Journalist attacked by violent mob

What makes you think the companies were under complete control of the government?

You must be joking.

If you're going to claim that companies are nationalized due to being "under complete control" of the government if, during wartime, their productive capacity is directed at the war effort then you could equally claim that American companies were nationalized during WW2.

Indeed. So?
 
You must be joking.

Not at all. Let me guess, you're also ignorant of the structure of large companies under Nazi Germany? Just let me ask you this then, if the Nazis started out with these companies under their complete control (nationalized under the Weimar republic) then why would they need to privatize them so as to gain favour of the large industrialists if they, by your assertion, had "complete control" over the entire industry (both public and private) anyway?

Indeed. So?

So...then you're using terms such as nationalization with a different meaning than the standard meaning, companies are generally not considered nationalized merely because they produce for government contracts.
 
Do you really think that private businesses in Nazi Germany were independant of the government? The Nazis brought the media and production under their control quite readily.


Goalpost moving. The businesses were privatized, not nationalized; and then heavily regulated/politicized. Nationalizing means that ownership is taken by the state, not private citizens.

You're really reaching here, verging on redefinition; and doing the exact same things you keep accusing others of.
 
So the Nazis didn't really nationalize industry, and even if they did, America did too.

It's a clever hybrid of apology for the Nazi regime and condemnation of the "Nazi" regime in America. A kind of rhetorical anarchy, if you will.

:rolleyes:

The Nazis didn't nationalize industry, they privatized industry. This is well-established historical fact, which you would be well aware of had you bothered to do some research on the subject. But it seems to be part of tradition on this board for people to make all sorts of assertions without having bothered to do even basic research on the topics of their assertions. A tradition that seems even all the more prevalent in political topics, from "antifa is just as violent as the fascists" to "gulags were death camps" to now "the Nazis nationalized the industry."
 
This line is a red herring.


Projection much?

One of the big problems with "antifa" is that they have a lot of difficulty actually finding someone who advocates these things. Now, for reasonable people, the response to this difficulty would be something like, "those advocates, whoever they are, don't seem to be much of a problem; if they actually show their faces we'll deal with it then".

But for antifa, the response is to go find other people to beat up instead.


That's hilarious. A complete and bizarre evasion of the point being made, and you're accusing others of a red herring?

This definitely shows the weakness and hypocrisy of the conservative position here.
 
The businesses were privatized, not nationalized; and then heavily regulated/politicized. Nationalizing means that ownership is taken by the state, not private citizens.

Ok I'll concede that. Still, there's little functional differences between such strict regulation and overwatch, and nationalisation,
 
Where are you seeing such mixtures?

The Unite the Right rally and a myriad of other rallies that took place during the attempted protection against the removal of Confederate Monuments.

I assume you're not literally seeing a group of people, some of whom are in the process of keeping others down, while others are carrying Nazi flags.

Yes, I am literally seeing that. I literally saw it in the case of Charlotesville. You're right though, they weren't held down as much as they were run over with vehicles, and beaten. Including a KKK leader shooting a gun.

Other than that you can see alt-right politicians holding down minorities in several ways from gerrymandering to policy decisions, and so on.

Obviously if you see a bunch of people grouped together in public, some of them carrying Nazi flags, it's reasonable to assume they're all Nazis.

Strawman. I never called them all Nazi's. I said they all shared the same ideological view of the world. After how many posts and we're still having to make this distinction?

One big problem I have with your overall methodology is that it seems to depend heavily on artificial groupings being fed to you in your online search results. You end up falling into a guilt-by-association trap, I think.

One problem I have is people not knowing the definition of "guilt by association". The definition is:

guilt ascribed to someone not because of any evidence but because of their association with an offender.

I hilited the important part. There is plenty of evidence, some listed by my opposition, to compare the two. Words mean things.
 
Does spouting constant white supremacist talking points make one a white supremacist, like say Tucker Carlson?

I think I've listened to Tucker Carlson for a total of about 10 minutes, so I can't really tell you what he's like.

As for the others. what we have in America today is that a whole lot of things get labelled "white supremacist talking points", even though they have nothing to do with white supremacy. However, the cool kids all know that it is "really" all about white supremacy, so it's a "white supremacist talking point." The best example is "Make America Great Again." Wearing a MAGA hat, or supporting Donald Trump, does not make someone a white supremacist, or even a racist, but I'm sure that there are people who are reading this who disagree.
 
Where do those who advocate repression and enslavement of minorities fall with respect to that line?
At a point less than those who advocate genocide, but a point greater than ordinary bigots who don't advocate repression and enslavement.

Yours truly,
Captain Obvious
 
While they're all deplorable, to advocate genocide crosses a line. It's an important distinction for non binary thinkers.

I kind of agree. But in the end mass murder is mass murder whether it is done in the name of race or in the name of political or economic ideology.
I don't know if you could apply genocide to what the Pol Pot regime did..there mass murder was based on economic theory....but in the end it was just as evil as murder for reasons of race or ethnicity.
 
Racism is real and a very serious problem, but that does not mean that the term "Racism" is not used as a label to discredit your political opponent.
Communism was real in the McCarthy era;that does not mean everybody Tail Gunner Joe accused of being a Communist was one.
 
Ok I'll concede that. Still, there's little functional differences between such strict regulation and overwatch, and nationalisation,

THIS.
There is little practical difference between a government taking over a business and an government regulating it so closely that the business owners need to get approval for anything more important then rearranging the office furniture.

I think you need some regulation to avoid abuses, but I am not a big fan of the government taking over and running businesses. Generally they do a pretty crappy job of it.This is where I disagree with a lot of "progressives" many of whom, I think, have a gut dislike of private business and want everything ran on a non profit basis. Won't work with human beings.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom