Journalist attacked by violent mob

Sounds pretty inconclusive to me. At best you can say that he's a middle-eastern hawk and islamophobe.

Gatestone is also (partly) funded by the Mercer's, one of which sits on the "Governors" board, and they are definitely alt-right. You can't be anything but if you fund Breitbart. Though both of your statements are true, he is an middle-eastern hawk and islamophobe, he definitely seems to surround himself with alt-right individuals.
 
From wiki:



I would guess from his past that he is, but I'm not really sure we found a way to say that an individual is for sure. I don't know that he has a quote saying he is or anything.

Do people generally label themselves as alt-right or is it just based on things they believe? You know, like 9/11 CTist don't all think that they're CTist, we decide it for them.

"Nazis."

In the past few weeks, we've gone from literal Nazis, to anyone we label as "alt-right", to anyone who has any conservative or republican associations. And all this from the same people justifying political violence against anyone they consider a "Nazi".
 
"Nazis."

In the past few weeks, we've gone from literal Nazis, to anyone we label as "alt-right", to anyone who has any conservative or republican associations. And all this from the same people justifying political violence against anyone they consider a "Nazi".

Sweet, now just show me where I "justified political violence against anyone I consider a 'Nazi'". Go ahead, I'll wait.

Also, anyone can read that post, or pickup on this article to see that Bolton doesn't just have sporadic ties. He's tits deep in it.

You obviously haven't read the last few pages, or you're just being obtuse. I'll let you decide which.
 
Then stop doing the dirty work for those who are.

Ooo guilty by association, eh? Classy, classy.

I'm not doing any dirty work though. I'm merely having a conversation about why I think differently and view this differently. I don't, nor have I ever, condoned violence of any form. I've smiled about it, but I don't condone it.

Is that how we are debating now, though? Do I get to now accuse you of all of the **** Trump's done because you "do the dirty work" of arguing on his behalf?

Come on. Lets not do that buddy.
 
You make gulags sound so awesome!

Only in comparison with the American prison system.

When the famine is caused by (or exacerbated by) the communist government, it still counts as the communists killing people. Especially when the famine is sorta on purpose to subdue a population that isn't getting with the program.

And what famine would that be? I was talking about the 1933 famine, which obviously was not on purpose and definitely not to "subdue a population that isn't getting with the program."

But even so, that wasn't the point under contention. The contention was that the gulag system was designed for "slave labour" where inmates were "worked to death." Evidence provided to support that contention was the mortality rates in 1933 and 1942-43. If the contention were true then the mortality rates should be relatively stable and independent of the mortality rate in the country at large over the period of existence of the gulag system, the mortality rate being determined by the inherent nature of the gulags as opposed to external influence. Yet what we actually see is that these specific years are outliers, concurrent with outliers in mortality rate in the country at large, respectively due to famine in 1933 and the second world war in 1942-43. The evidence hence doesn't support the contention, it is rather merely cherry-picked and withdrawn from its larger context (ie the concurrent outliers in mortality rate in the country at large).

ETA: I'm actually curious why one then wouldn't cherry-pick the 1938 peak in gulag mortality given that, although of course still not supporting the contention, this one was at least caused by overcrowding due to the Great Purge and can hence be much easier argued to be a political crime if that's what one would want to argue.
 
Last edited:
I'm not sure you realised, but you proved my point.


What point? That the alt.right was founded by neo-Nazis and is still closely linked to them?

If not, then what flavours of fascists and white supremacists do you consider to be acceptable enough to sanitized the alt.right's image and reputation? How many of those flavours decided not to closely associate themselves with neo-Nazis in various rallies and marches, like Unite the Right?

At this point, I'm not strictly sure what your point actually was; and I have a sneaking suspicion that neither are you.
 
What point? That the alt.right was founded by neo-Nazis and is still closely linked to them?

I don't know what point, but it seems to me that the term was coined by a neo-Nazi, and then promptly co-opted by politically-violent progressives to include a wide range of groups and views that were not part of the original coinage.

---

ETA: I suppose it's possible that Spencer himself was using an expansionist definition, in order to make his movement seem larger and more popular than it actually is. Perhaps the neo-Nazis and the anti-"nazis" are playing the same dishonest game, from opposite sides of the field.

This makes things pretty awkward for those of us who are moderate, non-bigoted, anti-establishment conservatives. Neo-Nazis with cynical delusions of grandeur on one side, and politically politically violent progressives who consider everyone to their right a "nazi" on the other. And a conservative political class that's too busy shoving both hands in the cookie jar to actually bother being conservative.
 
Last edited:
Either Ngo's a threat to civilization (warranting violent preprisals from vigilant antifascists) or he's a non-entity warranting nothing more than dismissal. Can't be both.

What if he's a threat, specifically, to communists, anarchists, and other anti-fascists but not to liberals (unless Jewish or otherwise specifically targeted other than for political reasons)?
 
I don't know what point, but it seems to me that the term was coined by a neo-Nazi, and then promptly co-opted by politically-violent progressives to include a wide range of groups and views that were not part of the original coinage.

---

ETA: I suppose it's possible that Spencer himself was using an expansionist definition, in order to make his movement seem larger and more popular than it actually is. Perhaps the neo-Nazis and the anti-"nazis" are playing the same dishonest game, from opposite sides of the field.

This makes things pretty awkward for those of us who are moderate, non-bigoted, anti-establishment conservatives. Neo-Nazis with cynical delusions of grandeur on one side, and politically politically violent progressives who consider everyone to their right a "nazi" on the other. And a conservative political class that's too busy shoving both hands in the cookie jar to actually bother being conservative.

Seems like a lot of words to tell me I'm right, theprestige.

*Walks away, personifying Danth's Law*
 
Ooo guilty by association, eh? Classy, classy.
I'm sorry. I was not intending to imply an argument of guilt by association. My argument is that you are guilty of aggressively expanding what it means to be a legitimate target of political violence, for those who advocate political violence.

Ironically, your entire argument over the past few pages has been one of guilt by association.
 
I don't think Nazi's started with as much hate as they had at the end either. I think it was spoonfed to them, as is shown by history. Along the same lines as the alt-right is moving. They've become emboldened in the last few years and I don't think the alt-right of even 5 years ago is the same as now.


Have to disagree here. The Nazis foundational documents, and their origins in the volkisch movements started out with a foundation of hate and elitism, which was just expanded upon from there. Now, it's possible that many of the rank-and-file were not coming from that same position of hate, but I doubt that is the case. One thing that allowed the Nazis to springboard into popularity as quickly and effectively as they did was that they played into existing antisemitic, anti-immigration, and anti-LGBTQ sentiments.

The only thing that really differentiated the Nazis from any other fascist or white supremacist group is 1) the amount and duration of the power that they held; and 2) their sheer efficiency in carrying out their attempt at genocide. Both of these were due entirely due to an accident of history providing them the right-place-at-the-right-time, and the tools they needed to carry out their programs with such a mechanical ruthlessness.

You think nationalisation, antisemitism, warmongering, eugenics and the like are minor differences?


Antisemitism is almost universal amongst alt.right groups and individuals. Mind you, some of a more religious mindset support Israel, while still maintaining a (poorly disguised) hatred for or distrust of Jews. It's certainly that way amongst the groups I listed in my earlier post, and many of the Dominionists/Identitarian Christian groups as well.

Nationalism is pretty much the definition of all groups under the alt.right umbrella.

Warmongering? This is a little more varied, but the majority, especially the religious nutcases, are perfectly happy to wage war against all they see as inferiour; and the Christian groups have a profound desire to see mass warfare in the Middle East as a fulfillment to their worldview. There are also a whole lot of militia groups who fall under the alt.right banner due to their white supremacist beliefs.

Eugenics. Well, what need be said about that, except that the Nazis got most of their ideas about eugenics from American eugenicists and their supporters. The overwhelming majority of alt.right ideologies believe in some form of eugenics, particularly those under the neo-Confederate banner, although the degree varies considerably.
 
Seems like a lot of words to tell me I'm right, theprestige.

*Walks away, personifying Danth's Law*

I make a good faith argument, and get this BS back in return.

Okay, let me try with less words so as not to risk confusing you again:

Antifa is wrong.

Antifa's fellow travelers on this board are wrong.

You are wrong.

If Spencer is doing it, he's wrong too.
 
I'm sorry. I was not intending to imply an argument of guilt by association. My argument is that you are guilty of aggressively expanding what it means to be a legitimate target of political violence, for those who advocate political violence.

Ironically, your entire argument over the past few pages has been one of guilt by association.

LoL :thumbsup:
 
I make a good faith argument, and get this BS back in return.

Okay, let me try with less words so as not to risk confusing you again:

Antifa is wrong.

Antifa's fellow travelers on this board are wrong.

You are wrong.

If Spencer is doing it, he's wrong too.

Sorry, I didn't mean to get in the way of you playing the victim.

You were crying about what now? I see you say that maybe I could be a little right because the person that coined the phrase WANTED to include everyone that had overlap in their ideology to show that his following was huge.

Then you say the right has delusions of grandeur, which is a ******* massive downplay to their extremely violent nature. You then accuse the side that DOESN'T have a body count of being violent.

If you want I can call your argument complete and total ******** if that would help. I made a very concerted effort to stop swearing, but in all honesty your post is nonsense. Congrats, you built a strawman and kicked the piss out of it. Keep going, let me know when you need a hanky
 
I don't know what point, but it seems to me that the term was coined by a neo-Nazi, and then promptly co-opted by politically-violent progressives to include a wide range of groups and views that were not part of the original coinage.

ETA: I suppose it's possible that Spencer himself was using an expansionist definition, in order to make his movement seem larger and more popular than it actually is. Perhaps the neo-Nazis and the anti-"nazis" are playing the same dishonest game, from opposite sides of the field.


You suppose it's possible? Perhaps you should actually read Spencer's justification for coining the term, then, since that is exactly what he had in mind. As I noted, it was intended to create a banner under which all white supremacists would gather to form a powerful social and political bloc.

Want to take a guess how many non-neo-Nazi groups showed up at the Unite the Right rally? Hint, it's a very substantial non-zero number. Those groups, and individuals, were more than happy to associate themselves directly with neo-Nazis like Spencer under the greater alt.right umbrella; and he and his cronies certainly didn't condemn them for it.
 
Of course not, it is morally unacceptable to use force on anything less than a total threat to civilization. Isn't that clear? Now we just need to figure out of a little genocide is really a threat to civilization or not.
Having trouble finding the quote where the Vietnamese American guy stood up for "a little genocide," but as a skeptic, I'm confident you must have your sources.
 
Antifa had already normalized violence as an acceptable response to speech, in Berkeley, a year or more before Charlottesville.


The United States federal government and its spinoffs had already normalized violence as an acceptable response to speech centuries earlier than that, and was quite happy to perpetuate that normalized violence during the Civil Rights era, at Stonewall, at Kent State and during the entire Vietnam War era, and so on.

Blaming antifa for this just shows either how little you understand of history, or that you're being the hyperpartisan you're accusing others of being.

Antifa is wrong.

Antifa's fellow travelers on this board are wrong.


So you support fascism then? 'Cause if you actually oppose fascism to any degree, and don't support it actively or tacitly, then you're antifa as well. There's a brain-exploding moment for you. Despite your and others attempts to re-define the term to fit your own straw men and well-poisoning, antifa is anyone and everyone who actively opposed fascism in any way. That what it has always meant.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom