Journalist attacked by violent mob

You were asked how widespread Nazi belief was. You pulled a stat based on a related but different group and were called on it.

You know, even if you decide to consider the set of neo-nazis distinct from the set of white nationalists, then it may very well be the case that the set of neo-nazis turns out to be more widespread than the set of white nationalists because of all the non-white neo-nazis (South American primarily, though also India has a significant number of them).
 
You think nationalisation, antisemitism, warmongering, eugenics and the like are minor differences?

I'm going to assume you meant to say nationalism rather than nationalisation, because if not then you're going to be in for some fun when you find out how the term "privatization" (ie the opposite of nationalisation) even got coined in the first place.
 
I see you say that maybe I could be a little right because the person that coined the phrase WANTED to include everyone that had overlap in their ideology to show that his following was huge.
Wanting doesn't make it so. Improperly expanding the definition is improper regardless of motive. It's just as wrong for Spencer to pad his popularity as it is wrong for antifa to pad his popularity as it is wrong for you to pad his popularity.

You seem to be appealing to Spencer's (hypothetical) cynical ploy as validation of your own flawed method. Is that actually the argument you intended?

Then you say the right has delusions of grandeur
I said that neo-Nazis (in this context, Spencer and his ilk specifically) have delusions of grandeur. Did you make a typo, or were you actually equating neo-Nazis with "the right"?

which is a ******* massive downplay to their extremely violent nature. You then accuse the side that DOESN'T have a body count of being violent.
I was referring specifically to the cynical padding of their popularity. I can't downplay something I wasn't even discussing to begin with.

And there's more to violence than body count. Antifa is in fact very violent. Maybe Spencer is also very violent. I wouldn't know; the only time he seems to make the news is when people are threatening him with violence or inflicting violence on him. I think you'll need to play up Spencer's violence before I can take a stab at downplaying it.
 
The United States federal government and its spinoffs had already normalized violence as an acceptable response to speech centuries earlier than that, and was quite happy to perpetuate that normalized violence during the Civil Rights era, at Stonewall, at Kent State and during the entire Vietnam War era, and so on.

Blaming antifa for this just shows either how little you understand of history, or that you're being the hyperpartisan you're accusing others of being.




So you support fascism then? 'Cause if you actually oppose fascism to any degree, and don't support it actively or tacitly, then you're antifa as well. There's a brain-exploding moment for you. Despite your and others attempts to re-define the term to fit your own straw men and well-poisoning, antifa is anyone and everyone who actively opposed fascism in any way. That what it has always meant.

Nope. Just as I reject attempts to associate me with Spencer's alt-right, I reject attempts to associate me with the political thugs in Berkeley.
 
Wanting doesn't make it so. Improperly expanding the definition is improper regardless of motive. It's just as wrong for Spencer to pad his popularity as it is wrong for antifa to pad his popularity as it is wrong for you to pad his popularity.

You seem to be appealing to Spencer's (hypothetical) cynical ploy as validation of your own flawed method. Is that actually the argument you intended?

I don't believe he was being cynical. I think he was trying to unite...the right. Which appears to be a haven for people with racist, bigoted and backwards thinking views by giving them a name\platform to get behind.

You just claiming my method is flawed means absolutely nothing to me at all. You're wrong.

I said that neo-Nazis (in this context, Spencer and his ilk specifically) have delusions of grandeur. Did you make a typo, or were you actually equating neo-Nazis with "the right"?

It was a slight typo. As has been said before, not all people on the right are Neo-Nazis, but all Neo-Nazis are on the right.

I was referring specifically to the cynical padding of their popularity. I can't downplay something I wasn't even discussing to begin with.

And there's more to violence than body count. Antifa is in fact very violent. Maybe Spencer is also very violent. I wouldn't know; the only time he seems to make the news is when people are threatening him with violence or inflicting violence on him. I think you'll need to play up Spencer's violence before I can take a stab at downplaying it.

I have never made the claim that Spencer is as violent as Antifa. You're comparing an entire movement, or group of people to a singular individual. This is what you call arguing in good faith? I call ********.

Either way, the alt-right AND Nazi's are way more violent than anyone else and they have shown it time and time again.
 
any conservatives painting the antifa side more violent is absurd in the extreme. This is a stupid game to play. I like what Ricky Gervais had to say in a series of tweets.

and

and


If I criticize antifa, that isn't an endorsement of NAZIsm or the proud boys or of the patriot prayers or of the 3 percenters. I ******* hate these people and so does everybody I know. It is only in Antifa that I run into apologists and sympathizers and so I feel compelled to say something about it. It doesn't matter that the others are worse. So what?

Very well said.
 
Nazis were fascists so if you want an example of an actual "by the book" fascist movement gaining power and behaving as their claimed ideology said to behave then they are a very useful example.

Could you give me an example of a fascist movement that gained power and was a relatively good state?

Francoist Spain?
 
The lure of vigilantism is strong in this thread.

If anyone had wondered how people who considered themselves good people could be part of lynch mobs, just read this thread.

Yeah, the lynch mob mentality is not confined to the right, as much as some people here would like to believe that.
 
And yet there is no evidence of them being death camps, and piles and piles of evidence of them being re-educational facilities. Sorry if the evidence refutes any beliefs you may held, but I am not responsible for that.

Where do you get your information about Gulags? Are any of your sources post-Stalin western sources?
 
What is amusing is that 90% of the advocates of violence here would turn tail and run away if they actually got caught up in a violent protest. Being a brave, heroic revolutionary is very easy from behind a computer keyboard.
It's a sort of Left Wing phony Machismo, no better then the similar crap on the right.
And I love the guy who thinks Every violent incident involving someone calling themselves Antifa is the result of an agent provocateur. Just another guy who thinks that the Right has a monopoly on political evil and stupidity.
 
Last edited:
If they are, there are police for that. We don't need the "protection" of antifa.

Is this another case of "mobbing and assaults are only ok if my side - cops - does it"? Because even so:

Anti-fascists were stabbed at a neo-Nazi rally. Then police tried to charge them

Revealed: California has not prosecuted anyone for the stabbings, but sought hundreds of charges against counter-protesters

California law enforcement pursued criminal charges against eight anti-fascist activists who were stabbed or beaten at a neo-Nazi rally while failing to prosecute anyone for the knife attacks against them, according to police records reviewed by the Guardian.

In addition to the decision not to charge white supremacists or others for stabbings at a far-right rally that left people with critical wounds, police also investigated 100 anti-fascist counter-protesters, recommending more than 500 total criminal charges against them, according to court filings from civil rights attorneys.

{...}
 
Nope. Just as I reject attempts to associate me with Spencer's alt-right, I reject attempts to associate me with the political thugs in Berkeley.


And that's your problem. For someone who engages in so much whiny hand-wringing and pearl-clutching about people equating all far-right hardliners with Nazis, you sure do seem to really get off on labeling all anti-fascists as violent thugs. There's a word for that, and I think you know what it is.

And given that labeling all anti-fascists as violent thugs is a favorite tactic of the alt-right...
 
And that's your problem. For someone who engages in so much whiny hand-wringing and pearl-clutching about people equating all far-right hardliners with Nazis, you sure do seem to really get off on labeling all anti-fascists as violent thugs. There's a word for that, and I think you know what it is.

And given that labeling all anti-fascists as violent thugs is a favorite tactic of the alt-right...
When I talk about the violent antifa goons, I am referring to those politically violent goons who perpetrate their violence under the banner of antifa. I don't call myself alt-right, because I don't want to be associated with the neo-Nazis, white supremacists, and other deplorables who march under that banner. If you don't want to be associated with the goons in Berkeley, and the goons in Portland, and the goons in Charlottesville, then don't call yourself antifa.
 
Francoist Spain?


I'm fairly sure that the trade unions, Basques, non-Castilian Spanish-speakers, women, Muslims, Protestant Christians, and other non-approved and "undesirable" groups that were suppressed, often forcibly, even brutally, by the Franco government would disagree with you. Franco's government saw a huge rollback in civil rights for women and minorities, as well as anyone who wasn't Roman Catholic; and his treatment of the Basque provinces in particular was an atrocity.
 
The ability of some people here to see evil only one one side of the political spectrum is truly astonishing.
When it comes to making people behave in stupid ways driven purely by emotion, religion has nothing on political ideology
 
Is this another case of "mobbing and assaults are only ok if my side - cops - does it"? Because even so:

Why is it most of the time someone posts an event to show the violence of the alt-right, it ends up showing mass violence from counter protesters as well? It seems each example points out the obvious, two groups come to fight and the inevitable happens.

You would think a rational person would be able to place blame on both without being a 'nazi sympathizer'.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom