Journalist attacked by violent mob

For the 500th time. Their beliefs are largely the same.

You understand that repeating a claim does not make it true, right?

Now if only I had done that.

I was obviously talking about some other guy over at the IMDB forum.

LoL this is getting insane.

Indeed. The lengths to which you'll go to deny saying what is a matter of public record is borderline crazy. You were asked how widespread Nazi belief was. You pulled a stat based on a related but different group and were called on it. Now you're trying to have your cake and eat it too, both saying that they are essentially of the same philosophy, enough so that we can ignore the differences for the purposes of the discussion, AND that you've never claimed they were the same thing. Which is it?

Do you agree or disagree that Nazism and those who identify as alt-right hold, largely, the same beliefs? i.e. white's are superior, anti-LGBTQ, anti-minorities, etc.

I don't strictly agree with the above because it's misleading. They hold some of the same beliefs, just like Hitler and Peter Dinklage share vegetarianism. Whether the overlap makes them sufficiently similar to be considered one and the same thing is a point of contention.
 
The ******* Nazis and the other groups are being used as the larger number because the ******* ideology is, largely, the same. That's why they were all on the same "side".

That makes no sense whatsoever. Enemies sometimes gather together to fight a third party. It doesn't make them the same at all.

Also, do you think you could calm down? It's really not helping your eloquence or your ability to present a well-constructed argument.

I did have to take logic, yes.

That wasn't my question. My profession, for example, requires me to use logic and inference constantly. Taking a logics course one time isn't the same thing.
 
Indeed. The lengths to which you'll go to deny saying what is a matter of public record is borderline crazy. You were asked how widespread Nazi belief was. You pulled a stat based on a related but different group and were called on it. Now you're trying to have your cake and eat it too, both saying that they are essentially of the same philosophy, enough so that we can ignore the differences for the purposes of the discussion, AND that you've never claimed they were the same thing. Which is it?

Yet despite all of the posts neither of you have actually ******* said what the differences between them are, have you? Zigg argued about google searches, and we're arguing about how similar they are while you downplay that massive amount of similarities between the two, all while implying I'm completely wrong.

You say they're related and I was asked about how accepted the IDEOLOGY is, of which the two are extremely similar. No matter how much you keep saying they aren't.

I don't strictly agree with the above because it's misleading. They hold some of the same beliefs, just like Hitler and Peter Dinklage share vegetarianism. Whether the overlap makes them sufficiently similar to be considered one and the same thing is a point of contention.

Sweet, now we're getting somewhere. What do you think is the most distinguishing difference where we can say "yeah, they are extremely far apart actually"?

I was obviously talking about some other guy over at the IMDB forum.

Yes, and I was saying it had absolutely nothing to do with anything I've done, and you replied to a quote about my actions with your tale.
 
Last edited:
That makes no sense whatsoever. Enemies sometimes gather together to fight a third party. It doesn't make them the same at all.

Also, do you think you could calm down? It's really not helping your eloquence or your ability to present a well-constructed argument.

Ah, you're one of those "if he's swearing he's really mad" type of people. I'm not riled up at all, I assure you. This is just the normal plague311.

Ok, so great. Enemies sometimes gather together to fight a third party. Are you saying that's what happened here? People of two completely different ideologies teamed up to fight?

That wasn't my question. My profession, for example, requires me to use logic and inference constantly. Taking a logics course one time isn't the same thing.

Neat, it was an irrelevant question so I gave at an irrelevant reply. I use logic in my daily work too. Moving on.
 
It's a keyword search. If it locates the word inside of those articles, etc. then it associates the keyword with the article. It so happens that my search criteria that included Nazi's brought up a ton of alt-right articles. Further proving my point. I didn't feel I needed to explain how ******* google searches work, but when you guys don't have **** to fall back on then you have to dick around with dumb **** like this.

I'm a network administrator by trade, and I can explain how each packet traverses the network and **** too. How specific do you want it? Christ.
This is an appeal to to popularity, bolstered by an appeal to authority.
 
Yet despite all of the posts neither of you have actually ******* said what the differences between them are, have you?

Well I assumed you knew, but it's becoming increasingly obvious that you don't. However since you seem to lump them together because they are part of a larger rally and occupied the same physical space, I think that has to do with your ability to distinguish objects.

Zigg argued about google searches, and we're arguing about how similar they are while you downplay that massive amount of similarities between the two, all while implying I'm completely wrong.

That's a very nice way to twist words to pretend like things happened differently than they have. I'm starting to think you're not half as pissed as you seem to be.

The thing you're completely wrong about is that they largely have the same ideology. You're not wrong about there being an overlap between the two groups, something I've already stated a few minutes ago.

You say they're related and I was asked about how accepted the IDEOLOGY is, of which the two are extremely similar.

See, there's that wordplay again. What do you mean by "extremely"? How much is extremely? What things don't they have in common, for instance? Which of those things are part of the other's core ideology?

What do you think is the most distinguishing difference where we can say "yeah, they are extremely far apart actually"?

I'm not sure I'm parsing this correctly. Are you asking me for the most crucial difference between the two?
 
Ah, you're one of those "if he's swearing he's really mad" type of people.

No, I'm one of those "if he's swearing repeatedly he's rather miffed" type of people. Asterisked words are disruptive to reading, so using them repeatedly certainly gives off the impression that you're not really trying to be understood clearly, but are rather venting.

Ok, so great. Enemies sometimes gather together to fight a third party. Are you saying that's what happened here? People of two completely different ideologies teamed up to fight?

Why are you always trying to find some hidden meaning in what I write? I responded to a specific argument of yours. The peg won't fit anywhere else.

Neat, it was an irrelevant question so I gave at an irrelevant reply.

The question was entirely relevant since the ability to understand logic was under discussion. Are you sure you know what "relevant" means?
 
Well I assumed you knew, but it's becoming increasingly obvious that you don't. However since you seem to lump them together because they are part of a larger rally and occupied the same physical space, I think that has to do with your ability to distinguish objects.

No, I don't lump them together because of the things you mentioned. I lump them together because they lump themselves together, because they share similar outlooks. As you said, they banded together to fight someone else. Why?

That's a very nice way to twist words to pretend like things happened differently than they have. I'm starting to think you're not half as pissed as you seem to be.

Ok...what words did I twist? Why do I feel like I have to milk answers out of people? I specifically told you I wasn't pissed, at all. Why would I be? This is an anonymous internet discussion forum.

The thing you're completely wrong about is that they largely have the same ideology. You're not wrong about there being an overlap between the two groups, something I've already stated a few minutes ago.

Awesome, for extreme clarification. You're saying that there are several more differences than there are similarities, right?

See, there's that wordplay again. What do you mean by "extremely"? How much is extremely? What things don't they have in common, for instance? Which of those things are part of the other's core ideology?

...that's what I'm asking. I've given examples of how the core tenants are exactly the same between these two. You and Zig have repeatedly told me that I'm wrong. I'm merely asking, how am I wrong?

I'm not sure I'm parsing this correctly. Are you asking me for the most crucial difference between the two?

Yes. I want to know what the key differences between the ideologies of Nazism and the alt-right movement that self identifies as white nationalists, etc.

I kept it swear free because I know how it bothers some.

ETA: I am not going to reply to the post after your first one as they're becoming somewhat redundant. I think we're on a forward moving track, so lets stick with this one for now.
 
Last edited:
No, I don't lump together because of the things you mentioned. I lump them together because they lump themselves together, because they share similar outlooks.

Now who's being pedantic? I'm pretty sure you know what I mean.

As you said, they banded together to fight someone else. Why?

Are you going to commit the exact same error of logic I earlier corrected you on? I'll remind you that people who hate each other often band together. Having a common goal does not mean you agree on the fundamental of each other's ideology.

Ok...what words did I twist? Why do I feel like I have to milk answers out of people?

It feels that way because I'm giving you the benefit of the doubt that you can read your way out of a paper bag.

It's your use of superlatives and exaggerated adjectives that I was refering to. You're trying to force a meaning onto other words by adding these.

I specifically told you I wasn't pissed, at all. Why would I be? This is an anonymous internet discussion forum.

Yeah anonymous internet discussions never get heated, after all.

Awesome, for extreme clarification. You're saying that there are several more differences than there are similarities, right?

No. Are you seriously suggesting that we resolve this question mathematically?

...that's what I'm asking. I've given examples of how the core tenants are exactly the same between these two.

You tell me. You're the one who claimed that they shared them. So which ones do they share, and which ones do they not?
 
You make gulags sound so awesome!



When the famine is caused by (or exacerbated by) the communist government, it still counts as the communists killing people. Especially when the famine is sorta on purpose to subdue a population that isn't getting with the program.

My observation of caveman1917 is that he or she is an apologist for communist atrocities who employs a form of DARVO (Deny, Attack, Reverse Victim and Offender).

1. Communism isn't as bad as you thought or not bad at all.

2. The virtues of western democratic capitalist institutions that you take for granted are a lie.

3. Democracy and capitalism are actually much more evil than any misinformed idea you have about communism.
 
Yeah anonymous internet discussions never get heated, after all.

They don't for me, I'm sorry they do for you.

No. Are you seriously suggesting that we resolve this question mathematically?

Ok, what other way would you like to do it? If we don't say they have more similarities than differences or vice versa, how do we come to a conclusion? If you just want to hear me say "Ok, you're right", I'm sorry it's not going to happen. You can sit here and imply I'm a moron that can't read as many times as you want. I don't really care. I have teenage kids, I get called worse consistently.

You tell me. You're the one who claimed that they shared them. So which ones do they share, and which ones do they not?

Tough to say as I can't list each and every aspect of it, which is why I focused on the core tenants. For instances:

White people are superior
Anti-LGBTQ
Anti-Immigrant
Anti-Semetic
Wearing Nazi clothing or displaying it on their vehicles\houses
Violence (whether the left uses it or not, the NC incident proves they will beat and kill people without hesitation)
Making it harder for ethnic people to vote

All of those they seem to have in common. The large differences is that they don't have the power to kill people.

The things they don't have in common:

They don't have death camps
Uhm...they, uhm, haven't taken over government, I guess?

I don't know. That's why I was asking you. Instead you told me I can't read. So what are their key differences? I honestly don't know.

Hell, give me some search criteria. After all, I can't read. I need some help.
 
Last edited:
(or, in the case of Harris, to pursue the victims).


To be fair, Harris did in fact throw the first punch.



The violence in Charlottesville was describe earlier (by you?) as "one sided", but that was far from the case. What I saw at Charlottesville was a group of white supremacists who were eager to be attacked, so that they could escalate, and a group of counterprotestors quite willing to give them the opportunity to do so. Some of the counterprotesters carried weapons and shields, and, in an interesting twist, balloons filled with mixtures of paint and human waste. I can't imagine using such an item in self defense.

What should have happened was that the two groups should have been kept far from each other. People should have been arrested or ticketed for interfering with "the other side", whoever that was. Instead, the police sat back and let a whole bunch of low level violence occur, and only stepped in when it got way out of hand.


The details of the Harris fight were covered in the thread about Charlottesville, but I'll put them hear, in a spoiler, in case anyone is interested.


A group of Nazis* were walking down the street. The gathering at the park had been dispersed, but they were walking through the streets, still in groups, basically returning to parking lots or gathering areas. Deandre (sp?) Harris and Corey Long were walking behind them, harassing and issuing vague threats. (Harris was taped waving some sort of club while saying "respect the bat"). At some point, a Nazi had his flag resting on his shoulder as he walked. Corey Long snuck up behind and tried to steal the flag. The Nazi and Long were struggling with the flag, when Harris stepped in and used the "bat" he was carrying to hit the Nazi in the head. That's what precipitated the fight. Several other Nazis came in to defend their friend, and they knocked Harris to the ground and he was struck while on the ground. Another man, white, was also knocked to the ground and struck on the ground, but I don't think anyone was ever charged for that.

As an aside, you might see footage of Charlottesville in which a man was using a lighter and can of spray paint as a sort of short range flamethrower to threaten the Nazis. That man was Corey Long. It was while he was using the flame-sprayer that the other white supremacist discharged his firearm, firing a shot into the ground near Corey Long's feet.


*I don't know if they would call themselves "Nazis", but it's close enough.
 
Last edited:
To be fair, Harris did in fact throw the first punch.

And I am sure the police were also right to ignore the crying nazi when he was only taking pot shots at those terrorist antifa. Really the sympathy that violent antifa like Heather Heyer gets for getting run over by a terrified person trying to flee for their life is sickening to all true Americans.
 
They don't for me

Sure they don't.

Ok, what other way would you like to do it?

Any other way would be better, since otherwise you'd either have to agree as to their exact number and how many are part of the set or not, or how many points each is worth on the balance, etc., and it would get ridiculous quite fast.

White people are superior
Anti-LGBTQ
Anti-Immigrant
Anti-Semetic

The last point is not quite right. Antisemitism is not a core feature of the alt-right and in fact some consider Jews to be white.

Wearing Nazi clothing or displaying it on their vehicles\houses

Pretty sure this is not a core feature of alt-right ideology.

Violence (whether the left uses it or not, the NC incident proves they will beat and kill people without hesitation)

Granted.

Making it harder for ethnic people to vote

I think that's included in the previous points. You padding the scoreboard, bruh?

All of those they seem to have in common. The large differences is that they don't have the power to kill people.

The things they don't have in common:

They don't have death camps
Uhm...they, uhm, haven't taken over government, I guess?

Come on, you can try harder than that. Are you seriously out of items, or would you rather not name the rest because it would boost the latter list? How about nationalisation of industry, for instance? Hell, you missed patriarchal tendencies in your pro-list.

I don't know. That's why I was asking you.

I'm not the one who made a claim.
 
The last point is not quite right. Antisemitism is not a core feature of the alt-right and in fact some consider Jews to be white.

And of course there are a number of gay white supremacists who think the blacks are the jews thugs. So the LGBT thing is also not universal as well. But does minor differences in the definition of white and such really count as enough to classify them differently?

Then there are the jewish antisemitic nazis who have podcasts because the world stopped making any sense. See the Daily Shoah

Do does being a pro holocaust anti Semitic nazi supporting jew, hit enough buttons to call them out as nazis or not just because they are jewish?
 
The last point is not quite right. Antisemitism is not a core feature of the alt-right and in fact some consider Jews to be white.

Ok, conceded.

Pretty sure this is not a core feature of alt-right ideology.

Maybe, but it certainly goes to show their support of the ideology we were talking about.

I think that's included in the previous points. You padding the scoreboard, bruh?

I didn't think it fell into anti-immigration because ethnic people are born here as well. I didn't think it fell into white people are superior because it's about voting. I'll digress though.

Come on, you can try harder than that. Are you seriously out of items, or would you rather not name the rest because it would boost the latter list? How about nationalisation of industry, for instance? Hell, you missed patriarchal tendencies in your pro-list.

As I said, I did vague research. I don't know if the alt-right supports or doesn't support the nationalization of industry. I know for sure Trump doesn't as he is trying to go in the complete opposite direction.

You are right though, the alt-right are misogynists as well. Thanks for the catch.

I'm not the one who made a claim.

Are we both not making claims right now? I'm claiming they're similar, you're claiming they aren't. I provided the reasoning behind my claim, why do I also have to provide the reasoning behind yours?
 
Last edited:
I didn't think it fell into anti-immigration because ethnic people are born here as well. I didn't think it fell into white people are superior because it's about voting.

No but both fit with the white supremacy thing anyway. I don't think they object to white immigrants from Finland.

I'll digress though.

You will? :)

I don't know if the alt-right supports or doesn't support the nationalization of industry.

Well then, do you not see why I find your claim that they largely overlap hard to accept? Clearly they overlap to a good degree, but although the Alt-Right are despicable in their own right it's just silly to use their own numbers to bolster the number of Nazis in the country.

You are right though, the alt-right are misogynists as well. Thanks for the catch.

Glad I could help out.

Are we both not making claims right now?

Well, if you want to be pedantic, anytime someone says "X" and the other on says "Not X!", you could say they are both making claims, but you've been here long to know that the positive claim is usually the one carrying the burden.
 
Nazis started normalising violence against those they targeted over a hundred years ago.

I think you must be referring to the Romans, more than 2,000 years earlier.

For something more contemporaneous to the literal Nazis, we can look at the Communists, who were just as active in the same ways during that period. I think it's a stretch to blame this "normalization" on the Nazis.

And certainly in America today, it's extremely narrow-minded and ahistorical to do so.
 
Last edited:

I disagree. The violence in NC can be attributed to one group. It does not demonstrate violence as a shared value across all the groups.

If it did, we'd have to conclude that antifa share something important in common with the "alt-right". Which when it comes to political violence, they kinda do. But I doubt that's the direction plague intended this to go.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom