a substance today to report it to police.
 
Eric Clanton exemplifies Antifa to many, and the fact that no-one associated with them has had a bad word to say about him would seem to confirm that they support his actions, perhaps even hold him up as a middle-class hero. ****wads.
 
Don't worry it's been comprehensively argued on this very forum, by some very good people, that there is nothing violent about a milkshaking.

It's violent. It's also crude and disgusting, and not okay. And, if you really want to get technical, it's a waste of food. (Well, "food.")

It's unlikely to be lethal or injurious in most cases. Doesn't make it okay.

I stopped hanging out with a girl I know because she threw her drink in a guy's face who was being kind of crude in a bar. Just tell him off - there's no reason for that ****. She made a dramatic scene and got thrown out.
 
Don't worry it's been comprehensively argued on this very forum, by some very good people, that there is nothing violent about a milkshaking.
What's been established time and time again is that liberals are possessed of 'moral relativism'. It isn't new, or unique to liberals, it's afflicted the morally-deficient and weak-minded throughout history.
 
Eric Clanton exemplifies Antifa to many, and the fact that no-one associated with them has had a bad word to say about him would seem to confirm that they support his actions, perhaps even hold him up as a middle-class hero. ****wads.

I misread the name as Clapton and was wondering what the hell he’s been up to.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom