Journalist attacked by violent mob

I guess it depends who "we" are.

The central point of contention in this debate seems to be whether antifa engage in political violence.

If we want to be logically consistent, I think we have to say that they do. Otherwise one could say that the alt-right aren't all violent and that the violent ones don't necessarily represent the whole, etc.
 
I expect the best people to ask what differentiates NAZI's from the rest of the Alt-right are the NAZI's, I'm willing to bet they can come up with a pretty comprehensive list of why the rest of the alt-right will eventually be purged.

Aside from that, NAZIism is a very clearly defined albeit incoherent ideology, which is what differentiates from other alt-right types which mostly have only vaguely defined notions of hating other people and blaming others for their misfortune.

So, the alt-right's big moment, charlottesville, how many showed up?
 
No but both fit with the white supremacy thing anyway. I don't think they object to white immigrants from Finland.

Ok.

You will? :)

Won't be my first or last.

Well then, do you not see why I find your claim that they largely overlap hard to accept? Clearly they overlap to a good degree, but although the Alt-Right are despicable in their own right it's just silly to use their own numbers to bolster the number of Nazis in the country.

I wasn't really doing that though. I was asked if I felt that the Nazi ideology was widely accepted. I didn't even limit it to this particular country since alt-right and, to some extent, Nazism is global. I mentioned that earlier.

I think if there were a Venn Diagram about this it would come out somewhere close to an eclipse. I think the differences are much more minuscule than the similarities. In my opinion, the reason we don't call them Nazi's is merely because of the negativity surrounding Nazi's because of their massive slaughter of humans. That doesn't mean that the alt-right wouldn't do the exact same thing given the opportunity.

Well, if you want to be pedantic, anytime someone says "X" and the other on says "Not X!", you could say they are both making claims, but you've been here long to know that the positive claim is usually the one carrying the burden.

I was.

If it did, we'd have to conclude that antifa share something important in common with the "alt-right". Which when it comes to political violence, they kinda do. But I doubt that's the direction plague intended this to go.

I would definitely say that antifa and the alt-right have stuff in common. I wouldn't say it's as much as the alt-right has in common with Nazism, but your point is valid.

The difference there is I can't really think of many people that have been killed by antifa, or the amount of bombs they've sent, or abortion hospitals they've shot up, etc. That doesn't mean they aren't violent, just not as...
 
I expect the best people to ask what differentiates NAZI's from the rest of the Alt-right are the NAZI's, I'm willing to bet they can come up with a pretty comprehensive list of why the rest of the alt-right will eventually be purged.

Again, I never said they were completely the same. I said the ideologies were the same. Something I stand by.

Aside from that, NAZIism is a very clearly defined albeit incoherent ideology, which is what differentiates from other alt-right types which mostly have only vaguely defined notions of hating other people and blaming others for their misfortune.

I don't think Nazi's started with as much hate as they had at the end either. I think it was spoonfed to them, as is shown by history. Along the same lines as the alt-right is moving. They've become emboldened in the last few years and I don't think the alt-right of even 5 years ago is the same as now.

So, the alt-right's big moment, charlottesville, how many showed up?

*shrug* I don't know. Enough to kill someone. That's more than enough for me. How many need to show up before it's a problem? It's by far and away larger than any antifa moment, but that's more of a whataboutism than anything, only in reverse I think.
 
Last edited:
I don't think Nazi's started with as much hate as they had at the end either. I think it was spoonfed to them, as is shown by history. Along the same lines as the alt-right is moving. They've become emboldened in the last few years and I don't think the alt-right of even 5 years ago is the same as now.

And of course like any large party they had a diversity of views as well, so clearly not all members of the German national socialist workers party can really accurately be called nazis.
 
Either Ngo's a threat to civilization (warranting violent preprisals from vigilant antifascists) or he's a non-entity warranting nothing more than dismissal. Can't be both.

Can there be something in the middle of those two possibilities?
 
Can there be something in the middle of those two possibilities?

Of course not, it is morally unacceptable to use force on anything less than a total threat to civilization. Isn't that clear? Now we just need to figure out of a little genocide is really a threat to civilization or not.
 
I wasn't really doing that though.

Plague, you linked to numbers that included a far larger group because, as you stated earlier, they pretty much had the same ideology. That sounds exactly like what I described.

I think if there were a Venn Diagram about this it would come out somewhere close to an eclipse. I think the differences are much more minuscule than the similarities.

You think nationalisation, antisemitism, warmongering, eugenics and the like are minor differences?
 
You think nationalisation, antisemitism, warmongering, eugenics and the like are minor differences?

And of course no one would accuse richard spencer the founder of the Alt Right of any of that. It is all peaceful ethnic cleansing, like the nazis before WWII only this time we will find someone to actually take the bastards. No death camps or anything certainly.
 
Plague, you linked to numbers that included a far larger group because, as you stated earlier, they pretty much had the same ideology. That sounds exactly like what I described.

Ok, I'll just have to say that I disagree. I still feel there is enough overlap to consider the ideologies close. That's totally like...my opinion man.

You think nationalisation, antisemitism, warmongering, eugenics and the like are minor differences?

I think the alt-right is warmongering. They're certainly violent, and plenty would just love the opportunity for war in the Middle East. I think those things are differences, but again this goes back to just them not having enough power. When they have power they ban abortion, they are aggressive in getting minorities not to vote, they try to take away protections for LBGTQ, and that's also been proven time and again.

Just because they aren't doing those things doesn't mean they wouldn't if they didn't have the power to do so. The alt-right was marching with torches shortly before that and they've threatened more than enough people during those "demonstrations".

This was good for a couple pages of debate, I certainly won't argue that, but at this point I just don't believe we'll agree.
 
Last edited:
That's totally like...my opinion man.



I think the alt-right is warmongering.

You mean the rank-and-file, or politicians you consider to be alt-right?

Just because they aren't doing those things doesn't mean they wouldn't if they didn't have the power to do so.

Yeah but that's why we should look at what they claim their goals are. Or at least what they say behind closed doors.

This was good for a couple pages of debate, I certainly won't argue that, but at this point I just don't believe we'll agree.

Don't underestimate the power of a good argument.
 

I was hoping that would land.

You mean the rank-and-file, or politicians you consider to be alt-right?

A little from column A and a little from column B. I see John Bolton as an alt-right figure, considering his past. He's about as pro-war as they get.

Yeah but that's why we should look at what they claim their goals are. Or at least what they say behind closed doors.

I truly believe that there would be an echo chamber between the two for the most part. I believe that our difference is how extreme we think each one is and that's a matter of opinion. I don't see the beginnings of Nazism much differently than I view the alt-right of today...or the last few years actually. It's taken a sharp turn.

Don't underestimate the power of a good argument.

Absolutely.
 
Something that warrants mobbing and assault?

I mean, maybe...? Such as?

I don't think there is anyone here arguing in good faith that anyone deserves to be mobbed and assaulted. The people that are definitely speak on their own and have received little to no support at all.
 
I don't know much about him. How is he alt-right?

From wiki:

Bolton has been involved with numerous conservative organizations, including the anti-Muslim Gatestone Institute, where he served as the organization Chairman until March 2018, and as a Director of the Project for the New American Century, which favored going to war with Iraq.

A Republican, his political views have been described as American nationalist, conservative, and "neoconservative". Bolton rejects the last term and uses the term "pro-American" instead.

I would guess from his past that he is, but I'm not really sure we found a way to say that an individual is for sure. I don't know that he has a quote saying he is or anything.

Do people generally label themselves as alt-right or is it just based on things they believe? You know, like 9/11 CTist don't all think that they're CTist, we decide it for them.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom